Condemned: Criminal Origins was one of the best early Xbox 360 games, and it's sequel was solid too.
Anecdote: a friend of mine got Condemned (might have been Condemned 2), and was just starting to play it when I came over one day. He insisted it was really scary. Eventually he got tired and passed the controller off to me. I started a new game and discovered that if you don't get a weapon, you kick instead. So I ran around kicking all the enemies to death. At one point, I kicked a dead body down a flight of stairs. There was also a jump scare where a guy jumps out of a hole, and since I had already seen my friend play through that section, I just kicked him in the face when it happened. At the end of the stage, the game tells you your preferred weapon. Mine was BOOT.
The next time I saw met this friend, he told me that he traded in Condemned. The experience had been too funny and he couldn't take the game seriously as a horror game anymore.
Says Silent Hill 2, posts Silent Hill 1 screen.The best horror game ever created is Silent Hill 2. It's honestly not even a contest.
Clock Tower. Fun, short, still gorgeous. The second game is also very good with friends if you want to have a good laugh.
Says Silent Hill 2, posts Silent Hill 1 screen.
Silent Hill is the best horror game imo. It was just so different to every other game that came before it. Truly a masterpiece and a horror classic. The team used sound so well. Never before or since has a game filled me with dread like Silent Hill.