• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

thepenguin55

Member
Oct 28, 2017
11,823
How good is the D-Pad on the 8bitdo controllers? During the Giantbomb Super NT stream Jason said the D-Pad was better on the controller with the analog sticks. I think Jeremy Parrish said it was not as good as an original SNES controller. I already have a SNES Retro receiver. Are the controllers worth it?

So I've never used any of their controllers but I actually get the sense that their controllers have historically been pretty good but that these SNES-style controllers are not very good. On the GB stream Jeff was also having an issue where hitting L or R once would cause his character in Super Mario Kart to hop 3 times

EDIT
Yep. I am sure it has actually been moving, and just not updating. I hope, at least. Really gonna be pissy if I paid $35 for shipping to have it sit at UPS for 3 days not moving.

I was annoyed because when I initially went to place my order the shipping came out to be $32 but then my cousin suggested that we should do both of our orders together in a single order so when I restarted the order changing the quantity from 1 to 2 my shipping jumped up to $38. Paying $19 for shipping is better than $38 but it could have been even cheaper if the price didn't arbitrarily jump up!
 
Last edited:

tommyv2

Member
Nov 6, 2017
1,425
How good is the D-Pad on the 8bitdo controllers? During the Giantbomb Super NT stream Jason said the D-Pad was better on the controller with the analog sticks. I think Jeremy Parrish said it was not as good as an original SNES controller. I already have a SNES Retro receiver. Are the controllers worth it?

I've done extensive testing with my SN30 Retro controllers. Although there's even a variation between the two, I find them excellent. As for people constantly discussing "accidental diagonals" that happen when pressing the cardinal directions, this happens MUCH more easily on the real SNES/SFC controllers I've tested. I'm using the Windows Gamepad Calibration which shows you your input in real-time. I'm sure everone's mileage may vary, but it's the best third-party controller I've ever used. I have 6 different DualShock 4s and they're all of varying quality, so it can happen with any brand.
 

TheDeep1974

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,012
Tried Unholy Night (ROM on Everdrive). Game worked fine on Retroarch but on SuperNT gives me a black screen with music playing in the background. I have no idea if the ROM is clean or if the game has Everdrive detection, or perhaps it had been patched/hacked to run on an emulator. Not really bothered, but tested to see if it works as something told me it wouldn't :P
 

lunch_box

Member
Nov 5, 2017
188
Anyone know where I can the matching controllers for these in the uk??

The ones on amazon seem to be for the classic mini!?

Any ideas?

Thanks
 

modoversus

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,677
México
I've done extensive testing with my SN30 Retro controllers. Although there's even a variation between the two, I find them excellent. As for people constantly discussing "accidental diagonals" that happen when pressing the cardinal directions, this happens MUCH more easily on the real SNES/SFC controllers I've tested. I'm using the Windows Gamepad Calibration which shows you your input in real-time. I'm sure everone's mileage may vary, but it's the best third-party controller I've ever used. I have 6 different DualShock 4s and they're all of varying quality, so it can happen with any brand.

Good to hear, thank you for the information!
 

Cien

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,526
So mine shipped the 7th. Expected by the end of day on the 13th. $40, 3lbs 2oz, and I'm in the US.

A USPS flat-rate box would have been both faster and less than half the cost.

All will be forgiven and forgotten upon the release of 8-Bit and ROM loading support.

I believe.

Yea, im not terribly happy about the pricey shipping to wait effectively a week for the unit to arrive. It is what it is at this point though.
 

modoversus

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,677
México
So I've never used any of their controllers but I actually get the sense that their controllers have historically been pretty good but that these SNES-style controllers are not very good. On the GB stream Jeff was also having an issue where hitting L or R once would cause his character in Super Mario Kart to hop 3 times

I skipped the part where they play Mario Kart. I'll check it later to see this. Thanks!
 

DOTDASHDOT

Helios Abandoned. Atropos Conquered.
Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,076
Dark1x Do you think you could do some best settings In your review? Like CRT comparable, height/width settings, Scanline etc for 720p, and 1080p ones?
 
Oct 27, 2017
12,305
My order page just updated saying that my order could not be delivered and shows it was out for delivery. Even though the actual tracking on UPS is showing it's still in transit for delivery next Wednesday
 

Deleted member 563

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,215
My order page just updated saying that my order could not be delivered and shows it was out for delivery. Even though the actual tracking on UPS is showing it's still in transit for delivery next Wednesday
Haha, wow. What the heck is going on.

