Actually the lack of platinum was what got me to go off, that's just bad behavior.
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Nier: Automata Mafia - To serve mankind... up on a platter via vote.
- Thread starter lokiduck
- Start date
They'll be Sori-an. haha! Actually, as neutral, this has got to be the most fun.
Kind of like your attempt?
I see people voting elsewhere and I know that mafia players avoid last minute swings away b/c it can get them in huge trouble, better to cut their losses & bus. So not at all concerned by lack of movement.
Guess there is no more time to check and post. But Haw already self quoted the posts I was looking for anyways.
I don't town read anex, I just didn't like the LP counter wagon because I don't see a reason to SR LP
I'm enjoying myself, whatever post Anex said above that thing I said to Saw a bit ago was what made me think scum but I really still don't trust Maol this my hesitation to follow his lead. I'm on my phone making dinner so I'm not looking that up now, ask me again tomorrow.
Thorny, I'm literally the first person to vote anex and haven't moved
OK, that is a a good point.
I do remember that you like to have multiple wagons. I forget that people are like that because it makes me nervous, I like to have a firm lead on the person I most scum read.
In case it's not obvious I'm not buying the claim after all despite the lack of counterclaim.
Yes, tried to save the guy I cased and voted for over a day ago
Yeah I got you confused with Sorian for some reason lol. My bad
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start - Day End
Anexanhume (10 votes)
Maolfunction - #560
Sawneeks - #631 #734
c4e5g3d5 - #1,001 #1,160
HPSauce - #1,083
TheChuggernaut - #1,098
Sawneeks - #1,111
Randomless - #1,157
c4e5g3d5 - #1,203
Hawthorn - #1,256
Sorian - #1,375
Stantastic - #1,403
Neki - #1,406
Lone_Prodigy (3 votes)
Hawthorn - #835 #1,256
Anexanhume - #863 #1,128
jman1954goat - #1,002
Ephidel - #1,027
EzekelRAGE - #1,052
Sorian - #1,116 #1,137
Hawthorn (2 votes)
TheChuggernaut - #485 #1,098
FateShirou - #498
NeonBorealis - #909
FateShirou (1 votes)
c4e5g3d5 - #248 #343
Randomless - #885 #1,157
Funky Dude Sparks - #905
Sorian (1 votes)
CheshireCat - #1,344
HPSauce (1 votes)
FateShirou - #89 #498
Randomless - #115 #347
Maolfunction - #123 #183
Anexanhume - #1,170
Maolfunction (1 votes)
Sorian - #238 #1,116
EvilChameleon - #390
Sorian - #1,137 #1,375
CheshireCat (0 votes)
Anexanhume - #840 #863
Stantastic (0 votes)
Sawneeks - #738 #1,014
TheChuggernaut (0 votes)
NeonBorealis - #152 #614
EzekelRAGE - #206 #761
Stantastic - #291 #795
Randomless (0 votes)
Maolfunction - #183 #362
EvilChameleon (0 votes)
c4e5g3d5 - #101 #248
Hawthorn - #724 #835
Funky Dude Sparks (0 votes)
Stantastic - #795 #1,403
EzekelRAGE (0 votes)
Sawneeks - #151 #612
NeonBorealis (0 votes)
c4e5g3d5 - #1,160 #1,203
Sawneeks (0 votes)
EzekelRAGE - #761 #1,052
Not voting: Lone_Prodigy
Post Counts:
TheChuggernaut: 234 c4e5g3d5: 167 Anexanhume: 136 Maolfunction: 133 EzekelRAGE: 114 Sorian: 113 HPSauce: 97 Funky Dude Sparks: 94 FateShirou: 89 CheshireCat: 86 Sawneeks: 79 Randomless: 74 Neki: 74 Hawthorn: 67 NeonBorealis: 52 Ephidel: 38 jman1954goat: 32 Stantastic: 32 EvilChameleon: 29 Lone_Prodigy: 23
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start - Day End
Anexanhume (10 votes)
Maolfunction - #560
HPSauce - #1,083
TheChuggernaut - #1,098
Sawneeks - #1,111
Randomless - #1,157
c4e5g3d5 - #1,203
Hawthorn - #1,256
Sorian - #1,375
Stantastic - #1,403
Neki - #1,406
Lone_Prodigy (3 votes)
jman1954goat - #1,002
Ephidel - #1,027
EzekelRAGE - #1,052
Hawthorn (2 votes)
FateShirou - #498
NeonBorealis - #909
FateShirou (1 votes)
Funky Dude Sparks - #905
Sorian (1 votes)
CheshireCat - #1,344
HPSauce (1 votes)
Anexanhume - #1,170
Maolfunction (1 votes)
EvilChameleon - #390
