-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Scooby-Doo Mafia |OT| Where are you?
- Thread starter Aeleus
- Start date
Why can't town pocket ppl? I like pocketing ppl, it keeps them safe.
Because it's not pocketing it's just being good town friends that are worried about the other one being scum that's pocketing them
nin: Has a tendency of making a bunch of posts in bursts (which partly seems like he's trying to mainly meet his post quota) but I get making posts because it's the only time you have to do so.
Liked Stu's list because he was actually putting forth lists and that mainly seems to be what he wants from people.
Voted himself day 1 and was the only vote left on his train at EoD LOL
Day 2:
Makes this post saying he likes when people are suspicious of him.
In general he wants people to not only make lists, but not give null reads and not town read him because they are having a good feeling about him.
This is seen by his response to Fanto and I's null reads on him.
Votes Abs who has been putting forth the theory that nin was trying to pocket Stu, but later votes for Sparks after Abs responses to him with a counter argument to his posts.
Was happy Sparks was forced to claim.
Didn't get the votes on Kits and Turm.
Voted Stu at the end of the day.
Overall assessment: A lot of his posts that stood out to me have been the ones telling people to be more active, to make lists, to not put forth too many null reads, and even be suspicious of him. This activity is odd and I'm not sure how to feel on it. His voting on day 2 made sense and I like that he unvoted Abs after Abs put forth a decent counter argument. However, i do not get his vote on Stu at the end of the day.
I know he's going to hate me for this, but I'm still getting a null read from him :/ though his activity over all is making me want to scum lean him more than town lean. It's just out of the remaining players, he's probably the least suspicious of my current suspects I guess you could say?
Liked Stu's list because he was actually putting forth lists and that mainly seems to be what he wants from people.
Voted himself day 1 and was the only vote left on his train at EoD LOL
Day 2:
Makes this post saying he likes when people are suspicious of him.
In general he wants people to not only make lists, but not give null reads and not town read him because they are having a good feeling about him.
This is seen by his response to Fanto and I's null reads on him.
Votes Abs who has been putting forth the theory that nin was trying to pocket Stu, but later votes for Sparks after Abs responses to him with a counter argument to his posts.
Was happy Sparks was forced to claim.
Didn't get the votes on Kits and Turm.
Voted Stu at the end of the day.
Overall assessment: A lot of his posts that stood out to me have been the ones telling people to be more active, to make lists, to not put forth too many null reads, and even be suspicious of him. This activity is odd and I'm not sure how to feel on it. His voting on day 2 made sense and I like that he unvoted Abs after Abs put forth a decent counter argument. However, i do not get his vote on Stu at the end of the day.
I know he's going to hate me for this, but I'm still getting a null read from him :/ though his activity over all is making me want to scum lean him more than town lean. It's just out of the remaining players, he's probably the least suspicious of my current suspects I guess you could say?
My assessment is lokiduck is right on the money which make her flip to scum all that much more unfortunate.
Stan: Day 1: Asked people as a joke to vote for him so he'd get more inspired to play.
When asked by Bae who would be his second lunch target he picked LP because of his posting style making him hard to read
Was critcal of Soneji's vote on Kits for a word she used.
Felt good about Fran and Fran's point that town Sparks doesn't care if people are scumreading him.
Agreed with Turm and voted for Stu
Was okay with a CS Lunch.
Day 2: Supported suspicion on Bae
Voted Stu again felt his stance on him hadn't changed.
Called out Sparks on his lack of actually putting forth his own thoughts.
Day 3:
Wanted Kits voters to explain their votes.
Tried again to get Sparks to put forth his own ideas.
Overall assessment: Found it interesting that like Kalor, he has started today suspicious of the Kits voters which does make sense considering she was town, but I find out interesting. He has been trying to get Sparks to actively scum hunt which is appreciate, but at this point i don't really get his reasoning for voting Stu two days in a row and I'd like to hear what he thinks of the other players in general. Looking over his posts, he was debating with people, but I'm not seeing much scum hunting so I definitely need to see more before I can consider town reading him.
He's a pretty big null read for me.
---
Z-Beat: Lots of fluffy death stranding posts. Said he'd kill Zeke out of spite, and then he asked Kits for her thoughts on Zeke which is interesting.
