This right here. Overrated is such a dumb ass term.
Unfortunately I've found on Resetera most people utterly lack the perspective necessary to understand that, and so, here we are.Bad idea for a thread, everyone has different opinions on different games, there's no real answer to your question. Just because someone really like a game and you don't doesn't mean it's "overrated'. They're rated just fine, to their opinion.
Every game you listed was reviewed with the right score.
There's a lot of critically acclaimed games conspicuously absent from that list.
You should have made the options: PC, Xbox, Playstation, Nintendo
More clear.
You spelled Breath of The Wild wrong, or did you miss all those "What can game X learn from BotW" threads for a year straightWhy isn't Bloodborne an option? It's far and away the most overrated.
It's a fine game for some tastes, but good god some people take the love a bit overboard wanting everything to be inspired by it.