• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
Happy Thanksgiving to everyone out there! Here's a short gallery of stuff to celebrate the occasion:
happy_thanksgiving_2017___by_shutterflyeqd-dbukjyc.png

tada__by_lulubellct-dbujnjh.png

final2.png


lazy%2BCompany%2BThanksgiving.jpg

I'll use this opportunity to post some art that I've been meaning to post as wel;:
csaxiht8fkzz.jpg

tumblr_oznd74c82R1sd50oqo1_500.png

I know I've already linked this, but I had to do it again
1588593.png

eqg_rainbow_dash_by_rvceric-dbu31nb.png

The theme for the past week on Reddit was Background ponies week but there were maybe 7 or so posts for it the whole week and none of them were very good so I won't bother to post any here.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Thanksgiving is good for turkey and autumn backgrounds in art. So that Treehugger art was found on a Five Guys board? That milkshake and pony Dash art is cute. Human Dash is alright.

Alright, no more Mono fics? No more Mono fics. (Well there is that alternate account she has for some reason, but I'll hold off on that). These are all the short stories I had bookmarked, and after this, I have longer ones I need to get through. And thanks to the chat, half of those longer ones are Sunset based. I'll probably space those out.

A Familiar Feeling by Poptard - Big Mac brings Sugar Belle to the Apple Farm, but
376224445817421835.png
is
376224445817421835.png
about her similarities to Pear Butter. Found via ED post. Rating: Alright.
There's an unexpectedly large focus on baking, including an extended scene with Mrs. Cake. The stuff with Sugar doing stuff exactly like Pear did, by pure coincidence, was kind of forced. I liked the part where Sugar misreads Applejack's animosity as her having a crush on her. It was kind of weird that the resolution involved Sugar telling the story of how she got to Starlight's Village, to remind Applejack how different she is from her mother, when, you know, Applejack was there when they saved her. It also played up Sugar's similarity in appearance to Pear too much at the end. It's one thing to get, well, a familiar feeling, but I doubt Sugar would think a black and white picture of Pear was a picture of herself. And even if the narration acknowledges this, it is still kind of creepy to have Big Mac talk about their similarities.

Sugar was presented well enough, given how little we've really seen of her, and though I haven't rewatched "Hard to Say Anything" yet, she matches up with my memories of that episode. There were nice moments, but the story pushed Sugar and Pear's similarities a bit too much, especially in the bonus chapter, where Big Mac talks about it.

I Have Many Forms, but This One is Mine by Raugos - Starlight talks to Pharynx after the events of "To Change a Changeling". Found via ED post. Rating: Liked.
This is a pretty simple story that captures Pharynx's personality well. It's a shame that with the show's format, we can't just have characters sit around and talk without it advancing a story of some kind. I would have liked something like this in the actual episode. There is some very light shipping between Pharynx and Starlight, but it works well enough just as them being friendly if you don't like that.

As Horns and Halos Surround You by Norm de Plume - Rarity's shoulder devil is injured, and while she recovers, the shoulder devils of her friends fill in. Inspired by that scene in "The Saddle Row Review" where Pinkie has Rarity's shoulder angel and devil. Found via ED post. Rating: Liked, but weird.
The premise on its own is weird, but it's weirder when it semi-seriously presents this world where shoulder angels and devils are known physical quantities that can be taken to the hospital, have unique relationships with their ponies, and even be killed. It gives special terms for them, YA novel style: they are collectively called observers, the angel is the conscience, and the devil is the temptation. That said, it was pretty sweet seeing how Rarity cared so much for her observers, I liked the scene of her talking with Twilight in the hospital (though Twilight's mention that she got her old temptation killed when she was young, and then it got replaced, raises all sorts of questions), and Rarity getting better insight into her friends through their temptations was nice.

Overall, I do think I enjoyed it, but there are a lot of, "wait, what?" moments.

I decided to write out my thoughts in the chat on the idea of Twilight turning out to have gone on dates before the events of episode 1 of the show, based on what I posted previously in response to a fanfic. The example dialogue I gave follows the same format as previous chat convos, but it's a bit more of a serious idea. Just a bit.
You know, after that post I made yesterday, I do think it would be interesting if the show revealed that Twilight actually did date before the events of the show. And it would cause a fandom freak out. Something like this (a rare non-joke emote conversation)
376224375717888000.png
Well darling, I'm sure you wouldn't understand, since you've never dated.
376224228246028300.png
What? I've dated before!
376224375717888000.png
Yes, but it's not--
376223420725198852.png
Wait, WHAT?! Twilight, explain!
376223681237483522.png
Uhhh
376223420725198852.png
Spike, explain!
377347619514613760.png
Well she's (1) a beautiful mare (2) from a rich family (3) who was Princess Celestia's personal student (4) and hung out in the barracks a lot.
376225181183508480.png
Shining Armor actually had to set a rule against hitting on me.
376223022773960704.png
But... but...
376225181183508480.png
I got my first kiss years ago from one of his groomsmen.
376223420725198852.png
I DON'T KNOW WHO YOU ARE(edited)
Cappy-Yesterday at 1:30 PM
no friends only suitors
376223189249949696.png

SigmasonicX-Yesterday at 1:37 PM
Following on my idea, you could justify things by saying that Twilight just did what was expected on her dates and wasn't all that romantic. She had more fun planning out the dates than going on them. Thus, that's why she wasn't used to actual close relationships.
376225181183508480.png
From my research, now seems like the right time for a kiss. Is that alright with you?
horse-racing_1f3c7.png
Uh, yeah, sure
Cappy-Yesterday at 1:44 PM
Then the follow up survey
SigmasonicX-Yesterday at 1:49 PM
horse-racing_1f3c7.png
So, is it alright if I came inside?
376225181183508480.png
First, how would you rate the dinner we had? How did the lighting affect the romance? Rate the night's romance from 0 to 5.
Cappy-Yesterday at 1:50 PM
WHOA
oh wait
ok
gets out of the gutter
SigmasonicX-Yesterday at 1:51 PM
371467336047263754.png
And full disclosure, I'll be taking a different stallion to the same restaurant in a few days and then a mare a few days after that for a range of opinions.
Well,
horse-racing_1f3c7.png
is asking for that, but Twilight doesn't get it
Cappy-Yesterday at 1:51 PM
Her scientific method will not be waylaid!
SigmasonicX-Yesterday at 1:53 PM
376224228246028300.png
Ugh! Why do none of these ponies cooperate with my surveys? Maybe dating is a waste of time. Also friendship.
377347619514613760.png
And thus we have season one.