Asked Kits later to answer the question and said the train on Fran was sudden and he thought either wee or Kits were scum
With the double claim, he suggested that the one lying is most likely the one claiming first because they are hoping to drag out the actual claim. He then also talked about who would have to put more work in flavor wise to make their claim.
Z-Beat loves his flavor so this is not surprising at all. XD
After Fran's death he analyzed the posts of who was commenting afterwords, finding Fanto the most suspicious because he thinks Fanto would have noticed Fran died before making some of his later posts.
This analysis was interesting and seems like something Z-Beat would do, but it doesn't mean much.
He was critical CS' flavor claim which proved to be fake. I'm quoting it purely because I really like this post (but that's because I'm an AA fan)
He mainly spent a lot of day 1 focusing on the claim between CS and Zeke.
Day 2: Focused on the Kopite matter and speculating who he hid behind.
Doesn't believe at all in a scum vig based on game play reasons.
Mentions Soneji a few times wanting him to post more.
Voted him only to unvote after Soneji backed up Sparks.
His top three scum when asked by Stu, notably two people who have largely been suspects and Kits who turned out town.
Found LP's theory Kopite hide behind Zeke interesting.
Votes for Kits based on these posts:
His reasoning was partly for her conversation about Zeke where she didn't answer his question about him and she responded later that she wouldn't vote for him based on meta and because she suspected a scum day vig.
This seams like weird reasoning to me.
Day 3: Apparently didn't see Turmoil's claim at the end of day 2?
Overall Assessment: One thing I noticed with this reread on him as that he has had a weird focus on Zeke, though apparently this is based on past experience with Zeke, but it's still a bit weird? I also feel like his reasoning for voting Kits was pretty weak. I've liked a lot of his posts, but I want to see stuff like a reads list from him. I was feeling okay about him earlier in the game, but now I'm kind of wondering why, but at this point I'll give him a slight town read as he hasn't done anything too suspicious.
When asked by Bae who would be his second lunch target he picked LP because of his posting style making him hard to read
Was critcal of Soneji's vote on Kits for a word she used.
Felt good about Fran and Fran's point that town Sparks doesn't care if people are scumreading him.
Agreed with Turm and voted for Stu
Was okay with a CS Lunch.
Day 2: Supported suspicion on Bae
Voted Stu again felt his stance on him hadn't changed.
Called out Sparks on his lack of actually putting forth his own thoughts.
Day 3:
Wanted Kits voters to explain their votes.
Tried again to get Sparks to put forth his own ideas.
Overall assessment: Found it interesting that like Kalor, he has started today suspicious of the Kits voters which does make sense considering she was town, but I find out interesting. He has been trying to get Sparks to actively scum hunt which is appreciate, but at this point i don't really get his reasoning for voting Stu two days in a row and I'd like to hear what he thinks of the other players in general. Looking over his posts, he was debating with people, but I'm not seeing much scum hunting so I definitely need to see more before I can consider town reading him.
He's a pretty big null read for me.
---
Z-Beat: Lots of fluffy death stranding posts. Said he'd kill Zeke out of spite, and then he asked Kits for her thoughts on Zeke which is interesting.
Asked Kits later to answer the question and said the train on Fran was sudden and he thought either wee or Kits were scum
With the double claim, he suggested that the one lying is most likely the one claiming first because they are hoping to drag out the actual claim. He then also talked about who would have to put more work in flavor wise to make their claim.
Z-Beat loves his flavor so this is not surprising at all. XD
After Fran's death he analyzed the posts of who was commenting afterwords, finding Fanto the most suspicious because he thinks Fanto would have noticed Fran died before making some of his later posts.
This analysis was interesting and seems like something Z-Beat would do, but it doesn't mean much.
He was critical CS' flavor claim which proved to be fake. I'm quoting it purely because I really like this post (but that's because I'm an AA fan)
He mainly spent a lot of day 1 focusing on the claim between CS and Zeke.
Day 2: Focused on the Kopite matter and speculating who he hid behind.
Doesn't believe at all in a scum vig based on game play reasons.
Mentions Soneji a few times wanting him to post more.
Voted him only to unvote after Soneji backed up Sparks.
His top three scum when asked by Stu, notably two people who have largely been suspects and Kits who turned out town.
Found LP's theory Kopite hide behind Zeke interesting.
Votes for Kits based on these posts:
His reasoning was partly for her conversation about Zeke where she didn't answer his question about him and she responded later that she wouldn't vote for him based on meta and because she suspected a scum day vig.
