• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Spikematic

Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,357
Simon lighting up the garbage people was so cathartic. I just wish the leader lady with the bad hair would've gotten shot in the head as well. Ah well, at least we got to see trash people get grinded into delicious zombie paste. If only she had jumped in too.
 

Zaph

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,108
When Jadis was left all alone at the end, anyone else get the feeling
she'll shave her head be back after the time jump as Alpha, leader of the Whisperers? It's the exact type of shit I expect from the writers who love twisting the knife in Rick.
 

Deleted member 2254

user requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
21,467
Jadis is the reason they were introduced. She must have some part to play if they decided to keep her around.

They juggled around with them for a while, only for useless fillers and ultimately to kill them all to make a compelling character. All this could have be done in one episode, for example instead of that dumb CGI deer episode from last season where Rick almost killed himself being an idiot in the amusement park. This was their master plan endgame for the whole dumpster storyline? Talk about wasting time.
 

ZeoVGM

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
76,219
Providence, RI
http://variety.com/2018/tv/ratings/walking-dead-season-8-ratings-lows-1202719271/

'Walking Dead' Drops to Lowest Ratings Since Season 1

"The Walking Dead" just can't catch a break.

This past Sunday's episode of the AMC zombie apocalypse series, the tenth episode of the show's eighth season, drew a 2.9 rating in adults 18-49 and 6.8 million viewers in the Nielsen Live+Same Day numbers. That is the lowest rating in the key demographic that the show has put up since its first season back in 2010. The last time "The Walking Dead," which is the top-rated show on television, drew less than a 3.0 rating was the Season 1 episode "Wildfire," which drew a 2.8. The last time the show drew less than 7 million viewers was the second season episode "Better Angels," which averaged 6.9 million.

This week's episode was also down around 20 percent in both measures compared to last week's midseason premiere, one of the steeper drop offs the show has seen between a midseason premiere and a subsequent episode to date. As Variety reported last week, the Season 8 midseason premiere was the lowest-rated midseason premiere in series history, putting up a 3.6 rating in adults 18-49 and 8.3 million viewers.

Previously, the Season 8 midseason finale was the show's lowest-rated since Season 2. The Season 8 premiere was also the show's lowest-rated since its third season, despite the fact that the Season 8 opener was also the show's 100th episode.

Again, it bears repeating that "The Walking Dead" was still the top-rated and most-watched cable show of the night by far and faced stiff competition from the Academy Awards on ABC, which also saw new ratings lows.
 

riotous

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,351
Seattle
So I didn't quite get it. Why would the garbage people speaking nonsense? To be different?

They are hiding at the very least, a helicopter. If not other tech and a more hospitable dwelling.. they use the dump and their grunt-speak to make it so nobody will care much about them. Who would want to take over a dump? Who would bother these grunting people who seem useless and live in a dump?

Meanwhile they are hiding the garbage Wakanda back there under those piles of trash.
 

okayfrog

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,968
A week behind, but I wasn't the only one who laughed at Carl killing himself with a silenced pistol, right? That goddamn sound effect was hilarious.
 

Deleted member 31923

User requested account closure
Banned
Nov 8, 2017
5,826
The mid season opener gave me slight hope (even if they dragged Carl's death on for too long), but this episode killed it with fire. You could have a drinking game for all the times Rick tells Negan he is going to kill him. And I'm so glad the garbage people are dead. I love how many times Rick risked his life for these people who do nothing but double and triple cross their allies and switch back and forth without actually fighting. Sure, if there were 300 of them, it may be worth the risk, but there were only about 30 of them after all that. I just wish Jadis would have died with them. Awful character. Of course her Mad Max Neanderthal dialogue was fake, but who would believe it anyway? Maybe with 500 years of Apocalypse, people would start talking that way. But 5? The show's ratings are tanking because it's so repetitive, but also it's too comic like and not at all realistic, as exemplified by the garbage people. You don't need a ton of realism from a zombie show, but there should at least be a little. Maybe the human characters can seem like they are actually human.
 

ZeoVGM

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
76,219
Providence, RI
A week behind, but I wasn't the only one who laughed at Carl killing himself with a silenced pistol, right? That goddamn sound effect was hilarious.

Nope, it was silly. It just didn't make sense for us, the audience, to hear the sound of the gun going off the way we did, considering where the camera was. It made a dramatic moment a bit silly.
 

Chitown B

Member
Nov 15, 2017
9,610
I have a feeling this is the pathway too. I feel like the show just looks tired at this point. There's hardly any new areas we see, we've seen Alexandria for what, 3 years now? I'm in it to the end though, as I do still love this universe.

