Disney wins antitrust approval for Fox purchase. Fox shareholder vote to take place July 27th.

ZattMurdock

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
10,333
Earth 616
I only hope the cooler heads in fact do prevail to avoid this getting even messier. I agree that this may be the most ideal outcome for both companies but to this point neither side has indicated a real willingness to compromise.

If Disney in fact did want to do this, how much freedom do they have to speak with Comcast under their agreement with Fox?
They don't have freedom to talk with Comcast. What's more interesting is that both Disney and Comcast might not have a choice but do this. It's not even about cooler heads or logic, it's literally about not being stupid. A counter by Comcast will inflate Sky numbers for an unreasonable amount. Basically, the bidding war will keep going, but the target will be Sky. Disney wins Fox, Comcast wins Sky.
 

SlyCoug88

Member
Jan 10, 2018
411
They don't have freedom to talk with Comcast. What's more interesting is that both Disney and Comcast might not have a choice but do this. It's not even about cooler heads or logic, it's literally about not being stupid. A counter by Comcast will inflate Sky numbers for an unreasonable amount. Basically, the bidding war will keep going, but the target will be Sky. Disney wins Fox, Comcast wins Sky.
A thought I had today, though-If a bidding war for Sky will ensue does Comcast bidding on Fox actually get the value of Sky higher than it would get anyway?
 
OP
OP
Oct 31, 2017
4,652
Videogame stocks are too expensive for media guys.

Comcast has numerous, more pressing targets it should look at before videogames.

Microsoft or Google though, I could see snapping up the larger publishers. But the future is mobile and those mobile developers are the real targets people should consider could be a hotbed of M&A.
The more I think about it the more I agree with avaya that Comcast should get a large Telecom company like Vodafone. It just makes sense.

Variety's follow up on Moddy's story:

39% of Sky is worth more than 30% of Hulu. It would not be a 1-1 trade.
 

Deleted member 40133

User requested account closure
Banned
Feb 19, 2018
6,095
It would be far cheaper and truthfully Not that bad of a decision.
They would get the world's largest TV and production company through SPTV (or second - they keep switching with Warner Bros.), and Sony has a decent presence in India that NBCUniversal could use to build out to rival Disney's acquisition of Star.
And then Sony Pictures' content library as well.
Why does everyone keep saying this? Kodera the new CEO of Sony , when laying out his plan for the future of the company has said Sony's way forward is as an IP company. In what way does literally selling off ip (film and TV) division help with that?

https://www.firstpost.com/tech/news...nd-other-intellectual-properties-4491431.html
 

SlyCoug88

Member
Jan 10, 2018
411
Agreed completely. Like I've said, I do see a bidding war coming, but not for Fox any longer. And those thinking that the numbers won't be nuts haven't realized how much both Disney and Comcast want Sky.
I also agree with this but once again I think the price for Sky will exceed the floor set through the Fox purchase, so Comcast may seek to further increase the price of Fox to Disney in order to price Disney out of outbidding Comcast on Sky. I really hope I’m wrong because I’m ready for the Fox deal to be finished, but I could see this motivating Comcast to make at least one more bid on Fox knowing how committed to it Disney is.
 

WastemanLoso

Member
Apr 16, 2018
571
D.C

WastemanLoso

Member
Apr 16, 2018
571
D.C
I also agree with this but once again I think the price for Sky will exceed the floor set through the Fox purchase, so Comcast may seek to further increase the price of Fox to Disney in order to price Disney out of outbidding Comcast on Sky. I really hope I’m wrong because I’m ready for the Fox deal to be finished, but I could see this motivating Comcast to make at least one more bid on Fox knowing how committed to it Disney is.
I expect one more bid from Comcast, so they can disrupt Disney as much as they can. I truly believe that Disney would've entered a bidding war for Sky if the number for FOX current number was still at 52 Billion, but now that they're in the $70s-$80s for FOX? Bob Iger & Kevin Mayer are probably like "nah, we'd just take Star India though".
 