This seams like weird reasoning to me.
Day 3: Apparently didn't see Turmoil's claim at the end of day 2?
Overall Assessment: One thing I noticed with this reread on him as that he has had a weird focus on Zeke, though apparently this is based on past experience with Zeke, but it's still a bit weird? I also feel like his reasoning for voting Kits was pretty weak. I've liked a lot of his posts, but I want to see stuff like a reads list from him. I was feeling okay about him earlier in the game, but now I'm kind of wondering why, but at this point I'll give him a slight town read as he hasn't done anything too suspicious.
Also seriously Sparks you are going to agree with my scum argument against Malus, vote for him, and then accuse me of being scum ???
??? ???
??? ???
I men
It felt really roundabout even though I thought my question was pretty straightforward
Zeke: First major posts were debating with Fran about the stu list thing.
His roleclaim made after CS's claim where he claims credit for the kill
His response to CS' claim was typical Zeke just saying he has no clue what CS was doing and again claiming credit for the kill.
Voted CS.
He analyzed how people responded to the double claim and later how they were reading him after CS turned out town, both of which seemed like a lot of good work honestly.
Mainly argued that his shot was NAI and him acting like himself is NAI which is why he asked why I was townreading Fran for being Fran when I was null reading him.
He's actively scumhunting and asking questions of people when he finds what they were doing suspicious.
I even appreciate that he quested my failed vote on Turmoil.
He even questioned Soneji and Sparks about if their alignments as lovers could be different which a valid concern even if that sort of issue would be more likely in a bastard game.
Over all Assessment: At this point I'm going to give him a strong town reading as while the vig shot will probably always be NAI (I've been suspicious of Day Vigs in other games after all), the rest of his posts have been fine.
---
Abs: was suspicious of why Sparks was concerned when he only had one vote on him.
His take on later CS votes was that the votes being made were too easy as CS is an easy target. He also threw shade on people being suspicious of Fran after Fran had died.
He seemed to believe CS' neutral power claimed telling him it wasn't his fault for messing up.
Another part of the later CS votes being lazy thing.
He definitely thought that both Zeke and CS had used a power.
Found Rac and Soneji weird for their conversation about the Fran matter.
He found nin's support of Stu's post suspicious but was unwilling to vote for him because he wouldn't be there. He was considering Kopite but didn't because he was sick. Mainly this post just shows that he likes to explain where he would vote if he could, but why he isn't.
Voted Kopite in the end.
Day 2: He has been pretty actively asking questions and putting forth his opinions on other players which I do appreciate.
Suspicious of Turmoil for the whole Sparks claiming matter.
Votes on Kits finding her train the most suspicious
This happened before the tie up between Malus and Kits more notably. I mention this because if Malus is scum, we need to look at who tried to break the tie by putting Kits in the lead.
Overall assessment: He's been pretty active in asking questions and finding posts for people, and really the only thing I find suspicious about him is when he throws shade at matters after the fact like I pointed up above. For now he's a town read.
His roleclaim made after CS's claim where he claims credit for the kill
His response to CS' claim was typical Zeke just saying he has no clue what CS was doing and again claiming credit for the kill.
Voted CS.
He analyzed how people responded to the double claim and later how they were reading him after CS turned out town, both of which seemed like a lot of good work honestly.
Mainly argued that his shot was NAI and him acting like himself is NAI which is why he asked why I was townreading Fran for being Fran when I was null reading him.
He's actively scumhunting and asking questions of people when he finds what they were doing suspicious.
I even appreciate that he quested my failed vote on Turmoil.
He even questioned Soneji and Sparks about if their alignments as lovers could be different which a valid concern even if that sort of issue would be more likely in a bastard game.
Over all Assessment: At this point I'm going to give him a strong town reading as while the vig shot will probably always be NAI (I've been suspicious of Day Vigs in other games after all), the rest of his posts have been fine.
---
Abs: was suspicious of why Sparks was concerned when he only had one vote on him.
His take on later CS votes was that the votes being made were too easy as CS is an easy target. He also threw shade on people being suspicious of Fran after Fran had died.
He seemed to believe CS' neutral power claimed telling him it wasn't his fault for messing up.
Another part of the later CS votes being lazy thing.
He definitely thought that both Zeke and CS had used a power.
Found Rac and Soneji weird for their conversation about the Fran matter.