If there are going to be spin offs, what I would like to see is a WD Anthology series. As in, every week we get a new location with a standalone story. Some before the outbreak, during the outbreak, and even go far into the future after the outbreak so we can see where society heads.

well just looking at the short synopsis of the remaining comics, there isn't much left. The way that Negan fight ends in the books can't happen, and since Carl is now dead and isn't dead in the books, that stuff will be left out. From what I see, there is another bad faction to deal with, but that's about it.

Farm
Prison
Woodbury
Terminus
Hilltop/Alexandria (FOREVER).

We need more traveling and new areas.
 
Last edited:

metalgear89

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
2,018
well just looking at the short synopsis of the remaining comics, there isn't much left. The way that Negan fight ends in the books can't happen, and since Carl is now dead and isn't dead in the books, that stuff will be left out. From what I see, there is another bad faction to deal with, but that's about it.

Farm
Prison
Woodbury
Terminus
Hilltop/Alexandria (FOREVER).

We need more traveling and new areas.
I want to see them go to a city, tired of some bumfuck place in the middle of nowhere.
 

Klean

Banned
Nov 3, 2017
641
This season is reaching Fear the Walking Dead levels of bad. Only thing keeping me watching at this point is my OCD for finishing a show because I've already watched it for years.
 

Pankratous

Member
Oct 26, 2017
9,268
The drop in quality after S1-5 is staggering (which was generally good with some bad mixed in). S6 had some good stuff but Alexandria was the beginning of the end. S7 and 8 are inexcusable.

I thought the beginning of S8 was decent again. The first few episodes was pretty much constant battles. Entertaining at least.
 

Surfinn

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
28,590
USA
I thought the beginning of S8 was decent again. The first few episodes was pretty much constant battles. Entertaining at least.
I thought that was some of the worst stuff the show had ever done. Literally just zoom ins on random people firing and nobody getting hit or dying. Spraying all over the place with random fire that never hits anything. Repeat. There's no intensity, no emotional weight to anything.

Compare that to something like the Gov breaching the prison walls.
 

Daitokuji

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,602
I think they've kind of done everything with the zombie genre that they could, especially since they didn't really show the beginning and aren't going to show the cure or the end.
 

BFIB

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,678
The drop in quality after S1-5 is staggering (which was generally good with some bad mixed in). S6 had some good stuff but Alexandria was the beginning of the end. S7 and 8 are inexcusable.

Its crazy how fast it fell once Gimple took over. I also think, from what comic fans have said, that once they leave Terminus, the comics really start to drag too. The best thing the show could have done was start branching out on their own after Terminus. If you are going to have Negan, then fine, but make it different.

I think the show is heading there now, and we are seeing some mistakes corrected (killing the heapsters, Negan getting some growth with his infighting with Simon), but it may be too little, too late as the ratings are really low. Eventually the budget is going to get cut, I'd imagine its sky high for the effects.
 

More_Badass

Member
Oct 25, 2017
23,623
I thought the beginning of S8 was decent again. The first few episodes was pretty much constant battles. Entertaining at least.
The only good one was Episode 3 because the battle and characters had a clear end goal to work towards and that propelled the narrative forward (Stop the Saviors from escaping with the 50 cal), and had actual character development for Ezekiel, ending with him dropping the facade

Of course the show threw both of those out the window soon after because Rick and Daryl accidentally destroy the gun next episode (thus all those Kingdom deaths and everything Carol did was for nothing) and Ezekiel is back to doing his medieval king routine, rendering that effective character moment completely moot
 

Surfinn

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
28,590
USA
Its crazy how fast it fell once Gimple took over. I also think, from what comic fans have said, that once they leave Terminus, the comics really start to drag too. The best thing the show could have done was start branching out on their own after Terminus. If you are going to have Negan, then fine, but make it different.

I think the show is heading there now, and we are seeing some mistakes corrected (killing the heapsters, Negan getting some growth with his infighting with Simon), but it may be too little, too late as the ratings are really low. Eventually the budget is going to get cut, I'd imagine its sky high for the effects.
The comics hit some rough/flat spots, definitely, but I never thought "wow this sucks". At worst it's decent. Most of the time it's good though.

There's a difference between hitting a few rough spots and having a shitty product for a couple years.

The biggest issue, IMO, is that the characters don't feel like they have individual personalities anymore. Their actions and decisions exist to push the plot forward, and the plot seems to exist primarily to provide drama.
 

More_Badass

Member
Oct 25, 2017
23,623
Its crazy how fast it fell once Gimple took over. I also think, from what comic fans have said, that once they leave Terminus, the comics really start to drag too. The best thing the show could have done was start branching out on their own after Terminus. If you are going to have Negan, then fine, but make it different.

I think the show is heading there now, and we are seeing some mistakes corrected (killing the heapsters, Negan getting some growth with his infighting with Simon), but it may be too little, too late as the ratings are really low. Eventually the budget is going to get cut, I'd imagine its sky high for the effects.
I'd disagree. Everything from the season premiere where they escape Terminus to the "Negan kills Glen" season premiere was top notch Walking Dead, the show at its peak.