Wololo

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Nov 20, 2017
1,564
I dont like how quiet comcast are being and i feel like their going to come back with a really huge bid.

One that will make bob iger and co really question moving forward with a counter offer im talking 90-95 billion. Ultimately i think Disney would at least match such a bid. But really both are over paying now.

Comcast are going to wait out the month and announce it the day or right before the shareholder meeting. Just to annoy Disney. But honestly im just tired of hearing about this now.But its hard to ignore it being a fan of the MCU.
 

famikon

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
4,604
ベラルーシ

0VERBYTE

Banned
Nov 1, 2017
5,555
I dont like how quiet comcast are being and i feel like their going to come back with a really huge bid.

One that will make bob iger and co really question moving forward with a counter offer im talking 90-95 billion. Ultimately i think Disney would at least match such a bid. But really both are over paying now.

Comcast are going to wait out the month and announce it the day or right before the shareholder meeting. Just to annoy Disney. But honestly im just tired of hearing about this now.But its hard to ignore it being a fan of the MCU.
Comcast dosn't have the capital and isn't big enough to form a new counter. They had to borrow the money they countered the first time. What private entity would help them against DIS of all companies. Plus still no stock option which would save on taxes. If they were to up their bid anymore it'll hurt the bottomline.
 
Last edited:

avaya

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,005
London
The more I think about it the more I agree with avaya that Comcast should get a large Telecom company like Vodafone. It just makes sense.



39% of Sky is worth more than 30% of Hulu. It would not be a 1-1 trade.
This is what is happening. Was in NYC last week for a conference, prevailing view now is that Comcast have come to their senses and have settled on Sky with a view to buying something much larger in Europe down the line. Which is the sensible strategy. They would be acquiring significant FCF that way in addition to much greater control of distribution. Outside chance at the moment for Disney is that Roberts has been making feelers our to PE funds if they want to get involved in breaking up Fox. Comcast doesn't want the studios business at all.
 

Wololo

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Nov 20, 2017
1,564
This is what is happening. Was in NYC last week for a conference, prevailing view now is that Comcast have come to their senses and have settled on Sky with a view to buying something much larger in Europe down the line. Which is the sensible strategy. They would be acquiring significant FCF that way in addition to much greater control of distribution. Outside chance at the moment for Disney is that Roberts has been making feelers our to PE funds if they want to get involved in breaking up Fox. Comcast doesn't want the studios business at all.
So will we hear something official about comcast withdrawing its fox bid and turning its attention to Sky? Or do you think theyll quietly fade into the background again.
 
OP
OP
Oct 31, 2017
4,652
Would Comcast have to bring something else to the table or does Disney just take Comcast’s Hulu share and call it a day
At 31B (which will probably go up if Fox closes at 71B given what's happening), the 39% is worth 12B. Let's go with that number.

An April analysis says Hulu is worth 8.7B, which is up from its 5.8B 2016 valuation when Time Warner bought a 10% stake in the company.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti...7-billion-value-on-hulu-is-dwarfed-by-netflix

https://variety.com/2016/digital/news/time-warner-hulu-investment-1201829514/

Let's be conservative in our analysis:

Assets that would be owned by Disney that Comcast wants:

Sky 39% = 12B
Fox's Dreamwork Animation VOD distribution rights = 0

Assets that are owned by Comcast that Disney wants:

30% of Hulu = 30% of 9B = 2.7B
Marvel Orlando theme park rights, Spider-man Japan theme park rights and outstanding Hulk and Namor movie rights = 1B

Even in this unrealistic scenario, Comcast would still have to pay Disney ~8.3B to get the rest of Sky.
 
Oct 27, 2017
27,140
Seattle
At 31B (which will probably go up if Fox closes at 71B given what's happening), the 39% is worth 12B. Let's go with that number.