He found nin's support of Stu's post suspicious but was unwilling to vote for him because he wouldn't be there. He was considering Kopite but didn't because he was sick. Mainly this post just shows that he likes to explain where he would vote if he could, but why he isn't.
Voted Kopite in the end.
Day 2: He has been pretty actively asking questions and putting forth his opinions on other players which I do appreciate.
Suspicious of Turmoil for the whole Sparks claiming matter.
Votes on Kits finding her train the most suspicious
This happened before the tie up between Malus and Kits more notably. I mention this because if Malus is scum, we need to look at who tried to break the tie by putting Kits in the lead.
Overall assessment: He's been pretty active in asking questions and finding posts for people, and really the only thing I find suspicious about him is when he throws shade at matters after the fact like I pointed up above. For now he's a town read.
LOL are you getting upset Zeke that people keep telling you they explained why when they voted instead of actually telling you then? XD
More annoyed. I feel that if it was a "genuine" vote they could give a lil short sentence or two on why they voted the way they did.
Them telling me to go look it up just makes me think their reasoning was weak in the first place.
I could accept that response of it was about a topic we've been going in circles about, but it isn't.
I hope that makes sense.
Yeah that makes sense. I guess it's why I always try to answer people's questions when they have them for me. XD
This also reminds me of when Sparks asked me who the low posters were on d1 when all he had to do was look at the voting tool. XD
Has been Scumreading Pirate_Malus all game which has definitely been consistent.
Asking questions of people and actively scum hunting. Serious vote wise day 1 voted for Fran, but ended up on Fanto do a suspicion. On day 2 voted for Bae and then Malus after the replacement.
Felt the "who Kopite hid behind argument" inconclusive.
Has a given a few read lists such as this:
Most of it seems reasonable, though the Kits comment seems to be a joke. XD
She argued that roles mean nothing alignment wise and it should be based on the reads of that player when talking about Zeke.
Didn't believe Sparks lover claim because the flavor didn't make sense. Accepted it more or less once Soneji backed him up.
Maintained her vote on Malus, but looked into Turmoil, so willing to look elsewhere at other suspects even if they turn out town.
Overall assessment: wee is still a strong town read as I have consistently not seen anything suspicious from her. Big Shocker I know.
---
Sparks: Day 1: His first comment was mostly saying "Welp everyone is shitposting"
He said this when I had my joke vote on him and people were discussing him and CS. Abs found this post suspicious
His first serious series of posts that weren't asking questions and trying to get people to talk. I actually asked for him to explain his reasoning better at the time.
He then made this weird post that Fran used against him later.
Voted for CS as a response to the double claims and what discussion had happened.
Then he made this response.
He stayed on CS for the rest of the day.
Day 2: The claim happened and that's been discussed. Basically I still believe he's partners with Soneji and because of Soneji I believe they are town.
He however has been riding on the lovers reveal as proof he's town and honestly this feels like something town sparks would do???
He had several votes on day 2, but he ended up on Malus after he replaced in and naturally I think that was a good vote. XD
Him voting Malus today is at least consistant.
Overall Assessment: Hey Funky Dude Sparks can you do my solid and give me a readlist of all the players when you have the time? Otherwise, he's a town lean largely because of Soneji.
Asking questions of people and actively scum hunting. Serious vote wise day 1 voted for Fran, but ended up on Fanto do a suspicion. On day 2 voted for Bae and then Malus after the replacement.
Felt the "who Kopite hid behind argument" inconclusive.
Has a given a few read lists such as this:
Most of it seems reasonable, though the Kits comment seems to be a joke. XD
She argued that roles mean nothing alignment wise and it should be based on the reads of that player when talking about Zeke.
Didn't believe Sparks lover claim because the flavor didn't make sense. Accepted it more or less once Soneji backed him up.
Maintained her vote on Malus, but looked into Turmoil, so willing to look elsewhere at other suspects even if they turn out town.
Overall assessment: wee is still a strong town read as I have consistently not seen anything suspicious from her. Big Shocker I know.
---
Sparks: Day 1: His first comment was mostly saying "Welp everyone is shitposting"
He said this when I had my joke vote on him and people were discussing him and CS. Abs found this post suspicious
His first serious series of posts that weren't asking questions and trying to get people to talk. I actually asked for him to explain his reasoning better at the time.
He then made this weird post that Fran used against him later.
