• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Oct 26, 2017
3,116
Amalthea
Another one of those FUNdamentals shorts. Didn't realize how many artifacts they've had over the show until they showed them off here.They still missed quite a few.





I'll try to watch and comment on those shorts tonight.

Wow that short looks very good!

The amount of pony content that's been released in terms of shorts, specials and fun little world building videos between FiM and EqG since the end of Season 7 has been downright overwhelming. Contrast that with the sheer volume of nothing released by Disney to keep interest up for DuckTales since they aired the first 9 episodes of Season 1 out of order before stalling into limbo last fall.

Are we sure Hasbro is intending to just drop G4 outright in a little over 18 months from now? DHX Media is an absolute machine. It's really quite impressive.

Granted, you can make a quantity vs. quality argument here... and that's justified. But it's not like this quality threshold bar has been outright abysmal or anything. Certainly not compared to countless other media properties that run themselves into the ground with overexposure. I think they've struck a really nice balance here.

Hmm, I can't imagine G4 being dropped immediately, especially since it's going so well. If it ain't broken, don't fix it!
I can see G5 getting pushed back for improvements and all that good stuff. But I really don't know much about generations for My Little Pony.
 

Strider_Blaze

Member
Oct 28, 2017
7,957
Lancaster, CA
And here is part 2 of Forgotten Friendship now up on YouTube.



Sunset checks RD's memory, in the form of the motocross race in Friendship Games. Plus another Indigo Zapp cameo. :(

Before Sunset and the Princesses enter the library, the former passed by Pony!Flash. She stops for moment, wondering if she just saw Flash.

Princess Celestia shows off a printing contraption in the forbidden section, which promptly breaks apart.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
I don't know what's worse, you being mean or your Rarity avatar looking like she agrees.
I'd love a clip of Tabitha saying that in her Rarity voice.

Unsolved Selfie Mysteries: Wish Timber would interact with literally any other character besides Twilight for once. It's alright.
Come to think of it, did anyone but SciTwi and Sunset even acknowledge his existence in Legend of Everfree? And the other girls only talk about him or communicate via text in the shorts.

Too Hot to Handle: Who adopts crabs? Also Pinkie is a menace. How is everyone else able to stand on the beach but Pinkie is not? Surely there's at least one other person on the beach not wearing sandals, which magically disappear after she takes off her costume. The big thing though is that Pinkie is a menace. Also maybe Rarity is giving the crabs their knives
I only watched that short once and assumed there was a reason why Pinkie was barefoot that I missed. They really just magically disappear? And yeah, fans assumed Rarity hated crabs, but she's actually going around arming them.

The Salty Sails: Apparently Rarity has Twilight's power of levitation now? And Twilight doesn't use it to levitate her map that gets blown away? Pinkie's really weird in this, and yeah Twilight does nothing despite being fully
Rarity has been using her powers to lift stuff for a while. Pinkie's sea obsession comes out of nowhere and not in the usual Pinkie way, yeah.

The amount of pony content that's been released in terms of shorts, specials and fun little world building videos between FiM and EqG since the end of Season 7 has been downright overwhelming. Contrast that with the sheer volume of nothing released by Disney to keep interest up for DuckTales since they aired the first 9 episodes of Season 1 out of order before stalling into limbo last fall.

Are we sure Hasbro is intending to just drop G4 outright in a little over 18 months from now? DHX Media is an absolute machine. It's really quite impressive.

Granted, you can make a quantity vs. quality argument here... and that's justified. But it's not like this quality threshold bar has been outright abysmal or anything. Certainly not compared to countless other media properties that run themselves into the ground with overexposure. I think they've struck a really nice balance here.
I remember when they aired Friendship Games and Legend of Everfree on the same day as a new episode and I was like, "Why would you do that?!" I'm glad they saw reason and aired the half hour specials during the mid season 7 break.

Though leaks and early airings have messed it up a lot, they have a pretty good release schedule now.

And yeah, it is weird that they're ramping up Equestria Girls so much with G4 ending soon. Plus we're getting some regular pony TV specials. If it wasn't for the leaked emails being from before the Movie came out, I'd suspect G4 ending was in response to the Movie not doing too well.

I can only assume that they intend to continue this system after the reboot. Looking at Hasbro's YouTube channel, pony stuff gets far more views than everything else, including Transformers.

It is. For the first time, they're really taking advantage of the fact that they have a spinoff with a wildly different production cycle and delivery method to keep the overall brand from taking a break, in a way I don't remember ever seeing another IP pull off.
Yeah, I can't think of any other show that does this at this level. Gravity Falls and DuckTales released YouTube shorts, but the amount of content is nothing compared to EQG and these other informational shorts.

Hmm, I can't imagine G4 being dropped immediately, especially since it's going so well. If it ain't broken, don't fix it!
I can see G5 getting pushed back for improvements and all that good stuff. But I really don't know much about generations for My Little Pony.
This is unprecedented for MLP, so looking back won't help much. Heck, it's unprecedented for a Transformers generation to last this long.

As for why start a new generation if things are going well, there's a lot of small issues that have been building up over time. Audiences respond well to the adventure stories, but things like Twilight being so much more powerful than everyone else, the sheer number of strong allies they have, and the fact that they can't point to a character and say that's the main villain have gotten in the way of that.

They resolved a lot of conflicts between characters early on, leaving less clean space to be mined later. This is something they shored up with Starlight and now the Friendship School, but there's less to do with the Mane Six themselves now and there are a ton of recurring characters to keep track of.

And there are world building decisions that I'm sure they want to take back, such as Celestia playing such a heavy role (meaning she has to be written out when there are threats), earth ponies just being boring compared to the other breeds, and various arbitrary decisions that they have to stick with. Keep in mind that few people from season 1 are still working on the show. It's almost all people who have to stick with decisions they weren't involved in.

While it seems safe to continue the show for a couple more years, certainly more so than I would have thought circa season 3, I think what's going on is that they want a clean slate creatively. I also think higher ups believe the key to getting more mainstream attention is a reboot movie. They certainly have the media infrastructure to handle it better than when G4 started. FiM got big without Hasbro doing much of anything to capitalize on it; imagine if they actually had the capability to produce tie in shorts and had a plan for conventions from the start.

And here is part 2 of Forgotten Friendship now up on YouTube.



Sunset checks RD's memory, in the form of the motocross race in Friendship Games. Plus another Indigo Zapp cameo. :(

Before Sunset and the Princesses enter the library, the former passed by Pony!Flash. She stops for moment, wondering if she just saw Flash.

Princess Celestia shows off a printing contraption in the forbidden section, which promptly breaks apart.

Damn, that's some interesting stuff this time. I'll have to watch it later, but commenting on what you wrote (I don't think it's a spoiler)
* In a short format, reading Rainbow's memories too makes sense because it's been a week since the last one. In a movie format, it's just redundant.
* Glad to see Twilight completely ignoring Pony Flash continues. I guess he got fired from his Crystal Empire job.
* A forbidden printing contraption is odd, given we know for a fact that they have the printing press, from "Ponyville Confidential".

BTW, in general, I'm glad people besides me are posting videos.
 

Strider_Blaze

Member
Oct 28, 2017
7,957
Lancaster, CA
Yeah, it's kind of a habit for people to check out the video first before discussing things sans spoiler tags.

Okay. Looking at the clip again, Celestia actually refers to the contraption as an "archives mechanical catalog." Huh. Would have never thought library catalogs would be designed that way.
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
Hmm, I can't imagine G4 being dropped immediately, especially since it's going so well. If it ain't broken, don't fix it!
I can see G5 getting pushed back for improvements and all that good stuff. But I really don't know much about generations for My Little Pony.

Sigma touches on a lot of the big things, but I feel like there's a lot of general issues with Generation 4 that have been festering for a very long time. Stuff like Twilight's (and now Starlight) overpoweredness compared to the rest of the cast as well as her narrative importance really limits their ability to tell grand stories since they pretty much always have to revolve around one or both of them. The general feel of the show has shifted over the years, especially if you talk about from Season 1 to 2 as well as from season 5 on. A lot of things don't make that much sense from a continuity standpoint and it's led to awkward stuff like the MLP movie completely ignoring countless characters' existence because it would make their story not make any sense. Also been said before but there's a lot of problems that are inherent with the fact that the staff currently working on the show is almost entirely different from the one working on it during the early seasons. Most of these issues are things I'm personally easily willing to overlook because they're almost unavoidable but starting over from scratch would help a lot with those issues.

I'd love a clip of Tabitha saying that in her Rarity voice.

So you want Tabitha to bully me too? :(

I only watched that short once and assumed there was a reason why Pinkie was barefoot that I missed. They really just magically disappear?

When she leaves for the cones, she's wearing her crab costume, which includes sandals. When she's at the stand getting the cones, she's barefoot in her normal swimsuit.

Rarity has been using her powers to lift stuff for a while

What is Twilight's supposed to be there for then, if Rarity can do the same thing as her? I get they don't want Twilight being OP like she is in Equestria but it seems odd that they would have another person also be capable of doing the thing that she can do.

Come to think of it, did anyone but SciTwi and Sunset even acknowledge his existence in Legend of Everfree?

Aside from Gloriosa, (duh) the rest of the Mane 7 mention him a couple times, but it's almost always in the context of pointing out that SciTwi has a crush on him.



Looks like Tara Strong is doing a Reddit AMA focusing on her role as Twilight next Monday.

 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
And here is part 2 of Forgotten Friendship now up on YouTube.



Sunset checks RD's memory, in the form of the motocross race in Friendship Games. Plus another Indigo Zapp cameo. :(

Before Sunset and the Princesses enter the library, the former passed by Pony!Flash. She stops for moment, wondering if she just saw Flash.

