• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

timeforsana

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,219
Isn't Cap actually going into a different timeline though? Rather than simply going back in time in his timeline? Meaning that Cap could have done a bunch of stuff in a different timeline we don't even know about, lived out his life there and then jumped back into his timeline when he was supposed to return.

And I assume the same can be said for all of the other jumps they do to collect the infinity stones. They're hopping through timelines pinching infinity stones to bring back into their own timeline?
 

Alexandros

Member
Oct 26, 2017
17,812
Isn't Cap actually going into a different timeline though? Rather than simply going back in time in his timeline? Meaning that Cap could have done a bunch of stuff in a different timeline we don't even know about, lived out his life there and then jumped back into his timeline when he was supposed to return.

And I assume the same can be said for all of the other jumps they do to collect the infinity stones. They're hopping through timelines pinching infinity stones to bring back into their own timeline?

Maybe, but to answer that definitively we would have to know if the quantum equipment that the Avengers use enable time travel in the main MCU reality or reality hopping. Both are definitely plausible.
 

Yerffej

Prophet of Regret
Member
Oct 25, 2017
23,557
It's funny, after the dumpster fire of season 4 on BBC, I look back on RDJ's first Holmes movie much more fondly, though I still think they dropped the ball with the 2nd one kind of.
It doesn't flow as well as the first but I still love it. I was watching the first on Netflix and didn't know they dubbed in Jared Harris' voice for the Moriarty scenes. I liked that. Less sinister but in line with what was to come, obviously.
 

EroticSushi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,988
Isn't Cap actually going into a different timeline though? Rather than simply going back in time in his timeline? Meaning that Cap could have done a bunch of stuff in a different timeline we don't even know about, lived out his life there and then jumped back into his timeline when he was supposed to return.

And I assume the same can be said for all of the other jumps they do to collect the infinity stones. They're hopping through timelines pinching infinity stones to bring back into their own timeline?
You are correct.

They established earlier on that whatever they do in the past doesn't effect the "main" MCU timeline. Those just branch off into new timelines. Meaning Cap could have gone back, been with Peggy, stopped 9/11 and Hydra taking over for all we know.

He would just be creating alternate timelines where those things didn't happen. He then came back to the main timeline when he was suppose to.

He pretty much just went back to get those 70 normal years that he lost with Peggy had he not been frozen, without messing with the main timeline continuity.
 
Oct 25, 2017
610
You are correct.

They established earlier on that whatever they do in the past doesn't effect the "main" MCU timeline. Those just branch off into new timelines. Meaning Cap could have gone back, been with Peggy, stopped 9/11 and Hydra taking over for all we know.

He would just be creating alternate timelines where those things didn't happen. He then came back to the main timeline when he was suppose to.

He pretty much just went back to get those 70 normal years that he lost with Peggy had he not been frozen, without messing with the main timeline continuity.

Trying to wrap my head around this.

So they're basically, in a very convoluted way, introducing the idea of Earth 616 (not by name, obvs) being the MCU timeline, but that there are others?

Also, what happens with Peter at the end? Does he go back to school, and everyone's in college except him? Does he go back in time?
 

EroticSushi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,988
Trying to wrap my head around this.

So they're basically, in a very convoluted way, introducing the idea of Earth 616 (not by name, obvs) being the MCU timeline, but that there are others?

Also, what happens with Peter at the end? Does he go back to school, and everyone's in college except him? Does he go back in time?
That's how I'm viewing this whole thing. The main MCU timeline is essentially Earth 616 and all these other timelines would be other "Earths" like in the comics. For example Nebula kills one of her past self but her "616" present version is fine because her killing the "past" version only messes with another timeline, one where that "past" version is now dead.

Not sure on Peter and how FFH works since Fiege has said it takes moments after End Game?
 
Fully understanding how the time travel works puts a completely different spin on Cap's ending, really.

