• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Can you afford a $1,000 unexpected expense?

  • Yes - I can cover it with cash

    Votes: 1,962 79.7%
  • No - I'd have to go into debt in order to cover it

    Votes: 500 20.3%

  • Total voters
    2,462

Cosmic Bus

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,013
NY
Still living paycheck to paycheck in my 40s, so anything unexpected (like that $4,000 IRS bill we got not long ago) ruins my life.
 

Ayirek

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,252
I can, and I recognize how fortunate that makes me.
first post nails it. It's the boat I'm in, and it's a very new one. I spent five years as a professional (non games) broadcast journalist earning barely over minimum wage. Before that, I worked part time in group homes and people's private homes, assisting developmentally developed and elderly adults to pay my way through university. Now, after news killed my soul, I am in sales and I earn what I consider offensive levels of money, coming off a job I thought would be meaningful yet failed to pay for a roof over my head.
 

kinoki

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,705
I just did a €600 (emergency) investment in my summer clothing. I had none. It is warm. Didn't even need to tap into savings. Just took it from my salary.
 

Stuggernaut

Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,904
Seattle, WA, USA
20 years ago that level of sudden expense would have been serious "WTF do I do now!??!".

But sudden expenses were a way of life for my family a few years back with lots of medical expenses for my daughter that came on quickly (she is fine now for those curious). Since then, we always make sure never to over spend or over commit our money. I consider myself lucky to be able to maintain a large cash "emergency" fund, and a few high limit credit cards with zero balance in case things get REALLY crazy.

If you can afford to have an emergency fund, I highly recommend it for peace of mind. I would think $1000 would be a minimum, more the better though. Depends on your situation.

I hope people just don't have to worry about stuff like this though. It sucks.
 

Pilgrimzero

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
8,129
Funny this pops up.

Just got a bill in the mail for $1K and no idea how we are going to pay it. Can't even afford the minimum monthly payment (with late charges added) of $300.
 

Stuggernaut

Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,904
Seattle, WA, USA
Yes. That should be step one for most people.
  1. 1,000 emergency fund
  2. Pay off all debts
  3. 3-6 month expenses emergency fund
  4. 15% into retirement (401k/Roth IRA)
  5. save for kid(s) college (if you have kids)
  6. buy/pay off home
  7. give generously and build wealth (investments)

I like that list :)

1. Check
2. 80% check (wife has PHD debt still)
3. Check
4. Check'ish? 401k through work, rest of investments are weak... need to get better.
5. Check - Done and done, daughter got her Masters last year (Proud dad!)
6. Will be paid of in 4 years, can't wait!
7. Always generous where we can be. Working on investments but still learning.

My wife gets worried about investments, so we play it safe and with small amounts. Maybe when house is paid off in a few years we can be more aggressive.
 

Lashes.541

Member
Dec 18, 2017
1,757
Roseburg Oregon
Nope lol. I live off of like 700$ a month. Luckily my medical and dental is paid by the government(until it implodes) I'm really hoping the transmission in my car does not go out or something because then I would be screwed
 

Fall Damage

Member
Oct 31, 2017
2,059
I try to keep enough savings to cover 3 months of expenses so I do have enough in my bank. I also have credit card debt that I'm paying off (no interest). I voted no since I already have debt.
 

cgpartlow

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,005
Seattle, WA
Yes, we currently putting any money we can scrounge up in to paying down our debt, but we have a small emergency fund to cover little things. After we pay off our debt we are going to build a larger emergency fund.
 

Dynamite Cop

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,002
California
Working as a contractor pretty much my whole life, and seeing a lot of layoffs, I've adjusted spending habits to make sure I save money that I can live off of in the event of unexpected expenses. Do not want to go back to living paycheck to paycheck..
 

badboy78660

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,737
Yes. I'm fortunate that I save a ton by being a fairly boring person (i.e. I don't spend much money because I only buy essentials; I'm not into fancy clothes, vacations, etc.), so I have a decent amount in my savings.
 

mxbison

Banned
Jan 14, 2019
2,148
Yes, would still hurt though.

Wife and me are more the "why work if youre not gonna spend it" type.
 