Princess Celestia shows off a printing contraption in the forbidden section, which promptly breaks apart.

Watched it, skipping through to the major changes.

I assumed "Most Likely to be Forgotten" was just the name of part 1, but it looks like that was the intended name of this entire story. Though the YouTube title for this story is "Sunset Shimmer Saga", with this part called "Homecoming".

A comment in ED's article mentions there's an additional scene of them going down stairs to the forbidden section, and some shots generally linger for longer throughout.

Wow, Flash looks bored out of his mind in front of the library. He really did get fired! Indeed, Twilight doesn't even notice him. And he's so forgettable that the animators forgot he's a pegasus.
small.gif


And yeah, the device in question is just a catalogue, and doesn't appear to be forbidden in and of itself.

What is Twilight's supposed to be there for then, if Rarity can do the same thing as her? I get they don't want Twilight being OP like she is in Equestria but it seems odd that they would have another person also be capable of doing the thing that she can do.
Well Rarity will have trouble lifting stuff that rolls around. That's the big difference! Besides, both pony versions can levitate things.

Looks like Tara Strong is doing a Reddit AMA focusing on her role as Twilight next Monday.
Placing all bets, what percentage will be production questions she has no connection to and what percentage will be leak questions?

==

Surprisingly epic trailer for the addition of deer to the Gameloft MLP game

Music
Some more good original music.
1.4everfreebrony - Second Chances (ft. A Bunch of Shredders) - YouTube
2.The Princess Of Friendship - YouTube
3.ertrii - Wish [Progressive House] - EP RELEASE! - YouTube
4.loophoof - Heart Up - YouTube
5.Memories of You - Riovelk [Eurobeat] - YouTube

Art
Timelapse creation of a Flutterbat figure


1.Disco Fluttershy by Art of lemonade
2.Cold bug by OrchidPony on DeviantArt - Chrysalis
3.[Reward] Proud Of You by vavacung on DeviantArt - Older Rainbow and Scootaloo
4.starlightglimmer | Illustration: "新阵容╭( ̄▽ ̄)╮" by 采妮老湿 [pixiv] - Also Chrysalis
5.Heroes EP-Healing WALLPAPER by Light262 and Jycrow by Light262 on DeviantArt - Mage Meadowbrook
medium.png

ColdbugbyOrchidPony1521055780360.png

RewardProudOfYoubyvavacung1521055781200.png

by1521055781786.jpeg

heroes_ep_healing_wallpaper_by_light262_and_jycrow_by_light262-dc5w0qo.png

1..:weird balloon:. (Commission) by The-Butcher-X on DeviantArt - EQG SciTwi, Pinkie, and a balloon from The Amazing World of Gumball
2.Sunset and SciTwi by k-nattoh
3.Applejack & Fluttershy by りゅーちゃん... - RainbowManes
4.Hippogriff Skystar by meekcheep
5.Twilight by ikirunosindo
medium.png

medium.jpeg

medium.png

bymeekcheep1521144202698.png

byikirunosindo1521144202544.png

1.Mindnight sketch #14 by Vistamage on DeviantArt - Sugar Belle
2.Oleander by JekiDrawings on DeviantArt
3.Limestone and Marble by JumbleHorse on DeviantArt
4.Relax with Rarity by Xjenn9 on DeviantArt
5.Occasional Drawing #1: Velvet by Check3256 on DeviantArt - Velvet reacting to plebs
Mindnightsketch14byVistamage1521237306585.png

OleanderbyJekiDrawings1521237306648.jpg

LimestoneandMarblebyJumbleHorse1521237306858.png

RelaxwithRaritybyXjenn91521237306961.jpg

medium.png

Comics
How to talk to Applejack by artiparty - Also Coloratura
large.png

Multiparter comic by ryuu about the EQG girls having their geode powers switched. There isn't a real ending; it's unclear if it will continue.
Part 1, 2, 3, 4
And here's the end!
Part 5, 6, 7, 8
tall.png

tall.png

tall.png

tall.png

==

We got some new Belle Eve 2.0 art from Myke ! I plan to include this in the season 8 OT header in some fashion.
belle_eve_2_0_switch_by_mykegreywolf-dc63vdy.png


And Sunday will be a very special stream.
1560325__safe_edit_capper+dapperpaws_my+little+pony-colon-+the+movie_spoiler-colon-my+little+pony+movie_abyssinian_animated_anthro_augmented+reality_ca.gif


It's a My Little Pony: the Movie stream!
1. My Little Pony: the Movie
2. Tangled: The Series - Challenge of the Brave - Rapunzel and Cassandra enter a fighting tournament.
3. Tangled: The Series - The Return of Strongbow - An old thieving buddy of Eugene returns for one last job.
 

fony

Member
Feb 17, 2018
67
Oh wow, loads of new content this week.

The amount of pony content that's been released in terms of shorts, specials and fun little world building videos between FiM and EqG since the end of Season 7 has been downright overwhelming.

Remember the pre-Season 3 hiatus? And how we got 13 episode and a hiatus again? Good times. (Well, there was EQG between 3 and 4.)

Another one of those FUNdamentals shorts. Didn't realize how many artifacts they've had over the show until they showed them off here.They still missed quite a few.

I feel this is even becoming a bit of a problem. Originally, they had a lot unknowns (like the everfree forrest) but now to capture the same feeling, they have to introduce more and more stuff.

Huh, this is the first time the EQG mirror has appeared in something animated that's otherwise pony only. And yeah, a ton of these things have shown up.

Purely based on the style, I'm speculating that this is written and produced by an entirely different group who may or may not follow the same "rules".

Edit: Fixed quotes. Thanks, Sigma.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Oh wow, loads of new content this week.
Uh, you kind of messed up with the quotes.

About the hiatuses, season 3 was pretty bad, but the break between seasons 4 and 5 was even bigger. I suppose we did get Rainbow Rocks and the tie in shorts during that break, though.

I think magical objects are a natural consequence of having more adventure stories, and Daring Do in particular.

About the supplemental videos, there's actually a behind the scene video.


Bunch of stuff today. First of all, more Belle Eve 2.0 art from Myke! This time in his normal style.
work_606_belle_eve_2_0_by_mykegreywolf-dc649qu.png


It looks like the Discovery Family app will be putting show clips up early too. Here's a song from the season premiere.

They also put up two animatics (1, 2). I think this is a pretty interesting way to preview episodes, giving you a hint of what's to come without it being the final product, while also showing you how things are behind the scenes.

And we have a guest star! Rachel Bloom, who starred in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend and various, uh, not child friendly online cartoons.

Lastly, I was planning on going for "Twilight Sparkle's Animal House" for the season 8 thread subtitle, but a new contender popped up.
 
Oct 26, 2017
3,116
Amalthea
This is unprecedented for MLP, so looking back won't help much. Heck, it's unprecedented for a Transformers generation to last this long.

As for why start a new generation if things are going well, there's a lot of small issues that have been building up over time. Audiences respond well to the adventure stories, but things like Twilight being so much more powerful than everyone else, the sheer number of strong allies they have, and the fact that they can't point to a character and say that's the main villain have gotten in the way of that.

They resolved a lot of conflicts between characters early on, leaving less clean space to be mined later. This is something they shored up with Starlight and now the Friendship School, but there's less to do with the Mane Six themselves now and there are a ton of recurring characters to keep track of.

And there are world building decisions that I'm sure they want to take back, such as Celestia playing such a heavy role (meaning she has to be written out when there are threats), earth ponies just being boring compared to the other breeds, and various arbitrary decisions that they have to stick with. Keep in mind that few people from season 1 are still working on the show. It's almost all people who have to stick with decisions they weren't involved in.

While it seems safe to continue the show for a couple more years, certainly more so than I would have thought circa season 3, I think what's going on is that they want a clean slate creatively. I also think higher ups believe the key to getting more mainstream attention is a reboot movie. They certainly have the media infrastructure to handle it better than when G4 started. FiM got big without Hasbro doing much of anything to capitalize on it; imagine if they actually had the capability to produce tie in shorts and had a plan for conventions from the start.

Sigma touches on a lot of the big things, but I feel like there's a lot of general issues with Generation 4 that have been festering for a very long time. Stuff like Twilight's (and now Starlight) overpoweredness compared to the rest of the cast as well as her narrative importance really limits their ability to tell grand stories since they pretty much always have to revolve around one or both of them. The general feel of the show has shifted over the years, especially if you talk about from Season 1 to 2 as well as from season 5 on. A lot of things don't make that much sense from a continuity standpoint and it's led to awkward stuff like the MLP movie completely ignoring countless characters' existence because it would make their story not make any sense. Also been said before but there's a lot of problems that are inherent with the fact that the staff currently working on the show is almost entirely different from the one working on it during the early seasons. Most of these issues are things I'm personally easily willing to overlook because they're almost unavoidable but starting over from scratch would help a lot with those issues.

Incredible, I never really thought about it like this. Thank you!

Now I have to say that yes the inconsistencies are a bit bizarre, especially when the kids can point them out. Hasbro's media division has grown (though seeing The Hub become Discovery Family again is a bit weird) and I'm sure if the first movie of G5 goes well we'll see more of that. And preferably have a distributor that isn't Lionsgate lol

Interested in seeing what the team will take from G4 and how they'll better G5, like not having an all-powerful alicorn rule the land.

Have a shrugging Rarity

19e159f58fbec4f1d7f221028fd03192.jpeg
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
Well Rarity will have trouble lifting stuff that rolls around. That's the big difference! Besides, both pony versions can levitate things.