As many have said there's no way that Cap would sit on the sidelines while evil was at work, and this way, there's no reason to assume he ever did. If anything Cap is armed with a ridiculous amount of knowledge on who is up to dirty deeds.

Of course there's an interesting question as to the fate of Steve Rogers in the universe Cap retired to. Perhaps he is frozen in ice. Maybe he died fighting Red Skull. All that's required is there was a Captain America in WW2 and Peggy Carter met him at that time.

In the future they could have it that our Cap made that world a better place with foreknowledge the other Rogers would one day be rescued. And at that time he stepped aside to retire as Old Steve, knowing a Cap would be there and that world's Peggy got to know it would all be okay in the end.
 

BWoog

Member
Oct 27, 2017
38,280
I would be remiss not to mention how amazing of an actor Tom Holland is. Him losing it at Tony's death and then his face during his funeral, where you can 100% see that Peter blames himself, is some hard hitting stuff.
 
Oct 25, 2017
610
I would be remiss not to mention how amazing of an actor Tom Holland is. Him losing it at Tony's death and then his face during his funeral, where you can 100% see that Peter blames himself, is some hard hitting stuff.

Ugh, I cannot wait to see this. They don't frame it as an echo of Uncle Ben, do they?

How do they handle his return to school? Is everyone older, or do they leave that whole re-set for FFH?
 

BWoog

Member
Oct 27, 2017
38,280
Ugh, I cannot wait to see this. They don't frame it as an echo of Uncle Ben, do they?

How do they handle his return to school? Is everyone older, or do they leave that whole re-set for FFH?

Nope, no Uncle Ben.

Peter returns to school and everything is normal which was kind of weird honestly. I guess all the people important to the Spidey franchise also died from the snap and everyone who didn't just aged out due to the five years? It will be weird if they don't address this in Far From Home.
 

Spocker

Member
Oct 27, 2017
14
I like that they actually confirmed that the TV shows are canon (atleast Agent Carter), by including James D'Arcy as Edwin Jarvis
 

Seraphic

Member
Oct 29, 2017
130
Could anyone explain why Thanos of the present timeline is one shotted by Thor but the Thanos of the past timeline is able to fight Thor/CaptA etc on equal footing?
 

Lukemia SL

Member
Jan 30, 2018
9,384
I see. But I thought the axe wound was healed?
Looks like it was at the end of the movie and when he flashes back to see child Gamora. Thanos even sees the wound is gone when he checks for it.

In the Soul Stone's dream state he went to, is where he checked both his hand (which had no gauntlet) and chest. When he came back into the real world he was cooked.
 

EdReedFan20

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,998
With Cap in the past, I wonder if he sees a lot of Tony growing up, as he was friends with Howard. Also, knowing what he knows, does he try to weed out Hydra from SSR/S.H.I.E.L.D.? And knowing Bucky is in his early days as the Winter Soldier, does he try to save him then. I would assume this would all have to be done in an alternate timeline.

Also, loved the bit with Thor, Korg, and Miek playing Fortnite. Though, I would've loved it if they were instead playing God of War and messing around with the axe.
 
Last edited:

BlueRose

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,389
I like that they actually confirmed that the TV shows are canon (atleast Agent Carter), by including James D'Arcy as Edwin Jarvis
I don't think Agent Carter's status as canon means much for the many other Marvel television series. The Disney+ series aside, everything else can now be relegated to one of the many alternate timelines.
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 30411

User-requested account closure
Banned
Nov 3, 2017
1,516
aight nevermind then. I thought you were commenting about it because you'd changed it specifically because of seeing the film and either way, it comes off as a bit backseat moddy of me to say anything. Hopefully it brings you no flak and yeah, it is cool.
 

Lukemia SL

Member
Jan 30, 2018
9,384
aight nevermind then. I thought you were commenting about it because you'd changed it specifically because of seeing the film and either way, it comes off as a bit backseat moddy of me to say anything. Hopefully it brings you no flak and yeah, it is cool.

