-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Monopoly Mafia - Proletariat of the World Unite
- Thread starter Faddy
- Start date
- Status
Who do you think is more likely to be scum, Fandorin or Xbro? And do you think they could be both scum, or just one of them?
thats how i feel it, i mean in my reality i was very vocal. Feel free to disagree ( like you did ). i consider high post count = vocal player.
We can of course talk about being vocal and being helpful which are two different things. There i can somewhat agree that i was vocal but not very helpful in the general sense but then we can argue about a lot of players not being "helpful".
All in All i feel good about myself
Ok. She's actually been in my mind since D1 end, so this is convenient.
I made note of liking one particular point of her D1 activity. When I pointed something out about Kalor, she actually did go back and reread him. It's not a big thing, but it felt genuine to me - particularly in a D1 like that, during which half the roster was hiding and not putting any work into scumhunting.
When reading back the final D1 moments, her vote gave me some pause because it was a late one outside of the two main trains. But her vote against Kyan made the total score Geno 4, Sexy Fish 3, Kyan 3 - so it's not like she was dodging the lynch.
And this is the thing that's on the back of my mind:
I was bothered by this apologetic tone because I originally didn't feel like she did anything wrong. But this post actually makes me think she did try to hide from the lynch by not switching her vote to one of the two main trains right at the end. She was following the thread when Kyan stopped being a real possibility.
Thanks. I feel a bit better about him than you do, but not enough to call it a town-read yet. Sitting on top of the fence right now. I actually felt like it was still the last phase when he started participating more - but only after being called out, which makes it one of those things.
Fair enough.
==== DAY 2 VOTES ====
Day Start
nin (2 votes)
stuart444 - #542
sweetnicole - #544
xbro (1 votes)
grizzly - #566
fandorin (1 votes)
geno - #501
empressdonna (1 votes)
nin - #554
geno (1 votes)
apollo - #551
sophia (0 votes)
stuart444 - #487 #505
Post Counts:
grizzly: 20 geno: 19 brazil: 14 kyanrute: 10 stuart444: 10 dcpat: 9 empressdonna: 7 kalor: 7 ketkat: 6 nin: 6 sophia: 6 zippedpinhead: 6 apollo: 5 fandorin: 5 sweetnicole: 4 xbro: 1 faddy: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
nin (2 votes)
stuart444 - #542
sweetnicole - #544
xbro (1 votes)
grizzly - #566
fandorin (1 votes)
geno - #501
empressdonna (1 votes)
nin - #554
geno (1 votes)
apollo - #551
sophia (0 votes)
Post Counts:
grizzly: 20 geno: 19 brazil: 14 kyanrute: 10 stuart444: 10 dcpat: 9 empressdonna: 7 kalor: 7 ketkat: 6 nin: 6 sophia: 6 zippedpinhead: 6 apollo: 5 fandorin: 5 sweetnicole: 4 xbro: 1 faddy: 1
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
As of my re-reads right now, I'm struggling to get a real read on Zippedpinhead since a lot of it is coming off as neutral in my eyes at the moment. Nothing is jumping out at me as 'hey! I'm scum!' but honestly, I feel like nothing is shouting that he is town either.
I'm going to be paying attention to his future posts to see if I can get a clearer idea in my mind.
I'm going to be paying attention to his future posts to see if I can get a clearer idea in my mind.
Atm definitely Fandorin, not that sure on xbro yet, but if he coasts today too then I might change my mind. I'm leaning on one being scum rather than both, but too early to tellm
Xbro, I'm going to need you to go a little more in-depth on all of this. The fact that you weren't caught up really makes me wonder why you went for Geno specifically over anyone else. Was there anyone else that you were leaning towards?
Come on, guys.
I just saw this and bursted out laughing.
That is accurate
As you can see with the post after that, it was an honest mistake. I forgot to put Vote there >_<
there is no need to explain why i was not around since it does not matter, what does however is that i was NOT around.
Feel free to leave that vote on me since its a lazy vote that can be called out by other members aswell as myself.
I mean i you really wanted to put pressure on me and hear me out you would not have unvoted. But since you did it just puts you into a bad light in my honest opinion.
Bad play all in all
Feeling slightly better. He's definitely been making an effort for a hunt today. Whether that's from coaching, or from his interaction with nicole earlier, I can't say. It's important to note on that though, that he's being mentored by Ty for his first game, stop even if it's coaching, it could be NAI.
At the time, no. I didn't have many strong reads beyond that. My post was aimed to be posted shortly after your post, because you were the one I was agreeing with. The only posts I had not caught up with were the posts that popped up between the time I started the post and the time I finished the post. Between me being in class and on mobile, it took me 10 minutes to write that post. In that time, a couple more votes came into play.
