-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
BREXIT MAFIA PHASE 2 | Border-Line Insanity!
- Thread starter cabot
- Start date
This is a really good post, but I think we need to consider the GP wagon also because there's no reason why scum couldn't be on that one as well. Kalor would of probably been the better mislynch for scum though so I wouldn't be surprised if scum decided to give that wagon more attention. I'm still sticking with Faddy for today, but I think we should come back to this list and I really want to look into AB and Melon
You can't make this shit up. And her reasoning the next day:
Just realizing this the second post includes catching up, when her first statement was won't vote CS despite the gambit. So what exactly was there to catch up?
also if Faddy is scum, do look into DCPat. I've stated why but I've seen town forget things when the people who would point them out are dead soooo lol.
Do you think you'll wind up dead in the near future? Because that's not what I'm expecting given the situation of the game.
Morning, everyone. I'm still torn on Faddy - I don't think I can honestly say that I feel the same way about his votes today as I did at the end of D2, but I don't think I'm going to place a vote on him just yet. Stuart's opinion on him feels solid, but I'd be interested to know if there's a consensus or if it's an individual tunnel.
That said, though, I do have a better feeling about Stuart today - he feels more like himself. I appreciate the work he's been putting in to his read and, as I mentioned, I think his feelings on Faddy are genuine. As such, while I don't think that I'm not in a position to switch my vote now, I feel that it would be inappropriate to keep my vote on him given my current stance.
UNVOTE
That said, though, I do have a better feeling about Stuart today - he feels more like himself. I appreciate the work he's been putting in to his read and, as I mentioned, I think his feelings on Faddy are genuine. As such, while I don't think that I'm not in a position to switch my vote now, I feel that it would be inappropriate to keep my vote on him given my current stance.
UNVOTE
Gorlak, I'm really not going to justify timezone differences with you. The thread started and has continued to progress primarily when I've been alseep. Don't be shitty.
also to bring up Faddy's votes from the past few days:
Started the wagon yes but could be an easy bus to slide into and stay on. The main reasons seem to be fluffy interactions and decides that since no one has put down a vote despite scum reading him, he puts one down.
Less than 24 hours into the day but it was something easy to justify and stay on so that if he flipped scum, it would give him town cred.
This was his original vote for Kalor - a confirmed dead town. Found an easy justification for the vote. If we're looking at Kalor's and GPs voters, this is one we should keep in mind despite him taking it off of them.
His OMGUS vote after I started pushing on him.
D2 and 3 dosn't put him in a good light, D1 could very easily be an easy bus using safe D1-style justification.
Started the wagon yes but could be an easy bus to slide into and stay on. The main reasons seem to be fluffy interactions and decides that since no one has put down a vote despite scum reading him, he puts one down.
Less than 24 hours into the day but it was something easy to justify and stay on so that if he flipped scum, it would give him town cred.
This was his original vote for Kalor - a confirmed dead town. Found an easy justification for the vote. If we're looking at Kalor's and GPs voters, this is one we should keep in mind despite him taking it off of them.
His OMGUS vote after I started pushing on him.
D2 and 3 dosn't put him in a good light, D1 could very easily be an easy bus using safe D1-style justification.
Okay, yeah. Looking at that, it doesn't really help. Especially because I'm pretty sure nin is town
It's not about timezones. Explain to me what changed regarding Coolest - AFTER he withdrew his gambit you already referred to D1.
Okay. I will preface this by stating I may still be drunk.
I'll pretend I haven't already answered this. I voted for him because the act continued after said gamit and his play towards EoD very anti-town and obnoxious. He was practically baiting a vote and I wanted to find out why.
So melon says she wasn't happy about D1 candidates. D2 she scumreads Zeke, Kalor, nin. When she arrives EoD2, she says nin is rolefishing. And doesn't believe Zeke states opinions from Fantomas. Then it's gif after gif after gif.
Here is her reaction to Kalor's claim:
Here is her reaction to Kalor's claim:
This doesn't feel like not believing. Grizzly asks what scum!Kalors plan would be
This trend continues. At that time there was ZERO benefit from voting Kalor. He was being pressured here to make a quick decision.
Wtf? She was a major creator of that heat yesterday - and at that point D3, when the note business was in play, she wanted the game to calm down?
She also went on to assume the note was a lie, after Zeke said he didn't move. This could be TMI, but isn't a strong point since it was Coolest talking.
Could you please answer this melonrabbit.
