Anti-refugee backlash in South Korea targets Yemenis fleeing war and seeking asylum

demosthenes

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,908
So as a wealthy -- but black -- guy, should I or should I not remove South Korea from my list of places to visit.

I'm not interested in going anywhere that will likely treat me like shit.
Friend from college has been living and teaching in South Korea for 6 or so years now. He hasn't had anything outside of what you can expect in the US in certain parts.
 

Psykodoughboy

Banned
Dec 17, 2017
782
someone in another discussion just mentioned not being allowed into a Busan bar in SK, as a black person.
Same, Mexican dude tho. I got a lot of the arm x in Japan. One time I tired to get in a bar, but got stopped. Got the x, but you could see a ton white people in the bar

Maybe only Russians could go in. Idk I was pissed tho.
 

Dreams-Visions

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
29,933
Miami, FL
Friend from college has been living and teaching in South Korea for 6 or so years now. He hasn't had anything outside of what you can expect in the US in certain parts.
I think you have a decent chance at a good vacation in Seoul. Not sure how well you would fair if you stepped out of there though.
I can only speak as a white dude, but I think you could enjoy yourself a lot if you stick to Seoul, which is way more cosmopolitan than anywhere else in Korea. Also, money talks--if you're wealthy, clean-cut, and stylishly dressed, you'll be a lot better received.
sounds good. I feel better. tyvm folks! (and everyone else that I didn't quote; i read your comment)
 

Kaseoki

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,022
It's not just the native Koreans but also the white foreigners/expats living in Korea who are part of this backlash. It's rather hypocritical. They point to all the problems in Europe and they say that Korea should remain a homogenous society and not become a terrible multicultural society, the fuck. White privilege sometimes goes too far in their heads.
 

TinfoilHatsROn

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
3,119
Ugh. Pretty sure the group likes Trump too.

Sigh. The boatowner at the end has the right mindset. The world is moving more right without realizing the consequences.
 

Spine Crawler

Member
Oct 27, 2017
9,755
this is embarassing as a korean. do people realize that there is a good chance that they must seek refuge as well if kim and trump plays foul?
 

Ganransu

Member
Nov 21, 2017
1,270
this is embarassing as a korean. do people realize that there is a good chance that they must seek refuge as well if kim and trump plays foul?
It's a spin on the popular "Got mine, fuck you" mentality. These people will be the first to cry when shit hit the fan for them, otherwise, it's "fuck you all" since they're fine, at this moment.

While this mentality isn't limited to Asians, it can get rather bad here because schools/parents have seriously failed to teach that here, as the first reply have said.
 

Myradeer

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,424
Canada
Europe and US get a lot of flak for racism, but they have nothing on East Asian homogeneous countries... especially if you're not white. I don't even think of it as racism, but xenophobia born from indifference and lack of experience.

Due to long history of being alone, they have yet to go through the cultural struggles of integrating multiculturalism - so many are even doubting whether it's even worth the effort to change. It's like Chinese rejection of democracy as "superior" ideal.
 

anamika

Member
May 18, 2018
1,303
Europe and US get a lot of flak for racism, but they have nothing on East Asian homogeneous countries... especially if you're not white.
Yeah, I often read threads on Era and think that if these folks live where I am living, they would be walking around throwing Soda in people's faces 24/7.
 

cjbenny

Member
Oct 29, 2017
167
sounds good. I feel better. tyvm folks! (and everyone else that I didn't quote; i read your comment)
As a fairly dark skinned Filipino American who traveled there for vacation last year, I personally didn't feel or sense any racial animosity towards me. On the contrary, I found almost everyone I encountered to be friendly. But I did stay in Seoul and Busan which are enormous metropolises, and as others have mentioned, these folks are refugees while I was effectively a tourist. South Korea is unfortunately a socially conservative and patriarchal country with a significant Christian population, so when I hear stories about this I both recoil in disgust, and still don't feel too surprised about it.
 

Ratrat

User requested ban
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,867
Europe and US get a lot of flak for racism, but they have nothing on East Asian homogeneous countries... especially if you're not white. I don't even think of it as racism, but xenophobia born from indifference and lack of experience.

Due to long history of being alone, they have yet to go through the cultural struggles of integrating multiculturalism - so many are even doubting whether it's even worth the effort to change. It's like Chinese rejection of democracy as "superior" ideal.
What a weird thing to say. This is South Korea.
 
Last edited:

Xiaomi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,987
So as a wealthy -- but black -- guy, should I or should I not remove South Korea from my list of places to visit.