It is a little hyperbole, yes. However, like you said, you deserve some heat for your absence, and I'm wanting to see some strong contributions out of you today. Don't just explain to me why you were absent, but give me some solid town posts.
Sophia I wanted to clarify that I was wrong with the zero votes. I was re-reading Brazil's post and about to point out why it was Geno 4, SF 3, Kyan 0 and then I realized I had fucked up looking over the votes from D1. There was two votes at the time you voted for Kyan and your third vote tied him with Sexy Fish. While like you said, I would have liked to see your vote shift to another train such as Geno who were slightly scum-reading once SF started wracking up the votes, I did want to clear up this inaccuracy in my post.
Good notes about her being apologetic today, and the fact that she was reading the thread when Kyan stopped being a potential lynch candidate. Something about her posts in general bother me - it feels like she isn't committed to scumhunting completely, and is more about doing weak contributions while trying to seem towny. And definitely that vote at the end of D1 felt weak.
OP
OP
==== DAY 2 VOTES ====
Day Start
xbro (2 votes)
grizzly - #566
stuart444 - #610
fandorin (1 votes)
geno - #501
empressdonna (1 votes)
nin - #554
geno (1 votes)
apollo - #551
nin (1 votes)
stuart444 - #542 #608
sweetnicole - #544
sophia (0 votes)
stuart444 - #487 #505
Post Counts:
grizzly: 22 geno: 21 brazil: 14 stuart444: 14 kyanrute: 10 dcpat: 9 nin: 8 empressdonna: 8 ketkat: 7 kalor: 7 sweetnicole: 6 sophia: 6 zippedpinhead: 6 apollo: 5 fandorin: 5 xbro: 2 faddy: 2
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
With 16 players alive the majority is 9
Day Start
xbro (2 votes)
grizzly - #566
stuart444 - #610
fandorin (1 votes)
geno - #501
empressdonna (1 votes)
nin - #554
geno (1 votes)
apollo - #551
nin (1 votes)
sweetnicole - #544
sophia (0 votes)
Post Counts:
grizzly: 22 geno: 21 brazil: 14 stuart444: 14 kyanrute: 10 dcpat: 9 nin: 8 empressdonna: 8 ketkat: 7 kalor: 7 sweetnicole: 6 sophia: 6 zippedpinhead: 6 apollo: 5 fandorin: 5 xbro: 2 faddy: 2
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
With 16 players alive the majority is 9
*nods*
Just woke up, reading stuff. Why does this game always seem to move only when I'm sleeping?
Same here Sophia, off work with the wife and kids today and just checked in to see a whole mother page...
*re-reads thread*
Er... says the bear who spend most of his day sitting on Apollo and jumped onto the Sexy Fish lynch at the end? :P
Actually, what specifically made you feel better about Apollo today, Grizzly? You have your vote on Xbro now, who admittedly you were scum reading back in your reads post when you voted for Apollo, but it didn't seem like you really tried to engage with him that much in Day 1? This post felt like a weird attempt to justify why you still had your vote there.
How do you feel about Geno now? Do you still think that he's scum? Any opinions on these?
There's a few people leaning towards you right now, and I'd really like to hear your thoughts on this.
Now that we know Sexy was town, I think there might be scum between Kalor and Xbro. Those three votes in succession came about 10 minutes after Grizzly said he felt good about kyan. In that post he basically repeated his argument, that I shared earlier, that kyan doubling down on his "accent" was probably a town move. Kalor votes Sexy, but throws shade into the kyan pile first.
Sexy explained his reasoning at the time after I called him out. I feel like the rest tried to play it off and town conceded that it was probably NAI.
Between both votes, I think Xbro is the scummiest. Kalor had previously commented on kyan and town reads, saying it's fun when someone gets on "the theme", while I don't actually remember much interaction between Xbro and kyan.
Sexy explained his reasoning at the time after I called him out. I feel like the rest tried to play it off and town conceded that it was probably NAI.
Between both votes, I think Xbro is the scummiest. Kalor had previously commented on kyan and town reads, saying it's fun when someone gets on "the theme", while I don't actually remember much interaction between Xbro and kyan.
Nothing has really changed about Geno for me. According to what he said today, his plan was basically to see how people would react to his claims against Kyan.
What do you think about Stuart voting for Xbro then if you leaning towards both of them being scum right now?
I know that considering that's how he set it up but I'm curious what Fandorin thinks about it.
Okay. Do you have any thoughts on the people voting/suspecting you right now? Do you have any reads you want to share?
Like Xbro said, it looks like a prod vote, which can go either way.
Stuart has already voted for 3 players this phase, all without much substance and admittedly prod votes. I don't remember him doing this last day, so maybe his mentor gave him an idea that lead to it? When I get the chance I'll reread Stuart D1 to try and confirm this.