I didn't like candidates day one. That's true. Nin was acting quite agression on D2 and his comment struck me as odd. Don't believe either, no. He's behavior has been off and I don't think we've gotten a proper tunnel until today. But meta aside, surely the amount of shrugging things off has gotten old. Also, Zeke started that gif chain. Is your argument anti gifs?
Is your argument that I and I alone as scum was somehow pressuirng Kalor so make a quick decision ... that he had already decided and told us?
You're reaching even for you, Gor.
Um, what are you talking? I was referring to Soph subbing out and that fact people were getting genuinely upset and not having fun. Seriously, this is what you nitpick?
As I mentioned a few posts above: that whole shitpost charade including you, coolest and zeke is suspect to me. In previous games there were times something like this stood out to me and it was a scum team doing it.
My argument is that you were quickly to speculate around Kalor. Raised the pressure (together with Coolest) by voting him, when there was absolutely no need to force him to decide quickly. Your post very clearly show you interested in how a potential override could play out (if he's gunning for actual scum?) You also contradict yourself with "his power after all" and "I don't believe it".
I missed the context when isoing you just now. You are right, this is nothing to complain about.
If this is your takeaway. Then both sarcasm and fun are lost on you.
To add to this - the conversation between ET and Z-Beat about sleep study is something very similar. Of course people having fun is a possibility, but I've been burned by that thought before.
Sure it was all fun and joy, while Kalor was close to being turboed - people voting him (yes you melon) and calling for a completely unnecessary claim from GP (looking at you Faddy). This created a sense of urgency that was redundant. You as one of the aggressors stand out to me. Couple that with your remaining behaviour - et voila: scum read.
If you think the conversation betwern ET and Z-beat why are focusing on myself, AB and Soph/LP?
While you are here, I know you probably need to catch up, but give me your input once you've done that. Your top scum candidates are still Zeke and nin I suppose?
What's your opinion on the current vote leaders - faddy and alexem?
And what do you think of turmoil7?
What's your opinion on the current vote leaders - faddy and alexem?
And what do you think of turmoil7?
I think Faddy is an exciting vote.
I forgot alexem was in this game.
ouch.
Well... at least it's not as bad as the LP burn earlier I guess.
There is literally nothing I can point at from Z-Beat, I have no memory outside of this little interaction because AB pointed at it in response to me one time. It is a kind of tell I was just explaining to you, that I see there as well. It's a note for the future once we have more flips. I could see a connection there between Donna/AB/Z-Beat, but those are premature thoughts that need info to verify.
As of right now I see You, AB and Sophia as much more likely to be scum. Hence why I argue for their lynches. Thinking of it - what do you think of the other two?
Thank you for your permission to go and catch up. I feel so relieved now.
I like turnmoil. He's able to express himself in a way that doesn't drive me insane and remain classy while doing so. He's probably town.
You've played with me before, you know that IS the case.
Fuck that. If I had just asked you for your opinion, you'd be screaming at me how you need time and are still drunk. I'm trying to be more friendly, ever since you said I'm always going harder on you than others in some spec chat somewhere. Guess I'm failing that again.
I didn't like Soph disppearing toward the end of D2 hence why I had questions. We won't get answers and LP will probably not even post so... that's probably the scum that got away.
I'd need to reread AB.
Z-Beat where do you think you'll be voting?
malus any thoughts as we get near EOD? Any idea who you want to vote
Lone_Prodigy caught up yet?
malus any thoughts as we get near EOD? Any idea who you want to vote
Lone_Prodigy caught up yet?
No, you are trying to discredit my reasonable case against you through ridiculing me. Ad hominem at it's best.
It is better or worse than responding with a gif or a *shrug*?
You're reaching in your arguments. And taking a lighthearted moment as this gotcha is gonna backfire on you and unravel your whole theory. But then I have the benefit of knowing I'm town, you don't.
I am not ridculing you personally. We just play differently. I disagree with the comments of mine you've chosen to latch onto.
We are disagreeing and you are wrong about me being scum but I do respect you. I hope you see that.
I'm currently assembling my thoughts so give me a minute. But at the moment I'm thinking of voting for absolutbro.
Rereading absolutbro:
D1 was basically nothing.
Joins EoD1 asking why ET over Coolest antics and lands on Coolest with his vote.
D2 is a whole lot of nothing, until the end:
Catch up, Mechanics, Reads: Kalor suspicious, Zeke looking worse. Grizz & Chuggs towny
Asking about Zeke's supposed night chat
votes Kalor "for now"
reads:
Zeke wants to wait for more chat claims
GP scummy, but today more town
Faddy burned out town
brings up nin - says looks bad
seems to be interested in mechanics, misunderstands and asks kalor about override.
