Bumping this old ass thread but only because I wanted to make the same thread.
Easily one of my favorite recent comedies of the past few years. I saw this as a Movie Pass movie in theatres earlier this year (actually the only Movie Pass movie I saw when I was a member) and was kinda blown away by how much I enjoyed it. I think the biggest knock I can give it is maybe some pacing, but it really consistently hit for me, over and over:
- Bateman was kinda made for this movie and he has a perfect portrayal of male sibling rivalry, with Kyle Chandler being the perfect scummy older brother.
- McAdams is at her absolute charmiest without feeling like the Wife side character or too aloof. The entire bar sequence, she just owns it. And then her day saving "and THAT'S how you get the drop on someone!" Full of charm without being too affected.
- Billy Magnussen is becoming one of my favorite actors. The last thing I saw him in was Ingrid Goes West and this is such a heelturn in terms for performances.
- Sharon Horgan (who I hadn't seen since Todd Margaret) balances Magnussen without being a stick-in-the-mud. The way their relationship evolves is nothing major but a natural back-and-forth that culminates sweetly.
- Kylie Bunbury and Lamorne Morris are a pitch perfect "together forever" couple. I honestly wasn't a fan of the continual "cheating" storyline until that amazing faux-Denzel payoff. "Stand back, baby--I'm about to burn this door down." "You're going to start a fire in a room with no windows?" "...oh, you sleep with Bill Nye the Science Guy?"
- Jesse Plemons--don't really need to say much but fitting in such a tonally oddball character into this could have felt hamfisted but it just works.
Every character has plenty of gags and quotable lines--it's just an extremely satisfying, "complete" comedy.