• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Papaya

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
2,474
California
Man, it's gonna be too late. Between Bush and Trump, the rest of the world is gonna think every 8 years the US turns crazy. Then the world will turn to China and Russia.
 

metalslimer

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
9,566
As a future doctor who has looked into the research there isn't great data that shows massive benefits of breastfeeding. Its is definitely the food of choice to feed children due to the antibodies crossing over and giving the infant protection from some gastrointestinal infections but the data on whether it improves IQ isn't there yet.

I agree that women shouldn't be shamed for not breastfeeding but women who do should be protected
 

hans_castorp

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,459
I was breastfed (and my mom can't shut up about how it's responsible for everything good in my life ) but I feel like I haven't seen strong, steel-clad evidence it makes a significant difference (it seems somewhat minor). I am not sure we need to badger women into necessarily breastfeeding their kids.
But I'll admit I have not researched the question deeply (just read a bit after looking at the corresponding items on 23andme)
There is plenty of literature about breastfeeding's benefits. Not just for the kid, but for mother too. It can even lower breast cancer risk.

And yeah the formula lobby is pretty big. They tried to pull some really shady shit in my city years ago. It was a big scandal.
 

bane833

Banned
Nov 3, 2017
4,530
Don't know a single country except the US were this degree of open corporate shilling is tolerated. Holy Fuck.
 

Lady Catherine de Bourgh

Teyvat Traveler
Member
Oct 27, 2017
832
What narrative that formula is better for your child? I've only ever heard how important breastfeeding is and even shaming of women that choose to (or must) rely on formula. And I have a newborn so I don't think I'm out of touch. Doctors are visibly uncomfortable even brining up the idea of supplementing with formula

I have understood that this was an issue in Europe in the seventies and still is an issue in some developing countries. Although I haven't actively read up on the topic in the lest 10 years so maybe this has changed in the last decade.
 

Chae3001

Member
Oct 27, 2017
597
Sure, but it brings tons of guilt to mothers who are not able to breastfed (I know at least two). There are lots of women who also would prefer not to breastfeed, even though they can, for multiple reasons.
I am obviously not behind the actual way this went down or even less supporting the nefarious effects of formula industry lobbying on health organization.
But it's interesting because in my experience the idea that women *should* breastfeed is much more conservative than liberal.

Resolutions like this are not really aimed at western nations, where the option of breast vs. bottle is not a question of public safety, but a choice. A few years ago, Nestle and other companies concentrated their advertising on poorer and developing nations, encouraging the use of formula, and making an argument that it was better than breast feeding. They provided new moms with samples of the formula, and encouraged them to start with the formula. This became problematic when the realities of cost and water availability caught up with young mothers, who had already stopped producing milk. It was evil.

Then again, we are talking about Nestle, who made noise about water not being a basic human right.

Edit: as you can see in the post just above.
 

Common Knowledge

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,251
I often find myself taking a step back on just reflecting on the sheer fuckery that is the fact that political lobbying is a thing that exists and is a thing that is an ingrained and accepted part of politics. Fucking buying the opinions of people in power is one of the main forces driving America.
 

harry the spy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,085
Resolutions like this are not really aimed at western nations, where the option of breast vs. bottle is not a question of public safety, but a choice. A few years ago, Nestle and other companies concentrated their advertising on poorer and developing nations, encouraging the use of formula, and making an argument that it was better than breast feeding. They provided new moms with samples of the formula, and encouraged them to start with the formula. This became problematic when the realities of cost and water availability caught up with young mothers, who had already stopped producing milk. It was evil.

Then again, we are talking about Nestle, who made noise about water not being a basic human right.

Edit: as you can see in the post just above.
Fair enough.
 

Parthenios

The Fallen
Oct 28, 2017
13,613
So this was the real play with the tariffs all along, eh? Show the world that we aren't afraid to self-immolate with a bunch of ill-advised trade wars, then once everyone knows we're actually dumb enough to do it, threaten more tariffs on weak trade partners to force dumb stuff no one wpul d normally otherwise agree to.

It would almost be brilliant, if you think things like tanking your economy and chilling breastfeeding are worthy outcomes.
 

Claire Delune

10 Years in the Making
Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,284
Greater Seattle Area
In a fantasy world, the next president's first term wouldn't count against the two-term limit because it won't be anything but trying to clean up the mess Trump has left behind.
 

