I used it as an example of "If you're town, doing this is anti-town"
Christ, I know I'm bad at wording things but I thought that was fucking self explanatory.
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Love Boat 3 Mafia |OT| This time it's Bearsonal
- Thread starter The Bear
- Start date
I used it as an example of "If you're town, doing this is anti-town"
Christ, I know I'm bad at wording things but I thought that was fucking self explanatory.
Am I a secret partner? Is that what we're trying to say here? Because otherwise your point here still makes no sense. At best, you are calling me not scum that is actively trying to help scum. At worst you got lost in your own nonsense.
Vote: Pirate Bae
Guess I'll park a vote here for now. There's just not much here besides a swerve, but not really a swerve on her Stuart read.
Someone come tell me I'm playing like shit, I feel like I'm talking to the void right now.
Guess I'll park a vote here for now. There's just not much here besides a swerve, but not really a swerve on her Stuart read.
Someone come tell me I'm playing like shit, I feel like I'm talking to the void right now.
It's not, last I checked, you are trying to lynch the mafia. If you were just looking for anti town then I'd direct you to Sparks first. You want to be mad at me because I'm signaling scum but for that to be the case then I can't be scum. You brought in a circular argument to justify your vote.
Best play I've ever seen, belongs in the MafiEra hall of fame if I'm being honest.
Even though I don't know where Stu is going with this, shouting out you see breadcrumbs D1 is kind of a dick move. It makes noise and causes tensions to run high like right now.
I suppose scum will have to comb through 25 pages of bullshit so that's a plus.
I suppose scum will have to comb through 25 pages of bullshit so that's a plus.
Yeah, I plan on going over some folks tomorrow at work when I'm not on mobile if time allows.
If you search your heart you'll know the answer. It always had to be him.
You're a stain on this community and you should feel bad for making such a fucking mess
Wow blatant pocket attempt tbh
Gonna split these up into two:
Last part is fine, but honestly, the stuff about reads tells me more about you and your preferences than anything about AbBro. Pretty standard in our meta for d1 reads to be meta-based or thin. I'd call it NAI. You call it lazy. Is that alignment indicative?
So you have no feelings on Geno, really, or just no feelings with regard to my question?
malus concerns me. He's not a high volume poster but this is really low. Kitsunelaine's drop off is also concerning. She had a very "okay, I've done enough for the phase!" attitude in GoT when she got recruited and I'd be concerned there, particularly if uneven engagement continues. I already said a low-posting feps makes me nervous.
Do you believe that Sorian could be bluffing about the breadcrumbs?
If they're overt, they're meant to be discovered. And now that Sorian's pointed it out, scum will obviously be able to identify it with the lot scouring for it together. I haven't noticed anything, myself, but I haven't gone back to look with that in mind.
In this context, then, would it be better for those involved to corroborate what Sorian is saying? Or maybe someone else who has identified it could just vaguely confirm that they see something as well.
What makes the Sorian vote easy? Memes? What has Sorian done that makes you want to keep him in the game or makes you not think he's votable? What do you think of Stan?
Same questions as to Kalor, tbh. And while I have your attention:
To vote? Why? You're asking other people about their votes. Why do you need to hear from your partner first? Do you not have your own opinions? Do y'all need to align? Did you agree to?
Yo, so l'm not going to treat you like a meme. Why do you think we are scum? What are we doing that's scummy? I don't care about other folks' reads; I want to hear YOUR opinion. You have plenty of opinions. I see you share them all the time. So why does SPARKY think we are scum? Do you think if I was scum I would not tell my scum mate Chuggs not to defend me so openly?
I'm struggling to remember when I've ever said "Kyaa engages more" and I think I'd have to go back to anime to say Kyaa was a true force in a game. I like his contributions here just fine and I think he's actually talking unprompted with others more than usual. Far be it from me to say someone else is hedging but this is honestly a little hedgy, Nat. "I like it but also I don't like it but also it's odd." What does that mean?
With that possibility in play, and with the potential of there actually being breadcrumbs out there, I do think it would be beneficial to have some sort of corroboration on the matter.
