Why can't town pocket ppl? I like pocketing ppl, it keeps them safe.
Okay then XD
Why can't town pocket ppl? I like pocketing ppl, it keeps them safe.
thats a good list.
See everyone ? You dont have to force down thoughts on every player this early in the game. Just put down your thoughts on those that you really have a feel for. Not saying that i agree with the list itself ( since i just came back), but the way it was done pleases me.
*love over*
will make myself a tea now and wait for further replies.
He made a list. (thats something)
He did not include everyone, only those that he felt are right to be mentioned ( thats something )
yet here we are.
you complained that we are still in the joke phase
Stu creates a list in order to open up and put his thoughts out in the open and then you complain about that aswell ?
Not sure what you want. But whatever it is, decide on it.
First of all, please stay suspicious of me. I cant understand or relate to people who say they have a good feeling about someone. This just leads to being missleaded.
Second: Yeah it sucks that i was not able to be there at end of day. Sucks but i probably would have voted out 80% Coolestspot or would have made an end game shinenigan of voting for Kopite. Either way i would have been wrong.
Waking up to see Kopte and Rac dead is also something sad to experience since i would have 100% voted Kopite today. Rac, dont know what to think about rac dying. I mean i am sad that we lost a hider but that it. :(
while i do really appreciate the props, i do not appreciate the null read.
Rather have me as a scum lean. calling someone null is something like not saying anything at all in order not to be called out later for it in the next day phases. Be ready for the pushback.
No need for the null thing. I can understand if you are unsure but still, take a side and stand on it.
Take a stand!
I expected more from you up to this point my man.
i will have to say this
at least thats a nice theory but then you contradict yourself by saying
Which way you want to go? decide.
I mean at this stage i would not back down on the theory of me coming into the conversation and trying to white horse stu. But we never know what it is going to be.
Today i will either go the AbsolutBro route or Sparks.
Either way. I for one will take a stance.
same as i did yesterday.
Thanks for the response AB. In no way did it come off as snarky, we played enough games together to kinda know each other.
I am fine with this vote however
Vote: Funky Dude Sparks
How are you doing stan?
I will go to bed now, but first I will cadt my vote on the following person
Vote: Stu
Can't shake the feeling off that you are scum.
You do not seem to be as agitated as I know you from past games. This could be due to you having the good position of being scum.
I know I know people will chime in and say.
Nin you are one shit player. First you defend him now you want him dead. That does not even make any sense.
And you know what? It does on my book
Habe a great night
??? What assessment?My assessment is lokiduck is right on the money which make her flip to scum all that much more unfortunate.
LP because its gonna be a crapshoot with him forever.
and i know everyone goes all "oh but we want a lynch that will give more info today" but that always means he is left till well late in the game when hes just as big a question mark only then everyone is to busy with whatever tunnels they have talked themselves into to justify lynching said big question mark.
Catch 22 i think they call it?
i dunno.
Coolest thats a fucking awful idea, the point of day 1 isnt really to lunch scum, like that would be great but its never an attainable goal, its to create enough chatter that can be utilized in later days with the benfit of hindsight, your plan would negate that entirely and day 2 would be similarly blind to day 2.
dude i think you are confusing "definitive" with "ultimate"
definitive just means its a clearly defined conclusion, not that it cannot change with new circumstances, which does fit what Kits is saying.
right?
that one screams opportunism and/or early bussing.
think im swapping back to my first vote.
vote: Stu
And yeah i can get behind the noise on pirate bae, she feels like, spectral?
Here but not really here, y'know.
dude, explain,
stop just tagging random people and actually explain what you are thinking
How about instead you give your reads for once?
Just really throw everyone for a loop.
right, let's get to it then:
Kitsune did you ever respond to this?
Kinda feels like a train just materialized out of nowhere for fran. I get nin's reasoning despite not having put a vote down, but wee and kits just sorta jumped on that, and the cynic in me thinks that one is legitimate and the other thinks that they can swing the vote that way with enough off the cuff prodding. So I think one of you two is scum
wrong cartoon
Anyway...
If I had to take any gambit from either end I'd think this
If one is lying then they probably wanted to get out ahead of the claim and claim it first to gain credibility because if one claimed then they'd be a confirmed town and scum would have to waste a night kill to get rid of them, but if we accidentally killed that one then that takes care of that problem and frees up a night kill for scum while also scoring a triple kill on the first day. While this would mean the other's death it would probably speed through day 2 with a majority vote wasting time for more speculation, screwing over town even more
As for who, I don't know. CS hadn't voted for fran at all and had their vote on lokiduck. Fran had quite a bit of suspicion already and like I mentioned before it felt really unfounded (and apparently I was right), so scum probably would've just let it ride. But I also know CS knows his Scooby Doo shit and could've pulled support for that flavor claim out of his ass no problem, while A Pup Named Scooby Doo is one of the most popular of the spinoffs and would require far less effort to support for Zeke. One of you thought that you were dead already and chose to sacrifice themselves in exchange for a triple kill.
