-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
The Mansion Mafia - Hold on tightly to your secrets
- Thread starter Brazil
- Start date
Anyway, I know my opinion doesn't mean shit at this point, but for my group, here's how I'd lay out the candidates:
Scum
weemadarthur
Zippedpinhead
Kitsunelaine
WhySoDevious
.
.
.
.
(looooooong gap)
.
.
.
.
Girlofgotham
StanleyPalmtree
BronsonLee
Fat4all
Town
Scum
weemadarthur
Zippedpinhead
Kitsunelaine
WhySoDevious
.
.
.
.
(looooooong gap)
.
.
.
.
Girlofgotham
StanleyPalmtree
BronsonLee
Fat4all
Town
before I go to bed I may as well RaNk tHoSe CANDIDATES!
Scum
WhySoDevious
Hecht
Zippedpinhead
NEUTRAL ZONE BEGINS
Fat4all
weemadarthur
Girlofgotham
NEUTRAL ZONE ENDS
StanleyPalmtree
BronsonLee
Town
Scum
WhySoDevious
Hecht
Zippedpinhead
NEUTRAL ZONE BEGINS
Fat4all
weemadarthur
Girlofgotham
NEUTRAL ZONE ENDS
StanleyPalmtree
BronsonLee
Town
No. Hecht claimed in a lull where noone is happening. This whole "so much chaos!!!" sentiment is the nonsense that got feps lynched when he should have been confirmed town.
Fuck no. The only info we get from this is that Hecht is town, which is not info worth lynching for.
I know I've been kinda arguing on the same side as kits here, but I really dislike the actual points she's been making.
I think it means you're both sleepwalkers, it doesn't tell us alignment.
To be fair why are you being so townread? I think there's a lot of sheeping going on around you.
Not fully caught up, and I'm going to be unavailable almost all day. Will post when I can.
Okay. Let's dig into this assertion: Why? Why would feps have been confirmed town? What avenue are you alluding to here, because I don't see it. You'll have to expand on that for me.
Well, you seem pretty sure that Hecht's town. "The only info we'll get". I'll choose not to dig into that phrasing though because for all I know that might be semantics, but I didn't want to let it zip by unremarked upon.
So anyway:
If it's just that you THINK Hecht's likely town, that'll be the point where we disagree on this. I think Hecht's been acting fairly scummy and I'm itching to see that flip. Like I said, I can wait for that, because I scumread people like Devious more. That might seem weird to you but I've just been responding to Hecht more because he's... Y'know, around.
For me it's that I just don't read Bronson as scum. Granted I put him pretty close to town on my read list-- that just means that there's less reason out there to suspect him than the others. I can't speak for others though; you may be right with the sheeping remark.
Fair play Bronson. At least you knew there were others who were going to vote that way before you turboed. I'd have voted there anyway. Thanks for considering that.
We can still talk about our group right?
We can still talk about our group right?
My nightmare is scum having a namecop shot from a JOAT or something any and they namecoping me for some reason so they know my name and prepared all of this beforehand but that would imply several things
-there is a way of knowing other player name and scum has it
-They namecop me at some point
-they decided to do a sleepwalker fakeclaim for some goddamned reason, like if a second sleepwalker would increase scum WSD chances of survival
-the only saving grace from all that madness play is the name WSD/the scumteam came up with
-and WSD not dropping the name in the claim! Instead wishing for me to miraculously having a moment of realization and ask for it myself
-there is a way of knowing other player name and scum has it
-They namecop me at some point
-they decided to do a sleepwalker fakeclaim for some goddamned reason, like if a second sleepwalker would increase scum WSD chances of survival
-the only saving grace from all that madness play is the name WSD/the scumteam came up with
-and WSD not dropping the name in the claim! Instead wishing for me to miraculously having a moment of realization and ask for it myself
Who looks worse if WSD tells the truth?
Kalor or splinter?
Right now everyone else who was silently ok with the wsd lynch doesn't come to mind
I've been going back and forth. If I end up voting him it'll be because of Godfather's role.
Not sure right now as Kalor said it was a tentative vote and Splinter has changed to... Bronson.
That was a pain of 4 or 5 pages to catch up on. My eyes just glazed over all the talk about Hecht because it felt so repetitive but I presume everyone sorted out their differences and are getting along. Also there was literally no reason to turbo. Especially when we don't get a flip until the end of the day. It benefits us in no possible way. It doesn't even clear up discussion because people were barely talking about the Group B lynches besides the occassional comment.
Unvote
I feel slightly better about Devious now with the additional details about their claim, and Turmoil willing to believe them.
Unvote
I feel slightly better about Devious now with the additional details about their claim, and Turmoil willing to believe them.
Why? His self watcher role leads proof that sleepwalkers exist I think. Unless you think turmoil should be lynched because they also claimed sleepwalker.
And if you want to say there is only one sleepwalker then if one flips sleepwalker, you're setting up for a chain lynch. Not the best thing to do imo.
I'm not saying there's only one sleepwalker, but the whole point of Godfather's role is he sees his attempted killer without knowing that for certain. Sleepwalker or not, he could have been trying to kill GF N1.
Just remembered, someone (I think Kits or Stan) asked me why feps should have been locked town. It's the switch from Grizz to Lux with 2 minutes to go. If town hadn't been asleep at the wheel that would have led to Lux' lynch.