An April analysis says Hulu is worth 8.7B, which is up from its 5.8B 2016 valuation when Time Warner bought a 10% stake in the company.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti...7-billion-value-on-hulu-is-dwarfed-by-netflix

https://variety.com/2016/digital/news/time-warner-hulu-investment-1201829514/

Let's be conservative in our analysis:

Assets that would be owned by Disney that Comcast wants:

Sky 39% = 12B
Fox's Dreamwork Animation VOD distribution rights = 0

Assets that are owned by Comcast that Disney wants:

30% of Hulu = 30% of 9B = 2.7B
Marvel Orlando theme park rights, Spider-man Japan theme park rights and outstanding Hulk and Namor movie rights = 1B

Even in this unrealistic scenario, Comcast would still have to pay Disney ~8.3B to get the rest of Sky.
Thanks for the explanation, I completely forgot about Hulk
 
Oct 25, 2017
5,470
At 31B (which will probably go up if Fox closes at 71B given what's happening), the 39% is worth 12B. Let's go with that number.

An April analysis says Hulu is worth 8.7B, which is up from its 5.8B 2016 valuation when Time Warner bought a 10% stake in the company.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti...7-billion-value-on-hulu-is-dwarfed-by-netflix

https://variety.com/2016/digital/news/time-warner-hulu-investment-1201829514/

Let's be conservative in our analysis:

Assets that would be owned by Disney that Comcast wants:

Sky 39% = 12B
Fox's Dreamwork Animation VOD distribution rights = 0

Assets that are owned by Comcast that Disney wants:

30% of Hulu = 30% of 9B = 2.7B
Marvel Orlando theme park rights, Spider-man Japan theme park rights and outstanding Hulk and Namor movie rights = 1B

Even in this unrealistic scenario, Comcast would still have to pay Disney ~8.3B to get the rest of Sky.
Wait they have the Spider-Man Japanese Theme Park rights? Holy shit, Universal lucked out before the Disney buyout.
 

Chaos Legion

Member
Oct 30, 2017
9,059
The more I think about it the more I agree with avaya that Comcast should get a large Telecom company like Vodafone. It just makes sense.

I agree. Vodafone would be great for them, but I'm wondering if they need to see how the T-Mobile and Sprint merger works out.
Also, do you think Roberts is completely against the VZ merger rumors?

Why does everyone keep saying this? Kodera the new CEO of Sony , when laying out his plan for the future of the company has said Sony's way forward is as an IP company. In what way does literally selling off ip (film and TV) division help with that?

https://www.firstpost.com/tech/news...nd-other-intellectual-properties-4491431.html
Yoshida is the new CEO.

Selling Sony Pictures would be short sighted. We forget, Sony Pictures (and its financial arm), bankrolled the rest of Sony when the world collapsed on them (iPhone, PS3, TV's and VAIO's). Yoshida has acknowledged, there is no money to be made in consumer electronics. Their mobile arm is non-existent.

But combining Sony Pictures, Sony Music and Sony Interactive Entertainment (PlayStation) and spinning them off into a separate entity would allow them to trade at a much favorable level, in my opinion. Yoshida is a numbers guy and I believe a company could convince him to jettison SPE.

This is what is happening. Was in NYC last week for a conference, prevailing view now is that Comcast have come to their senses and have settled on Sky with a view to buying something much larger in Europe down the line. Which is the sensible strategy. They would be acquiring significant FCF that way in addition to much greater control of distribution. Outside chance at the moment for Disney is that Roberts has been making feelers our to PE funds if they want to get involved in breaking up Fox. Comcast doesn't want the studios business at all.
Thanks for the insight! What do you think about the domestic market, though?
Verizon acquiring Charter essentially makes Comcast have to look at T-Mobile (or the combined Sprint/TMobile if it goes through) in order to really have a national footprint for distribution.

Do you think they'd pursue international growth first?
 

avaya

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,005
London
Thanks for the insight! What do you think about the domestic market, though?
Verizon acquiring Charter essentially makes Comcast have to look at T-Mobile (or the combined Sprint/TMobile if it goes through) in order to really have a national footprint for distribution.