It's okay, I understand your point of view on the matter. If mods think it is spoilery at all then I'll change it. I've had it since after the first Endgame trailer.
 

MrMephistoX

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
2,754
I don't expect another Avengers for like 5 years at least

I don't know where they go from here

I think next obvious move is the lady Avengers and Gwyneth team up with Captain Marvel given the reaction in my theater on both showings.

I'd kind of like to see X-men and FF get integrated sooner rather than later or maybe we get more solo Cap/Makie and Gweneth Iron Maiden films...technically if the box office starts to tank I guess they could do something convoluted with time travel to get RDJ and Tony back from the past for one final mission?
 

Caz

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
13,055
Canada
I don't expect another Avengers for like 5 years at least

I don't know where they go from here
Assuming Marvel keeps on good terms with Sony, they could do a Secret Wars film, something involving Galactus and the Silver Surfer or barring that...
19246412320_d3ba47101d_b.jpg

Of course, the latter assumes they've already planned out the roadmap for the MCU to lead to Doom after only recently reacquiring the character from the Fox merger as does the former given how prominent the X-Men are in the original Secret Wars.
 

ginger ninja

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,060
So Marvel has begun privately screening the first 20-30 minutes or so of this film to select groups of people in my area. Most of what they've shown to anyone was in house or to critics until recently. I won't say more than that other than I personally know someone who was selected that was able to get me in there as well. This is way too long to post in here but whatever. Yes, I took notes. Here goes.

The movie opens to the harsh continuous beep of an emergency broadcast over the Marvel Studios logo. Same one from the Antman and the Wasp post credits scene reading "THIS IS NOT A TEST. THERE IS A STATE OF EMERGENCY IN EFFECT. PLEASE STAND BY FOR FURTHER INSTRUCTIONS." Whole screen is a shot of that for a few seconds. Cut to the Barton farm. Clint is away from the family picnic teaching his daughter some archery. He jokes that the 30th time is the charm, to stay steady and not even think about it. She nails the center of the target. He and his daughter have a funny back and forth about who the better archer will be when she gets a better trainer. Clint turns his back to her for a moment expecting a response to his quip.

He turns back around and she isn't there. Clint looks amused for a second. He calls out her name, looks behind the tree. Nothing. He quickly begins to panic, asking his wife if she's seen her, that she was just with him. Laura has no clue. They frantically search around the house to no avail. Clint turns to see his two younger sons reduced to ash in front of him. Clint runs out of the room to Laura who also slowly turns to ash in his arms. Clint, in utter shock, walks into the living room where the tv is blaring the aforementioned emergency broadcast. "THIS IS NOT A TEST."

Back on Earth, Wakandans mourn their lost loved ones. We get a pretty emotional sequence there. The remaining Avengers gather themselves in the same lab Vision was kept in. Shuri has been dusted obviously. Okoye vows to do whatever she can to help them. Their wounds are attended to. Banner sits in stunned silence as does Rhodey. Rocket holds back tears. Thor groans that he "had him". Cap responds that it's no one's fault and that they have to get back home, regroup, and try to find whoever's left. That they can still help. Natasha ponders what they could've done differently, to which Rhodey responds "it doesn't matter now, we lost". Thor also mentions that while he regrets not going for the kill, he still managed to hurt Thanos badly. Bruce is given all the information Shuri collected on Vision and the mind stone before they head out, but it's said to be encrypted.

Cut to Tony and Pepper in a massive church standing in front of each other on the alter in full wedding getup. This entire scene plays very dreamlike, kind of unsettling. All the avengers, including those who were snapped, sit in the pews smiling and conversing. Happy stands behind Pepper with a baby nestled in his arms, who we can only assume is Morgan. The priest reads through the usual vows. Tony smiles and says I do. The Avengers cheer as they turn to ash. Tony looks into the crowd to see Peter die again. Happy and Morgan fade to ash as well. Tony is visibly horrified. Pepper gets dusted before she can say I do as Tony screams and we cut to him waking up from this nightmare in the Benatar, shaken.