Oh, so it's like how both Rainbow and Fluttershy can manipulate the weather and clouds as well. Or how Dog spike can breath fire.


I'm pretty sure at this point SciTwi has problems with rolling stuff too.

Incredible, I never really thought about it like this. Thank you!

Now I have to say that yes the inconsistencies are a bit bizarre, especially when the kids can point them out. Hasbro's media division has grown (though seeing The Hub become Discovery Family again is a bit weird) and I'm sure if the first movie of G5 goes well we'll see more of that. And preferably have a distributor that isn't Lionsgate lol

Interested in seeing what the team will take from G4 and how they'll better G5, like not having an all-powerful alicorn rule the land.

I imagine you probably have a pretty different perspective given that you got into the show relatively recently but I've been watching since season 2 and at this point I feel like 9 seasons and a movie is plenty. It's a really good run for any kind of show. Moving on to G5 I think one of the big advantages they have is to be able to see what worked with G4 and what was causing them problems as the show went on and be able to make changes accordingly.



That guy sure likes that pose.


EDIt: Have a non-shrug

tempest_shadow__mermaid__by_freckleplant-dc5y5o7.png
 
Last edited:
Oct 26, 2017
3,116
Amalthea
That's definitely one of my favorite Rarity humanizations from before Equestria Girls. Semehammer has a ton of great art like that, and it's a shame she stopped posting images publicly; her last image on DeviantArt was in 2014 and her Tumblr is gone. She straight up has my favorite Twilight humanization.
medium.jpeg

medium.jpeg

medium.jpeg

medium.jpg

Aw that's a shame! A friend of mine sent me that Rarity picture and I really, really liked it!
That guy sure likes that pose.
It's easy to work with I bet :P
 

Rhomega

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,624
Arizona
Our Tangerine World RPG campaign with Sigmasonic X is complete, and I'd like to thank him for setting everything up, as well as Cappy and Trigenometrize for also participating.
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
And I forgot to reply to one of your earlier points. You're right, since I started this show much later I'm a little afraid of the changes G5 would bring. But the fresh start may make it better than the last, so I look forward to it!

I think most people are a bit worried, but at this point I've been following the show for 7 or so years so a shakeup has me excited.



Cmon man, she's not even shrugging the right way.
 
Last edited:

fony

Member
Feb 17, 2018
67
Uh, you kind of messed up with the quotes.

Derp. That's what I get for fire and forget commenting.

About the supplemental videos, there's actually a behind the scene video.


Wow that was really nice! Now I want to search and watch all the other making-of pony videos I've probably missed.

Also didn't know there was not one but ten Heartfelt Scrapbooks! Gonna watch the others now. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLNXV9Mb7egjG4-t09bi14YDmW8OMkDmYi

I watched the first few and like them better than the FUNdamentals videos. Maybe there was more editing? Or maybe its just the chalk filter that I still find jarring.

This is unprecedented for MLP, so looking back won't help much. Heck, it's unprecedented for a Transformers generation to last this long.

As for why start a new generation if things are going well, there's a lot of small issues that have been building up over time.

I'm also looking forward to having G4 end and make way for something new. (Haven't seen any G5 spoilers/leaks and avoiding S8 spoilers so can't comment on that. ) They've tied up pretty much all major plot points by now. Even moved focus to Starlight and friends (which happens to be not as interesting for me).

* A forbidden printing contraption is odd, given we know for a fact that they have the printing press, from "Ponyville Confidential".

I thought that thing was a card catalogue. So you could use it to search and find index card but not really print new ones. And presumably the Ponyville printing presses are recent unlike this one.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Aw that's a shame! A friend of mine sent me that Rarity picture and I really, really liked it!
There are two things that can stop an artist from making MLP art: losing interest in the show/fandom, or simply not having enough free time. The fact that art stopped on her DeviantArt altogether points toward the latter. I don't know her situation, but it's likely she was in high school / college while she was an active fan artist. After getting a job, she probably didn't have the bandwidth to continue making art. A lot of artists are only active due to Patreon.

It's easy to work with I bet :P
There's a lot of room for fun variations, yeah. This is actually a meme many artists participated in, and the shrugging pony Pinkie Sylvee posted above is the source. Well, technically, this uncolored version is.

The remaining two from Semehammer, BTW.
medium.jpg

medium.jpeg



Our Tangerine World RPG campaign with Sigmasonic X is complete, and I'd like to thank him for setting everything up, as well as Cappy and Trigenometrize for also participating.
Thanks for this! Summary will be coming later.

Also didn't know there was not one but ten Heartfelt Scrapbooks! Gonna watch the others now. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLNXV9Mb7egjG4-t09bi14YDmW8OMkDmYi

I watched the first few and like them better than the FUNdamentals videos. Maybe there was more editing? Or maybe its just the chalk filter that I still find jarring.
There are a couple of things. The scrapbook concept allows for more variety visually, Pinkie brings more energy to the narration, and the subject matter (Pinkie recapping events for Flurry) is more fun.

I thought that thing was a card catalogue. So you could use it to search and find index card but not really print new ones. And presumably the Ponyville printing presses are recent unlike this one.
I was reacting to Strider_Blaze 's description, since I was at work and hadn't watched the video yet.

Is someone going to make an S8 thread before Saturday?

Yup, me. I'll make it Friday. Thread title will probably be "Princess Twilight's Animal House", but one idea suggested recently is "Teach Away, Mini Twilight!".

Stream follow up later.

EDIT: Oh, and news. Maurice Lamarche, AKA The Brain (of Pinky and the Brain) will be voicing a character in the season 8 premiere.
 

Sylvee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,562
Is someone going to make an S8 thread before Saturday?


Sigma does all of the threads, he's apparently working on banners and stuff right now so it should be out by then.


Some season 8 stuff: they've been using animatics to advertise the upcoming premier. They've already done 4 of them so far. These obviously contain spoilers so I'm only linking them rather then embedding:

1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hw9Q2nwya1Q
2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_oS-eJOqBS8
3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0oqGw-00Bww
4: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3eJ3Yty-p00



Maurice Lamarche, voice actor for The Brain from Pinkie and The Brain among other things, is voicing a character for the 2-part opener. Sort of a neat thing, but he's not exactly a celebrity talent, he lives in Canada so given that the pool of Voice actors that live in the area it's only a matter of time before he got on at some point.



In other stuff here's Twilight in a suit. (Reminds me a bit of Sigma's old avatar)

large.jpg
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
As mentioned, we had our final RP for now.
RP 14 - Tangerine World 9 (finale) - World of Chaos
Cappy - Fluttershy
Rhomega - Rarity

Last time, the heroes were able to stop the danger of the Everfree Forest, but then Tangerine World's Dr. Pinkie Pie absorbed chaos magic, turning into an alicorn. She sends the player characters back to their world and locked the door, but Twilight was able to figure out a way back.

Deciding to leave Spike behind, Twilight, Fluttershy, and Rarity head back into Tangerine World. They come out in the Tangerine family farm, where they find kangaroos helping harvest oranges, including Chandler the muscular lead kangaroo. Kumquat Salad, cousin of Clementine, appears, running away from a party cannon with legs.
jpg.png


The heroes and kangaroos flee the blasts of pure party and decide to head for Canterlot. Kumquat explains that Clementine is still in jail, because she said the prison break was for her. They come across another party cannon, but manage to get past it. They find three more party cannons having a tea party, and decide not to engage, leaving the kangaroos behind to fly to the castle. Twilight carries Rarity with her magic.

In the castle, they find Drowsy Moon, the unicorn whose magic went out of control before, sleeping in a room. He missed everything that happened. He decides to come with them after realizing his sister, the captain of the royal guard, is in trouble.

They sneak to the balcony outside the throne room. Pinkie is sitting on the throne with Princess Trixie Lula Moon, who insists it's fine if she doesn't get up. The other Mane Six native to that world are sitting at a dinner table. It wasn't mentioned, but there was food there. She brings up that Applejack wanted apples to be popular, so she makes it so. Clementine barges in demanding the same for oranges. Pinkie fuses apples and oranges together to resolve this.

The heroes come up with a plan: send in Drowsy, pretending his magic is out of control again via Twilight's magic. Then they sneak in and replace their counterparts; TW Twilight can't use magic, so Pinkie wouldn't think to consider that. From there, they can take the magic absorbing device from her. Pinkie pulls it out to absorb Drowsy's magic, reasoning her own probably won't help with that, and Fluttershy distracts her by declaring she's about to get married to TW Starlight (AKA Sunset Shimmer) and flying around to explain how the ceremony will go.

Rarity takes the device from Pinkie and uses it against her. It isn't enough, so the TW Mane Six activate their harmony magic to overwhelm her, leaving Pinkie as an earth pony again. They explain what Pinkie did wrong and she apologizes.

Trixie decides she isn't interested in the throne anymore, wishing to become a traveling magician. She randomly appoints Clementine as the new princess. Twilight decides there's a limit to how much they should interfere in this world.

As they leave, TW Fluttershy comes up to them. She says this is a perfect opportunity for her to leave, but she doesn't want to leave TW Starlight (AKA Sunset). Fluttershy suggests she becomes a tax collector, and she accepts, going back to the others. The ponies wave goodbye. Before the heroes leave, they finally catch sight of the lizardfolk they've heard about all throughout the Tangerine World adventure. Well, starting from part 3. Then, they're back home.

Today, we had the Movie stream.
1. My Little Pony: the Movie (2017)
2. Tangled: the Series - Challenge of the Brave
Last video not shown

Not many people were there at the start, but soon there were as many as five people total. Most left once the Movie ended, though. Our streaming service started messing up a lot, so we chose to stop after just one episode of Tangled, instead of the planned two. That episode will air next week instead.

