Kitsunelaine: Town read. Role claim came out of nowhere and I handn't considered the possibility that she could've claimed because of Gorlak's handprint reveal, but that's the only small gripe I have. General stubbornness over Gorlak's argument and reads seem to match with what I've expected.
Maolfunction: A hard read due to the mess this phase turned out to be, but a town lean nonetheless. Is still sharp when considering other players contributions including those related to his claim - like his town read on Fat4All due to his take on Monkey's red check (which we apparently are the only ones that liked). Maol is an experienced player and his meta play is still his own, but I don't think he'd be able to fake his overall "level headness" throughout this phase, like when he first claimed his role after attention was drifting from Monkey's read check.
malus: The player I feel better from the lower count posters, but nothing decisive one way or another. A slight town lean. Meta read is that i'm usually wary of everything he posts, but this game nothing jumped to my attention so far and I remember him having a few original thoughts that seemed genuine.
Fat4all: I've talked about how I liked his progression on Monkey's red check as the questions he made are on point and also seem sincere. Went to look back at his D1 since he was the only player that didn't put a vote down, but there's really not much there to go over.
#228 and
#249 are the only ones with content and (the first is about how he doesn't really like D1 and the second is about the Monkey x Gorlak scum numbers discussion).
Fat4all can you talk about your vote on D1? Apologies if I missed it.
Kalor: I'm not even sure at this point. I guess the post I made earlier about how I sorta town read how he doesn't really seem obliged to comment on everything (since that indicates he really doesn't care about "public opinion" of him) still stands, but despite him making a few other posts I can't say where he stands right now other than the fact that he wants closure on Maol this phase.
Vincent Alexander: Definitely a blind spot to me. I'm not confident at all on my read on him and I admit I'm legit leaning on Fantomas to guide me on this read. I generally read town when someone is openly unsure and his reads, VA to me is never quite there. I don't see him prodding others or participating in the discussion, so to me it looks like he's not solving the game, especially considering he has been pretty safe on his reads so far.
Kopite: Sorta null. He seems detached from the other lower count posters, which might be a good sign?
#995 he answered my question regarding his "Maol needs to go" take which I was wary of as possible Maol's bussers like I mentioned a bit earlier, and I could definitely see him as a partner if Maol flips scum.
Meatwad: Scum read. Has been participating a bit more on this phase, but still very safe and "sheepy" as Fantomas went over. Could be uninterested town, but I just don't see him trying to solve the game as well, seems content sitting in the sidelines taking easy potshots. Further, I don't think he even tried looking for scum into his D1 wagon, which is alarming to me.
Dr. Monkey: I'll reiterate my earlier read on her - I town read her for the claim, despite the blind spots on the claim. I'm sorta surprised about the confusion we got on her own role PM, but I'll willing to trust her on the "messiness" of her role since: a) she's been open about it in a way I don't see Scum! Monkey being; and b) her progression on the Maol read this phase.
Dr. Monkey I probably missed this, but did you answer Fat4All and I when we questioned whether your role is actually "targetable"? Since you had a post previous to Maol's claim supposing the amount of actions on him, I think this could be important.
Gorlak: Town read. I'm tired of writting this post so I'll just say that Gorlak is my top town read and I've seen zero to doubt that so far.
Fantomas: Solid town read, though a few notches down from Gorlak. Despite the usual scum hunting and solving, Fantomas seems more refrained to me this time around. It's probably due to his new job, and he ended up making a high standard for himself due to meta, but I've still noted it.
