Sometimes.
I still feel bad that I bounced off of Red Dead 2 -- RDR1 is one of the most memorable games I've ever played and I had high expectations for 2. It's actually not even that my high expectations weren't met, I just realized that my frame of preferences in videogames right now doesn't mesh well with RDR2's design and structure at all right now. I've just been assuring myself that someday it'll just click for me, though -- who knows if that'll actually be the case.
That said, I'm still glad for everyone that enjoys the game and I take it to heart that it's something people really cherish. I don't feel any need to slam the game since I bounced off of it, though I do try to make the point that it certainly didn't do much for me on my many attempts to get into it since its launch.
Outside of cases like that, I am finding that I have enough to play that lines up well with my current preferences that I'm never short of something to play, so I'm not guilty about it since it doesn't ever feel like people are off having a great time while I'm struggling to get into something. I've got plenty to play that's up my current alley, so I usually just don't even think about the games that review well or have good word of mouth that I can't get into.