Oct 25, 2017
810
Years ago I thought having $3000 in my checking account was great. I'd never ever let it go below that. Then I went back to school, quit my regular and lived off substitute teaching. Well school didn't quite go as planned as I changed my mind about wanting to teach and so here I was with basically nothing to my name. I struggled hard until I was lucky to find the job I'm at now and work my way up. I now feel sick if my emergency fund dips below $10,000

I realize how fortunate I am, but I also never had children (38 years old) so I also know how much that has factored into this.
 

Deleted member 25600

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 29, 2017
5,701
My wife and I make sure we have a buffer of several thousand dollars separate from our actual spending and saving accounts. It takes a while to replenish it once it has been depleted, but it's very reassuring to have.
 

Minx

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
1,229
Illinois
Still living paycheck to paycheck in my 40s, so anything unexpected (like that $4,000 IRS bill we got not long ago) ruins my life.
Genuinely curious how at that age you are paycheck to paycheck. I understand a lot of people are like this but just wondering what obstacles in life got in the way. Do you spend a lot of money? I have friends with combined income of over 150k that live paycheck to paycheck because they buy unnecessary things. Do you have any money saved from retirement. No judging just trying to get some perspective.
 

Neverfade

Member
Oct 25, 2017
715
"such as an emergency room visit"

$1000 ER visit here in America is like.... going to the hospital to get a Motrin for a stubbed toe?

I got a huge glass shard through my hand several years ago late at night and had to get two stitches and it was $2400+
 

Orioto

Member
Oct 26, 2017
4,716
Paris
I'm in that weird situation where i'm not making a lot with my art but as i can't pay for a full place to live, having a roomate, i'm not spending a lot, so i get extra money every month easily. 1000$ sudden expense would be fine.
 

Deleted member 29249

User requested account closure
Banned
Nov 1, 2017
3,634
Try to have a slush fund of about 10k to cover anything (car repairs, home repairs etc) at worst I have a CRedit card with high limit and zero balance if I have to float a bill for a while.
 

DanteMenethil

Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,058
Years ago I thought having $3000 in my checking account was great. I'd never ever let it go below that. Then I went back to school, quit my regular and lived off substitute teaching. Well school didn't quite go as planned as I changed my mind about wanting to teach and so here I was with basically nothing to my name. I struggled hard until I was lucky to find the job I'm at now and work my way up. I now feel sick if my emergency fund dips below $10,000

I realize how fortunate I am, but I also never had children (38 years old) so I also know how much that has factored into this.

Having that much money in a checking account is a bad idea, you're withering the value of it because of inflation.
 

ResetGreyWolf

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,427
I make about $2,400 monthly. $1,390 on average in expenses, so $1000 would be about a month worth of savings for me. That said, I'm in deep debt both from studying and buying an apartment.
 

Dingens

Circumventing ban with an alt account
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
2,018
I probably could, which is somewhat ironic, given that I can't think of a single scenario that would require such a sum
 

Deleted member 45211

User requested account closure
Banned
Jun 19, 2018
492
Afford is a weird term. I can't afford buying a take-out salad for lunch but catch me getting extra avocado at Chopt.
 

Cosmic Bus

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,013
NY
Genuinely curious how at that age you are paycheck to paycheck. I understand a lot of people are like this but just wondering what obstacles in life got in the way. Do you spend a lot of money? I have friends with combined income of over 150k that live paycheck to paycheck because they buy unnecessary things. Do you have any money saved from retirement. No judging just trying to get some perspective.

Didn't know what to do with my life, so I worked in retail until I was 30 before finally going to culinary school. Been a pastry chef for ten years, but surprise!, it's a super shitty line of work that pays like garbage and destroys your body. Gonna be 41 soon, and can't figure out how to change to a better career when I have neither the time nor money to do so.
 

nded

Member
Nov 14, 2017
10,576
I'm a boring guy with no dependents, so for now I've got some money squirreled away.
 

stone616

Banned
Oct 29, 2017
1,429
My savings budget is about to go down to about $1000 a month so If I encountered such an expense I'd charge it to a credit card and just divert my money savings / investing budget money to it for the month. I don't have that much liquid cash most of my money is in investments.

Not being able to afford a $1000 expense is no way to live. I can remember when I was living so tight and I'd just moved into an apartment that when the toilet clogged I had to take my last few dollars and buy a plunger to unclog it. Still have that plunger to this day but buying it I thought to myself never again will I live like this and I haven't.

It doesn't really matter what you make. You need to figure out how to live below your means so that there's money left over.
 

