Probably, but the last time there was a noisy player D1 in a game I was in they turned out to be scum.
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
The Mansion Mafia - Hold on tightly to your secrets
- Thread starter Brazil
- Start date
Was about to ask you what you thought about that Hecht, but it looks like B-dubs beat me to it. I agree with this assessment; monitor, but it seems a bit much to be scum this early in the game.
We have had a few games where scum ( or a nuetral) had to collect people into a certain chat/hand out items. Once enough of those were passed out the player would activate and all those in the chat/holding the item would die.
Its a very interesting mechanic, but since we all move not really viable for being by room. it would kill everyone, and I don't think Brazil would do that.
and the using a master ball on a bidoof or only pheonix down on the first boss of the game. it is patently ridiculous. Town will have the second most players tomorrow than they possibly could during the entire rest of the game. If this really does pass out BP to everyone it gives us information from night 1 roles, the day 1 flip and the day 1 NK. but we would have more time to work with that, and potentially no NKs to remove good roles from working a second night!
Of course it could just take away our day kill, and if so then my bad I'm sorry.
again though, if passing out the BP early is so bad why not the yellow room? It looks like the flip of the coin to the orange room? you all seem hung up on the using BP, but my real goal here is to not use a bad room up until we know better as to how the rooms work. My thoughts is that yellow room will have the same effect as orange room just only in scum chat. Why is that not a better idea than implementing a post restriction/requirement?
move: yellow room
Therefore scum has downpours figured out a pr and are sacrificing one of their own for a lynch bomb. So zipped is scum but we shouldn't lynch him. Truth really is stranger than fiction!
Zipped, who is looking most suspicious to you right now? Let's see you talk about people rather than rooms.
You're right, it may not be a post requirement, but it sure looks like it.
I see him as a fidgety townie trying every door in the entrance hall, unsure of what to do or where to go.
Other than room mechanics, it's the one thing that has garnered more attention on day one, which is probably the whole point... a starting point for the game.
OP
OP
The post at the start of the Day lists the options that are available for voting during this phase. The White Room is listed as unavailable:
This vote shows up in the vote tool because of the way it's built, but it isn't a valid one. Please move it to another option when you can.
Where has this starting point taken you so far? What info have you gleaned from all the Zipped chat?
You need nothing Godfather, you simply demand. Now that you mention it though...
VOTE: *Splinter
Now, I'm not one to talk, everyone knows how notoriously quiet I am in games. But right now you're sitting with me on the 8 posts bench and still have a vote on you from melonrabbit (a poke vote, but a vote none the less).
Timezones aside, what's going on buddy?
I'm wary of those trying to direct my vote in his direction.
Not gonna single any one person out right now, but my vote this day will probably be based on this - unless something else comes up, of course.
Sorry, I missed it at Day start.
Move: Purple Room
I want to split the votes up a bit more.
It's difficult to describe. Some of their posts just stick out and I'm not quite sure why yet.
reads list:
Scum leaning -
grizzly - played first 24 hours of this day like their first day of Monopoly. gives me a strong scum vibe.
Kitsunelaine - but this is more galaxy brain than anything, why vote for yourself ever? even if it is the first vote? we know there is no tanner, most people would think you are town screwing around but my gut says its scum trying to hide behind something silly.
null read
B-dubs - I'm torn, because I don't agree with you but I'm not sure if that pushes you towards scum leading or just a town disagreement
Town -
Hecht - Even though I disagree with you, you figured out my game on page 4 and then posted about it in the game thread, scum wouldn't go and post that, likely keeping it to scum chat, but town would so instant town for me.
Others that I am still formulating reads on are Stuart444, Kalor, and godfather. I feel like i should have reads on them by now with their posting but I don't.
If I had to vote right now it would be for Grizzly.
move: blue room
How can you not trust his room decisions when he's basically voted for all of them at this point, not really making an actual decision.
I've got a lot I'd want to say about the rooms (I think it has reached the point where my heart is set on going green), but honestly that kind of debate can wait for another day given that dark has a large lead and I don't think I'll change anyone's mind.
Personally I read Zipped's plays as anti-town but not neccesarily scum, though I can certainly understand lynching him to avoid a GoT blarg situation.