Voted for CS as a response to the double claims and what discussion had happened.
Then he made this response.
He stayed on CS for the rest of the day.
Day 2: The claim happened and that's been discussed. Basically I still believe he's partners with Soneji and because of Soneji I believe they are town.
He however has been riding on the lovers reveal as proof he's town and honestly this feels like something town sparks would do???
He had several votes on day 2, but he ended up on Malus after he replaced in and naturally I think that was a good vote. XD
Him voting Malus today is at least consistant.
Overall Assessment: Hey Funky Dude Sparks can you do my solid and give me a readlist of all the players when you have the time? Otherwise, he's a town lean largely because of Soneji.
Z-Beat I don't see where you went n depth on kits. I just searched "kits"
This was day 1. Do you still think there is scum between the two since kits has flipped.
This is your response to stu questioning kits in your top 3 scum. So is that it or am I missing something?
Stu: Day 1, Zeke was his second pick for lunching in response to Bae.
Makes that post of his top scum picks as a joke post to sees peoples responses and causes this to be the main discussion point for day 1 besides the Zeke vs CS stuff.
The post was a joke but it's fun noting that Fran, rac, and CS were town and wee has been pretty town read. XD Would Scum!Stu even as a joke pick all townies for a reads list? Possibly, but it's honestly NAI and means nothing. XD
However, unlike Zeke who in response to the posts about him after the double claims and went over them, he made this post
Without really analyzing what happening, instead telling us to "decide" whether it was useful or not.
Votes Sparks after Fran's post about Sparks.
Wasn't sure whether to believe Zeke or CS but thought the power was wasted.
Questioned CS throughly about his neutral abilities.
Didn't get why Fanto put Turmoil high up on his list and he found it weird.
Voted CS where he stayed for rest of day.
He told rac he would Turmoil or Sparks if CS hadn't claimed.
Day 2: Was suspicious of Soneji, Turm, Kalor, and wanted to look into Bae because he didn't remember her posts. Told others to look into LP because he can't read him.
A reasonable post he made in response to be about his activity on day 1
Seemed pretty consistently suspicious of Turmoil.
He even did a more serious analysis into Turm when asked about it so even if Turm was town I can see his reasoning.
Voted Sparks for Fran. XD
But then voted Kalor to mix things up.
Didn't believe Sparks claim until Soneji backed him up.
Commented that Soneji hasn't commented yet today.
Voted Turmoil for his "Sparks would claim eventually with us voting him so why not get it over with now" post.
Voted Bae to self-preserve.
Was getting nervous as vote lead.
Says scum might be someone no one would expect like me (First mention about me before his theory today), and votes Kits. Was the second person on her train besides Kits who voted as a joke LOL.
More suspicions about me all of this is just NAI though.
Votes Turm and largely tries to encourage people voting for him.
New Scum read list is wee (?) and Kalor (this makes sense LOL) and includes me again.
And we've all seen his theories about wee and I. xD
Overall Assessment: Not sure how to feel about him fully, though he was suspicious of (T) Turm for a while so his vote wasn't out of nowhere. He was the first to start the new Turm train that Kalor was calling for, which doesn't help his case. Like I said his current theories and recent suspicions on me is honestly NAI as town is going to town. He's a Null read for now because I'm still unsure.
Makes that post of his top scum picks as a joke post to sees peoples responses and causes this to be the main discussion point for day 1 besides the Zeke vs CS stuff.
The post was a joke but it's fun noting that Fran, rac, and CS were town and wee has been pretty town read. XD Would Scum!Stu even as a joke pick all townies for a reads list? Possibly, but it's honestly NAI and means nothing. XD
However, unlike Zeke who in response to the posts about him after the double claims and went over them, he made this post
Without really analyzing what happening, instead telling us to "decide" whether it was useful or not.
Votes Sparks after Fran's post about Sparks.
Wasn't sure whether to believe Zeke or CS but thought the power was wasted.
Questioned CS throughly about his neutral abilities.
Didn't get why Fanto put Turmoil high up on his list and he found it weird.
Voted CS where he stayed for rest of day.
He told rac he would Turmoil or Sparks if CS hadn't claimed.
Day 2: Was suspicious of Soneji, Turm, Kalor, and wanted to look into Bae because he didn't remember her posts. Told others to look into LP because he can't read him.