Doesn't even need to point to them. But if they're overt, then I think it would be difficult to assume that Sorian is the only one seeing them in a game this large.
I think that because Sorian is a high volume player and poster with a large game presence in any game he plays, it's easy to go "yeah, I'll throw a vote there because it's Sorian and he's a threat, just in case he's scum." Nothing this game has stood out to me as scummy so I don't understand the votes for logical reasons.
I have to take a closer look at Stan, but he's playing pretty par the course so far.
As for Malus, we agreed to discuss and align our ways of thinking before making any voting decisions. We agreed that it works better if we're on the same page considering the game format. He hasn't been around much so we haven't been able to discuss or bounce ideas off each other.
Really? I've always felt like kyan provides pretty good insights usually once you dig through the kyaa talk. His weird tangent on evaluating how people said they would interact with their partner just seemed so unnecessary though. Felt like someone trying to go through the motions. To address you're point though - where did I hedge? I actually never said anything positive about him in that post so I'm not sure where you're getting the paraphrased flip flopping from.
I didn't ask what he did that was scummy. I asked what he did that made you think he was town. There's a difference between people who you can clearly file as town and people who are just not scummy. Is he just not scummy to you?
Mainly about the question, concerning whether Geno/Sparks would change their playstyle if they were Scum because of some pre-game talk from Sorian. My thoughts on Geno are still pretty much what I posted earlier, other than continuing to go at Stu he hasn't left much more of an impression on me.
B-Dubs hasn't given me enough to put them in the solid town pile but I definitely don't feel scummy about them. Light town read as of now.
I don't disagree on Kyan's insights; I think he's very sharp. But he's sometimes one of those posters who just talks and people talk around him. I think of engagement as talking WITH others more. But your point about interaction is fair. Kyaa was also a little weird in MafiEra. How would you compare there?
As for hedging, I was taking "odd angles" as a better connotation, but I guess it wasn't? mb
He really isn't doing anything else at all, even to the point of paying attention to my posts, so I'd say that's accurate.
Why does it work better if you're on the same page as your partner?
Yeah that's fair, perhaps engage wasn't quite the right word. I don't know that I agree that he's always talked around, but I just expect his interjections to pack a bit more punch than I've seen so far. I didn't mean odd as in unique, I meant odd as in weird.
As for MafiEra I had honestly forgot he played that game until you reminded me just now - I'm thinking more of like Monopoly kyan.
By the way, I'm totally not getting weird flashbacks to MafiEra while sitting here with, well, half of the Scum team and two of the Cultists from that game...
Right there with you lol.
Good times.By the way, I'm totally not getting weird flashbacks to MafiEra while sitting here with, well, half of the Scum team and two of the Cultists from that game...
So you would call them not scummy, but can't state anything they've done that's town. You're not sure about them - it's a light town - but they aren't scummy.
Natiko, talk to me about this here. What do you think? I can't tell if I'm just tired and ornery or if this was a weird conversation. As for Kyan, I'm thinking of MafiEra because I said similar there (he's fine! he's great!) and reader, he was not.
Especially if you and your partner are having trouble getting together.
Who would you vote if it wasn't for that?
I mean, my partner is the only one I can trust 100%, why not be on the same page as them? Two heads are better than one.
Maybe it's just the military mentality of always working in teams, lol.
Now that's interesting, because I was sitting here wondering if I should vote Katsune or you guys. /thinking emoji
night, thread, see you in the morning
You said that you felt good about the Dr. Stu team before. What has malus said about them in your boat, considering that they've been the hot topic of this day phase, and are the ones who have the current momentum to getting lynched?
Not much. I asked how he felt about them to bounce my feelings off of someone else for an extra opinion. He mentioned that he wasn't so confident about the pair and that he would like to wait and see. I mentioned that I felt good about them so far so I was willing to look elsewhere today. Then he vanished.
Alright. I like the answer; it makes sense. I was going to vote for you depending on it since something was feeling off and I'm kind of at a loss, but that wouldn't seem right now.
I don't know why you need to wait on your partner to vote alongside him, but you guys do your thing, I suppose.