Also if we're gonna get weirdly meta with it:
Fantomas, you were the last person to post before Fran died, within the same minute, in fact. But then you went back and replied to rac instead of incorporating it into the post that was only a couple of posts before yours. Since you posted after the please wait I assume you were compiling the former before you refreshed the page. But that would also mean that you'd have to have posted again after the okay was given by Aeleus, which means you would've seen what happened to Fran but you still chose to section off the posts that were a reply to rac and your reaction. That doesn't seem...like you.
I'd hold off on that
You said your win condition was that you capture the last of the thirteen ghosts and get to leave. You seem to be taking elements from the movie 13 Ghosts and mixing them with The 13 Ghosts of Scooby Doo. That doesn't make a ton of sense as a win condition, CS
I still don't good about kits and Malus hasn't done much for me to remove suspicion from Bae
I didn't like the way she handled the conversation about Zeke and scum day vig possibilities
I men
It felt really roundabout even though I thought my question was pretty straightforwardCan you say exactly what you didn't like about how kits handled the conversation?
Ok...... so that was me. I'm daphne. Day vig. I have my butler "remove" a person. I chose Fran because I thought he was purposely creating noise when he said his poking stu was a shitpost. That was like his first time saying that.
*truffleshuffle*
re: votes on CoolestSpot
on the one hand I can see the "anti-town behaviour" or "get the neutral" opinions, they make sense. But jumping on the vote now is getting the side eye from me. It's an easy vote to jump on now.
this got me. and fwiw, I agree you've been toned down this game. People use day powers badly all the time, but you've got a history so the hammer comes down a bit harder. It's not really fair, but meta is meta :-\
I'm not saying "don't vote there". I'm saying "recent CS votes will get more scrutiny later", because it's an easy vote for scum to jump on and defend themselves later by saying 'but he was such an obvious vote!'. Several people (Stu and Fanto I think) had already expressed "CS is being anti-town" sorts of thoughts BEFORE CS claimed his wacky role, they're distinct from "ZOMG CS did something crazy, LUNCH! LUNCH! LUNCH!" votes. That clearer?
Soneji, Rac and nin were the first ones to really go for Fran over the "scum team size" post. The Soneji/rac exchange feels weird:
it just feels kind of unnecessary. Like Soneji is talking about Fran being on the list and then rac's post is basically "no need to defend me I got this", but... Soneji wasn't? Like what
Part of me wants a kopite vote with how cagey I think he's been, but having never played with him it could just be his play style (also he said he's sick, feel better dude). Would wait. Not feeling much better about rac, but at least there's something to read there unlike L_P and to a lesser extent Kalor. Feeling better about Soneji though. Sparks I'm ambivalent on; yeah his votes are usually just unsupported solo posts, but I dunno, feels like too easy of a fallback vote for just that.
I would vote for Nin, but he said he wouldn't be here EoD so he can't really defend himself. His defense of Stu, who made no attempt to defend himself even (and why would he, he admitted it was a joke post), just feels like someone trying to start pocketing someone.
Vote: Kitsunelaine
of the current seemingly viable trains that's my most suspicious. I may be away early as my doctor seems to want me to come in immediately, so I may vanish soon. sorry all.
😒I don't know why that got cut off. Should've said "I mentioned why a few times"
LOL are you getting upset Zeke that people keep telling you they explained why when they voted instead of actually telling you then? XD
More annoyed. I feel that if it was a "genuine" vote they could give a lil short sentence or two on why they voted the way they did.LOL are you getting upset Zeke that people keep telling you they explained why when they voted instead of actually telling you then? XD
Yeah that makes sense. I guess it's why I always try to answer people's questions when they have them for me. XDMore annoyed. I feel that if it was a "genuine" vote they could give a lil short sentence or two on why they voted the way they did.
Them telling me to go look it up just makes me think their reasoning was weak in the first place.
I could accept that response of it was about a topic we've been going in circles about, but it isn't.
I hope that makes sense.
Imagine how I feel. You're the third person to ask.More annoyed. I feel that if it was a "genuine" vote they could give a lil short sentence or two on why they voted the way they did.
Classic Bae scum move. Pretend not to know what's going on, come in late to the party, drop a half-out-of-touch fake Post.
AB has improved in my opinions, PB has not. Kopite has not. Soneji seems townish. Nin is vacant, no clues there.
Kalor's post content read like his town game to me on D1, however the quantity is already warned.
AB, I felt better about at end of day, obviously voting patterns will matter.