Deleted member 4247

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
8,896
How do we define afford? Meaning, if I have to go and put it on a credit card or take money from line of credit then I could't afford it? What if you are already in debt (especially unsecured) which is far more than you can "afford" so to speak and the 1000$ emergency falls on top of that, does it change the definition? If you have $1000 on your account that you weren't putting towards your debt, does that count as money that could go towards the emergency making you able to "afford" it or does the fact that you didn't put it towards your big debt elsewhere an indication that you couldn't afford it even though you had the necessary amount in your account that you weren't using towards the debt?

If you take into account someone with zero access to any sort of credit, then you still run into the limitation of the possibility of being able to "afford" the emergency and then being broke (say if you are unemployed or underemployed) after that or being able to "afford" it and then not being able to afford future emergencies (especially if they come back-to-back).

In the realm of fiat currency and debt as well as artificial pricing of capitalism, there has to be more information known before we can answer that question.

I basically read it as "can you cover it without it causing you any further debt?".

Which I could, since I have the money, but generally not in a liquid state, so I would have to use my credit card to cover it while I liquidate some savings. I would then pay off the credit card in full (as always), so it would cost me zero in interest or fees.

I do have a mortgage though, so if I count that I guess I can't cover ANYTHING (since it's money that could be going to paying it off). But my net worth (assets minus debts) is higher than $1000, so... yes?
 

stone616

Banned
Oct 29, 2017
1,429
Yeah, his personal/political views are shit (raaa socialists, etc.) but his financial advice is generally sound
His financial advice is more for people who lack self control or understanding when it comes to money. Debt can be useful if you can handle it and I use credit cards for all purchases so I can earn cash back on them.

He says silly stuff at times though like "You wouldn't take a paid off house and borrow money against it to invest. That's the same thing as not paying off your mortgage as quickly as you can and using that money to invest."

No that's not the same thing because If I was living in a paid off house right now almost all my income would be free to invest or do whatever with so there wouldn't be much of a point to borrow against the house.

Dave's advice is colored with his own experience mismanaging debt.
 

Isilia

Member
Mar 11, 2019
5,807
US: PA
When I lost my job and was left disabled, I had to wait over 2 years to get my financial situation in order. I thought I was more than prepared. I had a retirement plan to leech off of, a wedding fund, and just leftover cash. It still didn't cover everything I needed while the government and insurance companies fought to see if I actually was worth giving money for assistance and accident claims. I still haven't received anything, but I have been accepted into disability and will start seeing something next month.

$1000 is probably the bare minimum of an emergency expense nowadays sadly. Two days in the hospital was $10k. Two. My meds without my insurance would be over that a month. It's pretty insane.

I made it through in the end, but there were plenty of times I thought I would have to give up everything I worked for just to survive with the bare essentials. I would implore people to save as much as they possibly can, and, if you are better off like I was, send money to places for people who need that help drastically.
 

SweetNicole

The Old Guard
Member
Oct 24, 2017
6,542
His financial advice is more for people who lack self control or understanding when it comes to money. Debt can be useful if you can handle it and I use credit cards for all purchases so I can earn cash back on them.

He says silly stuff at times though like "You wouldn't take a paid off house and borrow money against it to invest. That's the same thing as not paying off your mortgage as quickly as you can and using that money to invest."

No that's not the same thing because If I was living in a paid off house right now almost all my income would be free to invest or do whatever with so there wouldn't be much of a point to borrow against the house.

Dave's advice is colored with his own experience mismanaging debt.

Sure. I don't think there's anything wrong with using credit cards and then paying them at the end of each month assuming you have the self-control and proper budgeting for it. His own experience of ruining himself with credit card debt certainly factors in his advice, but I don't think he is entirely off the mark. Most people, to be honest, lack the self-control with their finances and budgeting to be able to use something like a credit card appropriately. Yes, there's people who can use them responsibly, but the vast majority can't, so it makes more sense to tailor the advice towards the majority. Everyone wants to think they're special, and if you tel people there's a special case where if you're smart enough, wise enough, etc that you can make it work, everyone will think they're that person and try to make it work even if they aren't.

His big thing is people having a paid-off house. I agree with you that it isn't a fair comparison, but I'd still suggest paying off a house before doing something like investing in a real estate deal, etc.