I liked the Movie well enough the first time I watched it, but I also had a ton of complaints. This time, I feel like those complaints didn't matter as much, and it was a lot of fun. One thing I hadn't noticed before was that the one who rescued Twilight from Tempest's attack at the beginning (where Derpy was turned to stone) was Rainbow Dash.

The Tangled episode was the most enjoyable we've shown so far. The streaming service started messing up a lot around there, though.

Here are the YouTube videos I showed. Even after deciding not to show the second Tangled episode, I showed the remaining YouTube videos.
1.My Little Pony - One Small Thing (Xmas PMV) - YouTube - This was made before the Movie came out, filling in missing scenes with show clips, and they largely work well. Using "Pinkie's Present" clips was particularly inspired.
2.MLP The Movie PMV Power Rangers 2017 Fan-Made Opening - YouTube
3.MLP: Equestria Girls Minis - 'The Show Must Go On Pt.1' Digital Short - YouTube - Too bad Trigonometrize missed this.
4.MLP: Equestria Girls Minis - 'The Show Must Go On Pt.2' Digital Short - YouTube - The Movie aired after this
5.Call Upon The Sea Ponies (PMV) - YouTube
6.Everybody wants to rule the world - Tempest/MLP The Movie [PMV] - YouTube
7.DADDY - Capper/MLP The Movie[Mini PMV] - YouTube
8.Tempest Shadow - Theme of Infinite - PMV - YouTube - Edgy Sonic Forces music
9.My Little Pony: The Movie - 'The Mane 6 & Friends Act Out!' Official Stop Motion Short - YouTube - Pretty ridiculous official retelling of the Movie using stop motion.

Next Sunday, the stream will start focusing on that Saturday's episode premiere, along with related episodes, some Tangled, and other things once we get further into that.

I'm using this spreadsheet to keep track of episodes.

And on an unrelated note, new video from that guy that does all those weird Glimglam videos.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Hmm, I've been thinking. My plan was to keep this thread open while the season 8 OT is, but convert it to just be about the one major subject that won't be covered by that, fanfics. And then maybe to make this clear, I'd adjust the thread name. Once season 8 ends, we'd move back here.

However,
* It seems like they're serious about new pony content coming out all year, so it makes sense to keep the season 8 thread around.
* Even if I change the name, people will get tripped up by the purpose of this thread.

So I thought, maybe close this thread and make a new thread just for fanfics? Like "My Little Pony Fan Fiction |OT| Twilight Sparkle's Secret Shipfic Folder" (final name pending). It would be a slower community thread, but I feel that's fine. There are at least three people reading fanfics here, so there's an audience, and it could push others to talk about it too. And we could put Sciz 's recommendations in the OP.

Then we can just keep posting in the season 8 thread until season 9 airs, etc.
 
Last edited:

Nali

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,649
So I thought, maybe close this thread and make a new thread just for fanfics? Like "My Little Pony Fan Fiction |OT| Twilight Sparkle's Secret Shipfic Folder" (final name pending). It would be a slower community thread, but I feel that's fine. There are at least three people reading fanfics here, so there's an audience, and it could push others to talk about it too. And we could put Sciz 's recommendations in the OP.
The sole reason I'm willing to post about ponyfic on this site is because this thread is pretty low key and flies under the radar.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
The sole reason I'm willing to post about ponyfic on this site is because this thread is pretty low key and flies under the radar.
Oh, in that case, the original plan of continuing to use this thread in addition to the season 8 OT is better, then.

Maybe I could change the name of this thread to My Little Pony Fan Community (same subtitle). It kind of brings back the original problem I was trying to avoid, of it being unclear that general fan art and videos would be fine to post in the season OT, but it probably wasn't that big a problem in the first place.
 

Nali

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,649
Maybe I could change the name of this thread to My Little Pony Fan Community (same subtitle). It kind of brings back the original problem I was trying to avoid, of it being unclear that general fan art and videos would be fine to post in the season OT, but it probably wasn't that big a problem in the first place.
Stick a note and a link to the S8 OT at the top of this thread's OP and otherwise leave it alone, imo. You and Sylvee constitute the vast majority of posted fanwork already, people will follow your lead.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Stick a note and a link to the S8 OT at the top of this thread's OP and otherwise leave it alone, imo. You and Sylvee constitute the vast majority of posted fanwork already, people will follow your lead.
Another part of it is that I want to make the thread titles more distinct at a glance in the watched threads list.

Ah! Got it! I'll remove the "Friendship is Magic" from the title of this thread, making it just "My Little Pony"! It even works as future proofing for G5.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Sigma October 2017: "Sylvee you're overreacting. We don't need another place to purely discuss fanfiction."

Sigma March 2018: "Guys I think we need a separate thread to talk about fanfiction"
The difference is that people besides me actually talked about fanfics. Besides, back then the argument was about having this thread and a separate place for fanfics, not the season OT and a fanfic thread.

New EQG Mini video. It's been a while.


Jeez, between "Forgotten Friendship", the beach shorts, and now this, they've done the exact same gag three times!

Draft of the character guide for season 8, just the Mane Six + Starlight for now.
guide_season8_mains_no_sep.png


I'm also testing out having the "Flawless" hugs in between the respective characters (with Pinkie's butt hug replacing the AJ/Pinkie one).

Other FiM characters to be included are the CMC, Spike, and Discord. The last is mainly for a gag where a lot of it is missing, and the missing letters turn up in the image marking where the Discord invite is. To explain what I mean, here's the equivalent I made for the Magic thread.
MTG_Discord_invite_3.png


And as a brand new change, I decided to include Equestria Girls characters too. Namely, Sunset, SciTwi, and "And the rest".

And comic news... I checked and it turns out I never posted May comic solicitations, so here we go.

My Little Pony: Ponyville Mysteries #1
Christina Rice (w) • Agnes Garbowska (a & CVR A) • Philip Murphy (CVR B) • Brenda Hickey (CVR 1:10 RI) • Andy Price (CVR 1:20 RI)
MLP_PonyvilleMysteries_01_Acvr.jpg


Welcome to a new series of mystery and intrigue! The Cutie Mark Crusaders discover their inner detectives and solve crimes nopony else can! Will they be able to discover who is stealing supplies from Ponyville hospital and get their schoolwork done at the same time!

FC • 32 pages • $3.99

TENTATIVE RELEASE DATE: May 16th, 2018

If you weren't aware, there's a chapter book series of the same name, but according to ED's brief interview with Bobby Curnow (senior editor), while there will be some references, this can be read standalone. It's a five-issue series.

Honestly, I was expecting Equestria Girls to finally get a comic series, given the web series and everything. This is only five issues, so maybe after?

Also, from the ED article, I'm completely thrown for a loop that someone else remembered Sylvester & Tweety Mysteries.

My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #66
Ted Anderson (w) • Tony Fleecs (a & CVR A) • Sara Richard (CVR B) • Pedro Delgado (CVR RI)
MLP66-coverA%2Bcopy.jpg
MLP66-coverB%2Bcopy.jpg
MLP66-coverRI%2Bcopy.jpg



Twilight and friends are surprised to learn that a film is being made about them! When the story turns out to be less than accurate, the group decides to make their own film! But will they be able to agree on the same artistic vision?

FC • 32 pages • $3.99

Bullet Point:
  • A hilarious satire of Hollywood!
The FiM story seems like it could be fun.

June comic solicitations

My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #67
Jeremy Whitley (w) • Andy Price (a & CVR A) • Sara Richard (CVR B) • Naomi Franquiz (CVR RI)
MLP67-coverA.jpg
MLP67-coverB.jpg
MLP67-coverRI.jpg


"Tempest's Tale," Part 1 of 2. Tempest, a former foe, is exploring Equestria to learn more about love and friendship. Her travels take her to the Crystal Empire where she will come face-to-face with the pony who set her down a path to villainy! Will she come to grips with her past or return to treacherous ways?

FC • 32 pages • $3.99

Bullet Point:
  • The hit character from My Little Pony: The Movie makes her post-screen debut!

My Little Pony: Ponyville Mysteries #2
Christina Rice (w) • Agnes Garbowska (a & CVR A) • Philip Murphy (CVR B) • Abigail "LeekFish" Starling (CVR RI)
MLP_PonyvilleMysteries_02_Acvr.jpg
MLP_PonyvilleMysteries_02_RIcvr.jpg



There's a major mystery at the… bowling alley? Ponyville's team is set to break a bowling record, but the alley keeps being ransacked by a mystery criminal! Will the Cutie Mark Crusaders be able to set the pins right and solve the caper?

FC • 32 pages • $3.99

Bullet Point:
  • A moment to shine for everyone's favorite The Big Lebowski-inspired ponies!

My Little Pony: Art is Magic! Volume 2
Tony Fleecs, Sara Richard, Andy Price, Brenda Hickey, Agnes Garbowska (a) • Andy Price(c)
mlp-artIsMagic-cov_Page_a.jpg



From the pages of IDW's many popular My Little Pony comic-book series comes this very special collection. Your favorite artists are back to reveal their secrets and show you more of the pieces they love! See Twilight Sparkle, Rainbow Dash, Pinkie Pie, Rarity, Fluttershy, Applejack, and all their friends throughout Equestria captured in each artist's unique style! Discover what each artist enjoys most about drawing and painting the beauty, kind-heartedness, and fun that is MLP!

TPB • FC • $19.99 • 8.5" x 12" • 144 pages • ISBN: 978-1-68405-261-5

Bullet Point:
  • The magic of creativity comes alive once again in this beautiful collection of art featuring your favorite pony friends!