And some other Thanksgiving or autumn themed art.

On an unrelated note, MagnaLuna has started a new blog, for "canon" Luna drawings, just last week.
Newest one
bylunadarkesthours1511387415532.jpg


That hair really is pretty.
 
Last edited:

Unknownlight

One Winged Slayer
Member
Nov 2, 2017
10,557
People here and elsewhere in the past were pretty confident about the idea that fans could pick up the slack if the show ends, but I feel like no one really thinks that anymore.

I'd completely forgotten about that. I definitely remember the idea floating around that the MLP fandom might be able fund its own episodes if the show were to end prematurely. Ah, those were the days...

When the actual show is at 169 episodes and shows no sign of stopping, the idea of going to the effort to make unofficial episodes too is suddenly way less appealing.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
I'd completely forgotten about that. I definitely remember the idea floating around that the MLP fandom might be able fund its own episodes if the show were to end prematurely. Ah, those were the days...

When the actual show is at 169 episodes and shows no sign of stopping, the idea of going to the effort to make unofficial episodes too is suddenly way less appealing.
Hello person who may or may not have posted in the GAF threads but I don't recognize!

Good point on how there's no question about the show lasting, like there was back in the day, which explains why there isn't a fervent desire for fan-made episodes anymore. During season 2 and especially 3 there was a very real possibility of the show ending there. I wonder if that means we will start getting fan-made episodes again once the show is announced to end. That said, we do already get lengthy fan series like Pinkie Tales, but they tend to follow more a slideshow format.

News and art dump (yeah, I basically wait until I'm not double posting and then post everything that has piled up).

Forgot to mention before, but that last Legends of Magic cover?It's from fan artist dSana! Always nice to see fan artists turn pro.

Next in ED's fanfic writer interview series is Justice3442 on how to write a "random" story, and how that doesn't give you license to just write meaningless drivel. He makes some interesting points with how the randomness has to have one foot firmly planted in what's expected of the characters, and how it's good to have one character that acts exactly how they do in the show.

The EQG short "School of Rock" is officially on YouTube. Only a few more months until we get something new.
The song leaked last week, "Equestria Girls Forever" by Angelic, has an official music video now. It's super Disney Channel, with random EQG clips and cutie marks.

Movie art dump. With this, my movie art bookmarks are cleared, and now it's time to delve into what Derpibooru has that ED missed.

Why Starlight wasn't in the MLP movie by TheBadGrinch
why_starlight_wasn_t_in_the_mlp_movie_by_thebadgrinch-dbthmlv.png

Calaeno's New Pirate Ship by EMositeCC
calaeno_s_new_pirate_ship_by_emositecc-dbtfz05.png
 
Oct 25, 2017
5,143
Another Sunday, another stream. This time it's Twilight Sparkle day! Watch her magical journey from psychotic student, to anxious organizer, her ascension to alicornhood, to her being a third wheel in a Rainbow Dash episode and finally her being a tool for a sleezy opportunist! You'll laugh, you'll cry, and you'll get sick of me spamming the
tx18Che.gif
emote during Magical Mystery Cure! Don't forget the awesome PMVs and silly animations. Cya l8r skatrs

axkhzK7.png
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Another Sunday, another stream. This time it's Twilight Sparkle day! Watch her magical journey from psychotic student, to anxious organizer, her ascension to alicornhood, to her being a third wheel in a Rainbow Dash episode and finally her being a tool for a sleezy opportunist! You'll laugh, you'll cry, and you'll get sick of me spamming the
tx18Che.gif
emote during Magical Mystery Cure! Don't forget the awesome PMVs and silly animations. Cya l8r skatrs

axkhzK7.png
That sure is a set of episodes. But it has been a long time since I watched "Games Ponies Play"; most recent show rewatch (still ongoing), I skipped seasons 3 and 4, since I started from season 3 the rewatch before (after season 5 ended). So I have this to look forward to.
thumb.gif


This Bleeding Cool News article about a comic store mentions that one of the main reasons it can stay open is actually because of sales of the MLP comics. No matter what forces are driving readers away from Marvel, people are still keeping MLP on their physical comic pull list.

Amazing sprite animation by panyang-panyang.
tumblr_ozy0t2pZQA1rmh7iyo1_r1_500.gif


Realized that after going "oh wow this SciSet Diary blog has good art and actually updates near-daily" I should probably actually read it. Here's the chronological sort. The art uses a variety of styles, and generally is pretty nice. It starts out as just random doodles, but it does start having a story. And it's been over a year yet it still updates frequently, which is almost unheard of. It touches on some interesting things, such as how weird it is to be in a relationship where you're constantly jumping through a portal that changes your species, and the two partners are from different sides; and the idea that while SciTwi is very romantically attracted to Sunset, she has zero interest in sex with her, which is something that concerns SciTwi enough that she wonders if there's something wrong with her, and she gets assured by Sunset and others that it's fine. But in the end, this is mainly an art blog with cute/dumb jokes, so those aren't delved into quite as much as I would like. Also, one side ship weird as hell: Principal Cadance and Big Mac?! And their daughter makes frequent appearances so it's right in your face!