A reasonable post he made in response to be about his activity on day 1
Seemed pretty consistently suspicious of Turmoil.
He even did a more serious analysis into Turm when asked about it so even if Turm was town I can see his reasoning.
Voted Sparks for Fran. XD
But then voted Kalor to mix things up.
Didn't believe Sparks claim until Soneji backed him up.
Commented that Soneji hasn't commented yet today.
Voted Turmoil for his "Sparks would claim eventually with us voting him so why not get it over with now" post.
Voted Bae to self-preserve.
Was getting nervous as vote lead.
Says scum might be someone no one would expect like me (First mention about me before his theory today), and votes Kits. Was the second person on her train besides Kits who voted as a joke LOL.
More suspicions about me all of this is just NAI though.
Votes Turm and largely tries to encourage people voting for him.
New Scum read list is wee (?) and Kalor (this makes sense LOL) and includes me again.
And we've all seen his theories about wee and I. xD
Overall Assessment: Not sure how to feel about him fully, though he was suspicious of (T) Turm for a while so his vote wasn't out of nowhere. He was the first to start the new Turm train that Kalor was calling for, which doesn't help his case. Like I said his current theories and recent suspicions on me is honestly NAI as town is going to town. He's a Null read for now because I'm still unsure.
All right I am done with my reads =-= Here is a summary of where i put everyone alignment wise:
Town reads:
wee
Zeke
Soneji/Sparks (since they sort of have to be together)
LP
Chuggs
Abs
Z-Beat
null:
Stu
Stan
nin
Scum:
Kalor
Malus
Town reads:
wee
Zeke
Soneji/Sparks (since they sort of have to be together)
LP
Chuggs
Abs
Z-Beat
null:
Stu
Stan
nin
Scum:
Kalor
Malus
fukin ell sorry yall, i ended up bizarrely busy and had little time to put into this game.
Of the options that i think people pushed the most today i would be pretty down with a stu, kalor, or a malus lunch.
Stu would still be my strongest, tho by less than in previous days, and it doesnt seem like that would likely be followed so instead imma vote with my next in line,
vote: Kalor
i feel less strong about malus as i still cant parse much of baes behavior from her just being unable to play much, and malus himself hasnt really caught my ire.
Of the options that i think people pushed the most today i would be pretty down with a stu, kalor, or a malus lunch.
Stu would still be my strongest, tho by less than in previous days, and it doesnt seem like that would likely be followed so instead imma vote with my next in line,
vote: Kalor
i feel less strong about malus as i still cant parse much of baes behavior from her just being unable to play much, and malus himself hasnt really caught my ire.
I finally have time to play and the game has been quiet. And the people I suspect most aren't posting so I can't get anything new from them.
Since it's came up, and I don't have much else to talk about right now, I may as well address some of the votes against me. Obviously Turmoil flipping tracker reflects poorly on me since I didn't believe it at the time but I wasn't the only person who ignored the flip. Not that it exonerates me but it's worth looking at Stu/Kits/Malus/Loki who also ignored the claim. I think someone said it was a sudden shift for me but I was wary of Turmoil all day with the way they got Sparks to claim.
Also Soneji , Z-Beat why did you vote for Kits yesterday because I don't recall you two ever mentioning reasoning.
Since it's came up, and I don't have much else to talk about right now, I may as well address some of the votes against me. Obviously Turmoil flipping tracker reflects poorly on me since I didn't believe it at the time but I wasn't the only person who ignored the flip. Not that it exonerates me but it's worth looking at Stu/Kits/Malus/Loki who also ignored the claim. I think someone said it was a sudden shift for me but I was wary of Turmoil all day with the way they got Sparks to claim.
Also Soneji , Z-Beat why did you vote for Kits yesterday because I don't recall you two ever mentioning reasoning.
I finally have time to play again.
I don't have any strong feelings about Kalor, will have to do some further reading in that direction.
As previously said I felt worst about nin yesterday, but I'll have to go back again to see what specifically stood out to me.
I don't have any strong feelings about Kalor, will have to do some further reading in that direction.
As previously said I felt worst about nin yesterday, but I'll have to go back again to see what specifically stood out to me.
So about half way through day 2 nin said he would either vote AB or Sparks (at this time he had already voted AB)
But then com EoD he suddenly switches to Stu, when that train was quite behind the leading trains at that time. No comment on the vote leaders and a flimsy reasoning for his vote.