I'm not interested in going anywhere that will likely treat me like shit.
I'm in Taiwan, but as a foreigner I would highly recommend going to any east Asian country with some local friends if you have any, just to minimize your risk of running into racist bullshit. I have black and darker Hispanic friends who come as part of their military service, and they have a great time because they mostly hang with locals who are more open-minded and educated. At the same time, I've had black friends who are miserable because they have to be around people who giggle constantly, or insult them in Chinese because they think they don't understand (mockery is apparent from tone in any language).

The American custom of not pointing out people's ethnicities is not a thing here. There are ladies in my neighborhood who have said "foreigner, good morning" to me every single day for three and a half years without any self-awareness. Taxi drivers will comment on your foreign status often. It's a land of microaggressions and the only way to really mitigate it is by having decent people to hang out with.
 

Rangerx

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,329
Aquilonia
Why anyone would want to live in a completely homogeneous sociery is beyond me. Diversity is good. Helping people who are in desperate need is right and feels good.
 

JonnyDBrit

God and Anime
Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,234
"Fake Refugees"?
The fuck?
It's people from Yemen! You can't be more of a refugee than people who are from Yemen!
A frustrating little piece of rhetoric has developed over the last few years to undermine the entire concept of being a refugee; namely, that if one can 'afford' the means to escape so far away from home, and maybe have taken a couple of luxuries from their old life with them, well you're not really a refugee, are you? Thus the idea that these people are 'fake' refugees who do not truly deserve help, without ever defining exactly how one's country would help 'real' refugees.

Really do feel for the Yemenis in this case.
 

Ratrat

User requested ban
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,867
Why anyone would want to live in a completely homogeneous sociery is beyond me. Diversity is good. Helping people who are in desperate need is right and feels good.
I don't see how a few hundred people are going to make a dent in South Korea's society. But as to your point, they almost lost their culture not too long ago to Japan and they might face reunification in the future.
 

Chairmanchuck

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,369
China
Okay. So.. i dont know how to say this without being misunderstood by the mods. I have my own opinion. A totally different one. I'm a minority myself in my own country, our live existence literally depends on our government. We have our own problem without refugees, so i cant imagine how things will be if my country decides to accepts refugees in large groups without proper background check. What if they are large enough to control the government? What if some of the people intend to invade our own country? We are not first world country that we can easily propose asylum permission (*totem pro parte applies here)

I'm not trying to be very xenophobic, but there is this slight of fear that maybe some of them are actually harmful. That's what my fear is
Large groups? Around 500 came. Thats like.... nothing at all.

It's not just the native Koreans but also the white foreigners/expats living in Korea who are part of this backlash. It's rather hypocritical. They point to all the problems in Europe and they say that Korea should remain a homogenous society and not become a terrible multicultural society, the fuck. White privilege sometimes goes too far in their heads.
I think it happens everywhere in the world. The asian immigrant community in Germany is also for a big part in the "anti-refugee" camp, just judging by my anecdotal community. Korean, japanese and chinese friends are mostly all like that sadly.
 

Keasar

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,220
Umeå, Sweden
A frustrating little piece of rhetoric has developed over the last few years to undermine the entire concept of being a refugee; namely, that if one can 'afford' the means to escape so far away from home, and maybe have taken a couple of luxuries from their old life with them, well you're not really a refugee, are you? Thus the idea that these people are 'fake' refugees who do not truly deserve help, without ever defining exactly how one's country would help 'real' refugees.

Really do feel for the Yemenis in this case.
Oh yeah, that bullshit. It is completely absurd to think like that and truly quite angering that people do. If you look up "refugee" in a dictionary it should be a picture of Yemen circled in red with text saying "People from here!" They are the textbook example of people fleeing a horrible situation.
 

Kin5290

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,165
So as a wealthy -- but black -- guy, should I or should I not remove South Korea from my list of places to visit.

I'm not interested in going anywhere that will likely treat me like shit.
If you look and sound American or some other kind of Western you’ll probably be fine. Part of the backlash here is that these refugees are being seen as “taking something” economically that would “otherwise go to a South Korean”. If you’re a tourist you’ll be seen as bringing money.

Staying in more cosmopolitan areas would also probably help, same with racism anywhere else in the world.
 

Dirt McGirt

Avenger
Oct 29, 2017
2,631
A frustrating little piece of rhetoric has developed over the last few years to undermine the entire concept of being a refugee; namely, that if one can 'afford' the means to escape so far away from home, and maybe have taken a couple of luxuries from their old life with them, well you're not really a refugee, are you? Thus the idea that these people are 'fake' refugees who do not truly deserve help, without ever defining exactly how one's country would help 'real' refugees.

Really do feel for the Yemenis in this case.
Add to that the "bad guys are hiding among them" narrative and yeah, you have a recipe for xenophobia.

Asylum seeking, refugee status, all this things mean jack shit today. Media and conservative politicians have brainwashed societies to the point that refugees are seeing as evil, freeloaders, economic migrants and so on.

