You can question ppl on their reads/cores and things but dont want to answer when someone questions you on yours and act all pissy?
Yet im on your town core list. Last day phase, well after the cs note thing. You said I was scum. You've already admitted to lying about townreading me for days. Seems like you are more upset im not being scumread than anything else. Why am I the one that you are aiming at? I've stated my case on melon and voted for melon. Why arent you just as frustrated at melon/ab or the others?
cool
Because you are here ffs. Do something. Give out YOUR reads for once. How the fuck am I supposed to read you if all your posts boil down to "look at that: could be both. Oh and btw melon is scum"
CoolestSpot: With how close he was to dying, I figured a scum player (especially a scum x-shot) would use their power or submit the faction kill rather than risk another player.
Sorry, Tracker, yes. I didn't bother to follow Chuggs because I believed his claim (and said so repeatedly). I especially believed it because I was a tracker. A one-shot ninja vs. a tracker isn't much of an off-set. It's one shot and if I don't follow that specific person the ONE time they use their power, the ninja power is wasted. A sleepwalker, otoh, would give a read ANY time I followed that person. Seems like a stronger spanner in the works, so to speak. I was able to believe my results even knowing there was a ninja, because I never followed that player.
Read me however you want. Na, your frustration with me isnt equal to melon or abs. There are also 8 other players you can hound. So have at it.
Yep, which is why I wanted to see his reasoning for choosing the ppl he did. D3 he chose me instead of chuggs who claimed that day iirc.
Nope. You have been scumreading me. So me being on your town core doesnt make sense.
hmm, seems believable.
If you believed chugs claim, why did you have him in your top scum?
At least a couple people up for consideration were on my list, so it made sense to put this out there. I'm also dealing with a bunch of other non-game shit and haven't been able to do as much reading as I should.
I was lying about Chuggernaut. I actually did think I was onto something with Turmoil, so by throwing Chuggs under the bus I bought time (and if Chuggernaut got lynched we saw his flip, so win win in a way). Then Turmoil died and took TheChuggernaut with him and well, here we are.
That doesnt make sense.
It makes perfect sense to lie about scum reading chuggernaut if I'm actually scumreading Turmoil and plan to follow him that night. Which was the plan. Then they both died. There was enough of a train on Turmoil that if he was lynched and flipped scum (like I thought he would), I would follow someone that didn't vote for him. Basically I used Chuggernaut as a shield.
I am right here.
No it doesnt make sense to scumread Chugger because you scumread Turmoil. You couldnt thrown anyone else up there besides the person you leaned town on because you believed his claim. If you died that night and ppl saw you were a tracker they would look at chugger the next day, due to your power and read.
He's going on the theory that if anyone moves its a high chance they are scum.
I mean, the gossip clearly has to choose people. Powers that choose people tend to trigger any sort of motion detector, unless the power explicitly is untrackable like a hider or something.
I figured it was unlikely that I was going to die that night, especially if scum thought I was looking at two town players (since they would have known Turmoil wasn't scum). No plan is perfect. Besides, if I came out and said "I think x other person is scum" without building a case it definitely would have turned heads.
Not quite. It's less "they moved therefore scum" and more "they DIDN'T move and actions still took place, ergo they couldn't cause those actions".
I do yes.
1: Malus made graphs and has been keeping the claim list updated, so "coasting" is weird.
Still the same thing, the moving makes them look scummy. If you believe scum can put scum in the chat, why not check the other chat member tonight?
I wouldnt townread him based on those either. Just busywork. I dont think he has ever given a reads list.
what...
To be honest that's not really saying much (though I am quite proud of the graphs). In conspiracy mafia I took up the mantle of claim list updater specifically to appear to contribute something so I wouldn't read too much into it.
See above.
Ok, good point about CS not moving N1 so couldnt be Chat maker. Im probably just misunderstanding how a tracker works. You track when someone goes to another person? Or any action that person does?
thoughts on his reasoning for putting chuggs in his top scum list? I still dont like it.
