• Introducing Image Options for ResetEra 2.0! Check the left side navigation bar to show or hide images, avatars, covers, and embedded media. More details at the link.

Dark Phoenix Tracking For Record Low X-Men Franchise Opening ( Below The Wolverine)

Oct 25, 2017
2,139
Richmond, VA
#53
It just might be worse than X3. It’s crazy to think.

Still, Fox has two of the best films in the genre and one of the only three “masterpiece films” in all of comic book cinema, so there you go. They did alright.

People here talk like they churned out nothing but pure shit and it’s pretty fucking baffling.
They never made a good X-Men movie, and by that I mean a movie that did justice to the source material. Logan is a Wolverine movie. I’m talking about an ensemble movie about the actual X-Men.
 
Oct 29, 2017
1,669
#56
Hopefully Marvel succeed in returning the X-Men franchise to commercial and critical success.

Such a shame after Logan being one of the best superhero flicks made.

Not a massive fan of Deadpool, personally, think it's good but don't love it like some seem to.
 
Oct 27, 2017
2,469
#58
They never made a good X-Men movie, and by that I mean a movie that did justice to the source material. Logan is a Wolverine movie. I’m talking about an ensemble movie about the actual X-Men.
DoFP is an excellent film, as much as it pains me to say such a thing about a Bryan Singer work.

Just because it isn’t a faithful translation of the comic panels doesn’t mean there hasn’t been a good X-Men film.

People literally want an MCU envisioned X-Men film, and they forget that the first couple X-Men and Spider-man films pioneered this shit without needing to be 1:1 adaptations.

People wanted the 90’s era cartoon X-Men in a live action film and that shit just wasn’t ready for prime time. I appreciate what Singer (*shudder*) was going for with a more grounded, “what if” scenario with strong thematic relevance. It worked for several of these films and there have been more hits than misses, in my view.
 
Oct 25, 2017
7,547
#61
Box Office Mojo has the 2000 X-Men opening weekend at $91 million when adjusted for 2019 inflation. But I think Dark Phoenix has a shot to be the first in the X-Men series to not reach $100 million domestic, especially if it ends up being as bad as initial test screenings have said it is.
 
#63
IMO, X1 > X2 > First Class > Logan > Deadpool > Deadpool 2 > DoFP > The Wolverine > Apocalypse > Origins > X3

They've always been my favorite comic, so it's been really rough seeing how much they keep botching it.
And odd that Deadpool did it so much better. (I'm still bitter about Jubilee constantly getting shafted, especially in Apocalypse, when you had this great actress and everything, then... nada.)
 
Oct 30, 2017
3,787
#64
Even 40-50 million still seems high. Nothing about this movie seems remotely entertaining. I've never seen a worse opening to a trailer than Sansa Stark's hamfisted crying "Wha-wha-why did you m-make m-me do that?"

Simple Jack can deliver a line better than that.
 
Oct 25, 2017
9,652
#65
Deadpool though. Granted they had to be forced into doing that.
Which is precisely why I don’t count it.

It’s emblematic of their entire run; they’re out of touch with what fans wanted. Deadpool only works cause they had fuck all to do with it.

It’s like crediting Sony with Homecoming.
 
Nov 15, 2017
3,640
#66
Probably a blessing in disguise for Saoirse Ronan to not get in on this franchise in its dying days.
On this same note, originally the role of Storm was between Zendaya (now MJ in the MCU Spiderman films) and Alexandra Shipp (the current Fox Storm). At the time i'm sure Zendaya was disappointed but I bet she's not anymore.
 
Oct 25, 2017
2,139
Richmond, VA
#69
DoFP is an excellent film, as much as it pains me to say such a thing about a Bryan Singer work.

Just because it isn’t a faithful translation of the comic panels doesn’t mean there hasn’t been a good X-Men film.

People literally want an MCU envisioned X-Men film, and they forget that the first couple X-Men and Spider-man films pioneered this shit without needing to be 1:1 adaptations.

People wanted the 90’s era cartoon X-Men in a live action film and that shit just wasn’t ready for prime time. I appreciate what Singer (*shudder*) was going for with a more grounded, “what if” scenario with strong thematic relevance. It worked for several of these films and there have been more hits than misses, in my view.
Call it whatever you want, it’s not a good X-men movie.

I want one great movie with an actual lineup of X-men that actually respects the characters and source material. Not 100% translation, just basic respect.

A few more years and I’ll get one.
 
OP
OP
Slayven

Slayven

You probably post about me on another board.
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
29,618
#71
On this same note, originally the role of Storm was between Zendaya (now MJ in the MCU Spiderman films) and Alexandra Shipp (the current Fox Storm). At the time i'm sure Zendaya was disappointed but I bet she's not anymore.
I love a good reverse Eric Stoltz/Micheal J Fox story
 
Oct 25, 2017
9,652
#74
I doubt Zendaya would’ve accepted the role of Storm.

It wouldn’t have even been the first time she’s declined to take a role she feels should go to a darker skinned actress.
 
Oct 25, 2017
7,547
#82
If this is tracking low for the franchise, I can only imagine how low New Mutants is going to be tracking. That's probably going to be around $30 million OW at best.

I still consider these to be side-stories. As for me, Fox's X-men ended with Logan.
 
Nov 15, 2017
3,640
#85
Wow. Did not know that.
Apparently, she didn't take the role because it wasn't a "big enough" role.
Fox was interested in casting Zendaya for their young Storm.

Ultimately, it came down to Zendaya feeling like the role wasn't big enough and passed. Audiences gave mixed reviews about Alexandra Shipp, who was ultimately cast in the role. While it was nice to see the '80s punk version of Storm, complete with mohawk, come to life on the screen, the character wasn't given much to do or say, leaving viewers underwhelmed.
https://www.cbr.com/actors-who-were-almost-x-men/
 
Oct 26, 2017
4,328
#90
Yeah, people forget Dark Pheonix and New Mutants were originally suppose to come out last year. They were way fucked before the deal even became a thing
With how much people were speculating New Mutants to go straight to Hulu or something, seems Disney is doing the opposite. Although that may have been out of their hands due to contracts and whatnot.
 
Oct 25, 2017
5,703
#98
I would say I feel sorry for Fox going out so pathetically, but they dug this grave themselves by giving Kinberg total control over the X-Franchise.

It would've been way better if Deadpool 2 was the end of the Fox X-Men universe.
As far as I'm concerned, it was.
Logan would have been such a perfect conclusion.
Definitely not (unless someone resented the Fox universe in its entirety, then wanting that would make more sense to me).