Scooby-Doo Mafia |OT| Where are you?

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

Reading chuggs' contributions since subbing into a slot I have suspicions of:

TheChuggernaut said:
I skimmed a lot of day 2 because I ran out of time. From what I gathered Zeke and Malus are maybe okay. Anything else I missed?

TheChuggernaut said:
Didn't Turmoil track him/Bae or did I read that wrong? He could just be scum that didn't move I suppose

TheChuggernaut said:
I think there's scum between Kalor and Malus. Not sure if it's both of them because two scum stacking on town is shady. Going to read both of them later. I have a hard time reading both of them tbh

TheChuggernaut said:
Vote: Kalor

Just in the interest of having another train

Yeah, he starts with a save-bae/malus post, concentrates on the stuff that could protect the slot, pairs malus with kalor and then votes kalor first.

See this bugs me because he quick switches from town!malus read to scum!malus read, but has someone to put in front of malus either way.

Aeleus · Nov 30, 2019

With almost half the players being under 10 posts I'm considering giving a 24 hour day extension.

If enough people tell me they want it (PM me) I'll extend the day in around ~2:30 hours.

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

^ I don't care either way. I'll leave it up to everyone else.

Kalor · Nov 30, 2019

weemadarthur said:
Reading chuggs' contributions since subbing into a slot I have suspicions of:

Yeah, he starts with a save-bae/malus post, concentrates on the stuff that could protect the slot, pairs malus with kalor and then votes kalor first.

See this bugs me because he quick switches from town!malus read to scum!malus read, but has someone to put in front of malus either way.

Yeah. The Malus/Kalor pairing had been talked about enough prior to those posts that I could see scum Chuggs seeing that and deciding to use it since they weren't caught up enough to do anything else. Although there's nothing stopping town from doing the same so it's not particular indicative of anything.

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

Stuart444 said:
^ I don't care either way. I'll leave it up to everyone else.

Ditto. I don't unwant it.

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

I've moved Z-Beat from townread down to null. Never was sure why I townread him in the first place. Plausibly for his dry sense of humour. I'll work on that.

Nin is equal to him in my reads. Total null.

i'm not feeling badly about kalor, i have him as slight town lean. With stan.

Suspicious of: chuggs, malus, stu, my reasonings are posted earlier.

malus · Nov 30, 2019

LP is a hard read as always.
Here is his vote on Kalor from D2:

Lone_Prodigy said:
Fanto seems tougher to read this game. He's doing his usual high post count thing but he seems moody and inconsistent. Sorry if that's based on RL stuff, but that's my observation. I wouldn't vote for him today but wouldn't put him on my top town list.

I went through Sparks' posts and yeah there isn't too much substance despite his post count. You could justify his most recent vote on turmoil but you could justify any other vote on anyone at this stage.

Pirate Bae has been a non factor but says she's busy so I'm not sure why she's getting extra attention when there are a lot of other quieter posters.

Vote: Kalor

Doubt this does anything nor will this be my final vote but it's as good a place as any.

This vote came right after Stu had put his vote on Kalor as well. LP says he will probably switch again, but ends up staying there anyway.
He is there at EoD, but despite throwing some light shade at Turmoil, he still keeps his vote on Kalor, who at that point is clearly out of the race.

Lone_Prodigy said:
Turmoil is all over the place. Today he has voted for:

Sparks
malus/Bae
AB
Fanto
Stu
LP

This after he compelled Sparks to claim early.

How did you come up with 5?

Today he has thrown again some light shade my and Kalors way, but so far hasn't taken a clear stance.

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

weemadarthur said:
i'm not feeling badly about kalor, i have him as slight town lean. With stan.

why on both of those?

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

Stuart444 said:
why on both of those?

I reread kalor upthread and stan hasn't changed from previous day phase. I DID SAY.

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

LP has improved in my opinion in the past day phase or so.

malus is attacking low quantity posters. But not with much vigor. I could be self blinded but i don't see me moving on without flip.

vote: malus

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

weemadarthur said:
I reread kalor upthread and stan hasn't changed from previous day phase. I DID SAY.

Eh, the Kalor stuff you posted sounds like your trying to sound iffy incase the winds change so you can vote him without seeming like it's a bus attempt.

As for Stan, do explain again, and why hasn't your feelings on him changed?

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

Stuart444 said:
Eh, the Kalor stuff you posted sounds like your trying to sound iffy incase the winds change so you can vote him without seeming like it's a bus attempt.

As for Stan, do explain again, and why hasn't your feelings on him changed?

You must be confusing me with loki. When have *I* ever said I'd jump through hoops for other people's reads of me? I get other people to google things for me.

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

weemadarthur said:
You must be confusing me with loki. When have *I* ever said I'd jump through hoops for other people's reads of me? I get other people to google things for me.

🤨

Vote: wee

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

I move that we all vote Wee.

Failing that, I would move that we all vote Kalor.