LP I had felt ok about, but his lack of appearance, and willingness to up CS's weirdness like it was gospel, make me think he may be scum.
bae is still my top scum. I can't read sparky. Kits could go either way and since she isn't making me laugh today, i'm not on her boat.
A scum dayvig is a strong possibility in this game, but it seems odd to expect everyone to flip it on D2, when town dayvig is still kinda more mathematically likely. I'd guess that dayvig, across all games, is 80% likely to be town.
This is why trusting people based on role info is bad. Do reads. Zeke seems town to me based on his post content, but certainly a scum would take an opportunity to shoot Fran. I just don't know why a scum dayvig would counterclaim CS. Why do that when someone randomly volunteers to take the heat from you?
Detective Fanto did some gud muckracking in day 1
Unvote
[highlight[Vote: Fran [/highlight]
Scum list goes: Fran, Absolutbro, Stu
If I were in a scum role I, too, would distance myself from commotion
Sparks as town: I have no idea what's happening WTF is happening
Sparks as scum: um yasss pls destroy each other whilst I plan the NK
Guess what was going through my mind before I read detective fanto's post on Fran?
For this day phase I'm the 3rd person to ask?
No, you're the 3rd total
This was day 1. Do you still think there is scum between the two since kits has flipped.Kinda feels like a train just materialized out of nowhere for fran. I get nin's reasoning despite not having put a vote down, but wee and kits just sorta jumped on that, and the cynic in me thinks that one is legitimate and the other thinks that they can swing the vote that way with enough off the cuff prodding. So I think one of you two is scum
This is your response to stu questioning kits in your top 3 scum. So is that it or am I missing something?My questioning of the scum day vig felt like a dodge attempt using absurdity
[/QUOTE
Zeke.
Because of reasons I've forgotten about but it probably has to do with past games
*truffleshuffle*
Also good morning folks!
The read list did exactly what I want it to.
Generated some discussion though I admit, I was pleasantly surprised when it caused an exchange quite soon after between Fran and Soneji.
And it continues to generate some discussion which again is good considering how much shit posting is being done today.
Now these exchanges may or may not be useful today. You decide.
But it does mean there is something to look back on in D1 besides shit posting.
Fantomas I don't understand why Turmoil is so high on your list.
Like, I pointed out earlier how they have been all over the place, excessive even for D1. Very shifty and flip floppy overall.
Shouldn't be so high on anyones towns list imo.
On this note: Switching votes so close to the end for no reason to someone who wasn't around was weak.
By all means, vote for someone else but justify it without saying "Oh this is too easy, let's switch things near the end because why not"
If CS had come clean, I wouldn't have voted for him. Instead he maintained he was a neutral who wanted to win but was still sowing chaos within town.
I don't feel bad for lunching him nor do I feel bad for my vote on them.
Sparks-> You -> Bae
Reasoning:
Sparks in honour of our dearly departed Fran.
You over Bae is mainly a case of, I need to see more from Bae. Her link to you is mainly from your posts rather than hers.
I've seen nothing from Sparks that makes me feel 'town' though. So in that sense.
Vote: Funky Dude Sparks
fukin ell sorry yall, i ended up bizarrely busy and had little time to put into this game.
Of the options that i think people pushed the most today i would be pretty down with a stu, kalor, or a malus lunch.
Stu would still be my strongest, tho by less than in previous days, and it doesnt seem like that would likely be followed so instead imma vote with my next in line,
vote: Kalor
i feel less strong about malus as i still cant parse much of baes behavior from her just being unable to play much, and malus himself hasnt really caught my ire.
What are your thoughts on Nin?fukin ell sorry yall, i ended up bizarrely busy and had little time to put into this game.
Of the options that i think people pushed the most today i would be pretty down with a stu, kalor, or a malus lunch.
Stu would still be my strongest, tho by less than in previous days, and it doesnt seem like that would likely be followed so instead imma vote with my next in line,
vote: Kalor
i feel less strong about malus as i still cant parse much of baes behavior from her just being unable to play much, and malus himself hasnt really caught my ire.
Today i will either go the AbsolutBro route or Sparks.
Either way. I for one will take a stance.
same as i did yesterday.
Today he has a whopping 1 post. I would really love to hear more here, and especially what his thoughts on AB and Stu are now.I will go to bed now, but first I will cadt my vote on the following person
Vote: Stu
Can't shake the feeling off that you are scum.
You do not seem to be as agitated as I know you from past games. This could be due to you having the good position of being scum.
I know I know people will chime in and say.
Nin you are one shit player. First you defend him now you want him dead. That does not even make any sense.
And you know what? It does on my book
Habe a great night
D2:right?
that one screams opportunism and/or early bussing.
think im swapping back to my first vote.
vote: Stu
How do you feel about Stu today?Oh also i keep forgetting.
vote: Stu
I felt pretty bad about stu yesterday and his play today hasnt changed that.