Actually, I checked my status page after reading your post, and it still says "Order Confirmed." Lol...
 

Jockel

Member
Oct 27, 2017
683
Berlin
Any requests for testing? For this Sunday's video, I'm going to draw a comparison between real hardware, the Super Nt, Higan and the SNES Mini (using stock emulator). I have a bunch of tests ready but figured I'd see if anyone wanted to see something specific!
I'd like to know if the Dolby Pro Logic surround sound works. Tales of Phantasia or Seiken Densetsu 3 (Stereo > Wide mode) come to mind.
 

F34R

Member
Oct 27, 2017
11,999
This is what mine looks like so far:

Next Scheduled Event: Monday,02/12/2018 by 5:00 P.M.

LOCATION DATE LOCAL TIME ACTIVITY
Las Vegas, NV, United States 02/07/2018 11:19 P.M. Departure Scan
02/07/2018 7:00 P.M. Origin Scan
United States 02/06/2018 4:04 P.M. Order Processed: Ready for UPS
 
Oct 27, 2017
12,305
I'm not too worried about it since the actual tracking is fine. I assume their order page is just acting funky considering how long it took to update in the first place. Unfortunate that they're having these issues on their big break-out product release.
 
Oct 27, 2017
5,807
I've done extensive testing with my SN30 Retro controllers. Although there's even a variation between the two, I find them excellent. As for people constantly discussing "accidental diagonals" that happen when pressing the cardinal directions, this happens MUCH more easily on the real SNES/SFC controllers I've tested. I'm using the Windows Gamepad Calibration which shows you your input in real-time. I'm sure everone's mileage may vary, but it's the best third-party controller I've ever used. I have 6 different DualShock 4s and they're all of varying quality, so it can happen with any brand.

I disagree on the accidental diagonal presses. The 8Bitdo controller is far worse in that regards, to the point of being frustrating. I don't have that issue on my original SNES controllers, or on the 4 SNES mini controllers I've used. Last night I was playing Joe and Mac, and with the 8Bitdo controllers navigating around the map was frustrating because a diagonal press would make the character stop. I ended up switching back to my real controller and didn't have any issues.
 

JamesQuall

Member
Oct 27, 2017
749
My order says couldn't be delivered on the Analogue order status page, but UPS has it out for delivery. Just got emails from both places doubling down on those statuses. Real strange, but I expect it'll be here shortly.
 

tommyv2

Member
Nov 6, 2017
1,425
I disagree on the accidental diagonal presses. The 8Bitdo controller is far worse in that regards, to the point of being frustrating. I don't have that issue on my original SNES controllers, or on the 4 SNES mini controllers I've used. Last night I was playing Joe and Mac, and with the 8Bitdo controllers navigating around the map was frustrating because a diagonal press would make the character stop. I ended up switching back to my real controller and didn't have any issues.

So you're saying that on a real SNES controller, if you hold the tip of a cardinal direction, by wiggling it, you get no other inputs at all? Ever? I've tested an 2x SNS-105, SNS-102 and a Japanese SFC controller and they are all sensitive to diagonal inputs on cardinal directions. Are you really supposed to push the ends of two directions to register a diagonal? Is that what people are expecting? Honest question; I'm not trying to antagonize.
 
Oct 27, 2017
5,807
So you're saying that on a real SNES controller, if you hold the tip of a cardinal direction, by wiggling it, you get no other inputs at all? Ever? I've tested an 2x SNS-105, SNS-102 and a Japanese SFC controller and they are all sensitive to diagonal inputs on cardinal directions. Are you really supposed to push the ends of two directions to register a diagonal? Is that what people are expecting? Honest question; I'm not trying to antagonize.

I'm saying that on real SNES controllers I almost never get an unintentional diagonal press. If I purposefully wiggle the d-pad while pressing up or down then I can get one, but I never have it happen while I'm just trying to press straight up or down. On the 8Bitdo one I have to be very careful when pushing up or down, because if I'm not then I end up pushing diagonal almost every time. It's been very annoying, and games like Doom are very hard to play on it. Something like walking up the stairs in the first level become frustrating because it's hard to walk straight without turning.
 

thepenguin55

Member
Oct 28, 2017
11,823
I skipped the part where they play Mario Kart. I'll check it later to see this. Thanks!