Malus is probably going to be a bad lunch.

Soneji · Nov 30, 2019

Holidays are the worst in terms of remembering mafia, sigh.

VOTE: malus

Just sticking my vote here for now while I try to do a few things in the few hours left. Pirate Bae acted like they weren't in the know yet had insights into some players/situations as if they actually did and had some bad shade thrown my way.

Kalor · Nov 30, 2019

Stuart444 said:
I move that we all vote Wee.

Failing that, I would move that we all vote Kalor.

Malus is probably going to be a bad lunch.

Why should people vote Wee?

Soneji · Nov 30, 2019

In the interest of saving time finding anything, has Zeke made any other shots/claimed his exact role/explained the lack of further shots?

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

Kalor said:
Why should people vote Wee?

Her responses above.

And her flip will cement (or destroy) quite a few other suspicions in my mind.

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

Soneji said:
In the interest of saving time finding anything, has Zeke made any other shots/claimed his exact role/explained the lack of further shots?

no

Soneji · Nov 30, 2019

Kalor said:
Also Soneji , Z-Beat why did you vote for Kits yesterday because I don't recall you two ever mentioning reasoning.

My reasoning was carried over from earlier days when I thought they looked suspect for being hedgy, overly reactionary to suspicion and then later throwing doubt towards Spark's and I Lover's claim.

Soneji · Nov 30, 2019

Stuart444 said:
no

That's a bit wack. EzekelRAGE what's going on in regards to your role?

Z-Beat · Nov 30, 2019

Kalor said:
Also @Soneji , @Z-Beat why did you vote for Kits yesterday because I don't recall you two ever mentioning reasoning.

@zeeland you thought I was over exaggerating

Z-Beat · Nov 30, 2019

EzekelRAGE sorry that was supposed to @ you. Mobile is weird on mentions

Kalor · Nov 30, 2019

Z-Beat said:
@zeeland you thought I was over exaggerating

That doesn't answer the question.

Aeleus · Nov 30, 2019

Due to the day starting on a holiday and otherwise poor activity it has been decided that the day will be extended for 24 hours.

Day 3 now ends in:

lokiduck · Nov 30, 2019

weemadarthur said:
Response to loki's work:
my D1 vote on Fran was NOT a serious vote and i explained previously that I dropped it into the middle of a kits argument to see what would happen. There was 0 chance of my voting a townish looking fran on D1.

Thank you for the clarification.

lokiduck · Nov 30, 2019

LOL I decided to do laundry this morning figure I'd still have enough time to be back before end day and now we have an extension.

In either case I'll be doing Laundry between posting for a few hours.

absolutbro · Nov 30, 2019

yeah, I moved basically everything around to be here EoD. Checking in between groceries and feeding the animals. I'll be around in a bit.

Soneji said:
In the interest of saving time finding anything, has Zeke made any other shots/claimed his exact role/explained the lack of further shots?

Stuart444 said:
no

EzekelRAGE said:
Ok...... so that was me. I'm daphne. Day vig. I have my butler "remove" a person. I chose Fran because I thought he was purposely creating noise when he said his poking stu was a shitpost. That was like his first time saying that.

*truffleshuffle*

How can some of you remember how someone played seven seasons ago, but can't remember the first actual role claim of this current game?

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

absolutbro said:
How can some of you remember how someone played seven seasons ago, but can't remember the first actual role claim of this current game?

I just said no as in, no, he hasn't claimed in other shots or anything other than his role.

Sorry if that wasn't clear.

TheChuggernaut · Nov 30, 2019

Honestly, I'm alright with the Malus kill too. Just better to have multiple wagon's to see where votes land for the future.

TheChuggernaut · Nov 30, 2019

Stuart444

How confident are you about Wee being scum

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

TheChuggernaut said:
Stuart444

How confident are you about Wee being scum

I'd guess he's OMGUS confident. Lol.
He went from loki to me, and it's fine to be contradictory to the "general read" of the game, but he won't even go get his own ammo for the reasoning. I do enough weird shit he should be able to find some to throw rocks at.

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

Also thanks for that reminder, if stu is scum i'll feel more interested in seeing if zeke is scum, and no i won't explain that.

lokiduck · Nov 30, 2019

I hate apartment community laundry machines.

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

TheChuggernaut said:
Honestly, I'm alright with the Malus kill too. Just better to have multiple wagon's to see where votes land for the future.

Malus was tracked N1. If he's scum that didn't move, it's better to leave him for another time Let's look at it this way:

No scum have died
We have claimed lovers. Assuming they are telling the truth, scum could be waiting to kill them off near mylo/lylo for a quick win before town can figure out wtf is going on.
It's a game with 3 - 4 scum based on the size of the game.

Going after malus just now would be monumentally stupid right now and I can't support it.

