The other live action remakes might have their problems, they've been generally very well liked. For all the complaints of "why make film again" for TLK remake, it's ultimately had an overwhelmingly positive reception.
But this one, nothing seems to be working for it. Every promotional bit or news about the production seems to be totally off, or bad looking.
True. As I said in another thread recently that asked 'why live action anime adaptations don't work' it could be that Aladdin was simply never going to work in live action.
Given the crazy, Looney Tunes esque performance Robin Williams gave as the Genie recreating in live action with an actual actor was never going to be an easy ask. I suppose it's the difference between saying Jungle Book would work as a live action/VFX pic but Finding Nemo wouldn't.