Do you think they'd pursue international growth first?
So if you think the media stuff is actually about advertising and data then Verizon went a very different route via AOL and Go90. The latter is shuttered now, but with Vestberg now CEO it kinda feels like they have the wrong guy in place to manage a more aggressive M&A strategy. I was almost certain Ronan Dunne would end up with the top job since he was brought in from O2 UK to run Wireless, where he was very successful. Verizon Charter or Verizon Comcast has a similar impact, the problem is Malone is very difficult to buy assets from, he never cedes on valuation so he will make Charter difficult.

All of these guys know the lapse in regulatory oversight under the current administration gives them all a 2-3yr window in which to get everything done. Wireless buying broadband or vice versa is about customer lock-in and reducing churn, not necessarily control over distribution. AT&T thinking video-mobile convergence is a better churn reducer than traditional fixed-mobile, I'm not so sure either way. Verizon do need to buy FCF though to help with the pension, so buying big cable is worth it. I don't see these companies as independent 3-5yrs down the line.

Comcast though has eyes internationally since they are thinking about streaming and the future. So right now they will go for the international assets. So even if Sprint/TMUS is done it will be 1-2years at least to close and they would wait for the integration to finish too before buying so another 2-3yrs on top. In that time Comcast can buy other things and delever in time to then buy wireless.
 

Chaos Legion

Member
Oct 30, 2017
9,059
So if you think the media stuff is actually about advertising and data then Verizon went a very different route via AOL and Go90. The latter is shuttered now, but with Vestberg now CEO it kinda feels like they have the wrong guy in place to manage a more aggressive M&A strategy. I was almost certain Ronan Dunne would end up with the top job since he was brought in from O2 UK to run Wireless, where he was very successful. Verizon Charter or Verizon Comcast has a similar impact, the problem is Malone is very difficult to buy assets from, he never cedes on valuation so he will make Charter difficult.

All of these guys know the lapse in regulatory oversight under the current administration gives them all a 2-3yr window in which to get everything done. Wireless buying broadband or vice versa is about customer lock-in and reducing churn, not necessarily control over distribution. AT&T thinking video-mobile convergence is a better churn reducer than traditional fixed-mobile, I'm not so sure either way. Verizon do need to buy FCF though to help with the pension, so buying big cable is worth it. I don't see these companies as independent 3-5yrs down the line.

Comcast though has eyes internationally since they are thinking about streaming and the future. So right now they will go for the international assets. So even if Sprint/TMUS is done it will be 1-2years at least to close and they would wait for the integration to finish too before buying so another 2-3yrs on top. In that time Comcast can buy other things and delever in time to then buy wireless.
I had thought Verizon would have gone with Stratton as their next CEO, who seemed he was fully invested in the belief that content is the future of the Company and was a champion of Oath. I don't know much about Vestberg, but it makes me doubt they will really pursue anything aggressive in the upcoming time frame, but happy to be surprised.

Verizon/Comcast makes too much sense, but I don't think Roberts would go for ceding control in that union. Charter is attractive, I'd assume, moreso because I feel it would allow Malone to begin realizing an exit from his media properties. But even with stock, VZ/Charter would have ~$300bn of debt. Combined company would have about $70bn of EBITDA, but still, that's pretty aggressive.
 

SlyCoug88

Member
Jan 10, 2018
411
It's the weekend and next week is USA's biggest national holiday. I think the next "big news" will be that Comcast will officially bid for Sky in the UK. They still haven't made the official proper offer, they have up until July 13th for that.
I had no idea about this. What gives them that deadline? Hopefully they will indicate their position on the Fox bid when announcing an official Sky bid to give a little clarity on things.
 

ZattMurdock

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
10,333
Earth 616
I had no idea about this. What gives them that deadline? Hopefully they will indicate their position on the Fox bid when announcing an official Sky bid to give a little clarity on things.
Meanwhile, Comcast has also bid £22bn, or £12.50 per share, for Sky and must publish its formal offer to shareholders by July 13. Fox, which offered a £10.75 per share deal for full control of Sky 18 months ago, has yet to hit back and would require Disney’s approval to do so, if their US deal proceeds.
Source: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2018/06/23/comcast-could-forced-raise-sky-bid/
 

Schlorgan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,010
Salt Lake City, Utah
If this is the place to pitch stuff for after the merger, can I go ahead and pitch an animated series on Disney XD where Ellen Ripley and the Alien Queen have to team up and learn to be friends to get out of dangerous situations?
 