I'll take a look over the game again a while before the deadline to place a vote. Right now, it's very hard for me to determine where to point to. I don't feel better about Katsune, but I'm always wary of feeling noticeably off about a team this early on, where scum would work more to dissimulate themselves.
So the thing that's hard for me right now is I just thought about throwing a policy vote at a low post count player, but I checked and low post count players are paired with people who at least have more than 15 posts. Now I'm wondering what to do...
Eh, screw it! Who cares if their partners are active. I'm gonna pick... absolutbro
Vote: absolutbro
Where you at?
Vote: absolutbro
Where you at?
Well that was a much easier and more pleasant catch up than yesterday.
I dont doubt you but im drawing a total blank lol.
I easnt trying to say there was nothing noteworthy from it all, more just expreseing my frustration that it all dragged on pages and pages longer than it needed to thanks to a lot of petulant bickering rather than actual arguments.
The hell does the bolded mean? It looks confusing and potentially a hienous insult
Wait, where was i scum recently?
I dont doubt you but im drawing a total blank lol.
Nailed it.
Eh, smugly showing off his skill at the game is pretty NAI for sotian
Im confused at how you can say the bolded when in those same posts i did comment on several things from that first day.
I easnt trying to say there was nothing noteworthy from it all, more just expreseing my frustration that it all dragged on pages and pages longer than it needed to thanks to a lot of petulant bickering rather than actual arguments.
Im still at work atm. But when i get home ill give a proper look through the whole monkey and stu situation, right now its reminding me a lot of when B dubs and i were lovers a few games ago.
Specifically monkeys somewhat erronious defences for thier partner, which is very similar to how i acted in that game.
I feel like some full analysus on comparison to that personal experience will help a lot.
Specifically monkeys somewhat erronious defences for thier partner, which is very similar to how i acted in that game.
I feel like some full analysus on comparison to that personal experience will help a lot.
I think Kyan was just saying that you are a strong player late in the game. D[bignumber] just means day five or six, I think.
However, as for my comments (I can't see anything bolded in your quote) I wasn't a big fan of your aggressive and pissed off tone, I suppose. I think it was other people, such as CoolestOne, who said similar things about day 1 being bullshit that made me retroactively suspicious of how you opened your first post last night. When I see three or so players use similar language, it puts me on guard. Your beligerent attitude also struck me as being something of an act, but I obviously can't back that up as anything but a gut feeling.
To be frank, I'm not getting a town vibe from you yet, even if you don't come across as scum either. So I was skeptical of why Sorian seemed to be confident that you are town.
Not feeling that swerve tbqh
Looks organized as fuck with dr and chugs
I'll post some more concise, yes I said concise, what of it, thoughts later
And natiko exlover chill on shitting on chugs with that kind of tone and rhetoric.
Great way to get targeted by scum n1 is bluster and bullshit.
I'll have to read the entire thread if I want dr partner's read
Looks organized as fuck with dr and chugs
I'll post some more concise, yes I said concise, what of it, thoughts later
And natiko exlover chill on shitting on chugs with that kind of tone and rhetoric.
Great way to get targeted by scum n1 is bluster and bullshit.
I'll have to read the entire thread if I want dr partner's read
I feel like people are still voting for Sorian based on past actions rather than anything in this game. I don't really see a case for voting for them here. As for Stan, I don't really have an opinion so far. They seem fine I guess.
And finally a vote, because there's 0 reason for anyone not to have one at this point.
Vote: Fantomas
This is mostly because while they haven't been able to post much yet, they haven't really said much of importance in those posts. And also may as well give attention to the couples not really mentioned so far.
Vote: Fantomas
This is mostly because while they haven't been able to post much yet, they haven't really said much of importance in those posts. And also may as well give attention to the couples not really mentioned so far.
since you bring it up:
Not voting: FluxWaveZ, Xbro, B-Dubs, Fandorin, Pirate Bae, absolutbro, Stantastic, Ty4on, Kyanrute, Brazil, rac, SkyOdin, malus, Reki, Vincent Alexander, Z-Beat, Zippedpinhead
That's quite a few people without a vote down.
People should start putting their votes down soon. Majority is 18 so we're in no danger of majority.