Actually I kinda forgot this until now. When I was catching up end of D1, I was surprised noone reacted to feps vote faster. I can only conclude there were more scum on Grizzly who obviously wouldn't want to swap. This was the thing that made me start suspecting Hecht. He was one of the people I would expect to be ready to prevent a tie, and he didn't put a vote in until it was too late to count (which could be accidental or intentional).
Actually I kinda forgot this until now. When I was catching up end of D1, I was surprised noone reacted to feps vote faster. I can only conclude there were more scum on Grizzly who obviously wouldn't want to swap. This was the thing that made me start suspecting Hecht. He was one of the people I would expect to be ready to prevent a tie, and he didn't put a vote in until it was too late to count (which could be accidental or intentional).
Splinter made stu reveal the breadcrumb, IIRC then he was immediately saying WSD was a good lynch? Later after the WSD had rallied support he started saying he wasn't so sure of it, also he wants to lynch
IIRC then it kinda feels like if he put a mislynch in the table for us if WSD is town
IIRC then it kinda feels like if he put a mislynch in the table for us if WSD is town
Yes I'm trying to lynch the people I think are scum.
Welcome to mafia.
I'm a bit stuck because my gut reads don't align with my mechanical deductions. Mechanically we should lynch WSD, but gut says he's only a sleepwalker, and GF's claim lead to him being strong killed.
He switched to Lux one second after the day ended.
Three minutes before day end I said I would switch to Lux if there was a tie
But after I posted that the vote was 9-7 Grizzly at the moment so I relaxed and when I refreshed I saw the chaos and didn't knew what to do, when I finished writing my vote for Lux I looked at the clock and was X:00 so I didn't submit
I felt bad about not having a vote ready during N2
But me saying I would switch is why I think everything after that is NAI
Oh Bronson turbo'd.
How many sleepwalkers have claimed? turmoil and WSD? Did anyone else claim sleepwalker?
How many sleepwalkers have claimed? turmoil and WSD? Did anyone else claim sleepwalker?
Thanks, just wanted to make sure it was straight in my head
Bronson - town
Zipped - null, no idea. That room thing was annoying but I dunno how to take it
Weemadarthur - need to reread but slight scum vibes
Devious - the claim has me swaying from scum lean to town
Kits - leaning scum
Fats - town, the double choices have been people I town read and who could have a good impact on town
Hecht - unsure. I want to believe the claim but it's making the godfather kill confusing
Stan - null. Need a reread but my guy is swaying towards town.
Me - supertown
I am typing this on my lunch break so can't go back for quotes or anything on mobile
OP
OP
==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start
List of Groups
Group A
Kitsunelaine (1 votes)
Muffin - #4,134
Hecht (1 votes)
saenima - #3,956 #4,155
Stuart444 - #4,042
weemadarthur (1 votes)
turmoil7 - #4,411
StanleyPalmtree (0 votes)
Stuart444 - #3,870 #4,042
WhySoDevious (0 votes)
*Splinter - #4,058 #4,515
Kalor - #4,248 #4,511
Not voting: *Splinter, Kalor, B-Dubs, saenima
Post Counts:
Hecht: 174 Kitsunelaine: 114 turmoil7: 101 Stuart444: 94 Zippedpinhead: 53 *Splinter: 50 B-Dubs: 50 BronsonLee: 38 saenima: 38 Kalor: 35 Z-Beat: 29 Girlofgotham: 29 weemadarthur: 28 Fat4all: 24 WhySoDevious: 18 StanleyPalmtree: 15 Muffin: 13
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
List of Groups
Group A
Kitsunelaine (1 votes)
Muffin - #4,134
Hecht (1 votes)
Stuart444 - #4,042
weemadarthur (1 votes)
turmoil7 - #4,411
StanleyPalmtree (0 votes)
WhySoDevious (0 votes)
Not voting: *Splinter, Kalor, B-Dubs, saenima
Post Counts:
Hecht: 174 Kitsunelaine: 114 turmoil7: 101 Stuart444: 94 Zippedpinhead: 53 *Splinter: 50 B-Dubs: 50 BronsonLee: 38 saenima: 38 Kalor: 35 Z-Beat: 29 Girlofgotham: 29 weemadarthur: 28 Fat4all: 24 WhySoDevious: 18 StanleyPalmtree: 15 Muffin: 13
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
OP
OP
==== DAY 3 MOVEMENT ====
Day Start
blue room (Active votes: 8)
stuart444 - #3,817
b-dubs - #3,990
kitsunelaine - #3,993
kalor - #4,199
turmoil7 - #4,367
saenima - #4,368
zippedpinhead - #4,429
whysodevious - #4,527
yellow room (Active votes: 1)
weemadarthur - #3,838
blue (Active votes: 0)
b-dubs - #3,988 #3,990
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
blue room (Active votes: 8)
stuart444 - #3,817
b-dubs - #3,990
kitsunelaine - #3,993
kalor - #4,199
turmoil7 - #4,367
saenima - #4,368
zippedpinhead - #4,429
whysodevious - #4,527
yellow room (Active votes: 1)
weemadarthur - #3,838
blue (Active votes: 0)
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
I was on devious earlier, but I'm waffling now. I'll either stay or maybe move to Kits. I'm stuck away from Era for a lot of today though.
Why not Hecht? I know you've expressed doubt on them before so why not?
I would advocate for not lynching devious though.
I'm not sure about a Hecht flip today to be honest. After his disclosure today, I can more easily believe his claim. That's said, I'm still not totally sold on it.
I'll just put a vote down until I can get back.
Vote: Kitsunelaine