So the weird thing is that Jeff said the L and R issue only happened while playing Super Mario Kart so it could be some Super NT compatibility issue with that game? Or maybe the controller just started acting up then? Not sure. Also as someone who loves GB that stream was actually kind of annoying as it was basically just them complaining about cartridges and complaining about the features it doesn't have and shit like that.
 

Hero_of_the_Day

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
17,355
So the weird thing is that Jeff said the L and R issue only happened while playing Super Mario Kart so it could be some Super NT compatibility issue with that game? Or maybe the controller just started acting up then? Not sure. Also as someone who loves GB that stream was actually kind of annoying as it was basically just them complaining about cartridges and complaining about the features it doesn't have and shit like that.

The complaining about save states was weird, like they seemed to not fully get what this device was supposed to be.

The cartridge problems they were having seemed a little odd to me, though. I had a massive SNES collection up until a couple of years ago. I never had as many issues playing on real hardware as they did on that stream. I did always clean anything new I got with alcohol, but they were doing that as well and having issues still. Hopefully they just had some really dirty shit and that isn't a bad sign of things to come.
 

beelulzebub

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,600
I disagree on the accidental diagonal presses. The 8Bitdo controller is far worse in that regards, to the point of being frustrating. I don't have that issue on my original SNES controllers, or on the 4 SNES mini controllers I've used. Last night I was playing Joe and Mac, and with the 8Bitdo controllers navigating around the map was frustrating because a diagonal press would make the character stop. I ended up switching back to my real controller and didn't have any issues.

Agreed. Don't have any real SNES controllers on hand, but I do have the ones that came with my SNES Classic and had no issue with sensitive diagonals with those.

My 8bitdo controllers arrived before my Super NT, so I tested them out with Celeste, and the highly sensitive diagonals made that game unplayable. I switched to the Pokken controller and that D-pad is infinitely better. I'm in the process of returning my 8bitdo controllers. Absolute terrible controllers.
 

Hero_of_the_Day

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
17,355
Agreed. Don't have any real SNES controllers on hand, but I do have the ones that came with my SNES Classic and had no issue with sensitive diagonals with those.

My 8bitdo controllers arrived before my Super NT, so I tested them out with Celeste, and the highly sensitive diagonals made that game unplayable. I switched to the Pokken controller and that D-pad is infinitely better. I'm in the process of returning my 8bitdo controllers. Absolute terrible controllers.

Sucks to hear some people not liking them so much. I have a ton of real SNES controllers, so I will definitely be returning these 8bitdo controllers to Amazon if I feel as bad. $80 for two shitty controllers is too much.
 

GreenMonkey

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,862
Michigan
I'm saying that on real SNES controllers I almost never get an unintentional diagonal press. If I purposefully wiggle the d-pad while pressing up or down then I can get one, but I never have it happen while I'm just trying to press straight up or down. On the 8Bitdo one I have to be very careful when pushing up or down, because if I'm not then I end up pushing diagonal almost every time. It's been very annoying, and games like Doom are very hard to play on it. Something like walking up the stairs in the first level become frustrating because it's hard to walk straight without turning.

This, posted about this earlier in the week.

My NES30 is a bit worse than my new SN30... but the above is what happens.

Most noticeable for games that require straight down or up presses. Contra is a huge one, because, for example, down is DUCK to avoid fire (stop moving) and down forward results in you walking forward (for shooting downward).

It's not bad for a lot of games - but if you switch to an OEM one you can notice the difference. And games that need diagonals more are much more noticeable.

See post 70 here showing how the PCB underneath is very different from the SNES one (older SNES30 PCB). 8bitdo had a long, long thread about this on their forums before they took the forums down, so it's not like they didn't know about it.

https://www.resetera.com/threads/8bitdo-sf30-sn30-pro-controller.1742/page-2

The older 8bitdos are supposed to be improved with this tape mod:
https://i.imgur.com/Vs5xn20.jpg

Same problem / fix with the Switch pro controller:
https://www.reddit.com/r/8bitdo/comments/7jfiva/sn30_sf30_pro_disassembled/

See also this tape mod which someone reported helped on his new SN30:

https://www.reddit.com/r/8bitdo/com..._dpad_is_no_better_than_official_pro/dri1o25/
 

Darknight

"I'd buy that for a dollar!"
Member
Oct 25, 2017
22,857
As a Canadian having had to deal with UPS and their subpar services, I thoroughly disagree.
Knowing my unit was shipped with UPS made me prety unhappy since the last time they delivered something they put it in the god damned recycling bin and just left a note in the mailbox "on garbage day"!

