There are parts I like better than what we got in TRoS, but there is one massive thing that makes me glad this was never made:
Ben being "unredeemable" and dying a villain. Fuck that.
That's exactly what I wanted.
There are parts I like better than what we got in TRoS, but there is one massive thing that makes me glad this was never made:
Ben being "unredeemable" and dying a villain. Fuck that.
I'm quite open minded, redeem him, kill him, exile him, whatever but I'd rather have no shit where he gets his big romantic moment after psychologically abusing Rey in the TLJ "You had no place in this story, you're nobody, but not to me" that was some nasty predatory shit, and Rey is like "I wanted Ben's hand" that's like "it's not him, it was the drink." rather fucked up writing IMO. Vader did some horrible things but this felt more personal and realistic.There are parts I like better than what we got in TRoS, but there is one massive thing that makes me glad this was never made:
Ben being "unredeemable" and dying a villain. Fuck that.
I'm quite open minded, redeem him, kill him, exile him, whatever but I'd rather have no shit where he gets his big romantic moment after psychologically abusing Rey in the TLJ "You had no place in this story, you're nobody, but not to me" that was some nasty predatory shit, and Rey is like "I wanted Ben's hand" that's like "it's not him, it was the drink." rather fucked up writing IMO. Vader did some horrible things but this felt more personal and realistic.
I'm quite open minded, redeem him, kill him, exile him, whatever but I'd rather have no shit where he gets his big romantic moment after psychologically abusing Rey in the TLJ "You had no place in this story, you're nobody, but not to me" that was some nasty predatory shit, and Rey is like "I wanted Ben's hand" that's like "it's not him, it was the drink." rather fucked up writing IMO. Vader did some horrible things but this felt more personal and realistic.
My guess is because Rey kissed him... it was her choice, and it would avoid unfortunate implications, but I think the audince, except from hardcore shippers, would have preferred if Rey just told him to fuck off with his crush, and I think that's what RJ was trying to do, when the dice dissapeared from his hand, and she closes the millennium falcon door on him (I think was a nod to the godfather ending but could be wrong)
I've seen all these movies except the prequel and I have no idea what this "Rule of Two" is that I keep seeing mentioned in these threads.
For me a big difference is how when Vader dies, he looks so weak and kind of pathectic underneath the mask, other people run past him like he's nothing, whereas Kylo is literally romanticised and I think there's something not quite right about two men writing how our heroine Rey should reward her abuser with a make out session.Remember that in TROS, Rey is in love with a mass-murderer and makes out with him.
It did. Kylo redemption was a mandate.I wonder if the lack of Kylo redemption played a big part in him getting fired
the fact that it doesnt start with THE DEAK SPEAK makes it infinitely better than TROS
It's not her fault that Kylo looks and sounds exactly like Adam Driver.Remember that in TROS, Rey is in love with a mass-murderer and makes out with him.
Now we just need the Jack Thorne version (the one where Rey was the daughter of the Organa family housekeeper) and the George version (with Whills and midichlorians).
Looking like Adam Driver should be a massive turn-off, not a turn-on.It's not her fault that Kylo looks and sounds exactly like Adam Driver.
AgreedForce Ghosts being used as a means of Terrorizing people would completely destroy what the whole concept of Force Ghosts are. They aren't there so you can be an asshole to someone you want to torment. Force Ghosts exist to pass on Knowledge and in Lucas's case to keep the Order alive even if the last Jedi dies because select few Jedi were enlightened enough to transcend death and be able to pass on knowledge.
People cheer stuff like this on then complain Palaptine ruined the chosen one prophecy or other crap