CheshireCat (0 votes)
Stantastic (0 votes)
TheChuggernaut (0 votes)
Randomless (0 votes)
EvilChameleon (0 votes)
Funky Dude Sparks (0 votes)
EzekelRAGE (0 votes)
NeonBorealis (0 votes)
Sawneeks (0 votes)
Not voting: Lone_Prodigy
Post Counts:
TheChuggernaut: 234 c4e5g3d5: 167 Anexanhume: 136 Maolfunction: 133 EzekelRAGE: 114 Sorian: 113 HPSauce: 97 Funky Dude Sparks: 94 FateShirou: 89 CheshireCat: 86 Sawneeks: 79 Randomless: 74 Neki: 74 Hawthorn: 67 NeonBorealis: 52 Ephidel: 38 jman1954goat: 32 Stantastic: 32 EvilChameleon: 29 Lone_Prodigy: 23
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day 1 Ends
Devola: For some, death can be their salvation.
Popola: For others, death can only mean pain.
Devola: Sleep, young warrior.
Anexanhume has died
He was...
Night 1 Begins
Night actions are due two hours before day start.
Day 2 Begins in:
Edit: The third dot on this Role PM was a typo made by Era, it is being edited out because it's not supposed to be there.
Popola: For others, death can only mean pain.
Devola: Sleep, young warrior.
Anexanhume has died
He was...
Night 1 Begins
Night actions are due two hours before day start.
Day 2 Begins in:
Edit: The third dot on this Role PM was a typo made by Era, it is being edited out because it's not supposed to be there.
Last edited:
Day 2 Starts
Popola: Even the perfect plan
Devola: Can be laid low by chance
Popola: And so the world refused to change
Fog swept the land as if to remove every trace of his existence. Not even a murmur remained of his name.
Randomless has died
He was...
Day 2 Begins
Vote tool:
Day 2 Ends In:
Devola: Can be laid low by chance
Popola: And so the world refused to change
Fog swept the land as if to remove every trace of his existence. Not even a murmur remained of his name.
Randomless has died
He was...
Day 2 Begins
Vote tool:
Day 2 Ends In:
Last edited:
Ok. I'm preparing this post beforehand while we are waiting through the night phase. Hopefully I didn't get killed and I'm able to post this (Yay!!!). I'll be posting this as soon as the day begins, so I'll adress any night changes in a later post.
Finally, I have information to chew on.
So. The Anex wagon. Let's talk about that, shall we?
These were the people who voted for Anex:
That's 50% of the players. By mere probability there was surely a scum (or more) in there.
Out of these, I don't see us getting too much information out of both Neki and Stan, given that they voted during the last minutes of the day. Stan, in particular missed almost all of the dayphase (because timezones, understandable), and just folloed the bandwagon.
Sorian is w/e, he already said he was neutral and we'll presumably get confirmation of his ability via Chugg. I see no point for the time being in prodding here.
Out of the 7 remaining, the one that pings my radar the most (so to speak) is Hawthorn.
Her first post of note is her initial list of reads which has already been discussed before.
Later on she seemingly changes her view on LP (post # 721) and writes up her reads on both him and Anex (which, by that point were beginning to be discussed more).
After that she votes for LP despite her previous claims. This is before the Anex wagon even existed, at the time (and including Anex's vote on LP) the votes were tied 3 ways between Anex, Haw and LP.
And then, neqaring the end of the day (but not during the end-end of day) she changes votes for Anex because of his claim.
Given the direction the discussion was going to, this change of vote could be seen as understandable. But I have the feeling that her first vote on LP before was to remove attention from herself and move discussion onto anex/LP. The jump onto Anex's wagon seems like a not too early - not too late vote that seemed too convenient to make when discussion was at an all time high, without risk of being accused of hammering.