AimLow

Member
Dec 10, 2017
969
...A Russian delegate said the decision to introduce the breast-feeding resolution was a matter of principle.

"We're not trying to be a hero here, but we feel that it is wrong when a big country tries to push around some very small countries, especially on an issue that is really important for the rest of the world," said the delegate, who asked not to be identified because he was not authorized to speak to the media.

Russia is the last country that needs to be decrying the bullying other countries to promote special interests.
 

Messofanego

Member
Oct 25, 2017
26,189
UK
Nestle did some fucking nefarious shit in third world countries, experimenting their formulas on poverty stricken mothers that lead to a ton of infant deaths.

There was a massive boycott of their products as a result.

How far we've come!

http://www.businessinsider.com/nest...dermined-womens-confidence-in-breastfeeding-6
Nestle, also behind nefarious schemes for bottled water, and having massive campaigns to undermine tap water.That was a good read, thanks!
 

Deleted member 9986

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,248
'this administration' yeah because this is a new tactic for the US

THIS IS WHAT THE US HAS ALWAYS BEEN DOING

This is what the US is, the only reason people actually care is because of partisanship. Because of the dumb horse race narrative, team red versus team blue.

You don't even need a working memory for this just use Google. This is how the world knows the US. News flash.
 

Lady Catherine de Bourgh

Teyvat Traveler
Member
Oct 27, 2017
832
You literally have no idea who I am, so no, you don't. A career lactation consultant is not an expert in the science of this, that's not her job, in the same way doctors are not pharmacologist experts. And you are not your mom.
I am not talking about about women without access to clean water, obviously.


Sure, but it brings tons of guilt to mothers who are not able to breastfed (I know at least two). There are lots of women who also would prefer not to breastfeed, even though they can, for multiple reasons.
I am obviously not behind the actual way this went down or even less supporting the nefarious effects of formula industry lobbying on health organization.
But it's interesting because in my experience the idea that women *should* breastfeed is much more conservative than liberal.

I absolutely agree with you on not shaming or bullying new mothers into breastfeeding . It's a personal and free choice and should not be judged by others.
 

Mona

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
26,151
Followed by the right wing propaganda machine:

hiroshima1.jpg


And the cycle will continue.

Apologizing for Hiroshima? Say it isn't so!!!!
 

Rex Griswold

Member
Oct 29, 2017
221
I didn't say I know nothing about it - I said I am not an expert. From your inability to read a one line post, I am guessing I might very well know more than you do about it. Having an informed position about this would take more than reading a few articles from the news. Science reporting in general is pretty bad, and that kind of science is difficult to do properly because of confounding effects. There is a reason why scientific articles tread very lightly with their conclusions. And from what I read following the 23andme items on breastfeeding (some genes seem to correlate with breastfeeding having a postiive effect on IQ, for instance), the science seemed a bit uncertain. Yes, it is better, but the extent to which is quite uncertain. Hence it's a tradeoff for many women.

Breastfeeding costs zero dollars compared to formula feeding. That alone makes it much less of a "tradeoff" and more of a really obvious solution.

My wife and I aren't financially distraught, but for us, zero dollars every few days vs $35 every few days was a really easy decision to make. Some women also refuse to do formula because they just don't want to do it. They want to feed their kid the natural way, i.e.: my wife.

23andme is a decent source, but if you're really interested in breastfeeding, I'd talk to a lactation consultant. They can tell you a lot about it.
 

Dragonelite

Banned
Oct 29, 2017
544
As a future doctor who has looked into the research there isn't great data that shows massive benefits of breastfeeding. Its is definitely the food of choice to feed children due to the antibodies crossing over and giving the infant protection from some gastrointestinal infections but the data on whether it improves IQ isn't there yet.

I agree that women shouldn't be shamed for not breastfeeding but women who do should be protected

It does helps the child develop nasal breathing skills which again has great influence on jaw development. Doesn't breast milk not also transfer over more bacteria for a better gut flora in the baby. Helping in future development hell there is more research done in gut microbiome and the influence on mental health/obesity and depression.
 

Pooh

Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,849
The Hundred Acre Wood
Russia is the last country that needs to be decrying the bullying other countries to promote special interests.
If the alt-right was consistent at all, they'd realize that Trump and the GOP are... to put it their way, "cucked" by Putin and Russia. Every one of these things turns into a PR coup for Russia playing the part of good guy against the bully USA.
 

wenis

Member
Oct 25, 2017
16,113
I would be ok if any world organization just stopped listening to America. Go do your things guys. We're that friend that keeps shitting the bed at social events and eventually you just gotta cut ties because they keep embarrassing you and you gotta apologize for them constatntly.
 