New Target commercial with Pinkie. Hmm, they were able to get Tabitha for Rarity last year, but that's definitely not Andrea playing Pinkie. Also, I guess millennial pink is a thing.

And bizarrely, it resulted in this chat convo.
SigmasonicX-Today at 6:26 PM
377347619380264961.png
Hey, how about some apple orange?
371467037702356993.png
Sure, if you wanna die
377658284100026370.png
Just kidding
371467037702356993.png
Or am I?
376223189249949696.png
Apple... orange?
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 6:27 PM
371466012345892865.png
Don't die, I still need your souls
SigmasonicX-Today at 6:28 PM
377528175846096907.png
Place the apple orange on the tree to release the souls of the world. It is all written in the Dead Sea Scrolls.
377347619380264961.png
Hmm... do I want to do that?
377658284368199681.png
Celestia has broken the cycle of reincarnation by trapping your souls on this plane. It is the goal of all souls to reach enlightenment and end the cycle, but Celestia has provided a false end. However, by breaking her containment, you risk reincarnating into a lesser form, and having to suffer reincarnation for further eons.
377658284368199681.png
But I exist outside the cycle, so do whatever you want.
376223681237483522.png
Why did this get so complicated now?
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 6:33 PM
376223681237483522.png
And just when one of the authors is trying to put together his stream content for tomorrow
377658284343033858.png
Make it worse!!!
SigmasonicX-Today at 6:35 PM
377347619510419456.png
The Celestia you know is a false deity! Flurry Heart is the descendant of the true Celestia, sent here to rescue us from the sinful rule of the false Celestia
376223681237483522.png
Does that mean Cadance is...
377347619510419456.png
No
377528175846096907.png
I am the true Celestia
377528175846096907.png
In the sense that a being who has achieved enlightenment is part of Celestia, but I am physically not Celestia, and yet we are all Celestia
377528175846096907.png
Except the false Celestia, who is a being of nothingness
377528175846096907.png
She doesn't exist
377528175846096907.png
In fact none of you exist
376224228246028300.png
But then
377528175846096907.png
Sorry, what was that? I didn't hear anything
377347619510419456.png
You see, in addition to Fake Celestia, there are also Fake Fake Celestias! You must not be fooled!
377658284100026370.png
Ah, but according to some variants of Buddhism, even the deities are subject to the cycle of karma and reincarnation. It is impossible for Celestia to have broken it.
371467037702356993.png
Meaning there isn't actually anything weird going on.
371467037702356993.png
Look, Applejack, just put that orange apple thing on the tree.
christmas-tree_1f384.png
Yay
377347619514613760.png
Oh, I get it! Applejack thinks apples are orange because that's what color she is! Hence apple orange.
376223420725198852.png
That's what she meant?!
376224445817421835.png
Alright, fine, I'll put on the orange-colored ornament. There, I'm being clear and specific, you happy now?
377347619380264961.png
Just like an apple.
376224445817421835.png
Here goes nothing
377658284368199681.png
(munch)
christmas-tree_1f384.png
small-orange-diamond_1f538.png

Cappy-Today at 6:43 PM
Is that a cheese single!?
SigmasonicX-Today at 6:44 PM
Sure
376224445817421835.png
Putting it on... now....
collision-symbol_1f4a5.png

And it all comes tumbling down, tumbling down, tumbling down
ghost_1f47b.png
ghost_1f47b.png
ghost_1f47b.png

376223681237483522.png
Huh, I guess we were all in this soul trap thingy
371466012345892865.png
I told you not to do it
[THE END]

Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 6:46 PM

SigmasonicX-Today at 6:47 PM
Look, it's your fault for bringing up souls
This chat convo was brought to you by a mix of Evangelion and random things I remember from religious studies classes in college
371467336047263754.png

Also Xenogears
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 6:56 PM
Should've taken a second to offer my knowledge on Buddhism
376224314329923584.png
dammit
Cappy-Today at 6:58 PM
lol
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:03 PM
Now the question is, when I post this in the thread, do I stop at [THE END] or include the conversation after that up to this point?