FoS: Hawthorn.
Now. The other player I want to discuss is HP. Granted, scumdar is pinging less on him. But does anyone else feel like his contributions on day 1 were... kinda flat?
The biggest contributions I could find from him were his post roundups (which, honestly, kinda feel like a small smopkescreen to seem helpful), and his adamant refusal to vote inactives (which, granted, I also participated in) resulting in his vote against Anex.
He also said he was going to post a read list, but never did (this could be because of real life, so I don't think this is that important).
For such a flat performance, I'm surprised many people read HP as a townie. Even I said that HP seemed townie. But now I'm not so sure.
In particular, I'd like to point out Anex's take on this:
FoS: HP.
I don't have many comments on the other players on the wagon. Random and C4 do appear like genuine townies. Chuggs seems talkative and protownish. And I need to reread Saw and Maol.
Let's see the other mayor wagon of yesterday. LP's wagon consisted of the following players:
I'm keeping Haw's vote here to illustrate her voting patterns
Now here is the other biggest wagon that formed yesterday. There could be scum hiding here as well. Out of the three remaining voters, I'm not seeing much. None of them strike me as inconsistent. And I don't know what to make of Zeke yet. jman in particular has little to go on besides the whole baiting me thing he did when I asked about night activity clarification.
Ephi was kinda against my initial Haw analysis response to Chugg. But She actually seemed to support Anex.So I think that is just town play.
I do agree with previous posts that the reasons to vote LP later on were kinda weak, and the three posters mentioned above gave little to no explanation. Maybe a reason to keep an eye on them.
Besides the two main wagons, I'd like to point out the following:
1.- LP pretty much disappeared when his bandwagon was starting (he was around three votes at the time). Him offering no further comment kinda muddies the waters around him, so to speak. He was the only one to not vote, so that leaves us with little information about him besides the meta reads (which I can't comment on). His absence makes me a little suspicious, but it could be real life.
2.- Chesire's vote on Sorian near the EoD was interesting in that she used it supposedly to "try and gauge reactions", but nothing ever came out of it. Was this a poor attempt to start a wagon against Sorian at the time Anex was suggesting it? If Chesire was scum, it could be seen as an attempt to say that she was active votewise during EoD while remaining free of the wagon.
3.- Fate remained steadfast on his vote against Haw. We'll have to see what Hedin has to say about the day before coming to any conclusions. I'll reread his posts later.
4.- FDS and EC give little to no information to go on with their votes. FDS claim is also kinda funky.
Given what I've explained above, my current biggest suspicions fall on the following (in order, from most, to least):
Of course, this analysis is subject to change given the results of N1, but I'll get there when I get there.
Ok. That is enough for now. Going to go back to Anex's posts to see if I can find something else.
Addendum:
Also C4, bringing back this because I'd like to know what made you think this. As in, what did I say?
Finally, I have information to chew on.
So. The Anex wagon. Let's talk about that, shall we?
These were the people who voted for Anex:
I'm not listing Saw's and C4's previous posts to keep this cleaner.
That's 50% of the players. By mere probability there was surely a scum (or more) in there.
Out of these, I don't see us getting too much information out of both Neki and Stan, given that they voted during the last minutes of the day. Stan, in particular missed almost all of the dayphase (because timezones, understandable), and just folloed the bandwagon.
Sorian is w/e, he already said he was neutral and we'll presumably get confirmation of his ability via Chugg. I see no point for the time being in prodding here.
Out of the 7 remaining, the one that pings my radar the most (so to speak) is Hawthorn.
Her first post of note is her initial list of reads which has already been discussed before.
This was immideately responded with pushback by Chugg c4 and Sorian due to the weak reasoning. After that the topic was dropeed while the players focused their attention elsewhere. She then voted for EC at roughly the halfway point of Day 1.
Later on she seemingly changes her view on LP (post # 721) and writes up her reads on both him and Anex (which, by that point were beginning to be discussed more).
After that she votes for LP despite her previous claims. This is before the Anex wagon even existed, at the time (and including Anex's vote on LP) the votes were tied 3 ways between Anex, Haw and LP.
