• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Oct 25, 2017
41,368
Miami, FL
Let's ignore the callous disregard for people with addictions issues here. Gambling, around the word, is a highly regulated industry because of the predatory nature. The shit that EA and other major developers pull would straight up be considered illegal if a casino or lottery was doing it. Tbh, it probably is illegal - just no ones gone after them yet.

Things like advertising to kids, not disclosing odds, etc.
goddamn that was one callus post you replied to. Holy shit at the abject lack of empathy.
 

ShadowAUS

Member
Feb 20, 2019
2,109
Australia
goddamn that was one callus post you replied to. Holy shit at the abject lack of empathy.
You can tell the people who are fortunate enough to never have had to deal with severe addiction issues either personally or in their family. If they had they would know just how fucking debilitating it is and how asinine, if not just plain insulting "just seek help" is. The complete lack of empathy is astounding.
 

ImaLawy3r

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Jun 6, 2019
619
Let's ignore the callous disregard for people with addictions issues here. Gambling, around the word, is a highly regulated industry because of the predatory nature. The shit that EA and other major developers pull would straight up be considered illegal if a casino or lottery was doing it. Tbh, it probably is illegal - just no ones gone after them yet.

Things like advertising to kids, not disclosing odds, etc.

Usually I don't argue this side of things and perhaps side of the argument relating to kids got the better of me. Addiction is tough and a disease - I understand it well enough so my hardened tone on Adults is a little misaligned here. Having said that - advertising to kids has been a thing going on forever, but adults need to step in and engage with kids about these tactics.

If a few developers are trying to make a buck with MTX but the advertising is so wide it casts children in its net are we going to blame the developers? Maybe. If a few developers are trying to prey on kids by specifically advertising to them are we going to blame them? Perhaps. But seriously, where are the parents? Are we seriously raising our kids today without this conversation? Do we blame Walmart when our kids want all the F'n candy on the lines? Do we blame Mc'D or their happy meals? Do we blame Mr. Softy Ice Cream Trucks. Come on.

Also, looking into Apex's loot box situation doesn't even warrant this type of response. It's either you buy it or you don't. Lock down these consoles and ensure kids aren't spending your money. And if they do - talk to them. It's seriously this simple.
 

Merv

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,460
Let's ignore the callous disregard for people with addictions issues here. Gambling, around the word, is a highly regulated industry because of the predatory nature. The shit that EA and other major developers pull would straight up be considered illegal if a casino or lottery was doing it. Tbh, it probably is illegal - just no ones gone after them yet.

Things like advertising to kids, not disclosing odds, etc.

Yup.

The only F2P game I play regularly is Rocket League. The system there is ok. I liked it better when you got decryptors during events. That way you could use them to open the crates you already have to try for items you want. Now you can only open crates for the current event.

I have spent very little, but I would rather pay straight up for what I want.
 

alexiswrite

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,418
Ok, Lets just ignore that f2p actually hire economists and psychologists to implement mechanics that are easy, addictive and yes predatory.

I'm not ignoring anything, you bring up examples that are nothing like in-game purchases. And we have seen excesses with kids buying in game gear and it's on a fucking other level than hiding a fucking gundamn doll. I'm actually getting rather annoyed because you keep denying this while we seen it over and over. Parental controls aren't there because these things are fucking safe. And even that's not enough! It's the combination of everything I mentioned, AT THE SAME TIME, while also being able to directly act on impulses. I fucking studied this stuff, it's not a joke, it's not fun, and it's not sustainable.

The games industry needs to grow the fuck up and take some damn responsibility.

Every large company who sells anything spends a lot of money on advertising for that thing, advertising which tends to exploit ways in which we think. The point where it becomes bad to me, is when it becomes legit gambling. Simply putting a digital item up for sale and having people buy that shit isn't gambling, and isn't bad at all.

It's super easy to create blocks which stop kids buying things with stolen cards. I advocate for that. I don't know why that's ignored as a way to solve the real problems you and many other people point out.

Just because a child has the opportunity to do something bad with something, that doesn't mean we should eliminate that thing. It means we should childproof that thing, which again, is really fucking easy.
 

Tawpgun

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
9,861
I think my main issue with all this is when gamers (rightfully) denounce lootboxes...

but then complain about prices on direct purchases.
 
Sep 14, 2018
4,624
I think my main issue with all this is when gamers (rightfully) denounce lootboxes...

but then complain about prices on direct purchases.

You mean the prices that are set high specifically to encourage buying loot boxes instead? The economy is connected, if loot boxes are available everything is warped around them.

Those damn gamers and their complaining are what ruins everything, no insidious monetization schemes here!

It's super easy to create blocks which stop kids buying things with stolen cards. I advocate for that. I don't know why that's ignored as a way to solve the real problems you and many other people point out.

