It's a gaming enthusiast forum, comes with the territory.
That being said I still don't feel like a slogan is the way to go. Is the forum a product/brand that we're actively trying to grow? I always thought of it as an online social space (pub) for people to discuss common interests. Slogans and the like seem like a sleazy business thing.
I'd like to see the community to grow and thrive, yes. There's nothing wrong on being both, imho. Knowing how costly forums actually are, I don't see where it's the harm on thinking of ResetEra as a brand. Our brand.