And then, neqaring the end of the day (but not during the end-end of day) she changes votes for Anex because of his claim.
Given the direction the discussion was going to, this change of vote could be seen as understandable. But I have the feeling that her first vote on LP before was to remove attention from herself and move discussion onto anex/LP. The jump onto Anex's wagon seems like a not too early - not too late vote that seemed too convenient to make when discussion was at an all time high, without risk of being accused of hammering.
FoS: Hawthorn.
Now. The other player I want to discuss is HP. Granted, scumdar is pinging less on him. But does anyone else feel like his contributions on day 1 were... kinda flat?
The biggest contributions I could find from him were his post roundups (which, honestly, kinda feel like a small smopkescreen to seem helpful), and his adamant refusal to vote inactives (which, granted, I also participated in) resulting in his vote against Anex.
He also said he was going to post a read list, but never did (this could be because of real life, so I don't think this is that important).
For such a flat performance, I'm surprised many people read HP as a townie. Even I said that HP seemed townie. But now I'm not so sure.
In particular, I'd like to point out Anex's take on this:
FoS: HP.
I don't have many comments on the other players on the wagon. Random and C4 do appear like genuine townies. Chuggs seems talkative and protownish. And I need to reread Saw and Maol.
Let's see the other mayor wagon of yesterday. LP's wagon consisted of the following players:
I'm keeping Haw's vote here to illustrate her voting patterns
Now here is the other biggest wagon that formed yesterday. There could be scum hiding here as well. Out of the three remaining voters, I'm not seeing much. None of them strike me as inconsistent. And I don't know what to make of Zeke yet. jman in particular has little to go on besides the whole baiting me thing he did when I asked about night activity clarification.
Ephi was kinda against my initial Haw analysis response to Chugg. But She actually seemed to support Anex.So I think that is just town play.
I do agree with previous posts that the reasons to vote LP later on were kinda weak, and the three posters mentioned above gave little to no explanation. Maybe a reason to keep an eye on them.
Besides the two main wagons, I'd like to point out the following:
1.- LP pretty much disappeared when his bandwagon was starting (he was around three votes at the time). Him offering no further comment kinda muddies the waters around him, so to speak. He was the only one to not vote, so that leaves us with little information about him besides the meta reads (which I can't comment on). His absence makes me a little suspicious, but it could be real life.
2.- Chesire's vote on Sorian near the EoD was interesting in that she used it supposedly to "try and gauge reactions", but nothing ever came out of it. Was this a poor attempt to start a wagon against Sorian at the time Anex was suggesting it? If Chesire was scum, it could be seen as an attempt to say that she was active votewise during EoD while remaining free of the wagon.
3.- Fate remained steadfast on his vote against Haw. We'll have to see what Hedin has to say about the day before coming to any conclusions. I'll reread his posts later.
4.- FDS and EC give little to no information to go on with their votes. FDS claim is also kinda funky.
Given what I've explained above, my current biggest suspicions fall on the following (in order, from most, to least):
- Hawthorn
- HP
- CheshireCat
- LP
Of course, this analysis is subject to change given the results of N1, but I'll get there when I get there.
Ok. That is enough for now. Going to go back to Anex's posts to see if I can find something else.
Addendum:
Also C4, bringing back this because I'd like to know what made you think this. As in, what did I say?
Wait. A scum died. This changes my read posts.
2 hours semi down the drain.
Anyways. Back to the post pile.
2 hours semi down the drain.
Anyways. Back to the post pile.
This is why you don't pre-write posts for posting the moment the day kicks off.
There could always be the possibility of a Janitor in the game. but for the time being let's go with the assumption that Rando was indeed scum.
True could be, but what we can chew on that is a fact is the clusterfuck of the Anex vote. Ill go thru it later, let's see what yall come up with.
Oh god I hope that flip is fake. I am not prepared for two scum teams with a game of this size
my thought as well since this game is bastard. but for the sheer sake of my sanity i'm just going to go with it until we get evidence that suggests otherwise.
???????????
The PM says they can only use their ability on even nights. Implying that there's another team on odd nights
Yeah. If we continue with the suposition that Rando is legit scum, I'm feeling more confident in my HP read.
Although if there is a second team, that means we probably had some scum on scum violence last night, so thanks other scum