Ooh, it's been a while since we've had the comic do what the show dares not. This stuff about Tempest finding the pony who turned her evil is a bit odd, though. Also, I wonder if they'll call her Tempest. I expect that she'll decide she prefers that name.

The Ponyville Mysteries comic seems cute. I'm surprised to see a showcase for the Big Lebowski ponies of all things.

I liked the first Art is Magic, which had interviews and sketches, so I'll check this one out too.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Season 8 OT draft!

season_8_header_png.png


The end is coming... but not quite yet.

The season 8 premiere of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic shakes things up more than ever. Following the events of My Little Pony: the Movie, Twilight and the others realize that they are meant to spread the magic of friendship beyond the borders of Equestria, and to this end, they open the School of Friendship. Students include not just ponies, but also changelings, dragons, griffons, hippogriffs, and yaks. However, in a season premiere that 4chan hot takes have described as "anti-Trump shit", the heroes have to deal with ponies that are uncomfortable having a school where all species are invited.

Starting on March 24, new episodes will air every Saturday at 11:30 AM ET on Discovery Family. They're usually put on iTunes the next day. Seasons 1-7 can be found on US Netflix.

Also ongoing is the Equestria Girls YouTube series, which has a new short every Friday. This is a spinoff where the characters are humans in high school.

If you want to get started, then good news, we have an episode guide! Many episodes not listed as recommended are still good, and if you like how an episode sounds, feel free to watch it too. Also includes Equestria Girls.

Note that there was a huge leak of episodes from this season. In short, don't talk about the contents of leaked episodes until they air, even using spoiler blocks. However, leaked information regarding the upcoming Generation 5 (G5) and the fact that FiM is ending with season 9 can be openly discussed, since it doesn't spoil anything.

We have a Hangouts thread for fanfic discussion and such. And we have a Discord! See the bottom of this post.

Oh, and that mare in the header? That's Belle Eve, our mascot! Well, Belle Eve 2.0, since her old look was based on the other place.

guide_season8_mains.png

guide_season8_side_png.png

guide_season8_eqg_png.png


XC0WXn9.png

New episodes air on Saturday at 11:30 AM ET on Discovery Family. They're usually put on iTunes the next day. Seasons 1-7 can be found on US Netflix.

1-2. School Daze - March 24
Following the events of "My Little Pony: The Movie," in the back-to-back season premiere episodes titled "School Daze Part 1" and "School Daze Part 2," the Mane 6 discovers that the Friendship Map has expanded to show the world outside Equestria. Through two exciting original songs, Twilight Sparkle learns that friendship needs to spread beyond the limits of the kingdom and decides to open her very own School of Friendship. But things come to a head when the new non-pony students ditch class on Friends and Family day, putting the entire school in jeopardy!

3. The Maud Couple - March 31
Pinkie Pie's super-best-friend-sister bond is challenged when Maud gets a boyfriend that Pinkie can't stand.

4. Fake It 'Til You Make It - April 7
Fluttershy is the only pony available to look after the Manehattan boutique while Rarity is away and takes on a series of characters to cope with the intimidating clientele. But as her characters get more and more exaggerated, Fluttershy learns that she was already the best pony for the job just by being herself.

5. Grannies Gone Wild - April 14
Granny Smith and her elderly friends are headed to Las Pegasus, and Rainbow Dash tags along as chaperone so she can ride the best rollercoaster ever before it closes. Unfortunately, following Applejack's care-taking rules for the "Golden Horseshoe Gals" keep Dash so busy, she doubts she'll even get to see the rollercoaster!

6. Surf and/or Turf - April 21
The Cutie Mark Crusaders try to help a young Hippogriff figure out where he belongs. With family members on Mt. Aris as well as Sea Pony relatives in Seaquestria, he can't decide where to live. Unfortunately, the CMCs are so taken with both places, they can't decide either!

0bUcTBq.png

This thread is for the discussion of all things pony, including Equestria Girls, the IDW comics, and as a change from before, general fan content. Fan fics are encouraged to go in our Hangouts thread, but there is no issue if you bring them up here.
* Episode titles and official synopses can be freely discussed, along with things tweeted by show crew and such.
* If an episode is released early, but legally, then discuss it behind spoiler blocks until it airs in the US.
* If an episode is leaked illegally, the contents can't be discussed here at all until it airs legally.
* G5 leaks, and the fact that FiM is ending with season 9, are fine to talk about openly, but be careful about posting the actual leaked emails and such.

highlights_png.png

I like to include a sort of table of contents with my threads. I'll link to the first post of each Monday and then list notable events for that week.

CIXMCcN.png

Hangouts thread
Old Community thread
Old season 7 OT

The Round Stable Forums - A devoted MLP forum that some of us post on too. Note that a hacker deleted every post from before late October 2017.
Equestria Daily - The primary MLP news blog.
Derpibooru - Massive screencap and fan art database for MLP. Without an account, you shouldn't see too many unsavory images.
MLP Wikia - Good source for information and screencaps.

mlp_discord_invite_png.png

Hidden content
You need to reply to this thread in order to see this content.
Credit to DrForester for the older assets, and everyone in the PonyEra Discord for feedback on the new assets

thumb.gif
thumb.gif
thumb.gif


==

And because this seems like a better time than when the new thread is made tomorrow, Sunday's stream is our first (non-EQG) episode premiere stream! And since we have a school-based premiere, I thought, why not take a look at the school based series? The other one.

28797__safe_screencap_bon+bon+%28g1%29_bright+eyes_clover+%28g1%29_melody_patch+%28g1%29_starlight_sweetheart_my+little+pony+tales_animated_g1_laughing.gif


1. My Little Pony Tales - Battle of the Bands - Melody is too busy babysitting to join the battle of the bands.
2. My Little Pony Tales - The Masquerade - Bon Bon is worried everyone will laugh at her dream of being a model.
3-4. School Daze
5. Tangled - The Return of Strongbow - And old thieving buddy of Eugene's returns for one last job.
6. Tangled - Great Expotations - An inventor's fair is held, and we check back in on those spikes appearing everywhere.

Tales episodes are only 12 minutes, hence why there are two. The first Tales episode actually isn't too bad, and has a good song by Kelly Sheridan (Glimglam's VA). The second, though, while it has a straightforward premise, the editing and sound just makes it... weird.
 
Last edited:

Strider_Blaze

Member
Oct 28, 2017
7,957
Lancaster, CA
Forgotten Friendship part 3 up.



Additions were probably a little more subtle. Twilight considers fixing library catalog and volleyball scene extended with Rainbow Dash showing motivation.

And watched 4 more episodes of season 7. Personally enjoyed them overall.

Rock Solid Friendship - I kind of felt the flashback with Maud and Starlight didn't affect much of the plot. Maud's new home looks nice and Pinkie shows off very funny moments as always. Overall solid episode (pun intended).

Fluttershy Leans In - Not that bad of an episode. Fluttershy continues to prove how much she has grown as a character with her semi-assertiveness. Though felt the characters that were called to build the sanctuary felt wasted and could've learned a lesson.

Forever Filly - Like a Flurry of Emotions, this yet another episode that I can relate to. Your younger sibling has grown up and wouldn't enjoy the exact same stuff as they use to. Of course, just about anyone grows up and enjoy different things. And another episode on how well the characters have progressed, this time with the CMC. All in all, this was a good episode too.

Parental Glideance - Got some good laughs with this one. RD's parents are just very excited throughout this episode. Though the episode here shows that you shouldn't act mean towards your parents no matter how embarrassing things can be, I feel this was kind of an example of a broken pedestal occurring. Your mentor acts all mean towards her parents for no apparent reason, other than "you embarrass me!" I believe that's the first time Scootaloo has ever shown this kind of resentment towards RD, seeing as she idolized the latter for so long (to the point of being like a sister), she felt hurt that much to see RD yell at her parents. At least they make things up in the end. Pretty heartwarming episode overall.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
New thread coming at 4 PM PDT, or in about five hours. This thread will remain open basically just to discuss fanfics, but all other discussion should be in the new thread. This just makes it less cumbersome if most discussion is in one place.

Feel free to continue conversations started here in this thread, though.

EDIT: New thread

This shot is so bizarre. Why is the one with the bottle briefly smiling after ruining her sundae? Why does the one that gets all the crap on her suddenly change from being super grumpy to instantly laughing like the other two with no transition between the two?
The first is a nervous smile, pretty normal. The lack of transition shows that ponies have no in between states for emotions.

And no thoughts on the hoof hands? There's actually an even worse example in the opening, but Derpibooru didn't have it in GIF form.

Additions were probably a little more subtle. Twilight considers fixing library catalog and volleyball scene extended with Rainbow Dash showing motivation.
Haven't watched it yet, but I guess that first scene was to reestablish why they were looking through the books individually, which is something I didn't think had to be explained in the first place. Extended volleyball sounds fun.

Rock Solid Friendship - I kind of felt the flashback with Maud and Starlight didn't affect much of the plot. Maud's new home looks nice and Pinkie shows off very funny moments as always. Overall solid episode (pun intended).
Revealing that Maud was involved in Starlight's evil plans wasn't necessary for their relationship, but it was a fun gag. It does demonstrate that she's perfectly willing to look past that, though.

Fluttershy Leans In - Not that bad of an episode. Fluttershy continues to prove how much she has grown as a character with her semi-assertiveness. Though felt the characters that were called to build the sanctuary felt wasted and could've learned a lesson.
Wasn't a fan myself, but I did like how Fluttershy was consistently assertive. The helpers just leaving without learning anything was indeed odd.

