Some of y'all need to learn how to express your opinions without trying to be "correct", or fluffing your chest feathers to try and express a "superior" opinion on a purely subjective topic (or at least be less aggressive about it). All the BioShock games are well received and have their fans and detractors, since all three games are relatively different and have different strengths and weaknesses. Happy it seems people on current consoles will be able to pick the one's they want individually though, to match their taste, forge their own opinions, or pick up whichever ones they didn't own and didn't want to buy them all again.