The continuing reaction seems logical and not scummy, until:
Honestly the EoD2 is giving me a better feeling about him.
D1 was basically nothing.
Joins EoD1 asking why ET over Coolest antics and lands on Coolest with his vote.
D2 is a whole lot of nothing, until the end:
Catch up, Mechanics, Reads: Kalor suspicious, Zeke looking worse. Grizz & Chuggs towny
Asking about Zeke's supposed night chat
votes Kalor "for now"
reads:
Zeke wants to wait for more chat claims
GP scummy, but today more town
Faddy burned out town
brings up nin - says looks bad
seems to be interested in mechanics, misunderstands and asks kalor about override.
The continuing reaction seems logical and not scummy, until:
Honestly the EoD2 is giving me a better feeling about him.
I also noticed that Sophia seemed go quiet while I was re-reading Kalor's claim and over-ride - she was calling for people to avoid turbo-ing Kalor, which is perfectly understandable, but didn't seem to be around when people were putting the pressure on. I considered that she might have been away when the pressure mounted - especially if she was expecting the over-ride to come nearer to deadline time - but then I noticed that she greeted GP about six minutes before Kalor used his action, so I think she was still around. Given her earlier responsed to the situation, I would have expected a little more resistance from her when there were calls for Kalor to go ahead.
AB was of a similar mindset around the time, but was a little more involved - he responded to some points that were raised, for instance.
I feel like instead of focusing on the ones voting for ET on D1 (faddy, alex and we already "lynched" kalor) we should have a look at the votes on CS.
I do have a strange feeling on Faddy because he seems so different to his other games and his flip could give us some information on other players, but I'm not sure the feeling is strong enough for a lynch. But between the two top wagons at the moment he would be my preference.
I feel the worst about absolutbro, since his votes were badly explained and he wasn't exactly helpful today.
I'm also getting bad vibes from nin. His votes have been less than stellar so far (CS and GP) and there was some serious flip flopping yesterday. Today he seems to be mostly coasting along not contributing much. This all reminds me very much of our conspiracy game where he did basically the same thing.
What stood out to me was the following post:
Which brings me to Chuggernaut. I felt his claim was genuine but I guess it's an easy enough claim to make. I thought he made some good posts but also nothing ground breaking.
I was quite skeptical of Stuart, but he's been much better today and has put in quite a bit of work I think.
Sophia was in my scum list, but her subbing out kind of put a damper on that.
Not sure what to make of z-beat and melon. zb hasn't really done anything and is mainly just there. Could be scum coasting along but is null for me for now.
I do have a strange feeling on Faddy because he seems so different to his other games and his flip could give us some information on other players, but I'm not sure the feeling is strong enough for a lynch. But between the two top wagons at the moment he would be my preference.
I feel the worst about absolutbro, since his votes were badly explained and he wasn't exactly helpful today.
I'm also getting bad vibes from nin. His votes have been less than stellar so far (CS and GP) and there was some serious flip flopping yesterday. Today he seems to be mostly coasting along not contributing much. This all reminds me very much of our conspiracy game where he did basically the same thing.
What stood out to me was the following post:
He goes hard on Chugger but is swayed by some flimsy arguments? Could be he's protecting a team mate there.
Which brings me to Chuggernaut. I felt his claim was genuine but I guess it's an easy enough claim to make. I thought he made some good posts but also nothing ground breaking.
I was quite skeptical of Stuart, but he's been much better today and has put in quite a bit of work I think.
Sophia was in my scum list, but her subbing out kind of put a damper on that.
Not sure what to make of z-beat and melon. zb hasn't really done anything and is mainly just there. Could be scum coasting along but is null for me for now.
This was an unusual emotional answer.
And this is what's bothering me today. He hasn't offered any new insight. He is withholding himself from the game.
He's low activity, is lacking input and had two bad votes. But the reaction to Kalor's claim looks fine to me.
I end up being less sure about my scumread, but I don't know how long he should get a pass for minimal input. This is making it hard to read him and/or finding connections.
unvote
Is there any sort of comment on why he stayed on Kalor? "For now" doesn't seem definitive, but it was.
I just felt a lack of presence from her as the day wind down and it just seemed so odd. Also, the fact barely anyone else has spoken about it until nowish. Her posts lacked exactly what I liked so much about her exchange with Gorlak initially. Very muted.