Here's why it's ignored: it's nonsense, not a solution to anything.

Out of the many stories of parents finding out their children took their credit cards for mtx, they usually had in common that the parents were not aware of the situation, how then are you expecting "blocks" to solve the problem that people aren't even aware of until after they can't do anything about it?

You and the attempted defenses of respawn here just look to blame literally anything but the devs, the kids are stupid, the parents are stupid, people ringing the alarm are stupid (and justify abuse of developers).

You know, maybe the problem is aggresive, predatory monetization models that look to exploit vulnerable people, such as those employed by EA, how's that sound? Am I getting warm?

Here's a real solution:

 
Last edited:

Tawpgun

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
9,861
You mean the prices that are set high specifically to encourage buying loot boxes instead? The economy is connected, if loot boxes are available everything is warped around them.

Those damn gamers and their complaining are what ruins everything, no insidious monetization schemes here!

idk to me it seems fine. My only complaint is I have to buy apex coins. Its nice having a choice between trying my luck at a lootbox to see what I'll get or just paying extra to directly get it.

spending money on any of this shit is stupid anway.
 

alexiswrite

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,418
You mean the prices that are set high specifically to encourage buying loot boxes instead? The economy is connected, if loot boxes are available everything is warped around them.

Those damn gamers and their complaining are what ruins everything, no insidious monetization schemes here!



Here's why it's ignored: it's nonsense, not a solution to anything.

Out of the many stories of parents finding out their children took their credit cards for mtx, they usually had in common that the parents were not aware of the situation, how then are you expecting "blocks" to solve the problem that people aren't even aware of until after they can't do anything about it?

You and the attempted defenses of respawn here just look to blame literally anything but the devs, the kids are stupid, the parents are stupid, people ringing the alarm are stupid (and justify abuse of developers).

You know, maybe the problem is aggresive, predatory monetization models that look to exploit vulnerable people, such as those employed by EA, how's that sound? Am I getting warm?

Do you honestly think I'm talking about manual blocks set up by parents after the fact and not the masses of automated card payment restrictions which already exist?!
 
Sep 14, 2018
4,624
Do you honestly think I'm talking about manual blocks set up by parents after the fact and not the masses of automated card payment restrictions which already exist?!

So the actual root of the problem is not what needs a solution, it's the intended effects of it, I see. What an interesting approach, I wonder how this is all even an issue then.
 

alexiswrite

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,418
So the actual root of the problem is not what needs a solution, it's the intended effects of it, I see. What an interesting approach, I wonder how this is all even an issue then.

What do you mean by the root of the problem? Do you mean Lootboxes or pay to win mtrx? I already think they should go. I'm saying that cosmetic items aren't inherently bad because they're expensive. Of course, there are scenarios where it can be bad, and we should stop those, and I've already pointed out how we can do that.
 
Sep 14, 2018
4,624
What do you mean by the root of the problem? Do you mean Lootboxes or pay to win mtrx? I already think they should go. I'm saying that cosmetic items aren't inherently bad because they're expensive. Of course, there are scenarios where it can be bad, and we should stop those, and I've already pointed out how we can do that.

Then what are you arguing with me for? I replied to tell you that "blocks" are not an answer because the only real solution is to stop the practice dead in it's tracks with legislation, unless you think the industry can regulate itself, which you know, would never happen unless they were threatened with legislation anyway.
 

Jarhab

Alt account
Banned
Jul 26, 2019
189
It is NOT the same.

There isn't a systematic oppression towards gamers like there is towards black people.

Someone saying gamers are trash is not going to make it the lives of gamers harder.

So don't go there.

Okay. How about offensive generalizations towards Asian people who are in no way systemically oppressed in the U.S? Are those okay?

The fact that you consider certain offensive generalizations to be acceptable is... odd. How about we just refrain from making offensive generalizations at all?
 

Jarhab

Alt account
Banned
Jul 26, 2019
189
I'm not agreeing with something offensive. I'm saying I'm not a part of the discussion so why would I even find it offensive. I'm white. I'm male. I'm a gamer. But I'm still going to criticize men. White folk and gamers in general terms. It dilutes the entire argument if you start with the #notallmen style garbage imo. The only gamers offended by people saying "gamers are trash" are the trash gamers. Most normal level headed gamer folk understand that that sentiment isn't aimed at them. But they also understand that it is a dumpster fire community.

I think it's pretty absurd to criticize men, white people and gamers in general terms because we're talking about millions of people here. Your opinion is based on the vocal minority that shout the loudest on the internet. That's maybe 1% of the actual demographic you're broadly criticizing. But hey, you do you. Who needs statistical evidence anyway?