I've been holding off coming into this thread as I wanted to actually have something to say when I did. I'd like to stress that I've never been comfortable being described as an 'insider' but I do have connections and hear loads of industry chatter which I'm happy to share when I can verify that it isn't just rumour for rumours sake.
Where to begin..., Justice League. So I heard, just days after the 'other place' went up in smoke, that Justice League was "alright" from someone who had seen it. This same person said that Wonder Woman was "alright" (though I personally really liked it) so I assumed that it wasn't going to be a BvS style critical disaster. But that wasn't the problem, the problem was the perception that this film was a lightning rod for tragedy, controversy and overall PR problems. Apparently no one in the studio had known such a big film to attract so much bad news. It seemed like every day there was another problem for PR to try and out out. Ignoring the reception of BvS and Suicide Squad this film just couldn't catch a break.
The studio's box office expectations for this film were pretty modest, relatively speaking, as the hope was that it would (worldwide) at least come in around or better than Wonder Woman because of the increased interest from female audience in the character after the smash performance of Wonder Woman as the biggest film of the summer at the North American box office.
But then everything changed when, to go along with the all reshoot stories which WB just couldn't shake, Harvey-Gate broke and with it Affleck was swept up in it and then that swept up Ratner (whom Gadot had been friends with and pictured at his house having dinner parties) and then there was more Affleck scandal as to whether he knew about this stuff or not and suddenly the main female audience were being turned off this film. While this was all good for the industry with people like Harvey and Ratner being exposed Justice League was constantly in the orbit of these stories. Just to clarify Ratner never had any involvement in the WB slate beyond passive investment. The studio even used to hammer that point home to directors and producers when they came to pitch!
As if to hammer the point home when the film finally did have its premiere, neither of the two directors who worked on the film (Snyder and Whedon) made themselves available to speak owing to previous family related issues, and then arguably the two biggest stars, Gadot and Affleck, had to miss the red carpet too just in case they are asked any awkward questions. This is unheard of for a film of this size.
All in all WB were hoping that as long as, worst case scenario, Justice League opened to nine figures then that would at least insure that it would still be a 'AAA' franchise and given how few of them there are would still allow the studio to save some blushes. And then it opened under that. In short this film has under performed to a degree that even the studio wasn't expecting.
There have been rumours Kevin Tsujihara was going to named 'Executive of the Year' by a Hollywood trade before the Justice League opening but that now seems less certain even if he did steer the studio to five billion worldwide. There has even been talk that Sue Kroll (the studio's marketing guru) could be made to walk the plank for this leaving her protege, who headed the IT campaign, in charge. The studio have a habit of kicking out execs at Xmas as it's seen as the quiet time of the year when everyone's away on holiday and quieter in terms of industry news. They did it to Silverman last year.
All in all this is undoubtedly a black eye for the studio but it doesn't signal the end of the DCU by any means. Justice League did under perform and do way under what was expected but, to many, the film simply had too much baggage attached in almost every conceivable form in a way that recent Marvel films, for example, haven't and the studio knew it. When was the last time a Marvel film was mired in some PR quagmire?
So, what's next? Apparently Affleck's super agent Ari Emmanuel (inspiration for Ari in Entourage no less) has been working closely with WB's new head of development/production (or head of "Content" as his official title goes) Toby Emmerich to help form the studio's slate and likely stick his clients in plum studio projects (the story behind WB boarding Six Billion Man is nuts, I was surprised to see it mentioned in the THR story) which suggests that Affleck probably isn't done at Warners, but he is likely done as Batman. Especially after Justice League there's a feeling that a "new broom sweeps clean" and someone like Gyllenhall (whom the studio apparently originally wanted to play Batman in George Miller's Justice League many moons ago) could freshen the whole DCU up working with a director like Matt Reeves. Affleck could still have a great relationship with the studio in a less pressured role doing fare like Argo and starring in the Accountant sequel for example.
Whedon is still writing Batgirl but as far as him actually directing that film is now (according to someone) "unthinkable" given how JL has performed how he was subject to his own scandal of sorts. The thought is that the studio just doesn't want that headache again though Whedon could still have a creative role in the DCU moving forward. I wouldn't be surprised if WB seeks a female director for Batgirl now given WW''s success.
Wonder Woman 2 and Shazam are definitely going ahead as is Suicide Squad 2 (also for 2019 probably), which apparently still prints money for the studio as a property. But beyond that? I suspect that Black Adam will also go regardless given how the studio likes Dwayne Johnson and how relentlessly he pushes his projects on social media, they could do with arguably the world's biggest film star pushing their brand. I also said, months ago, in the 'other place' that I heard Harley Quinn was getting her own solo film. Warners want to pivot Quinn away from the Joker's girlfriend to a character in her own right a'la Wonder Woman. Apparently Robbie is totally behind this and is eager to play the character in a slate of films..., but what happens if she wins some big awards for I, Tonya? Who knows.
I can imagine WB pushing ahead with Flash Point (how it's written now I believe) but then again I can also see them pumping the brakes a little to make sure that the general audience are into this film version of The Flash given how Justice League may have muddied the waters a little. Also, reports that this film will extensively feature Wonder Woman and Aquaman are apparently a little wide of the mark at time of going to press. It's possible that could change and they make it a pseudo Justice League sequel.
Also, I heard that Zack Snyder was instrumental in how Wonder Woman came together, both in development and actual production, even more than has been reported. While Snyder has arguably come off worse than anyone in the BvS and Justice League fall out I still think that he's a really talented, visual director and he can 'clear his name', so to speak, with a great film that really engages and critics alike. Just maybe no more superheroes.
Ummm, I think that's it. Nothing that sensational, I'm afraid. I heard that Ready Player One is really good with some saying it could end up in the 'pantheon' of all time Spielberg blockbusters with ET, Jurassic Park and the first three Indy films.
As always, we shall see.