TheChuggernaut said:
Stuart444

How confident are you about Wee being scum

Right now, it's 50/50 but part of me feel sure that they are more scum than not. So I guess 51/49 (or 52/48 :P)

But for me, if she flips scum, it could give a lot of connections to other players like Kalor, Loki and possibly even make malus look better since wee is on them right now.

I'll protest lunching malus all the way til EOD unless given a damned damned good reason to lunch them of which we do not have right now.

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

weemadarthur said:
Also thanks for that reminder, if stu is scum i'll feel more interested in seeing if zeke is scum, and no i won't explain that.

Why don't you explain it? It shouldn't hurt you to explain why.

absolutbro · Nov 30, 2019

Stuart444 said:
I just said no as in, no, he hasn't claimed in other shots or anything other than his role.

Sorry if that wasn't clear.

Got it. My post was meant to be tongue in cheek and not exasperated or anything. Apparently this is the game where rereading all my posts makes me feel like an a-hole.

Also, will almost certainly not be around for the new EoD. I will be at the rescue for a test ride. Unless the weather turns to shit or something, I really can't afford to miss it.

Kalor · Nov 30, 2019

Stuart444 said:
But for me, if she flips scum, it could give a lot of connections to other players like Kalor, Loki and possibly even make malus look better since wee is on them right now.

I'll protest lunching malus all the way til EOD unless given a damned damned good reason to lunch them of which we do not have right now.

Can you give more examples of these potential connections?

EzekelRAGE · Nov 30, 2019

Soneji said:
In the interest of saving time finding anything, has Zeke made any other shots/claimed his exact role/explained the lack of further shots?

Soneji said:
That's a bit wack. EzekelRAGE what's going on in regards to your role?

Lol, what is there to explain. I was pretty straight forward in my claim.

weemadarthur said:
Also thanks for that reminder, if stu is scum i'll feel more interested in seeing if zeke is scum, and no i won't explain that.

Please explain why I would be scum of stu flipped scum.

EzekelRAGE · Nov 30, 2019

Z-Beat said:
EzekelRAGE sorry that was supposed to @ you. Mobile is weird on mentions

Kalor said:
That doesn't answer the question.

EzekelRAGE · Nov 30, 2019

*truffleshuffle*

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

Kalor said:
Can you give more examples of these potential connections?

Wees reasoning about feeling town on you. Also having barely spoken about you outside of a quick post on D1 saying it felt like your town game and the posts today.

their voting record isn't the greatest either.

Stan
Fran
Fant
Bae/malus
Bae/malus
malus
malus

See the voting til and click on wee to see that ^ (would post but copy/pasting from that section of the vote tool is really messy x.x)

This feels very careful of wee and is making me feel even more like they may be scum.

TheChuggernaut what do you think?

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

EzekelRAGE said:
Lol, what is there to explain. I was pretty straight forward in my claim.

Please explain why I would be scum of stu flipped scum.

I have spoken.

EzekelRAGE · Nov 30, 2019

*truffleshuffle*

weemadarthur · Nov 30, 2019

Stuart444 said:
Wees reasoning about feeling town on you. Also having barely spoken about you outside of a quick post on D1 saying it felt like your town game and the posts today.

their voting record isn't the greatest either.

Stan
Fran
Fant
Bae/malus
Bae/malus
malus
malus

See the voting til and click on wee to see that ^ (would post but copy/pasting from that section of the vote tool is really messy x.x)

This feels very careful of wee and is making me feel even more like they may be scum.

TheChuggernaut what do you think?

If malus is scum then my voting record is actually aMAZing. Also you left in the joke votes for why? Real votes start at Fant.

Stuart444 · Nov 30, 2019

weemadarthur said:
If malus is scum then my voting record is actually aMAZing. Also you left in the joke votes for why? Real votes start at Fant.

Because it makes you look worse without those votes at a glance.

absolutbro · Nov 30, 2019

I mean, that's a heck of a tunnel, one way or another.

Z-Beat · Nov 30, 2019

Lone_Prodigy said:
Hmm actually looking at it again, no one moves their vote after Kalor besides loki. Turmoil claimed and then there was some discussion, most of which was disbelief. Since we know both Kits and Turmoil were town, scum wouldn't move their vote

This isnt necessarily true. If Turmoil claimed as an investigative role they'd rather him over kits

Kalor said:
That doesn't answer the question.

Then go back and read that whole back and forth, man. I ain't tracking that shit down on mobile

EzekelRAGE · Nov 30, 2019

Z-Beat · Nov 30, 2019

Funky Dude Sparks can you explain yours and Soneji's role again?

Scooby-Doo Mafia |OT| Where are you?

Community Resettler

Resettlement Advisor

Community Resettler

Community Resettler

Community Resettler

Community Resettler

Community Resettler

Resettlement Advisor

One Winged Slayer

One Winged Slayer

Resettlement Advisor

Community Resettler

Community Resettler

Resettlement Advisor

Community Resettler

Community Resettler

One Winged Slayer

One Winged Slayer