But then com EoD he suddenly switches to Stu, when that train was quite behind the leading trains at that time. No comment on the vote leaders and a flimsy reasoning for his vote.
Today he has a whopping 1 post. I would really love to hear more here, and especially what his thoughts on AB and Stu are now.
I reread Kalor. His basic criticisms of poor play decisions read fine, and take up a bunch of space. He has voted with reasoning.
It's possible to conclude he is protecting malus, as he keeps asking why people are voting malus, then drops a vote there himself, then moves back to turmoil. So it looks like a pretend vote.
His content could be seen as town, but voting matters, so if malus is scum I'd be doubly interested in seeing Kalor's flip too. But since that's the only note that bugs me about Kalor, I'd lunch malus > kalor.
It's possible to conclude he is protecting malus, as he keeps asking why people are voting malus, then drops a vote there himself, then moves back to turmoil. So it looks like a pretend vote.
His content could be seen as town, but voting matters, so if malus is scum I'd be doubly interested in seeing Kalor's flip too. But since that's the only note that bugs me about Kalor, I'd lunch malus > kalor.
Response to loki's work:
my D1 vote on Fran was NOT a serious vote and i explained previously that I dropped it into the middle of a kits argument to see what would happen. There was 0 chance of my voting a townish looking fran on D1.
my D1 vote on Fran was NOT a serious vote and i explained previously that I dropped it into the middle of a kits argument to see what would happen. There was 0 chance of my voting a townish looking fran on D1.
Stan is really hard to read at the moment. He doesn't bring forth many opinions and yesterday he voted Stu pretty early in the day and just left it there. Him not being present for the EoD spectacle doesn't make it easier either.
His reasoning for the vote was basically that nothing had changed since day 1.
D1:
His reasoning for the vote was basically that nothing had changed since day 1.
D1:
D2:
How do you feel about Stu today?
One player I'd love to hear more from is also Sparks. They've been able to coast on their lovers claim when normally, they'd probably be a lynch candidate by now with the contents of their posts being brief and a lack of reasoning/theories.
Reread Soneji, who seemed towny on D1 for going after leads and didn't appear to be leaving anyone out of reads. I've liked his arguments which has misled me in the past lol, but still he makes good points.
His scumread of me is expected from someone who has never played with me before. I do a lot of weird shit. Next game it can turn to paranoia voting like stu and fanto lol.
Soneji, where are you. We've got some things to do now.
His scumread of me is expected from someone who has never played with me before. I do a lot of weird shit. Next game it can turn to paranoia voting like stu and fanto lol.
Soneji, where are you. We've got some things to do now.
OP
OP
==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start
malus (2 votes)
lokiduck - #1,835
Funky Dude Sparks - #1,836
nin (2 votes)
Kalor - #1,820
absolutbro - #1,886
Kalor (2 votes)
Stuart444 - #1,726 #1,772
TheChuggernaut - #1,851
Stantastic - #1,883
lokiduck (1 votes)
Stuart444 - #1,772
Z-Beat (1 votes)
EzekelRAGE - #1,882
Not voting: nin, malus, Z-Beat, weemadarthur, Soneji, Lone_Prodigy
Post Counts:
lokiduck: 38 TheChuggernaut: 23 EzekelRAGE: 22 Funky Dude Sparks: 16 weemadarthur: 15 Stuart444: 13 Stantastic: 11 absolutbro: 10 Kalor: 9 malus: 8 Z-Beat: 6 Lone_Prodigy: 6 Soneji: 2 nin: 2
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
malus (2 votes)
lokiduck - #1,835
Funky Dude Sparks - #1,836
nin (2 votes)
Kalor - #1,820
absolutbro - #1,886
Kalor (2 votes)
TheChuggernaut - #1,851
Stantastic - #1,883
lokiduck (1 votes)
Stuart444 - #1,772
Z-Beat (1 votes)
EzekelRAGE - #1,882
Not voting: nin, malus, Z-Beat, weemadarthur, Soneji, Lone_Prodigy
Post Counts:
lokiduck: 38 TheChuggernaut: 23 EzekelRAGE: 22 Funky Dude Sparks: 16 weemadarthur: 15 Stuart444: 13 Stantastic: 11 absolutbro: 10 Kalor: 9 malus: 8 Z-Beat: 6 Lone_Prodigy: 6 Soneji: 2 nin: 2
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!