Escaped an war zone with your smartphone? Not a refugee!

But dont worry the problem can be easily fixed, just mark Yemen as a safe country./s
 

Ogami Itto

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,612
Okay. So.. i dont know how to say this without being misunderstood by the mods. I have my own opinion. A totally different one. I'm a minority myself in my own country, our live existence literally depends on our government. We have our own problem without refugees, so i cant imagine how things will be if my country decides to accepts refugees in large groups without proper background check. What if they are large enough to control the government? What if some of the people intend to invade our own country? We are not first world country that we can easily propose asylum permission (*totem pro parte applies here)

I'm not trying to be very xenophobic, but there is this slight of fear that maybe some of them are actually harmful. That's what my fear is

The fuck am I reading here? Refugees taking over the government? The hell are you talking about?
 

acheron_xl

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,880
MSN, WI
This is, I think, exactly why Yemen is one of the 7 countries in Trump's travel ban. The US has been captured by fascists, so they want to make sure that marginalized or displaced Muslims are driven into countries that haven't been captured by fascists yet, to agitate the kind of anti-immigration sentiment fascists feed off of.
 

Richter1887

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
30,863
Or warring and doing the oppression as the case may be...

Yemen in particular is a direct result of proxy warring between Iran and Saudi Arabia.
...which is being supported by the US and the west. Yemen in particular.

Also current Iranian government and the current Saudi government were installed by the US. Read up on the Iranian revolution and the Saudi king assassination. The west was involved in both of these.
 

Dreams-Visions

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
29,933
Miami, FL
If you look and sound American or some other kind of Western you’ll probably be fine. Part of the backlash here is that these refugees are being seen as “taking something” economically that would “otherwise go to a South Korean”. If you’re a tourist you’ll be seen as bringing money.

Staying in more cosmopolitan areas would also probably help, same with racism anywhere else in the world.
roger that.
 

Deleted member 274

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,564
Okay. So.. i dont know how to say this without being misunderstood by the mods. I have my own opinion. A totally different one. I'm a minority myself in my own country, our live existence literally depends on our government. We have our own problem without refugees, so i cant imagine how things will be if my country decides to accepts refugees in large groups without proper background check. What if they are large enough to control the government? What if some of the people intend to invade our own country? We are not first world country that we can easily propose asylum permission (*totem pro parte applies here)

I'm not trying to be very xenophobic, but there is this slight of fear that maybe some of them are actually harmful. That's what my fear is
I'd be willing to bet you're a non-muslim minority in a non-muslim country, am I right? 'background checks" and people fleeing from muslim countries seem to go hand by hand, mysteriously.

Even putting your crystal clear xenophobia aside, your pretty bad arguments and your far fetched "theories", fucking over millions of people because of your fear towards hundreds of individuals with negative backgrounds is just inhumane. Although with how scared you are about them becoming majority I guess you think the ones with shady backgrounds leans more into the millions.

It's appaling to hear people like you, in the position you say you are, who know they're wrong, because you admit it, be so selfish and insensitive even with this in mind.
 

MilesQ

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,494
Okay. So.. i dont know how to say this without being misunderstood by the mods. I have my own opinion. A totally different one. I'm a minority myself in my own country, our live existence literally depends on our government. We have our own problem without refugees, so i cant imagine how things will be if my country decides to accepts refugees in large groups without proper background check. What if they are large enough to control the government? What if some of the people intend to invade our own country? We are not first world country that we can easily propose asylum permission (*totem pro parte applies here)

I'm not trying to be very xenophobic, but there is this slight of fear that maybe some of them are actually harmful. That's what my fear is
You're a pretty shitty person who is driven by nothing more than debilitating paranoia and easily manipulated by propaganda.
 

Riversands

Banned
Nov 21, 2017
5,669
'd be willing to bet you're a non-muslim minority in a non-muslim country, am I right?
What?? No. How to say this... you can say i'm a minority living in a country where our lives could be at stake. But this is from my personal experience explaining how i somehow understand what the koreans (the ones in the rally) feel. I'm not talking about being right or wrong, it's more about how they act like that
 

AlsoZ

Member
Oct 29, 2017
3,003
Why anyone would want to live in a completely homogeneous sociery is beyond me. Diversity is good. Helping people who are in desperate need is right and feels good.
Is this just a figure of speech or are you literally unable to understand the reason? Diversity doesn't just pop into existence. It's the result of a process.