And then right after that, was this convo.
Sylvee-Today at 7:11 PM
https://78.media.tumblr.com/1aac8fc2c9fd14f77df1cb9a9ab056d8/tumblr_p000turygx1uxdv6do1_1280.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 7:14 PM
377347619523002368.png
Oh, there you are, Trixie's beloved. Trixie has a hard time remembering what anyone but her looks like, so Trixie will trust you.
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:18 PM
>same VA
377347619514613760.png
I'm going to pencil that in as incest
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:18 PM
Wait, they really have the same VAs?
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:19 PM
I had to double check to make sure I wasn't crazy, but yeppers
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:20 PM
Yeah, just checked myself
Cappy-Today at 7:20 PM
the Great and Powerful Chryssy
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:20 PM
I like that IMDB credits Trixie as Trixie Lulamoon(edited)
Sylvee-Today at 7:20 PM
So what you're saying is that Starlight and Chrysalis are going to hook up as well?
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:21 PM
377658284100026370.png
Anyone who hooks up with Fluttershy must also hook up with me. It's pony law.
Sylvee-Today at 7:22 PM
Pinkiecord sounds legit
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:22 PM
371467336047263754.png
It and Disclestia were the big Discord ships before season 3.
377658284100026370.png
Now where's that Treehugger? I want a Piehugger!
Cappy-Today at 7:23 PM
376224314329923584.png
Hey!
376224628412121101.png
That's not law it's just a custom.
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:24 PM
377528175846096907.png
Laws change. In many societies, customs and social pressure are much more effective and longer lasting.
377658284100026370.png
I want some Angelpie!
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:25 PM
377658284343033858.png
But the US is somewhat of an exception to this as it has the longest lasting governing document in the history of the world at over 200 years old!
Cappy-Today at 7:26 PM
376224445817421835.png
What's a US?
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:26 PM
377658284343033858.png
Add on the fact that the political landscape is very polarized and the constitution is somewhat designed to make the legislative process slow, and I think even the most simple-minded foal would reject your premise, Derpy
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:27 PM
371466012345892865.png
Thanks to this custom, I have access to all of Cheerilee's hot hook ups. Like, uh, Big Mac.
Cappy-Today at 7:27 PM
371466816041648130.png
That's hot!
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:29 PM
377528175846096907.png
Ah, but that just shows how important customs are. Think of how laws change, but then society will often prevent them from being applied effectively. Anyway, the point is, thanks to my multiple VAs
Wait shit, she was voiced by Tabitha in Slice of Life too
377528175846096907.png
Uh, well, uh
371468074475323392.png
I get Applejack!
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:30 PM
376224445817421835.png
Ah am notta bargainin' chip in yur little sexual game
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:31 PM
371466965727838209.png
I'll give you Quibble Pants if you give me...
371468504190156810.png
Oh wait, never mind, there's no one I want from you that I don't already have
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:32 PM
376223189249949696.png
Which camp do I fall into? Do you already have me or am I... am I...
376223022773960704.png
NOT WANTEDhEDHED?!
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:34 PM
376223681237483522.png
We are both voiced by VAs with only one main role. We are nothing
Cappy-Today at 7:35 PM
376224628412121101.png
Mmm, apple barganing chips...
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:35 PM
376223189249949696.png
You're really throwing the CMCs under the bus there too, aren't you darling
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:36 PM
377658284427182081.png
Don't get me involved in this!
377658284427182081.png
Nopony else is getting Button Mash!
376224375717888000.png
Oh darling, how cute, he's practically a fan character
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:37 PM
377658284343033858.png
But Sweetie Belle, you were already involved through the intersubjective reality—
377658284427182081.png
377658284427182081.png
377658284427182081.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 7:38 PM
377658284150095883.png
This story is illogical and inconsistent. Shouldn't Twilight already have a ton of ships? And you already acknowledged that Rarity's VA voices other characters.
371466012345892865.png
I'm ending this confusion. It is now law.
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:39 PM
377658284364005377.png
Am I too late to put my out-of-character comment in?
377347619514613760.png
A bill...
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:40 PM
376223681237483522.png
I feel sad for you, only having access to humans for your other roles.
Cappy-Today at 7:40 PM
377658284100026370.png
A quill for a bill!
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:40 PM
377347619514613760.png
BUT I'M STILL JUST A BILL
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:40 PM
376224314329923584.png
Then we can stop this! It isn't a law yet!
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:41 PM
377658284343033858.png
Your only hope is to petition Celestia to veto at this point
SigmasonicX-Today at 7:41 PM
377658284100026370.png
You'll have to get through me first! I want some Meadowbrook!
376224628412121101.png
Wait, do I even get shipped with her?
(off to dinner, find a way to resolve this)
Cappy-Today at 7:42 PM
376224445817421835.png
Fahnally, legal rhetoric, mah greatest strength!
376224445817421835.png
Spike take a letter!
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:43 PM
377347619514613760.png
Ready!
376224228246028300.png
(luke skywalker voice) this is not going to go the way you think!
Cappy-Today at 7:48 PM
376224445817421835.png
Dear Celestia, Society is a lot like an apple orchard. We, the ponies, are the apples. Our customs hold us to the trees but will release in time to allow our trees to flourish. By making a law out of this you threaten to make cantaloupes of us all. And I'll be damned if I become a no-good, cantaloupe! Yours Apple-ly, Apple Orange
376224445817421835.png
Er, Applejack
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:49 PM
377658284150095883.png
Well I'm convinced
371466012345892865.png
As am I, my faithful orange(edited)
376225181183508480.png
I think we can all agree we learned a valuable lesson today about cantaloupes
377658284343033858.png
No no no, the lesson was about the American political experience
Cappy-Today at 7:50 PM
376224445817421835.png
Cantaloupes!? Where!?
Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:50 PM
376224314329923584.png
OH My GOD FUCKING KILL THEM
377658284343033858.png
Good thing we are an armed society!
376224628412121101.png
I agree, a well-regulated militia is essential for modern day Equestria
371466012345892865.png
Hmm... I have an idea for the next law...
[THE END]
Cappy-Today at 7:52 PM
ok-hand-sign_1f44c.png

Juniper Montage (Trig)-Today at 7:52 PM
hundred-points-symbol_1f4af.png

hundred-points-symbol_1f4af.png

3
SigmasonicX-Today at 8:27 PM
I'm proud of you guys
 

Ogodei

One Winged Slayer
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,256
Coruscant
Traveling back home (from my parents' home which is also home! It's confusing) on Sunday, won't be able to make it. I do want to join y'all at one point, seems fun.
 
Oct 25, 2017
5,143
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Bit of art.
Princess Skystar by mysticalpha on DeviantArt
PrincessSkystarbymysticalpha1511640144979.jpg


When I see this gif I imagine them singing:
Hey, hey
You, you
I don't like your girlfriend
No way, no way
I think you need a new one
(that comprises two loops of the gif)
Huh, it actually does work really well. Nice of Twilight to provide five choices; shame Rarity is taken by Cadance.

Traveling back home (from my parents' home which is also home! It's confusing) on Sunday, won't be able to make it. I do want to join y'all at one point, seems fun.

Hey, me too! Except after the stream is over.

One benefit of working in San Francisco is that it's too expensive to not live with my parents! I guess.