Last edited:

GraveRobberX

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
2,056
Hey remember how some were rooting for Fucking Comcast to get Fox, cause somehow Disney would become a "Monopoly" (they still don't know how to use that word correctly)

You know cause XMen and FF, Marvel Properties from the get go, now coming back in the back fold was gonna destroy competition movie wise, but still not even a blip on this whole monopoly talk

Well let's see what's Comcast up to, you know how some were holding them up as bastion of the people

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.re...nity_mobile_is_now_throttling/#ampf=undefined


Straight from an email I received today:

Update on cellular video resolution and personal hotspots We wanted to let you know about two changes to your Xfinity Mobile service that'll go into effect in the coming weeks.

Video resolution

To help you conserve data, we've established 480p as the standard resolution for streaming video through cellular data. This can help you save money if you pay By the Gig and take longer to reach the 20 GB threshold if you have the Unlimited data option.

Later this year, 720p video over cellular data will be available as a fee-based option with your service. In the meantime, you can request it on an interim basis at no charge. Learn more

This update only affects video streaming over cellular data. You can continue to stream HD-quality video over WiFi, including at millions of Xfinity WiFi hotspots.

Personal hotspots

If you have the Unlimited data option, your speeds on any device connected to a personal hotspot will not exceed 600 Kbps. At this speed, you'll conserve data so that it takes longer to reach the 20 GB threshold but you'll still be able to do many of the online activities you enjoy.

Want faster speeds when using a personal hotspot? The By the Gig data option will continue to deliver 4G speeds for all data traffic.
This is just the start. Net neutrality gutted, incomes the price gouging. This is mobile even though it's piggyback off Verizon, but take everyone in here who said Comcast can't be trusted because them owning it as an ISP and owning a huge share of IPs and content would just pay wall it off

With AT&T and WB going through, watch now the big fish feast on everything to corner themselves a share of the pie

Incoming Verizon + someone merger or getting bought out
 
Last edited:

Alexandros

Member
Oct 26, 2017
11,554
Hey remember how some were rooting for Fucking Comcast to hey Fox, cause somehow Disney would become a "Monopoly" (they still don't know how to use that word correctly)

You know cause XMen and FF, Marvel Properties from the get go, now coming back in the back fold was gonna destroy competition movie wise, but still not even a blip on this whole monopoly talk

Well let's see what's Comcast up to, you know how some were holding them up as bastion of the people

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.re...nity_mobile_is_now_throttling/#ampf=undefined



This is just the start. Net neutrality gutted, incomes the price gouging. This is mobile even though it's piggyback off Verizon, but take everyone in here who said Comcast can't be trusted because them owning it as an ISP and owning a huge share of IPs and content would just pay wall it off

With AT&T and WB going through, watch now the big fish feast on everything to corner themselves a share of the pie

Incoming Verizon + someone merger or getting bought out
Holy shit, that sucks.
 

Schlorgan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,010
Salt Lake City, Utah
Hey remember how some were rooting for Fucking Comcast to hey Fox, cause somehow Disney would become a "Monopoly" (they still don't know how to use that word correctly)

You know cause XMen and FF, Marvel Properties from the get go, now coming back in the back fold was gonna destroy competition movie wise, but still not even a blip on this whole monopoly talk

Well let's see what's Comcast up to, you know how some were holding them up as bastion of the people

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.re...nity_mobile_is_now_throttling/#ampf=undefined



This is just the start. Net neutrality gutted, incomes the price gouging. This is mobile even though it's piggyback off Verizon, but take everyone in here who said Comcast can't be trusted because them owning it as an ISP and owning a huge share of IPs and content would just pay wall it off

With AT&T and WB going through, watch now the big fish feast on everything to corner themselves a share of the pie

Incoming Verizon + someone merger or getting bought out
That seems worthy of its own thread.
 