Norwegian_Imposter

Circumventing a ban with an alt account
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,757
Don't forget this is a country that went into meltdown when Janet Jackson showed a fucking nipple. Here during the school run we have songs that lyrics are "fucks sake" (fy faen)
 

Rei no Otaku

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
3,349
Cranston RI
I'll be honest, I have major issues with the breast feeding community in the US at least. My wife wanted to breast feed my first child and everyone we talked to at the hospital really pushed for it. Constantly telling her how formula was awful for the baby and breast milk was the only way to make sure that the baby would be healthy. After my son was born it became apparent that my wife just wasn't producing enough milk. She went to a bunch of lactation consultants and nurses, but she just couldn't produce enough. The whole time she's getting stressed out because my son wasn't getting enough so in turn he wasn't gaining enough weight. Lost count of how many nights she was in tears because she assumed she was a terrible mother who couldn't feed her son. I'd bring up the possibility of using formula but she'd just get more upset because the lactation people were STILL telling her not to use it. I finally had to go to the pediatrician by myself and tell him what was going on and between the two of us convince my wife that formula is perfectly fine.

I do believe that breast milk is obviously better, but the insane vitriol that the breast feeding community has towards formula is ridiculous and they shame the hell out of mothers that can't or don't want to breast feed.
 

Taki

Attempt to circumvent a ban with an alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
5,308
Just throw the USA out of the WHO
 

Ensorcell

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,458
The Americans were blunt: If Ecuador refused to drop the resolution, Washington would unleash punishing trade measures and withdraw crucial military aid. The Ecuadorean government quickly acquiesced.

This would be funny if not so goddamn cruel. What in the fuck is going on?
 

smurfx

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,578
It has the backs of at least Reckitt Benckiser and Abbott Laboratories. So pretty deep pockets.

edit: oh and Nestlé too.
wasn't there some controversy with nestle? like they were trying to convince mothers in 3rd world countries that formula was safer than breast milk?

ah looks like somebody already linked the article. nestle is an evil corporation.
 

Deleted member 11517

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,260
I didn't say I know nothing about it - I said I am not an expert. From your inability to read a one line post, I am guessing I might very well know more than you do about it. Having an informed position about this would take more than reading a few articles from the news. Science reporting in general is pretty bad, and that kind of science is difficult to do properly because of confounding effects. There is a reason why scientific articles tread very lightly with their conclusions. And from what I read following the 23andme items on breastfeeding (some genes seem to correlate with breastfeeding having a postiive effect on IQ, for instance), the science seemed a bit uncertain. Yes, it is better, but the extent to which is quite uncertain. Hence it's a tradeoff for many women.
Literally "got mine fuck you".

And you're completely clueless about the matter too.

Don't bother replying I won't see it.
 

Deleted member 21709

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
23,310
Lobbyists are paying our politicians so we can bully small countries with threat of retaliation (by way of withdrawing aid) by the US military? This is insane.
 

Keasar

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
5,724
UmeĂĄ, Sweden
tumblr_m48ucx4DQI1qaybgdo8_250.gif


I am starting to think we should just exclude the US. and Russia out of any decision making process regarding health, environment and safety of anything.
 

Kasumin

Member
Nov 19, 2017
1,932
Yeah I can't help but feel that their efforts weren't only to set US policies align with theirs, but to discredit the country and allow Russia to step in like the good guys in the international stage.

This. And this is the most important point here. That people in the thread are distracted by debating the science of breastfeeding is unfortunate.

THIS is the real point of the story. Russia undercutting the US on everything on the world stage and the US allowing it to happen.

This is really, really bad. Like, undercutting over 70 years of painfully crafted American foreign policy work bad.
 

Deleted member 11517

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,260
How did you get that from that?
You need to take a break from this thread.
Read the whole thread then you maybe understand.


It's not even the subject of the thread that's how Russia undercut the US and the US let it happen. Embarrassing. So let's stay on topic, I got nothing else to say on the matter of trying to distract from the subject.
 

Deleted member 2620

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
4,491

Dyle

One Winged Slayer
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
29,944
Man the US dairy industry is ridiculously powerful