So, it looks like after the stream, we're going to have an RP event in the chat or something. I don't know, I'll have to figure out what it's actually going to be.

Oh wow, it turns out The Art of My Little Pony: the Movie is on Comixology. So I don't have to buy a physical copy! I guess you can expect a post about it later. *thinks* Probably not this week, though.

Here's a good remix of Open Up Your Eyes. ED's description of it:
Vocal - Chillout
An interesting remix of Open Up Your Eyes, this focuses on a generally chilled out atmosphere, with some minor future elements and arps here and there.
Daniel Ingram ft. Emily Blunt - Open Up Your Eyes (Cynifree Remix)
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562

When I recently rewatched it I realized I had totally forgot about the really neat looking routine they did. I pretty much forgot almost everything about that episode though so...



Do you think it's weird that Spike is more interested in ponies then he is in dragons? I mean like socially. Do you think Ember thinks less of him because he has the hots for Rarity?

Also I feel like if the changelings were just more upfront about being changelings they would be getting hella action. Who wouldn't want to go out with someone that could be literally anything?
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Do you think it's weird that Spike is more interested in ponies then he is in dragons? I mean like socially. Do you think Ember thinks less of him because he has the hots for Rarity?
We already know Garble and presumably most dragons think less of him simply for hanging out with ponies. I don't believe any dragon has been made aware of Spike's interest in Rarity; I imagine they would have to be weirded out by it. As for me, Spike hadn't even seen any other dragons until "Dragon Quest", so I don't find it weird at all.

Plus, I have a headcanon that the magic Twilight used to hatch Spike actually did make him biologically part pony.

Also I feel like if the changelings were just more upfront about being changelings they would be getting hella action. Who wouldn't want to go out with someone that could be literally anything?

It would shut down pony society. Though I imagine a big issue is that changelings aren't attracted to ponies in that way.

Bit more art, from recent or upcoming conventions.
1.EQLA 2017 Conbook Cover by Hollulu
2.Everfree Northwest Conbook Cover 2017 by Hollulu
EQLA2017ConbookCoverbyHollulu1511472578963.png
EverfreeNorthwestConbookCover2017byHollulu1511472579194.png
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
It would shut down pony society

Man, now I'm thinking of all those people that are saying that civilization will end when sexbots are created...

We would appreciate it if more people would join in next time.

Just figured I'd throw out my 2 cents. RPing is something that I would be interested in but the kind of stuff that I've seen so far is a bit more focused on being funny rather then then being a serious attempt at RPing, which is the kind of stuff that I would be more interested in. There's nothing wrong with the stuff you guys like to do but it's not something I would really want to participate in, even if I do find it funny to read.


I like how they had a comb come with it even though his hair is like a half an inch long.


Here's some Starlight, this one's pretty old though:
flying_buddy_by_lachlan765-dbgax81.png
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
So today, SigmasonicX and I (with a little help from Lupin) decided to create our own MLP story, roleplaying characters as they visit Ponyville's WidgetCon, and thinks start to take a turn for the spooky. We have a transcript here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1gKQtM0AI7aYmwfQMATCp_jr_Gyd7IV9b3EMm5LFMD_A/edit#

We would appreciate it if more people would join in next time.
We went with a freeform format where anyone could jump in and voice any character, but I noticed there was a lot of stepping over each other's lines. Next time, I think we should go a bit more structured, with particular characters assigned to certain people. To handle people jumping in, we'll reassign characters every 30 minutes or so.

Then later, we can figure out if we maybe want to switch from just using the main characters to using original characters.

dvCWAsb.jpg


I saw this in the store the other day. Big Mac apparently decided instead of speaking, he's going to simply project his thoughts onto his skin.

377347619523002368.png
And Trixie thought Trixie was self-centered.


Haha, oh wow.

Just figured I'd throw out my 2 cents. RPing is something that I would be interested in but the kind of stuff that I've seen so far is a bit more focused on being funny rather then then being a serious attempt at RPing, which is the kind of stuff that I would be more interested in. There's nothing wrong with the stuff you guys like to do but it's not something I would really want to participate in, even if I do find it funny to read.

I think we could be more serious later, but I wanted to make it similar to the existing chats at first. Honestly, I think sticking to the Mane Six and chat emotes is what keeps it comedic. Some day, we could do a no-emote chat or something, maybe using OCs instead of the Mane Six.

I like how they had a comb come with it even though his hair is like a half an inch long.

Hey, it'll grow ou--wait, never mind.

Here's some Starlight, this one's pretty old though:
377347619523002368.png
Trixie will show you the world. Great, glimmering, powerful~

Today's stream was more active than last week. "Lesson Zero" was even better than I remembered, but everyone was experiencing big ads issues. I hadn't seen "Games Ponies Play" in a long time and had forgotten a lot of it, including Chickadee having claustrophobia, and the sequence of her running around destroying everything. The cheerleading sequence (see above GIF) and Rainbow crashing into the window are highlights, but everything else wasn't that great, especially when it connects to the super forced conflict and the resolution.

The story of "Magical Mystery Cure" doesn't make much sense, but I'll be damned if the songs aren't great and it isn't emotional. "Top Bolt" was still good, with some nice Twilight moments, and of course, shy pegasus mares remain OP (in terms of cuteness). I still like "Once Upon a Zeppelin" a lot.