Not really for the first one. They have reason to suspect me that are very much legitimate reasons to do so. I can't really take back the things I've said, though I can give assurance that I wasn't doing so with nefarious intent. The most I can give is my thought process while posting.
As far as reads, there are a couple I'm trying to get my thoughts around, I want to go through the game again when I get the chance with them in mind. I have a hard time putting my thoughts into posts.
Zipped gave me some bad vibes earlier on. Though, chalk that one up to a gut feeling more than anything. #494 triggered some alarm bells with the way he worded the space kill, but it's worth noting that he immediately rectified his mistakes.
It was either a mentor, or the interactions with Nicole from the first day. He was subjected to a prod vote that he reacted very poorly to.
I was at Apollo, but once it became obvious he wouldn't be a lynch candidate on D1, I moved my vote towards the people who were viable - something you didn't do even though you were participating in the thread at the end of the day.
As for why I feel better on Apollo:
Although granted, this post has aged by now, because Apollo hasn't been on the thread since his vote on Geno almost 12 hours ago.
Aye, I was reading the sexy fish votes, as I noted near day end.
Stuart's votes on Day 1:
Prod vote on Royal.
Prod vote on Sexy Fish, which is where he left it at day's end. I poked him about why he left it earlier, and this was his reply
Not sure how I feel about it as far as a scum read goes, but it didn't come off as positive to me.
I've forgotten to point out exactly this while typing posts on other stuff twice before, but I completely agree. Xbro's unvote was the one that made me raise an eyebrow at the time, and he immediately reacted in apparent outrage at what had happened.
I hate it so much that Zippedpinhead is there on the sidelines once again. I've seen this film way too many times.
This is the list of people I'm currently leaning scum on:
Stuart444
Geno
nin
Sophia
Xbro
Hopefully I'm right about at least one :P
Stuart444
Geno
nin
Sophia
Xbro
Hopefully I'm right about at least one :P
Unvote
I'm leaning town now with Xbros recent posts. Will probably give a full list tomorrow but right now, town wise
Town:
Brazil
Grizzly
Sweetnicole
Leaning Town:
Xbros
Ketkat
Fandorin
Everyone else, I'm unsure on. Will wait and see how things progress and maybe do a reread later or tomorrow.
I'm leaning town now with Xbros recent posts. Will probably give a full list tomorrow but right now, town wise
Town:
Brazil
Grizzly
Sweetnicole
Leaning Town:
Xbros
Ketkat
Fandorin
Everyone else, I'm unsure on. Will wait and see how things progress and maybe do a reread later or tomorrow.
okay i am going to put down my town list.
Town
14. [m] Nin UTC+2
Potential Scum
01. [m] Stuart444 - NEW UTC+1 - Mentored by [m] Ty4on
02. [f] KetKat - NEW UTC-4 - Mentored by [m] Hecht
04. [f] Sophia
05. [m] Grizzly UTC+2
06. [m] Fandorin UTC-3
07. [m] Xbro UTC-6
08. [m] Apollo
09. [f] SweetNicole UTC-5
10. [f] empressdonna UTC+1
12. [m] Brazil UTC-3
13. [m] DCPat
15. [m] Kyanrute UTC+2
16. [m] Zippedpinhead UTC-6
17. [m] Kalor UTC+1
18. [m] Geno UTC+3
Town
14. [m] Nin UTC+2
Potential Scum
01. [m] Stuart444 - NEW UTC+1 - Mentored by [m] Ty4on
02. [f] KetKat - NEW UTC-4 - Mentored by [m] Hecht
04. [f] Sophia
05. [m] Grizzly UTC+2
06. [m] Fandorin UTC-3
07. [m] Xbro UTC-6
08. [m] Apollo
09. [f] SweetNicole UTC-5
10. [f] empressdonna UTC+1
12. [m] Brazil UTC-3
13. [m] DCPat
15. [m] Kyanrute UTC+2
16. [m] Zippedpinhead UTC-6
17. [m] Kalor UTC+1
18. [m] Geno UTC+3
Could you explain where you're feeling about zippedinhead right now? Reading your first post by itself, I assume that post would be a strong indication that you're leaning scum on him, yet he isn't in your list of leaning scum. Does this mean you're reading him as town or null?
what do you want to know ?
i am going to lay it down for you and everyone else if you want to
I'm going to make a very narcissistic observation right now.
This is the first time you've mentioned my name or acknowledged me in any way throughout this entire game. You haven't quoted me or talked about me to other players.
This is actually something I've been paying attention to since halfway through D1.
Now that I've voted against you without giving out any real reasoning for it, you mention my name for the first time by putting me in your town-read list.
I don't have a read on him yet, which is what scares me. Scum!Zipped blends into the room like a well-placed piece of furniture.
- Status