Seeing the group on the road, becoming more ruthless, them trying to adjust to normalcy within Alexandria, Rick and co definitely not adjusting and planning to take over the town, the massive horde arc, the Wolf attack and ruthless killer Carol, the Saviors being introduced, the outpost massacre, the initial Negan introduction when he's actually menacing and his shtick isn't played out yet, him psychologically messing with Rick

All of that was the thrilling, intense television. It's all been downhill from there
 
Last edited:

ZeoVGM

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
76,219
Providence, RI
Its crazy how fast it fell once Gimple took over.

I don't generally agree with this. I think seasons 4 and 5 were likely the peak of the show, flaws and all. It was season 6 where things started to go downhill with the terrible gimmicks and fake deaths. Then with 7 and 8, it has been a consistent mess that has only gotten worse and worse.
 

Surfinn

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
28,590
USA
I don't generally agree with this. I think seasons 4 and 5 were likely the peak of the show, flaws and all. It was season 6 where things started to go downhill with the terrible gimmicks and fake deaths. Then with 7 and 8, it has been a consistent mess that has only gotten worse and worse.
One of the biggest downers for me was the casting in S6. Almost every single extra/side character in Alexandra were terrible actors coupled with bad writing. And for whatever reason, these problems remained and carried over even got worse in S7/8.

Truly bizarre.
 

Daitokuji

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,602
Terminus was maybe the last good arc. Short but sweet. Then I guess they remembered "oh we're a TV show on a moderate budget so we can't build and destroy an entire set for 3 episodes and we have to stretch everything out for 16 episode seasons and make sure to add cliffhangers for the mid-season breaks as well."
 

Surfinn

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
28,590
USA
Terminus was maybe the last good arc. Short but sweet. Then I guess they remembered "oh we're a TV show on a moderate budget so we can't build and destroy an entire set for 3 episodes and we have to stretch everything out for 16 episode seasons and make sure to add cliffhangers for the mid-season breaks as well."
The main baddie at Terminus was the beginning of consistently poor casting though IMO. Guy was bad.

At least they did something with that arc though.
 

Chitown B

Member
Nov 15, 2017
9,610
Terminus was maybe the last good arc. Short but sweet. Then I guess they remembered "oh we're a TV show on a moderate budget so we can't build and destroy an entire set for 3 episodes and we have to stretch everything out for 16 episode seasons and make sure to add cliffhangers for the mid-season breaks as well."

They pull 10 million viewers in most seasons, at least. ON CABLE. Can't be that much of a shoestring budget. I think they're second to Big Bang Theory which is around 13 million and that's broadcast. Plus only 30 minutes for commercials.
 

jelly

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
33,841
One of the worst things about this season is the editing and how it constantly jumps around in time and place. It's almost incomprehensible at times, I've thought on more than one occasion that I missed something, wait what's going, when is this, before that or after that, how did they get there.
 

SeanM

Member
Oct 26, 2017
2,434
USA
Looking back on it, the back half of Season 4 is where the show started to go downhill for me. That's when they seemingly got the idea to split the cast up into groups of 2-3 people in order to slow things down / stretch things out. I didn't mind it at the time because it felt organic to the story and those episodes were still very solid (Carol killing those kids etc). But it should've been more of a temporary thing until the group reunited rather than a permanent shift in storytelling. There doesn't need to be standalone episodes for all these shit characters like Tara for example.

I thought Season 5 was decent, but lost interest once the Alexandria storyline started. Season 6/7/8 is mostly a big blur to me, I would have a hard time remembering what exactly happened in what season or naming any big character moments. There's a lot of uninteresting new characters and factions, a lame villain, and the way the story is structured makes it hard to form any kind of momentum.
 

RedMercury

Blue Venus
Member
Dec 24, 2017
17,672
The show is in Virginia now. Would be nice if they went to DC
I'd love this bu it would never happen, people would expect a lot of set pieces that their budget might not allow for, it's pretty cheap to just shoot 95% of the show in the fucking woods and dilapidated indoor sets haha

I haven't seen anyone talk about the camerawork that really harkened back to season one, just the style they did some things like with the weird zooms. Maybe it's just me.
 

vsMIC

Member
Oct 31, 2017
432
When Jadis was left all alone at the end, anyone else get the feeling
she'll shave her head be back after the time jump as Alpha, leader of the Whisperers? It's the exact type of shit I expect from the writers who love twisting the knife in Rick.

was my first thought as well...
 
Oct 25, 2017
1,747
Gabe still having faith during the zombie apocalypse might be the dumbest thing on the show.

But then 40% of Americans think the universe is 6000 years old, so I guess he's in good company.