Other videos in the stream
PMV | Back To You - YouTube
Twilightlicious - BlackGryph0n - YouTube
Twilight Sparkle Fan Art (Era Stream) - YouTube
Twilight Sparkle & Shining Armor's Song - It'll Be Ok - Friendship Is Witchcraft - Episode 8 - YouTube
1/6 A STORY TOLD (animatic) + lyrics - YouTube
My Tiny Pony - YouTube
My Little Wicked-Defying Gravity - YouTube
Logic With Pinkie Pie: The Number of Stars in the Night Sky - YouTube
Twilight's Journey - Ponyphonic - YouTube
When I'm Magic - YouTube
PMV Chained to the Rhythm [BronyCon PMV Contest - 3rd Place Technical] - YouTube
Princess Luna's Song - Princess Of The Night - Friendship Is Witchcraft - Episode 6 - YouTube
PMV Moana: You're Welcome - YouTube
What More is Out There - Twilight and Sunset Duet - YouTube
Derpy - Nyan Nyan Dance - YouTube
MLP: FiM PMV Vanilla Twilight (Owl City) - Twilight Sparkle Tribute - YouTube
Twilight Sparkle's Song - I Can't Wait - Friendship Is Witchcraft: Horse Women - YouTube

About Logic With Pinkie Pie, there is an actual solution, according to the end of the video. The most likely solution in the comments is that:
Twilight hasn't been giving answers with "stars" as units. She's just been giving numbers. You can give any number, as long as you use the unit "stars".

Fat4all , check out the fanart stream for a surprise!

So this is a thing.
Capture.JPG


Toward the middle of this page, there's an announcement that an older MLP fanfic, The Steadfast Sky, has been converted into a "proper" novel, stripping out the pony stuff.
My old 6-star fic (like, 2011~2012 old) The Steadfast Sky has finally made it into print!

The Steadfast Sky was a tale about Luna, Celestia, and Discord's adventures in their youth. It described how they originally obtained the Elements of Harmony and saved Equestria from the corrupted Shadow Stallion. This book is an expanded retelling of the first arc, where the trio are trapped in a city ruled by the Stallion, and must escape after stealing the Element of Kindness. This book has been rewritten from the ground up into a similar, but separate adventure. I avoided any overt connection to MLP, but anyone familiar with the original work will notice the similarities.

The book follows the lives of four teens as they struggle to live in the enclosed city of Canterbury (now known as Helleborus). Celestia and Luna (now known as Melody and Violet) live in poverty, but after Celestia takes a job as a family spy, they are caught up in the currents of political and social schemes. Discord (now known as Brynth) and an OC, Crusher, live in the underground castle, as part of an elite hunting force called Chimeras (formerly Draconiquis). These Chimeras kidnap people from the streets at night and offer the corpses to the God of Kindness.

Things can only get worse for these teens, as the Chimera's hunts are turning up less and less, and food is slowly becoming harder and harder to come by. A decision is made among the elders; if the situation continues, they will begin culling & selling the meat of their own children. All of Chimera kind is whipped into frenzy from this decision, and many hunters are prepared to do drastic things to stop this from happening.

With the God of Kindness having fallen silent, there is no higher authority available to help these struggling teens. They all have to figure out and conquer these impossible situations on their own.

A Spy. A Scholar. A Musician. A Magician.
Trapped in a city of shadows and nightmares, four teens bridge the barrier between their worlds
(Diehard, but in a fantasy city. Also, Alan Rickman is a pony.)

Writer : Grey Scot Potter | Illustrator : Paige Halsey Warren

Website | Amazon

Honestly, the cover shown in the Amazon link looks terrible, and the writing samples in the website are alright for a fanfic, but definitely not that great for a novel. I never heard of this fanfic, but still, this might interest fans of it.

And some art, all EQG this time.
Raripie by fromamida on DeviantArt
thumb.png


And apparently there's an EQG background human that started out as a Crystal Prep student, but then mysteriously started showing up in Canterlot High afterwards.
thumb.png
thumb.png


Which of course, leads to this uotapo comic.
medium.jpeg


I think we all know that feel.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
I think we could be more serious later, but I wanted to make it similar to the existing chats at first. Honestly, I think sticking to the Mane Six and chat emotes is what keeps it comedic. Some day, we could do a no-emote chat or something, maybe using OCs instead of the Mane Six.

My main issues are less the emotes and using actual characters and more the general tone of ridiculousness. I'm fine with a bit of silliness, but having it be the general end goal is a bit much for me.


I still like "Once Upon a Zeppelin" a lot.

The jokes themselves are hit-or-miss, but aside from Shining's portrayal, I liked all of the characters in this episode. It's especially nice after Fame and Misfortune where all of the randos act like complete jerks for them to be generally well-mannered but not understanding Twilight's feelings since she wasn't explaining them. The moral was handled very well too.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3cRWJcZjW4

It's a shame Coloratura has a guest VA, since I'd like for her to show up more.


What about Cheese Sandwich though? We're probably never going to get him back...

Lena Hall isn't the biggest star they've ever had. Maybe there's a chance, although I honestly don't know where they would really go with her character from here. She's already more or less completed her arc and they already have Sapphire Shores if they need a popular music pony for a plotline. It's my same general feeling about people wanting Moondancer back. She's already completed her arc so I don't know where they would go with her from here, especially since her character is basically just Season 1 Twilight at this point and we already have both actual Twilight and another character that already fills a similar role to Season 1 Twilight in the cast.
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
EQD is doing a new poll about what people want done with Starlight. Since I figured it's interesting enough here's my thoughts on all of the choices they have for the poll:


Adventure arc Across Equestria with Trixie and Maud Pie
This one is winning but unless it's a one-off episode I don't really want this. I've said it before but I feel like Starlight needs to do more to integrate with the rest of the core cast, and although Season 7 definitely helped in that regard I feel like more still needs to be done, and the idea of sectioning her off from the rest of the cast to help develop a relationship that is already extremely well-established feels wasteful. I'd definitely like to see Trixie and Maud play off of each other but not as a major story arc.

Alicorn
As much as people troll about this, I doubt anyone really wants this to happen. Having her end game just end up being the exact same thing as Twilight would be disappointing by making Twilight's role less special and also end up making the characters feel too similar to each other. Maybe as a show finale or something, but honestly I'd rather that she ended up getting offered the position and then turn it down. It would be a neat shakeup at least.

