This is like the exact oppposite of my take on the pre-typed post, but sure.
His contributions got better on EoD since he started catching some heat (my vote included) and they were basically zero before then. I still think Meatwad's vote on turmoil (post below) is the worst of the bunch and the fact it didn't even get a mention from you on your analysis is actually weird since you're usually very through on vote analysis.
He explained that Turmoil was who he found sketchiest, and reiterated it by EoD. The overall behavior seemed fine to me because he was taking a firm stance and wasn't being wishy-washy with his reads or anything in my opinion.
Only small issue I have is on bolded point. I understood that a modifier of your role could mess with the results and that would happen regardless of any other action as in it's actually part of your own role. Is this the possibility your considering
Not sure I follow you, but I've seen town PRs that have "hateful" and "loved" X-shot modifiers, which could be my guess in this,.
Me neither, honestly. I was just considering how differently people react to pre-typed posts after your response.
I just realized I forgot to post the Meatwad quote I referred here:
I'm asking why a Town would willingly hand out things that might make other Town look like Scum
so they are giving scum things that make them read as scum?
i was confused, I thought the modifier also made them appear as scum
I was getting really confused was well lol
Those were your posts prior to that:
So I take it that that quick mention of turmoil, which was actually your first in game though, was your reasoning to the vote then? It really does read to me like you wanted to put a vote down just for the sake of it.
This is fascinating to me, teach me your ways please!
I'm pretty tired right now so I'll get back to you in the morning on this, I just fell asleep at my desk for the second night in a row lol.
There is one thing and I honestly don't know what to make of it, like if it's flavor or a hint at bastardy and Natiko gave me nothing when I asked. I am Mama and my information (results) comes from my connection with the other side. As in dead players. That is specifically indicated.
Well, don't do that. But between Fat4All's prioritization of information in his posts and the mixup about the Hated modifier, I'm getting a weird sense from his reactions here. Everyone else makes sense to me and some of the reactions I've been using to kinda get a sense of how bastard they think the game might be but his I can't get a fix on.
i'll investigate him tonight he might be the weird spooky thing the backpack is supposed to detect
I'm in bed so I'm not grabbing the actual posts but I asked if Maol was aligned with town and got a no, not aligned with town. The answer was p traditional investigation type response which is why I don't know if my role stuff is actually just flavor or real like if I'm really asking people or if it's just a dressed up investigation role or what.
For me it was pretty obvious that Mao simply stated that the thread implicitly agreed upon not lynching more active posters D1. You and monkey felt directly attacked, which wasn't true. Mao wasn't defensive, he explained something obvious to monkey. Following his train of thought wasn't something that needed witchcraft at this point. Monkey claims she questioned him to get a deeper understanding. Do with that what you will.
I think it's important to state the correct order of who came out there. I was the first one to sway away from a Meatwad lynch yesterday. Monkey and Fantomas agreed/did the same afterwards. Which is part of why they ended up in a possible team for me in my night thoguths. Using my position to help a mate? Classic paranoia when people agree.
How is your role more powerful if town knows? Are you thinking of coordinating your target?
Do you know who these players are?
Scum Kits once openly asked for a mass claim 10 mins before day end lol.
Not necessarily. If the thing she can detect isn't aligned with scum they would have no reason to roleblock or kill her and the thing probably doesn't have access to a roleblock and so far there hasn't been an extra kill so it's probably also not a serial killer.
Ding ding ding. You're right.
You're right, I was only factoring alive/dead players. Still not good odds. And yeah, I was thinking of coordinating my target. But purely outside of that, this gives town game solving powers it didn't have before, which is a "power" my role has even if that power only exists in the meta. That kind of information is only good for town.