Forever Filly - Like a Flurry of Emotions, this yet another episode that I can relate to. Your younger sibling has grown up and wouldn't enjoy the exact same stuff as they use to. Of course, just about anyone grows up and enjoy different things. And another episode on how well the characters have progressed, this time with the CMC. All in all, this was a good episode too.
I enjoyed this episode, though it really needed Sweetie dragging Rarity to something she likes such as experimental theater and Rarity not getting it at all.

Parental Glideance - Got some good laughs with this one. RD's parents are just very excited throughout this episode. Though the episode here shows that you shouldn't act mean towards your parents no matter how embarrassing things can be, I feel this was kind of an example of a broken pedestal occurring. Your mentor acts all mean towards her parents for no apparent reason, other than "you embarrass me!" I believe that's the first time Scootaloo has ever shown this kind of resentment towards RD, seeing as she idolized the latter for so long (to the point of being like a sister), she felt hurt that much to see RD yell at her parents. At least they make things up in the end. Pretty heartwarming episode overall.
Scootaloo getting upset at Rainbow is good stuff, yeah. I don't think it's quite about never getting mad at your parents, but rather both parents and children reaching an understanding.
 
Last edited:

fony

Member
Feb 17, 2018
67

This is ridiculously good! Hope they make more.

I was reacting to Strider_Blaze 's description, since I was at work and hadn't watched the video yet.

Whoops, missed the "commenting on what you wrote".

It even works as future proofing for G5.

That's some serious foresight. (No preference for new/old thread or title from me.)

New EQG Mini video. It's been a while.


Having altered EQG watch the MLP movie. I'm sure no disastrous paradox could result from this.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
That's some serious foresight. (No preference for new/old thread or title from me.)
It's more to make the threads easier to tell apart at a glance. Already helped when I had both threads open in two tabs.
371467336047263754.png


Having altered EQG watch the MLP movie. I'm sure no disastrous paradox could result from this.
It's already an alternate dimension, so it should be fine.

Whoops, never made a post for this. New season 8 thread!

And as a convenient case study for what should still go in this thread, chat story from a couple of days ago, that somehow led to me planning out an MLP harem series with Twilight as the lead.

VirtuaSanus-Last Wednesday at 9:10 AM
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/293693603950362624/426025175977295880/IMG_20180321_093140.jpg

UberTag-Last Wednesday at 9:11 AM
That's very cute.
Sciz-Last Wednesday at 11:25 AM
harem comedy spinoff would probably be better on average than EG actually is
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 11:32 AM
Hmm, that makes me think. "Twilight never cared much for relationships, but she transfers to Canterlot High and discovers that not only do they all know her, but all the cutest girls in school are in love with her! Twilight doesn't want to get distracted from her studies, but on the other hand, these girls are fun to hang out with. Can she make them understand she isn't the same person they fell in love with without destroying their friendships? And perhaps will something new bloom out of this? Coming this fall, it's I Just Transferred to a New School and Everyone Thinks I'm a Horse From Another Dimension and They're In Love With Me!"
Cappy-Last Wednesday at 11:40 AM
377347619514613760.png
Pre-order form filled out!
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 11:43 AM
371467336047263754.png
You get a mouse pad for each girl!
376223681237483522.png
But Rainbow's is--
371466965727838209.png
Don't say it.
376225181183508480.png
The show is called JustHorse for short
Cappy-Last Wednesday at 11:53 AM
376224314329923584.png
Finally, a place to rest all my mouse friends!
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 12:17 PM
376223189249949696.png
A harem show? Time for me to practice!
raised-back-of-hand_1f91a.png
376224375717888000.png
Ohohohohoho--
376224816463609857.png
Hckhckhck(edited)
Twilight meets every single character by running into them and both falling in a compromising position. Except for Flash, who is specifically left out.
Oh, and Timber too.
You know, it occurs to me that none of those pony dating sim projects are from the perspective of Twilight. I get that they want to provide the option to date Twilight, but it's built right into the premise.
Cappy-Last Wednesday at 1:02 PM
ojou-sama rarity
eyes_1f440.png

SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 1:31 PM
376224228246028300.png
Technically, I'm the one from a rich family, so I should be the ojou-sama here.
376223189249949696.png
Let's see you try, then.
376225181183508480.png
Ohohohohohoho!
376224375717888000.png
I'm impressed, darling! You even have the hoof to the mouth built in! Together, now!
raised-back-of-hand_1f91a.png
376224375717888000.png
376225181183508480.png
Ohohohohohohoho!
376223681237483522.png
(What am I doing?)

[...]

Cappy-Last Wednesday at 2:17 PM
Old-money humble overachiever Twilight x Low-born self-made business horseperson, now-ojou-sama Rarity
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 2:17 PM
Yes, that's part of the appeal for me
Cappy-Last Wednesday at 2:22 PM
it's a good dynamic
but
what about cowgirl apple horse x clothes horse
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 5:16 PM
It's fine for comedy, not a fan of them as a couple.
Cappy-Last Wednesday at 5:19 PM
v_v

And then this chat conversation led to a fanfic recommendation for Shipping Sickness, a short farce where Twilight brings furniture to life and ships them. I'd do a write up, but the chat more or less covers my thoughts.
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 7:21 PM
Changed two of the Applejack vectors

Sylvee-Last Wednesday at 7:25 PM
The right AJ looks really excited about the other AJ being used as a sofa
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 7:28 PM
Whoops, didn't realize there was a new comic today. Probably won't get to it until later.
Conker-Last Wednesday at 7:29 PM
i'ts nto great
UberTag-Last Wednesday at 7:32 PM
AJ makes a good fainting couch.
Don't ship ponies with their furniture, people. It's not healthy.

[...]

Cappy-Last Wednesday at 8:11 PM
can i ship ponies with other people's furniture?
Sciz-Last Wednesday at 8:21 PM
"It... certainly seems that way," said Princess Mi Amore Credenza. "I mean, Shining Armoire is a handsome enough wardrobe. I think we could be pretty good friends, at least, right?"
I never thought I'd get to quote that in context
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 8:41 PM
Source?
Sciz-Last Wednesday at 8:41 PM
this bit of metafictional goofiness: https://www.fimfiction.net/story/44054/shipping-sickness
Fimfiction
Skywriter
Shipping Sickness
Twilight Sparkle and her bedside table: like two 'ships that pass in the night.

SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 8:46 PM
And that's another "Read It Later"
Sciz-Last Wednesday at 8:48 PM
Skywriter's got a lot of relatively short and immensely clever stories under his belt that are all well worth the time
and is also one of the only authors to ever take a serious interest in Cadance's character
Cappy-Last Wednesday at 8:52 PM
that was pretty funny
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 8:53 PM
Oh, it's pretty short. I guess I'll read it now, then.
That was good. Bedside table
376223420725198852.png
!
Cappy-Last Wednesday at 9:06 PM
It held her books up for her like nothing else wood.
SigmasonicX-Last Wednesday at 9:07 PM
The final pun was good.
ok-hand-sign_1f44c.png

1
Cappy-Last Wednesday at 9:08 PM
i'm inspired to finish this furniture-based piece.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Alright, the size of these chat stories means splitting off the fanfic part into another post.

Chat stories
And it's been a while, some dumb as hell chat stories.

Chat story that started out about Transformers, then went in a different direction.
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:37 PM
https://cybertronological.files.wordpress.com/2015/10/optimus-helps-megatron-transform.gif
optimus-helps-megatron-transform.gif

A.M.-Today at 2:42 PM
426074196129611776.png

Franling-Today at 2:42 PM
377528175846096907.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 2:44 PM
TFW Optimus will never transform you into a gun
A.M.-Today at 2:44 PM
I don't like guns
so it works out
\o/
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:45 PM
Megatron is sometimes a tank instead
You know, the reason why Megatron is a gun is because the original Transformers toy line was a combination of three different transforming robot toys.
McNum-Today at 2:46 PM
Or a jet.
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:46 PM
One of which was household items
That's why he turns into a gun
McNum-Today at 2:46 PM
I kind of like the Prime and also the movie Megatron just flat out refusing to get an Earth form.
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:46 PM
And why Soundwave is a stereo
Yeah, that's a good direction to take
McNum-Today at 2:47 PM
Megatron finding hiding his Cybertronian origin disgusting seems about right.
If Megatron shows up in person, the time for subtlety is over.
His minions may disguise themselves if they think it'll help their performance, but Megatron will not.
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:49 PM
Though there's just some charm to him turning into a gun other people have to carry
pistol_1f52b.png
You know this is the only reason I keep you around, Starscream. You don't ask what the trigger matches up with in my robot form.
airplane_2708.png
...
McNum-Today at 2:51 PM
Where does the trigger end up on the toy, anyway?
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:51 PM
I don't know
The original toys were kind of junk, so it was probably still clearly visible on his back or something.
[...]
McNum-Today at 2:58 PM
The trigger is on his back: https://youtu.be/02UMy5Nvfqg
[...]
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:02 PM
pistol_1f52b.png
You see Starscream, every time you pull the trigger, you're actually giving me a nice massage.
McNum-Today at 3:03 PM
airplane_2708.png
That was less disturbing than I feared...
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:03 PM
airplane_2708.png
Well then, I'm not going to--
airplane_2708.png
pistol_1f52b.png
Not going to what, Starscream?
airplane_2708.png
What?! You can fly in gun form?!
pistol_1f52b.png
Of course, you outdated Windowsbot! You really think I'd be that vulnerable?!
airplane_2708.png
But--
pistol_1f52b.png
Now give me a massage while we fire at Wheelie over there.
377658284427182081.png
Hold on! Wheelie wasn't introduced until after you already turned into Galvatron and killed Starscream!
McNum-Today at 3:07 PM
...I don't think Wheelie agrees.
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:07 PM
airplane_2708.png
Is that a talking horse?
pistol_1f52b.png
Shut up and shoot
[...]
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:09 PM
collision-symbol_1f4a5.png
377658284427182081.png
Sweetie Dodge
377347619514613760.png
"And thus Sweetie Belle dodged their attacks until Megatron ran out of power."(edited)
A.M.-Today at 3:12 PM
426072837871108106.gif