Oct 27, 2017
27,140
Seattle
https://mobile.nytimes.com/2018/07/01/opinion/disney-fox-deal.html?smid=tw-nytopinion&smtyp=cur

NY Times editorial board says this happened to fast

The Department of Justice spent nearly two years investigating AT&T’s acquisition of Time Warner and bringing an ultimately unsuccessful lawsuit against the deal that involved two companies not directly in competition with each other. So it was stunning when the department announced on Wednesday — just six months after the deal was announced — that it had approved Disney’s $71 billion purchase of the entertainment assets of 21st Century Fox, one of Disney’s top rivals.

The approval of the Disney-Fox transaction took about half the time that regulators usually need to evaluate deals of this size. And the Justice Department’s Antitrust Division attached only one requirement — that the companies divest 22 regional sports networks. Government officials appear unconcerned that the combined Disney-Fox will account for about half of the box office revenue nationally this year and about 30 percent of scripted TV programming, according to the Writers Guild of America West, a Hollywood labor union.

The Trump administration has denied that politics plays a role in its antitrust enforcement decisions. But it’s hard not to be skeptical of the possible motivations behind the Justice Department’s approach to these deals.
Does the ends justify the means? Is it okay that this might have gone through faster for Disney-Fox because Trump likes Murdoch and dislikes Time Warner?

Do you take this and run because the outcome of Disney losing out would have been worse? (Comcast)

Interesting to think about
 

WastemanLoso

Member
Apr 16, 2018
571
D.C
https://mobile.nytimes.com/2018/07/01/opinion/disney-fox-deal.html?smid=tw-nytopinion&smtyp=cur

NY Times editorial board says this happened to fast



Does the ends justify the means? Is it okay that this might have gone through faster for Disney-Fox because Trump likes Murdoch and dislikes Time Warner?

Do you take this and run because the outcome of Disney losing out would have been worse? (Comcast)

Interesting to think about
It would not surprise me, DOJ probably hated the thought of Comcast getting bigger.
 

Silver-Streak

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,342
https://mobile.nytimes.com/2018/07/01/opinion/disney-fox-deal.html?smid=tw-nytopinion&smtyp=cur

NY Times editorial board says this happened to fast



Does the ends justify the means? Is it okay that this might have gone through faster for Disney-Fox because Trump likes Murdoch and dislikes Time Warner?

Do you take this and run because the outcome of Disney losing out would have been worse? (Comcast)

Interesting to think about
I'm actually wondering if it's the inverse.

The other merger review took so long because the Trump DOJ hated the companies involved.
 

Yasuke

Member
Oct 25, 2017
16,057
Yeah, I remember people saying it could be a year before we got the go ahead for the merger. It seemed pretty obvious it was fast-tracked, and I can understand why.

Seriously, no one wants Fox in Comcast’s hands. Nobody.
 

Choppasmith

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,225
Beaumont, CA
Hey remember how some were rooting for Fucking Comcast to hey Fox, cause somehow Disney would become a "Monopoly" (they still don't know how to use that word correctly)

You know cause XMen and FF, Marvel Properties from the get go, now coming back in the back fold was gonna destroy competition movie wise, but still not even a blip on this whole monopoly talk

Well let's see what's Comcast up to, you know how some were holding them up as bastion of the people

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.re...nity_mobile_is_now_throttling/#ampf=undefined



This is just the start. Net neutrality gutted, incomes the price gouging. This is mobile even though it's piggyback off Verizon, but take everyone in here who said Comcast can't be trusted because them owning it as an ISP and owning a huge share of IPs and content would just pay wall it off

With AT&T and WB going through, watch now the big fish feast on everything to corner themselves a share of the pie

Incoming Verizon + someone merger or getting bought out
I swear "But Disney Monopoly" sounded like the next "But her e-mails"