Guess what happened

Your shitty driver isn't indicative of the service as a whole. Every delivery service has bad delivery people. Regardless, you were commenting on it being UPS's fault for it costing $40 to take a week to deliver in the US where as it's only 2 days for the same price outside. The speed and price has nothing to do with UPS; that's Analogue's fault for shipping it in the middle of the week and shipping it UPS ground for domestic delivery where as they shipped it via air for international.
 

thepenguin55

Member
Oct 28, 2017
11,823
The complaining about save states was weird, like they seemed to not fully get what this device was supposed to be.

The cartridge problems they were having seemed a little odd to me, though. I had a massive SNES collection up until a couple of years ago. I never had as many issues playing on real hardware as they did on that stream. I did always clean anything new I got with alcohol, but they were doing that as well and having issues still. Hopefully they just had some really dirty shit and that isn't a bad sign of things to come.

So I have the Analogue NT and NT Mini and they're both super sensitive to dirt. Having said that something that always drives me nuts about GB's retro game streams where they're using actual hardware is that every single time they seem to be stunned by how dirty their games are. At this point you would think they would just assume their games are dirty and clean them ahead of time. That way they're not spending half of the stream cleaning carts. I mean, they were even joking about just how much dirt they were getting off of their carts as they were cleaning them.

So, in recent years I've actually used degreasers on games that needed to be cleaned so at this point for most of my collection the most I'll need to do is blow on the cart and I'm good to go. I saw a degreaser suggested once as a cart cleaner somewhere and have found any information since then so maybe I'm actually doing irreparable damage to my carts but its worked well for me thus far...
 

Fularu

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,609
Your shitty driver isn't indicative of the service as a whole. Every delivery service has bad delivery people. Regardless, you were commenting on it being UPS's fault for it costing $40 to take a week to deliver in the US where as it's only 2 days for the same price outside. The speed and price has nothing to do with UPS; that's Analogue's fault for shipping it in the middle of the week and shipping it UPS ground for domestic delivery where as they shipped it via air for international.
I never commented on the price, just on the delivery window.
 

Mikespit1200

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
57
Has there been any talk of a jailbroken firmware similar to the NT mini? I've been holding off on getting a Super NT for this reason. If such a firmware were released, which 8/16-bit cores would it support? Which cores are ready to go?
 

Darknight

"I'd buy that for a dollar!"
Member
Oct 25, 2017
22,857
I never commented on the price, just on the delivery window.

The price was in the quote you were replying to. The delivery window is dependent on how they shipped it. Like I said, they shipped it ground from the west coast so it takes 4 to 5 business days to make it to the east coast. It's going on a truck cross country; that's ground delivery service. That's the method Analogue picked. That's their fault. You can't complain it's not arriving until next week when Analogue shipped it ground, Analogue shipped it in the middle of the week so that anyone on the east coast would get hit with the weekend delay which doesn't count as part of those 4 or 5 days, and Analogue shipped everyone else air delivery which is faster. That's all on Analogue and not UPS's fault.
 

Fularu

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,609
The price was in the quote you were replying to. The delivery window is dependent on how they shipped it. Like I said, they shipped it ground from the west coast so it takes 4 to 5 business days to make it to the east coast. It's going on a truck cross country; that's ground delivery service. That's the method Analogue picked. That's their fault. You can't complain it's not arriving until next week when Analogue shipped it ground, Analogue shipped it in the middle of the week so that anyone on the east coast would get hit with the weekend delay which doesn't count as part of those 4 or 5 days, and Analogue shipped everyone else air delivery which is faster. That's all on Analogue and not UPS's fault.
Are you done telling me what I can or can't do regarding my stance through years of dealings with UPS in Canada?
 

querulous

Member
Oct 27, 2017
41
Black Hole Planet 3
Has there been any talk of a jailbroken firmware similar to the NT mini? I've been holding off on getting a Super NT for this reason. If such a firmware were released, which 8/16-bit cores would it support? Which cores are ready to go?