SigmasonicX-Today at 3:12 PM
377347619514613760.png
Nani?!
[...]
A.M.-Today at 3:13 PM
426074198088089612.png
That wasn't Sweetie. We found her body in the water this morning. She was found dead for over 72 hours.
426074198100672513.png
You can see a tear in the Sweetie imposter's costume, from where Megatron did graze her.
426074198226501633.png
You can also see that Megatron did in fact hit the imposter multiple times.
426072209870684170.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 3:15 PM
377658284427182081.png
Fufufu, so you have seen through me.
235573486985281536.png
235573254704594946.png

A.M.-Today at 3:16 PM
426074198025175040.png
Who are you, Sweetie imposter!?(edited)
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:16 PM
377658284427182081.png
I am, in fact
377659374371602432.png

A.M.-Today at 3:16 PM
426072201947774986.png
...
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:16 PM
376223681237483522.png
That explains everything
A.M.-Today at 3:17 PM
426074198075768855.png
Owlowicious... but why? Why?!
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:17 PM
airplane_2708.png
I've been tricked by an owl?!
377659374371602432.png
This world is impure. It must be rewritten in my beauty.
377659374371602432.png
Sweetie Belle is the only one who knew.
377347619514613760.png
"But that wasn't the end of the twists!"
A.M.-Today at 3:19 PM
426074197131788288.png
slams coffee mug down
426074197131788288.png
This has been nothing but a joke--a farce--an insult.
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:20 PM
377659374371602432.png
Nani?!
A.M.-Today at 3:20 PM
426074196129611776.png
I'm hoppin' away!
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:21 PM
377659374371602432.png
That creature... Could it be?!
377347619514613760.png
"Once it got far enough away, it transformed into the true mastermind!"
sparkles_2728.png

A.M.-Today at 3:22 PM
312659629073235968.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 3:23 PM
pistol_1f52b.png
K-kono puresha
376224375717888000.png
Kefka, darling, mind getting out of the way?
312659629073235968.png
Yes, my queen
376223681237483522.png
Yes, of course, only one person would allow Sweetie to die like that!
376223189249949696.png
You see, I am the true mastermind behind everything! It was quite amusing watching you run around transforming into guns that had to be picked up and going on friendship missions and the like, but the time had come.
377347619514613760.png
"And then she said"
376224375717888000.png
But my true purpose has always been to get the attention of the one writing this, dear Spikey Wikey.
377347619514613760.png
"Wait, wha--" I mean, wait, what?!
376223022773960704.png
It's true, I gained all this power so I could reach out to you. Because I love you!
377347619514613760.png
Oh Rarity
376223022773960704.png
Oh Spike
377347619514613760.png
kisses scroll
376224314329923584.png
Hello there Spike, I was wondering if
376224628412121101.png
Oh, uh, OK, I see that you're busy.
376224628412121101.png
I'll just go over here, then.
376224628412121101.png
Away.
376224628412121101.png
door_1f6aa.png

The End
A.M.-Today at 3:31 PM
426074197131788288.gif
barges in Remember to buy my CD on your way out. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMnrl0tmd3k
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:40 PM
You know, I don't think that Rarity is right for Spike. She did just allow Sweetie Belle to die.
I really do question that dragon's taste sometimes.
Plus in the end that Rarity was just words on a scroll. Not even a drawing.
Well maybe he drew something saucy, but I'm not sure of his art skills.
Cappy-Today at 3:47 PM
he drew those rpg characters, right
seems good enough
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:49 PM
Hmm, yeah, probably
376224628412121101.png
Meanwhile, I'm over here imagining myself with an idol version of myself and--
376224628412121101.png
Um, never mind.
A.M.-Today at 3:53 PM
I do that a lot too

This story came out of that thread where Russian spies were pretending to be furries on Tumblr.
SigmasonicX-Today at 1:15 PM
https://www.resetera.com/threads/fo...een-pretending-to-be-furries-on-tumblr.32352/
371467037702356993.png

Weirdest thing is that many of these Russian agents apparently were posting legit high quality art.
Cappy-Today at 1:27 PM
maybe they're legit russian agents
er
furries
whooooooooops
SigmasonicX-Today at 1:46 PM
I'd like to come clean to the fact that my posts are actually written by a team of Russians
Fluttershy is the sign
Cappy-Today at 1:54 PM
they're doing good work
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:03 PM
376224314329923584.png
flag-for-russia_1f1f7-1f1fa.png
(edited)
376224628412121101.png

spaghetthoy-Today at 2:12 PM
Splaseebay
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:13 PM
371465156208885760.png
That's the trigger word.
pick_26cf.png
371465156208885760.png

hammer_1f528.png

1
She digs a hole with the pick
hole_1f573.png

376224314329923584.png
I'm going back home!
376224628412121101.png
jumps down
376224314329923584.png
milky-way_1f30c.png

376224314329923584.png
house-buildings_1f3d8.png

376224314329923584.png
house-building_1f3e0.png

376224314329923584.png
open-mailbox-with-raised-flag_1f4ec.png

376224314329923584.png
door_1f6aa.png

376224314329923584.png
couch-and-lamp_1f6cb.png

Cappy-Today at 2:19 PM
whoa that is her couch
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:19 PM
376224314329923584.png
Yes, it's my couch!
376224314329923584.png
sleeping-accommodation_1f6cc.png

371465156208885760.png

376224314329923584.png
hocho_1f52a.png
sleeping-accommodation_1f6cc.png

376224314329923584.png
bed_1f6cf.png

Then Fluttershy had a well deserved rest after infiltrating the brony community
371467037702356993.png
Alas, so close to a story where no one died.
Cappy-Today at 2:26 PM
i thought she just woke the sleeper up and gave them brownies
SigmasonicX-Today at 2:29 PM
377658284100026370.png
Ooh, Comradeshy, is that what you did?
376224628412121101.png
... Yes, probably

And then this story came about from the normal discussion of Twilight's love of books.
Sylvee-Today at 3:41 PM
https://derpicdn.net/img/view/2018/3/26/1691146.gif "When you hurt a book so hard it's felt across dimensions"

Cappy-Today at 3:42 PM
lol
376224314329923584.png
She took it and threw it on the GROOOOOUND!
376224314329923584.png
We're not gonna be part of the system!
376224314329923584.png
Rules are for-
377658284368199681.png
It was actually in the lake.
376224628412121101.png
Oh.
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:44 PM
I haven't watched those other five non-song EQG shorts yet. Or the CYOAs after the one where Twilight has to relax.
You know, Twilight should consider the fact that her students could drop books in the pool
Cappy-Today at 3:45 PM
Or a Yak D:
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:45 PM
Or Silverstream could dive in while holding a book.
Or a yak holding a book could be dropped in.
Cappy-Today at 3:46 PM
371466816041648130.png

Sylvee-Today at 3:48 PM
I think Twilight has just accepted that Friendship > Books
Cappy-Today at 3:49 PM
you can't always cheer someone up with dresses and cupcakes, friendship is more important than books, "Not even a princess can do whatever she likes when it comes to shaping young pony minds."
this season is really shaking my worldview
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:49 PM
Maybe AJ will decide she prefers strawberries after all!
Sylvee-Today at 3:49 PM
That last line is a lie though
She basically says "fuck your rules I'm the Princess of Friendship"
Cappy-Today at 3:51 PM
yeah i thought it was true before ;-;
but it turns out big princess royalty takes precedence over everything
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:54 PM
376225181183508480.png
Since this facility houses non-Equestrian citizens and is property of a princess, I'm free to declare it as outside the jurisdiction of Equestria.
376223681237483522.png
And in this building outside the bounds of the law, book marriage is legal.
Cappy-Today at 3:56 PM
lol
SigmasonicX-Today at 3:57 PM
blue-book_1f4d8.png
376225181183508480.png

377347619514613760.png
376224314329923584.png
376223420725198852.png
blue-book_1f4d8.png
wedding_1f492.png
376225181183508480.png
377658284368199681.png
371465951562039298.png
377658284100026370.png
376224445817421835.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 4:00 PM
bed_1f6cf.png
blue-book_1f4d8.png
376225181183508480.png

bed_1f6cf.png
blue-book_1f4d8.png
376225181183508480.png
door_1f6aa.png
376224445817421835.png

Chained Prometheus-Today at 4:00 PM
LOL
AJ secretly ships RariTwi
Sylvee-Today at 4:01 PM
Would Twilight really pick book over Rarity?
Or better yet Book over Flash Sentry?
Chained Prometheus-Today at 4:01 PM
I mean, most people would pick a book over Flash Sentry
376225181183508480.png