"Diversity is good" is a meaningless, dogmatic mantra to most people in the world. "Diversity" is, as can be plainly seen by reading the news, often a cause for conflict, transitional pains and erosion of social trust. Most people want to be surrounded by people that superficially look like them and belong to the same "group", and the arrival of anyone from an "outgroup" (who isn't a tourist or trader) causes distress to them. They can be taught/raised to feel different but most people who grew up in relatively homogenous societies never had to do that by the time it's too late.
Not only are there people like that, but also those who don't have a problem with "others" per se but have seen what happens when "others" increase in numbers. The aforementioned people are going to be afraid, angry, and then vote right wing governments into power which means life gets worse for EVERYONE who isn't rich.

Sure it would be great if this deeply rooted aspect of humanity which fuels bigotry and racism worldwide did not exist and everyone could get along fine, but let's go back to reality for a second.
 

signal

Member
Oct 28, 2017
27,958
Does the UN or some organization move refugees or did they themselves make their way from Yemen all the way to South Korea?
 

gozu

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,133
America
South Korea is quite delicious, especially if you like meat, but they are quite socially backward compared to US/EU/AUS. I cringed watching some of their TV shows.

What saddens me is how strong the negative attitude towards muslims is. That's some serious low-key racism right there. The kind that part of Bill Maher's "liberal" audience applauds.

Why not do some research for yourself and make up your own mind on whether or not you feel like its a good idea to visit a foreign country?
Asking questions on a forum is a perfectly valid part of research. In fact, future people researching the topic might read answers to his question and decide based on those.

I am not black and I have not been to SK before.
I'm sure your intentions were good but I would have just stayed silent if I didn't have knowledge to contribute :)
 

travisbickle

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,817
Koreans love a protest, you can get a photo of them protesting anything. Even on New Year's eve there was a small group of protesters near the town hall wanting the release of Park Gun Hye, the previous president. But you usually get larger groups protesting outside Samsung/Hyundae about wages/monopoly power, or protesting about rising University costs. And Conservative protesters are pretty pissed Moon Jae In is president, he's practically a communist to them.

Main thing now is that the government (who aren't really that left-wing) do the right thing.
 

Myradeer

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,424
Canada
What a weird thing to say. This is South Korea.
Sorry for not being clear. They do have foreign workers demographic of course, but they really do not have multicultural culture. I am just pointing out that the country is really super homogeneous and "western liberal ideas" does not really apply to them: like how China doubts democracy, single-race countries like SK doubt benefits of multiculturalism.
 

Heshinsi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,991
Turkey is. Erdogan is planning to receive hundreds of thousands yemeni refugees by the end of the year. Currently there are approximately 7 million illegals in Turkey, 4 million of them alone are from Syria.

And this country literally had no money left and in serious recession.
Turkey are pretty damn selective as to what Muslims they tolerate. Their own Kurdish Muslim population? They’ll wholeheartedly commit ethnic cleansing on.
 

Deleted member 22354

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
250
So as a wealthy -- but black -- guy, should I or should I not remove South Korea from my list of places to visit.

I'm not interested in going anywhere that will likely treat me like shit.
Pretty selfish to go on a thread about people fleeing war and terror and who get discriminated against, just to ask the question "Yeah but what about ME and MY problems though?"
 

yogurt

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,768
...which is being supported by the US and the west. Yemen in particular.

Also current Iranian government and the current Saudi government were installed by the US. Read up on the Iranian revolution and the Saudi king assassination. The west was involved in both of these.
Not quite. The current Iranian government came into power after Iranian citizens overthrew the government of the Shah, who was installed by the US. They promised the Iranian people a representative democracy and instead installed a theocracy. The current Iranian government is vehemently anti-US.

Also, it seems that a lot of US-centric ERA posters would be surprised how xenophobic and racist some culturally homogenous nations are. We see a lot of racist behavior and rhetoric in the US because we're such a diverse nation, so those who feel xenophobic actually have to confront folks who aren't like them. Even with that vocal ~40% of the country, though, our attitudes towards immigration and race are, on the whole, less regressive than many, many other nations.

That's not to say that we live in racial harmony - we obviously don't. But having traveled to a few culturally homogenous countries and talking to friends who've traveled to others, the things that people just casually say openly - even urban, well educated people - blew me away.

Here are some sources to consider:
A study of American and European attitudes towards immigrants
Stats on Americans' views towards immigrants
A comparison of racial tolerance around the world
 

9-Volt

Member
Oct 27, 2017
10,648
Turkey are pretty damn selective as to what Muslims they tolerate. Their own Kurdish Muslim population? They’ll wholeheartedly commit ethnic cleansing on.
Of course an asshole like Erdogan has not-so-good intentions for receiving refugees. He'll screw them as soon as he gets what he needs. Two things he wants: votes and their language. He's been doing everything to reverse Atatürks language and alphabet reforms since he came to power. Reverting back to the Arabic script is a wet dream for him, now the country has 4+ million Arabic speakers, that dream is much closer to becoming a reality.