Its highly rumored but there are no official announcements. As far as anyone knows there are no additional 16 bit cores outside of the SNES ready to go, so if it happens it would only contain whats currently available for the NT Mini + Snes.
 

thepenguin55

Member
Oct 28, 2017
11,823
Has there been any talk of a jailbroken firmware similar to the NT mini? I've been holding off on getting a Super NT for this reason. If such a firmware were released, which 8/16-bit cores would it support? Which cores are ready to go?

No and the probability of that stuff happening is all kind of iffy now that kevtris is an Analogue employee (his work on the previous systems was contract work and then he put out all the jail breaking stuff afterwards). Even if it does happen I doubt that he would put out any new cores. I think he would just make all of the cores he made for the NT mini compatible for the Super NT.
 

Fuzzy

Completely non-threatening
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
18,138
Toronto
If Analogue plans to still make money on 8-bit consoles (whether with the Nt mini or something new) then I don't expect anything more than kevtris releasing ROM loading for SNES games on the Super Nt. Why would they want an employee releasing the previous cores on the Super Nt if they can still make money from them?
 

Fularu

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,609
I just got ANOTHER email saying my shipping status was updated, check the status... same thing. lol their system is crumbling.
There's a disconnet between their tracking and the one UPS provides. The order states that UPS couldn't deliver it while UPS says it's still in California. I guess they have issues using the API for tracking?
 

Dark1x

Digital Foundry
Verified
Oct 26, 2017
3,530
I did the Speedy Gonzales test! Whew, that took some time as the game is super cheap (blind jumps and attacks out of nowhere are the norm).
 

thepenguin55

Member
Oct 28, 2017
11,823
I just got ANOTHER email saying my shipping status was updated, check the status... same thing. lol their system is crumbling.

Same thing just happened to me. It's super weird.

If Analogue plans to still make money on 8-bit consoles (whether with the Nt mini or something new) then I don't expect anything more than kevtris releasing ROM loading for SNES games on the Super Nt. Why would they want an employee releasing the previous cores on the Super Nt if they can still make money from them?

Honestly, I think that's only true if an NES core is made available for the Super NT. If a NES core isn't made available for the Super NT then I think there would still be an audience for a cheaper plastic NT mini with only two controller ports. It would be an admittedly smaller audience but I think there would still be one.

EDIT: Having said that, the more I think about it I think a cheaper NT mini will never happen due to them already having done multiple waves of each version of the Analogue NT and the double whammy of the NES Classic and AVS existing.
 

stumblebee

The Fallen
Jan 22, 2018
2,504
Wonder how hackable this thing is going to be. Watching the Giant Bomb stream and this thing looks dope. Hope I can eventually run games off of an SD card or hack in savestates or something.
 

malrock

Member
Oct 26, 2017
230
North Carolina
Your shitty driver isn't indicative of the service as a whole. Every delivery service has bad delivery people. Regardless, you were commenting on it being UPS's fault for it costing $40 to take a week to deliver in the US where as it's only 2 days for the same price outside. The speed and price has nothing to do with UPS; that's Analogue's fault for shipping it in the middle of the week and shipping it UPS ground for domestic delivery where as they shipped it via air for international.
Wait, in what world is $40 for UPS ground shipping for something that weighs just a smidge over 3 pounds normal?
 

Darknight

"I'd buy that for a dollar!"
Member
Oct 25, 2017
22,857
Wait, in what world is $40 for UPS ground shipping for something that weighs just a smidge over 3 pounds normal?

It's not which is why I don't think people should be blaming UPS for those shipping prices. That's on Analogue. Even worse is the shipping rates are going up at Analogue for newer shipments compared to before.
 

SoH

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,739
Wonder how hackable this thing is going to be. Watching the Giant Bomb stream and this thing looks dope. Hope I can eventually run games off of an SD card or hack in savestates or something.

Reasonable possibilities, there is nothing technically preventing this to my knowledge, but obviously no guarantees.
-Basic rom loading (not supporting every expansion chip)
-Cart dumping
-8-bit cores + rom loading

Extremely unlikely
-Rom loading for expansion chips such as Super FX games
-Genesis, TG16, etc.. cores
-Save states -- I am going to put this in this category, not because it is impossible, but this is much more difficult to do in FPGA and likely to be error prone.
 

Hexadron

Member
Oct 25, 2017
750
I hope Analogue does a cheaper plastic cased revision of the NT Mini in the near future. It seems they are pro cartridge so I'm thinking it's more likely for a revised product versus cores.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.