Become a New Friendship Teach graduated from Twilight
Again I feel like there needs to be more of a differentiation from Twilight so having her end game be the same thing is a bit boring. Additionally even after 2 seasons Starlight is still nowhere close to being a good teacher for this kind of thing and it feels unfitting as she's still trying to figure everything out.

New Castle Archmage (Taking Star Swirl's Place)
This was a path I had actually suggested for her. Now that Starswirl is in the mix he could potentially take her on as a student. I'm hoping for something like this because it would be a good way to have magic play a more significant role in the series, which is something that would be cool by me.

Secretly Still Evil All Along and Gets Revenge!
This would be a fun idea as a one-off episode where Starlight plays a practical joke on the rest of the Mane 6. It'd be a cool way to show off her villain side again while still having her stay good.

As for a serious arc, obviously no.

Removed from the Series
Kappa

Seventh Element of Harmony
I've talked about it before but I feel like it's actually a sensible character arc for her and now that the pillars are in modern times and Stygian has always wanted to become one, I feel like there might be an arc where he becomes a pillar, creating a seventh element that Starlight ends up getting. Plus giving Starlight her own element would really cement her as a core member of the main cast rather then some other character that is usurping them[/u]
 

Rhomega

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,623
Arizona
An alicorn wouldn't be fair to Twilight. While this will be her third season as a good pony, she hasn't had nearly as much screentime as Twilight. Maybe she should complete her apprenticeship and finds a new calling in life somewhere in Ponyville.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Lena Hall isn't the biggest star they've ever had. Maybe there's a chance, although I honestly don't know where they would really go with her character from here. She's already more or less completed her arc and they already have Sapphire Shores if they need a popular music pony for a plotline. It's my same general feeling about people wanting Moondancer back. She's already completed her arc so I don't know where they would go with her from here, especially since her character is basically just Season 1 Twilight at this point and we already have both actual Twilight and another character that already fills a similar role to Season 1 Twilight in the cast.

Forgot to talk about this before. I'm not necessarily looking for an episode all about her, but something like Sapphire Shore's appearances in the past, like in "For Whom the Sweetie Belle Toils"... which was in season 4. Probably not the best example, then. She can also appear in a more Applejack-related capacity, for a story not about family or farming.

I've had an idea for a while about a story where Sweetie Belle's voice changes, and she finds she has trouble singing. So she goes on a musical journey where she sings with the various singers they met throughout the show, including Coloratura and Cheese Sandwich, until she regains her confidence in her voice.

As for Moondancer, she can be a side character in a story. I had the idea before of Twilight introducing Sunburst to Moondancer and Starlight getting super jelly, but that more or less already happened in "Uncommon Bond".

EQD is doing a new poll about what people want done with Starlight. Since I figured it's interesting enough here's my thoughts on all of the choices they have for the poll:

I agree that doing anything to make Starlight's development match Twilight's would be a mistake. However, I feel like giving her an Element of Harmony at this point would be the same; what actually is accomplished character-wise by doing that? I prefer her as this side thing to the Elements of Harmony; if you've watched Person of Interest, then it's like that part of the show where Root was working as the Machine's human interface, but not directly with Reese and Finch.

Honestly, I have no idea what to do with Starlight in the future. Affiliating her with Starswirl sounds like the best option out of those presented. Shame for Twilight, but it seems like Starlight has more potential for fun interactions with him than her, since Starlight wouldn't be obligated to be nice.

An alicorn wouldn't be fair to Twilight. While this will be her third season as a good pony, she hasn't had nearly as much screentime as Twilight. Maybe she should complete her apprenticeship and finds a new calling in life somewhere in Ponyville.

We saw from season 8 promotional art that there's a house with Starlight's color scheme. It seems like she'll be kicked out of the castle, at least.

All of MLP season 7 is now on Netflix in the US and Canada!
Capture.JPG


Nick Confalone Confirmed for Writing a Few Episodes of Season 8 - He wrote some great episodes, including "Rock Solid Friendship" and "Saddle Row Review", so it's great to hear he's writing more than one.
Capture.JPG


Next in ED's fanfic writer interview series is Crystal Wishes on the subject of romance, and stories focused on original characters. I hadn't heard of her or her stories, and honestly the fact that they're all about OCs makes me less interested, but I do see a lot of praise of her in the comments.

Also, Sylvee mentioned the newest ED poll, but not this.
1.JPG


377658284368199681.png
It begins

And some art.
Dragon Twilight Sparkle, Give-away art by KodarDragon (Note: FurAffinity link)
bykodardragon1511815146687.png


This dragon Twilight art is really neat!
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Glim Glam kills a pony
Ooh, might check this out then.

No one likes spike :(
Remember that Spike in season 7 just means "Triple Threat", and he was by far the worst part of that episode.

Honestly, surprised that with Guitarity and Punkity, Rarity is only in fourth place, and not that far above Rainbow. (Speaking of which, that's two slots for the season 8 character guide) Though I suppose a big part of this is Fluttershy's memorable showings in "Discordant Harmony" and "A Health of Information".
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
No one likes spike :(

I think he's a neat character idea but he's never really had strong characterization and as I said before, his character varies wildly based on what the episode needs him to act like for the sake of a punchline/the plot. He's been much better from season 6 and beyond but as Sigma said, the only episode he had this season he acted pretty badly in.

Honestly, surprised that with Guitarity and Punkity, Rarity is only in fourth place, and not that far above Rainbow. (Speaking of which, that's two slots for the season 8 character guide) Though I suppose a big part of this is Fluttershy's memorable showings in "Discordant Harmony" and "A Health of Information".