Nebula asks if he's ok. He brushes it off and says he just dreamt that they didn't make it back, complains "gosh it's cold in here". Nebula mentions that the heaters stopped working too. Much of the ship was heavily damaged in the battle on Titan. It's also mentioned that the ship can no longer jump travel. Something about missing parts and some coils being burnt to a crisp. Very pseudosciencey as per usual in superhero films. From here, we jump into a relatively fun montage of Tony and Nebula passing the time playing paper football and hard at work repairing the Benatar, played to the tune of Dear Mr. Fantasy. Tony jokes if they could use some of Nebula's parts to "speed this up". Nebula gives Tony some sort of medicinal concoction for an infection he got from the wound in his abdomen.

This is the opening sequence critics got to see last week. I'm assuming the rest was obviously deliberately cut out for those screenings. Some scenes for this screening may have been cut or reshuffled as well.

Tony and Nebula manage to get the heaters back up but fail to restore jump travel. They are quickly running out of food, water and oxygen as mentioned in the trailers. The montage ends as we cut to New York. Desolate. Shots of looters and protesters. A guy holding up a sign of some bible verse while yelling that there is still time to repent. Most of the remaining Avengers are present in the facility, save Thor and Rocket. Bruce studies Fury's pager as they surround him. Natasha mentions it was recovered by police and brought to them, along with some of Fury's other belongings. They had no idea what or who it was for and that it kept turning on and off.

This is the problem Bruce is hoping to fix if they can bypass the battery as mentioned in the mid credits scene for Captain Marvel. He says it'll take him some time. The rest of this scene is a lot of the same stuff we've seen from the trailers. Nat's line about Thanos doing exactly what he said he was gonna do. That he wiped everyone out. And that they have no idea where he could possibly be. It's also mentioned here that they're working under the assumption that Tony is dead. Nat says Clint tried reaching out to her, but has gone ghost since. She is determined to find him. Cap is willing to help while Rhodey thinks it's better that they stick together for now. Bruce yells off-screen "Got it!" Nat quips that that wasn't a lot of time. Bruce says he never said he would need a lot. The signal will stay on for now.

Cut back to Tony as he sits in silence on the floor of the Benatar. He is exhausted and emaciated. This where he records his message to Pepper. Sad as you can imagine. They've been stranded in space for weeks now and he fully expects to die. "When I drift off, I'll dream about you. It's always you Pep." Tony rummages around for clothes, throwing on a red long sleeve. He slumps into the passenger seat of the ship as Nebula walks in. He asks her if she got all that to which she responds "yeah". Tony mentions that it feels weird "stealing" Quill's clothes. He says something along the lines of "I saw him turn into dust. All of them. Plus we never really got along you know". Nebula can relate. They have a funny and endearing heart to heart where Tony thanks her for her help in at least trying.

The last scene of the footage we were shown is basically just the mid credits scene from CM. The signal from the pager finally "craps out" and they turn to see her arrive.

Just saw this on the marvel spoilers sub reddit. What do you guys think?
Lmao so where did this movie disappear.
 

Cuburger

Member
Oct 28, 2017
10,975
How do people feel about having had followed along with the leaks and speculation so closely after having seen the movie?

I tried my best to stay away from all speculation due to the early set leaks and toy leaks basically spilling the beans on the Quantum Realm being used for time travel to the old movies. After getting that much spoiled for me, I decided it was too much and avoided all but the main trailers and I feel great about my decision.

Just from seeing people's reactions to the spoilers (real or not) without much context, spoiling themselves and working themselves into a frenzy of how it sounds like it will suck, I can't imagine it being necessarily a good thing, especially since some seem to claim that it convinced them to want to avoid the movie?