I was there and remember hunting down a flat-screen CRT as soon as they were commercially viable. Unlike scanlines, games weren't designed around curved glass panels.
Oh I agree. It's a nostalgia thing from years of playing in smokey arcades. I even used to run with a filter on MAME that replicated a slightly knackered CRT! Can't remember the name of it now though.
Methinks you are projecting. They are replying to your "you had to be there" comment; it's entirely fair for them to point out that they were, in fact, there. They have even explicitly acknowledged it's down to taste.
Seriously, are you OK, man?
I'm happy with people disagreeing, not so much being told my preference is somehow objectively "bad". It's not that nuanced really.