I'm wary of it leading to a single bus lynch, so I'll also make a gut vote and go for
VOTE: Z-Beat
Seems to me like a strong move for someone who was newbie scum, as it might lead to a proper conversation with one of the stronger players.
Personally I read Zipped's plays as anti-town but not neccesarily scum, though I can certainly understand lynching him to avoid a GoT blarg situation.
I'm wary of it leading to a single bus lynch, so I'll also make a gut vote and go for
VOTE: Z-Beat
Saenima is currently one of my few town leading reads, not a strong one mind you and I'm probably completely off base but Saenimas reaction to this post:
Seems to me like a strong move for someone who was newbie scum, as it might lead to a proper conversation with one of the stronger players.
Zipped's votes have been all over, but the argument has been for the teal room.
I've been thinking about voting zipped, but that just seems like an easy wagon to fall into without much thought behind it. And he seems to be baiting scummy feels with the room hopping. Idk.
I'll just put a vote down for melonrabbit for now as she's one of the less active posters, with nothing much to offer so far.
Vote: melonrabbit
Any thoughts on the game so far melon?
I'll just put a vote down for melonrabbit for now as she's one of the less active posters, with nothing much to offer so far.
Vote: melonrabbit
Any thoughts on the game so far melon?
Probably more like somebody who read the post requirement theory, and then started to fuck around with it for fun. Wouldnt be the first time for somebody doing something like that in this community.
Having trouble deciding on a vote, Zipped is the one who stands out the most, but thats too much of an easy vote tbh.
Surprisingly I'm town reading Bronson, since he didnt have a mentor I was wary of him maybe acting like he was mentored by the scum team, but it doesnt seem that way so far.
You kinda answered your own question, but on top of that I don't fully agree with seemingly orbiting around teal so early.
I'm curious as to why you're throwing out a gut vote but also criticising a other gut vote.
Also your defence of Saenima is that they asked someone a question?
I figure even if all a Zipped vote does is clear up a bit of smoke, it's probably the only real option atm
If you're referring to my questioning on Stuart's vote I was curious to why he voted, whether it was out of annoyance or actual scum read
If you mean Kalor's I'm definitely not criticising it, it's definitely something to look at, but why not tell him my views, I found certain behaviour from Saenima towny, why hide it from him?
In terms of my feelings on Saenima, I saw the post, thought
and then noted it down to remember for later and then when Kalor brought up his reads, I thought it would be sensible to mention my opinion on the matter.
If you think it stood out to me an unreasonable amount then that's fine but do you want me to pretend I didn't think that?
Yeah I'm going to put my vote down today. Still shooting for the low posters, knowing I'm among them.
I'm thinking to myself about the possible mechanics because apparently talking about it is a good way to catch a bullet around here. I'm thinking about the map layout in particular.
I toyed with that yesterday but nothing jumped out.
We have three "colors" that aren't part of a rainbow: pink, dark, and grey. Purple would be violet and teal would be indigo.
There's no pattern from jumping to red to orange to yellow. etc.
Can't think of any other prominent color arrangements than your typical ROYGBIV.
You still haven't elaborated on your gut read.
And no I wasn't referring to Stuart's vote. I was talking about Kalor's. I'm not suggesting you hide anything, I'm simply questioning you further.
I'm just intrigued that you threw out a gut vote (with no reason as to why you're feeling this) and your defence of someone else was simply that newbie scum wouldn't ask questions. Seems like quite an assumption to make. In both cases really.
I still think that rooms will be more than just "red room", but we won't know for sure until we move.
But, seriously, what room in a house would have glass walls? A Conservatory? There's one of those in Clue.
But, seriously, what room in a house would have glass walls? A Conservatory? There's one of those in Clue.
I'm guessing voting/unvoting is relatively normal?
In which case Vote: Zippedpinhead
I'm amenable to it but I will freely admit the whole constantly changing his room vote is hella confusing to me and I really don't like it
In which case Vote: Zippedpinhead
I'm amenable to it but I will freely admit the whole constantly changing his room vote is hella confusing to me and I really don't like it
I was just letting people know that I'm thinking about them. If I think something is worth sharing and I can defend it as not mere speculation I'll share it for our benefit.