I fee like there's a LOT of overlap between people that like Starlight and people that like Rarity and you can only pick one for this poll. Starlight is generally very popular on the EQD polls but it's still surprising that she won by that big a margin. It's not even a case of Season 6 where I would say that most of the Mane 6 had no real standout moments for the season because there were a lot of good appearances by all of the Mane 6 with the exception of Applejack. That being said I imagine that most people that like Starlight in general voted for her here regardless of her performance in the season. And Rock Solid Friendship and Secrets and Pies both didn't make it into the second round for their favorite episode of the season poll so their opinions are a little bit objectively bad.
 

Nali

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,649
Spike is an adorable little snark machine, but they've never figured out how to manage "is a kid", "is a guy", "is a dragon", "is Twilight's servant", "is Twilight's sibling" in a show that's predominantly about 20-something pony girls.
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562

Whew, that ending message is something else. It shows such a bewildering misunderstanding of Starlight's character and the show's themes as a whole that I don't even know what to start with in terms of addressing it.

The actual animation is alright. The basic premise is that "Starlight's a psycopath" and I didn't find it THAT funny. Other people might though.

spike is lame

he just pretends to like Hoofball

Does this look like someone that only pretends to like Hoofball?

latest
 

Fat4all

Woke up, got a money tag, swears a lot
Member
Oct 25, 2017
92,580
here
What's his angle for faking it though? It's definitely not popular with his close circle of friends, besides maybe AJ and Rainbow? Perhaps he has a secret mancrush on Big Mac and he's trying to get closer to him...
because he needs something in his life to 'have', but you can tell it's just a charade to supplement his already shallow existence

as time steal more of his essence, all he will truly 'have' is a shallow hole to call home for the rest of eternity, a dark chasm of reprise from the hollow place we all share on this gravel together

aka, he fake AF
 
Oct 25, 2017
5,143
because he needs something in his life to 'have', but you can tell it's just a charade to supplement his already shallow existence

as time steal more of his essence, all he will truly 'have' is a shallow hole to call home for the rest of eternity, a dark chasm of reprise from the hollow place we all share on this gravel together

aka, he fake AF
313829__safe_artist-colon-talentlessfiend_pinkie+pie_animated_higurashi+no+naku+koro+ni_insanity_laughing_pinkamena+diane+pie_simple+background_solo_tr.gif
 

Virtua Sanus

Member
Nov 24, 2017
6,492
Long time lurker on the old site, figured I would finally make an account to join in on communities here I found interesting.

Been following the series since a bit before season 2 started. Got really into it for a time but that sorta tapered off. It is still on my mind a lot but I have a bunch of episodes to catch up with now and a lot of episodes do not do much for me. As a big Applejack fan I feel like the writers sometimes go out of their way to make her look kind of lame or uninteresting next to the rest of the cast and it honestly is really starting to get to me.

I did really enjoy the movie though. Kinda shocked how much screen time Pinkie had but otherwise it felt like the first season again with some extra rad animation!

That was kind of a depressing introduction so to counterbalance that:

1270888__safe_artist-colon-theanonshy_edit_edited+screencap_screencap_applejack_big+macintosh_where+the+apple+lies_animated_cute_eye+shimmer_eye+shimme.gif
 

Village

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,807
Spike is an adorable little snark machine, but they've never figured out how to manage "is a kid", "is a guy", "is a dragon", "is Twilight's servant", "is Twilight's sibling" in a show that's predominantly about 20-something pony girls.
Kind of makes sense. I like spike but yeah I he feels like a character that feels... I dunno....troped in? Like they felt like they needed a little brother character, but everyone else here is like... an independent adult it seems, so in most situations all these characters would be living with out siblings. So went with an orphan angle, but then again there's no reason why isn't just living with celestia? Who would make a much better mother figure is actively immortal.

Its weird because they make him a dog in equestria girls, and that's like the one setting where he works as little bro. But fuck you, he's a dog I guess.

I like spike but i'll be one of the first ones to admit he's one of a few characters that I feel like got " troped" in because someone felt like those characters were necessary to this type of show, but in reality the show kinda evolved past it
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
Long time lurker on the old site, figured I would finally make an account to join in on communities here I found interesting.

Welcome to the club. We have a Discord server that we are usually more active in, so if you're interested in that I would recommend checking it out. I'm not sure if there's still an approval process or whatever for it so Sigma would be better to ask about that.

Been following the series since a bit before season 2 started. Got really into it for a time but that sorta tapered off. It is still on my mind a lot but I have a bunch of episodes to catch up with now and a lot of episodes do not do much for me. As a big Applejack fan I feel like the writers sometimes go out of their way to make her look kind of lame or uninteresting next to the rest of the cast and it honestly is really starting to get to me.

Being an AJ fan would be pretty rough since I feel like she's rarely given things to do. For what it's worth there's a certain episode in Season 7 that I would HIGHLY recommend checking out, episode 13.

The show in general has evolved into a different kind of thing then it used to be, especially if you're comparing it to season 1. I personally have enjoyed Season 5 and Season 7 the most out of all of them so far but they have a different feel to many of the episodes that were made under Lauren. I've enjoyed them moving on to more complex stories and don't really care for the slapstick that was frequent in the earlier episodes but I understand the appeal. I fell out of the show and the fandom for a couple years after I got burnt out of it, but I returned about a year ago and I've been having a lot of fun with the show again.

I did really enjoy the movie though. Kinda shocked how much screen time Pinkie had but otherwise it felt like the first season again with some extra rad animation!


Pinkie and Rainbow are the two most popular characters from the show, so I suspect that they had a stronger presence in the movie since they knew kids would like them. The animation was definitely the strongest part of the movie for me. From what we've heard from Hasbro about the movie they've been fairly happy with its performance and are already talking about a second movie, so there's that to look forward to.