Sylvee-Today at 4:02 PM
Did a book stop Twilight from getting framed by Sunset Shimmer?
Didn't think so
SigmasonicX-Today at 4:02 PM
Even in The Enchanted Kingdom, I'm pretty sure it's mentioned at one point she'd marry a book if she could.
Chained Prometheus-Today at 4:03 PM
Did Flash Sentry ever let Twilight meet her number one influence and inspiration, Starswirl the Bearded?
Sylvee-Today at 4:03 PM
Which book though?
SigmasonicX-Today at 4:03 PM
blue-book_1f4d8.png
This picture is fake. I can tell from the pixels.
Sylvee-Today at 4:03 PM
The book was lazy and made Twilight do all the work. It doesn't deserve her
Chained Prometheus-Today at 4:04 PM
Au contraire, it was a bonding experience that allowed the other Mane 5 get to pitch in some of the work too
SigmasonicX-Today at 4:04 PM
My one weakness is that I can't come up with book puns even though it keeps coming up.
Chained Prometheus-Today at 4:04 PM
All according to Book-kun's keikaku
* Note: Keikaku means "plan"
UberTag-Today at 4:07 PM
To answer Sylvee's question, there's no doubt in my mind that Twi would pick
blue-book_1f4d8.png
over
376223022773960704.png
.
SigmasonicX-Today at 4:07 PM
371466816041648130.png
376225181183508480.png
Oh Book-kun, you're so amazing at seeing pixels.
376223681237483522.png
I... Is it alright if we... If I get more copies of you? I don't mind if you aren't into that, but--
blue-book_1f4d8.png
Baby, I'm already a bestseller.
376225181183508480.png

UberTag-Today at 4:09 PM
books_1f4da.png
/me wink at
376225181183508480.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 4:10 PM
blue-book_1f4d8.png
376223681237483522.png
blue-book_1f4d8.png
blue-book_1f4d8.png

376223681237483522.png
So many at once... Can I even handle this?
UberTag-Today at 4:11 PM
Nothing quite like being the filling in a book sandwich.
SigmasonicX-Today at 4:12 PM
376224445817421835.png
Now hold on! One book was bad enough, but this is just unnatural!
376224228246028300.png
Applejack, nothing could be more natural!
UberTag-Today at 4:12 PM
green-apple_1f34f.png
red-apple_1f34e.png
/me wink at
376224445817421835.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 4:13 PM
376224445817421835.png
You see! Us Apples prefer what's natural!
peach_1f351.png
376224445817421835.png

376224445817421835.png
That is disgusting.
376224228246028300.png
These books are made with all natural paper!
UberTag-Today at 4:16 PM
I ship bookhorse with books. I ship applehorse with apples. And I ship
371466965727838209.png
with
371466965727838209.png
.
371468504190156810.png
371465951562039298.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 4:17 PM
376224314329923584.png
Cheer up, Fluttershy!
371465156208885760.png

376224314329923584.png
376224314329923584.png

UberTag-Today at 4:18 PM
377658284192038924.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 4:18 PM
376224628412121101.png
376224628412121101.png
Sorry Discord, do you mind giving us some alone time?
Chained Prometheus-Today at 4:20 PM
UberTag Okay, as great that ship is, we all know by now that
371466965727838209.png
is with
377658284100026370.png
(edited)
SigmasonicX-Today at 4:20 PM
376224628412121101.png
376224628412121101.png
I can't believe this is how we'll have our first time...
376224314329923584.png
376224314329923584.png
257343857967104012.png
257343857967104012.png
Double animal petting!
Cappy-Today at 4:21 PM
MULTI-OTTER PETTING!
377658284343033858.png

SigmasonicX-Today at 4:23 PM
377347619380264961.png
You know, I learned a valuable lesson that love comes in all forms.
house-building_1f3e0.png
(Twilight inside) Yes, shove that TOC right in my face!
371466816041648130.png

1
376224445817421835.png
I can allow it, but that doesn't mean I have to like it.
[The End]
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
One oddity of the fandom came up in the chat: SpiderTwi. You see, there's a fanfic series crossing over MLP and Spider-Man, shipping Peter Parker and Twilight, and it wouldn't have gotten much attention if it wasn't for the author and/or an oddly invested fan commissioning tons and tons of fan art. And the thing is, a huge chunk of the art is very good! Not only did they commission from pony artists, but also superhero fan artists. While I'm not a fan of her superhero outfit, I really like the human Twilight design they go with. I'm particularly a fan of the stuff drawn by kitsuneanii.
medium.png

medium.png

medium.png

There's a ton more at the first link. Seriously, a ton more. And if you're not signed in, you're missing just short of half of it >_>

However, what I've been able to glean about the story itself from art and comments and its general reputation sounds pretty pretty bad.

And That's Terrible by InsertAuthorHere was recommended as an actual good crossover fic, with the premise being that Lex Luthor steals Celestia's cakes and thus she seeks revenge. The key is that everything is played straight. Luthor discovered Equestria and set a plan in motion to use its magic to defeat Superman, and in the process, he got hungry and decided to steal from Celestia's baking contest. Celestia fights back not just because of the cakes, but because of the threat he poses to her kingdom. The story is set during the ending of "MMMystery on the Friendship Express" and was started in 2012, so no Princess Twilight or anything. Well, until the last chapter where she's retconned into being a princess, because that was written in 2015. The story was fun, and it was nice to see Celestia kick ass, but it went on a bit too long for my taste.

There's a new chapter of The Enchanted Kingdom by Monochromatic.

I have to say, it is pretty hilarious that the reason Celestia hasn't been responding in all this time is because she didn't have paper and ink. Although I don't think that's the real reason, and she only responded because it was Twilight.

Prof. Awe has a good point that Twilight is the only one who broke out of her curse, and thus they need to get as much information about that process as they can, even if it's painful for Twilight to talk about. And that brings us to this part.
And then her gaze shifted towards Rarity, and she found the unicorn did not share the rest of the group's enthusiasm. There was no smile on her lips, no glimmer in her eyes, nothing but the mild apprehension that seemed to suffuse her every action.

Two years ago, Twilight thought, Rarity would have been the first to force Twilight to talk about the possession.

Two years ago, Rarity pushed and pushed and pushed through every defense, every barrier, every tangle of Twilight's existence.

But now? Now Twilight struggled to find the fearless unicorn who'd faced dragons, spirits of chaos, and Twilight herself.

Their eyes met for a moment, as if Rarity had heard by Twilight's thoughts, and so the alicorn quickly looked back down at the letter Celestia had sent.

I hadn't thought about the fact that Rarity would have forced Twilight to push through the pain of the possession in the past, and that part of her isn't there anymore. This goes to show the depth of their shared trauma over the experience. I wonder if that part of Rarity will ever come back. The entire thing with neither Twilight nor Rarity wanting to talk about the possession because each thinks the other will blame themselves is kind of frustrating, but they seem to be working through it, bit by bit.

It's nice to finally get a plot hook on what to do next. We're off on an adventure once again! Yet at the same time I wonder if the adventure and romance will integrate as cleanly as they did before. It sounds like we might get stuff with Nightmare Moon from the author's comment.

And of course, Twilight being absolutely baffled by the fact that the guards would need breaks and get distracted while reading books is fantastic. The owls getting upset about the changelings trying to help Twilight when that's their job was cute, too.

I hadn't noticed this in the paragraph with Rarity's last line in the chapter until I read the comments.
"Isn't there always?" She paused again, and her chest fell and rose with a breath. Mere habit, no doubt. "Care to share your thoughts?"

And then there's this line from the prologue.
Rarity looked up at him, suddenly amused. "Love makes ghosts of us all, it would seem."

Well, she's definitely cursed. I had assumed this before, but... wait, hold on, what does this mean about how much time passed? Checking...
At that moment, North Ridge learned three important details about his new friend.

One: Her name was Rarity.

Two: She had last been seen several days ago near a place called Dodge Junction which, if memory served, was entirely on the other side of Equestria.

Three: A mere two days ago, Princess Denza had launched a kingdom-wide search for her.

Phew, not that long, then. I thought maybe there was going to be a reveal that Rarity was cursed for decades, but the kingdom-wide search only starting a few days before makes that unlikely. Of course, there's still a chance this goes on far past this prologue.

There are a couple of other hints about Rarity being see-through in the prologue, such as her sitting in the shadows and not drinking her coffee.

This was a good set up chapter.
 

Nali

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,649
The Super Dictionary is the gift that keeps on giving.

Pulled that one out of my future recommendations queue early because jesus christ that Spiderman stuff sent shivers down my spine.
 

Nali

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,649
Greetings, pony fans, particularly those of you in the audience who like fanfiction and Sunset Shimmer.

I've been writing.

If the thought of reading fourteen thousand words of self-serving, vainglorious, fourteen year old Sunset Shimmer having her world turned upside down by the arrival of Cadance sounds like a good time, then drop me a PM for a link to what I've been up to. Feedback is thoroughly welcomed and appreciated, as this is the first thing I've seriously put to page in six years, but if you just want to poke your head in and read, that's fine too.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Greetings, pony fans, particularly those of you in the audience who like fanfiction and Sunset Shimmer.

I've been writing.

If the thought of reading fourteen thousand words of self-serving, vainglorious, fourteen year old Sunset Shimmer having her world turned upside down by the arrival of Cadance sounds like a good time, have I got (the first chapter of) a story for you. There's a comments-enabled GDocs link behind the hide tag below. Feedback is thoroughly welcomed and appreciated, as this is the first thing I've seriously put to page in six years, but if you just want to poke your head in and read, that's fine too.

Hidden content
You need to reply to this thread in order to see this content.
Did you only want feedback in the doc, or here too? Anyway, I'll try to start it tonight. I think the premise of young Sunset and Cadance could be very appealing to readers and you'd really just need good cover art to draw people in.
 
OP
OP
SigmasonicX

SigmasonicX

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,474
Gonna try to whip something up on the old art tablet I've got sitting around, but I'm even less practiced as an artist than I am as a writer, so uh, we'll see about the "good" part.
Well, we do have a pretty prolific artist who posts here and in the chat.
EDIT: Removed part of that.
 
Last edited: