• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
OP
OP
IrishNinja

IrishNinja

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
9,837
Vice City
new page, new tweets



also as a supporter of SPLC, their recent stance on alt-right activity was a bummer



I'm just imagining the mind of a skeptic. He hears bad things about Group, he tries to learn about group, but they have no platform to teach him about themselves. Said skeptic may feel they are being represented poorly and are victims of oppression, therefor taking them more seriously than they deserve. If we want that skeptic to truly learn what these people are, we need to let them communicate...

have no fear, there's no shortage of white supremacist information to be found online - YT alone has it in droves

moreover, if your fear is that said skeptic will feel the lack of public & digital spaces for those with genocidal agendas makes him more sympathetic to their cause, this says a great deal more about said skeptic

Do sparkles stop people disagreeing with you?

i don't recall saying (much less expecting) everyone to agree with me here, but you're welcome to quote me if you see otherwise. i was clearly implying the hope that people would simply read what was there, but you knew that before this post, i figure.
 

Deleted member 15326

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,219
I'm just imagining the mind of a skeptic. He hears bad things about Group, he tries to learn about group, but they have no platform to teach him about themselves. Said skeptic may feel they are being represented poorly and are victims of oppression, therefor taking them more seriously than they deserve. If we want that skeptic to truly learn what these people are, we need to let them communicate...

If your hypothetical skeptic only accepts information about hate groups from those groups, I'd say the battle's already over
 

Ms.Galaxy

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
1,653
I'm just imagining the mind of a skeptic. He hears bad things about Group, he tries to learn about group, but they have no platform to teach him about themselves. Said skeptic may feel they are being represented poorly and are victims of oppression, therefor taking them more seriously than they deserve. If we want that skeptic to truly learn what these people are, we need to let them communicate...

Books and historical records exist of what the platform of Nazis, fascism, and white supremacy is, you don't need to give them a platform to advocate their toxic trash to learn about them. The best part of these books and historical records is that they are given context and are based off reality, rather than the uncontextualized lies that the far right create to induce a reactionary, emotional response from people.
 

Kodama

Banned
Feb 7, 2018
303
have no fear, there's no shortage of white supremacist information to be found online - YT alone has it in droves
Exactly and deplatforming would ruin that. That information should always be there...

moreover, if your fear is that said skeptic will feel the lack of public & digital spaces for those with genocidal agendas makes him more sympathetic to their cause, this says a great deal more about said skeptic
That's why I used the term "group", this isn't exclusive to just nazis but all groups of idealogy...
 
OP
OP
IrishNinja

IrishNinja

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
9,837
Vice City
Exactly and deplatforming would ruin that. That information should always be there...

no, you can have a wiki/footnote about dangerous fascist views without actual propoganda/recruitment tools like YT allows

germany allows no memorials for nazis & hitler, yet historical text & details survive. this is an important distinction.

That's why I used the term "group", this isn't exclusive to just nazis but all groups of idealogy...

this thread is about the distinction between nazi/violent white supremacist views and why they are dangerous & require deplatforming. treating them the same here is disingenuous.

I disagree. You can never really know what someone is about 2nd hand...

they why not take a stroll off to voat, /pol/ etc and learn first hand how valuable these precious views are
 
OP
OP
IrishNinja

IrishNinja

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
9,837
Vice City
Salon: "Alt-right" vs YouTube: hitting white supremacists where it hurts

"This isn't the usual, 'We're under an attack, thank you for the support, share links.' No, no, no. This is — we're done, we're off the internet, they're banning us," complained conspiracy theorist Mike Cernovich on a recent episode of Infowars, during which he and Jones vowed to organize a protest of Google at this year's SXSW conference in Austin, Texas.

Cernovich added, "They want us in gulags, Alex," and darkly warned that "death camps are coming."

mike is fortunate that death by irony is not a thing

There's also "not a lot of pushback against these people" from progressives on the service, Holt added. In a sense, YouTube allows white nationalists to hide in plain sight. Few liberals have the stomach or time to actually watch and respond to right-wing videos that spread fabricated theories or outrageous falsehoods. Social media in text form, as on Twitter or Facebook, attracts far more criticism, but videos can transmit far-right ideas far more widely while encountering relatively little pushback.

Rebecca Watson also noted that despite recent attempts to crack down on "fake news," YouTube and similar services rely on "algorithms that are based on popularity and 'upvotes,' and are easily gamed." "Alt-right" users have become experts in exploiting such algorithms to get more eyes on their videos.

Last week, Kelly Weill of the Daily Beast exposed the ways "alt-right" trolls push their content on YouTube, often by creating "fake accounts in order to boost visibility of their preferred videos and bury videos they don't like."

This matters, said Ryan of Media Matters, because the "alt-right" is focused primarily on recruiting young people and there's "a readymade audience of young people" who "think of YouTube the way [older generations] think of our cable programs on TV." If a young person watches a right-wing video out of curiosity, she noted, the autoplay feature on the site will immediately queue up a related video. Before you know it, that viewer has consumed "five or six videos with those same points being repeated over and over again," making the arguments seem more acceptable, or at least less outlandish, than they otherwise would.

really can't be stressed enough that YT is a recruitment ground for this garbage, and should not be treated by the left as though it was just the next AM radio or the like. this platform is huge for them, and YT is terribly slow to do anything - with the exception of the recent Parkland conspiracy bullshit.

to that end: No Platform for Fascism toolkit, a great tool to report such hateful recruitment videos on YouTube - think i should work this into the OP

I understand that, I should only post if I agree...

plenty of people in here haven't agreed, they've occasionally had arguments worth engaging. you should definitely either read the OP & have something to say next time in actual disagreement (rather than trolling) or keep it moving...
 

mael

Avenger
Nov 3, 2017
16,748
Deplatforming is the worst thing you can do IMO. Instead of people learning for better or worse from them, they will not even know of their existence and their potential for danger. Also it gives them the edge of being oppressed...
This has got to be a joke.
Some "opinions" are not worth having a platform.
Anti vaccination, pro murder, flat earth or creationism are not "opinions" worth having a platform and neo nazism share the same space of shitty ideas that should better be left in the past.
Might as well argue for bona fide pre Lavoisier Alchemy to be taught in school while we're at it.
 

convo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,364
I can't remember the name of the german comedian who said it but the mantra still holds when asked about if it's ok to make fun of nazis: you must make fun of Nazis, remember them as pathetic idiots and failures. A Trash, absolute garbage ideology doesn't need dignity ascribed to it.
 

Timothy

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
110
Has anyone mentioned the Antifa Anti-Handbook by an Ivy league professor Mark Bray?

Basically he studied Antifa and facism in the 20s and 30s and basically said this. Hitler and Mussolini were democratically elected. They weren't violent. And look what happened then.

He argues for de-platforming and violence.

I think it's an interesting perspective and puts some academic gravitas into the need to at least de-platforming.



This fact about Hitler and Mussolini should definitely be mentioned in the first post.
 
Last edited:

xbhaskarx

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
5,143
NorCal
'Alt-Right' Ringleader Richard Spencer: We Attract the Mentally Ill
The new documentary 'Alt-Right: Age of Rage' explores the violent rise of the 'alt-right' in America and how white nationalists feel emboldened under President Trump.

When asked about the string of terrorist attacks carried out by white nationalists, an ever-growing list that now includes Parkland shooter Nikolas Cruz, Spencer confesses that the "alt-right" movement tends to attract the mentally infirm.

"I think it means something in the sense that the alt-right is getting at that fissure, you know? It's getting at the really taboo issues, it's getting at the most difficult aspects of society, and so that might attract people who are ill in some way," Spencer says.
 

Deleted member 4413

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
2,238
So people like this guy?



It's actually concerning me what to do if this happens when I'm out with my family and one of these knuckledraggers starts talking.


I would have a very hard time not hopitalizing a douchebag like this, fuck the consequences. One of these days he's going to piss off the wrong person.
 

Snack12367

Member
Oct 28, 2017
3,191
A great video from Innuendo Studios explaining the tactics used by the Alt-Right in their recent rise and debatable fall from grace.

 
Feb 18, 2018
421
I'm a big fan of this thread

I'd like to discuss some things though, this thread should also focus on the alt-left who I personally find just as dangerous as the alt right


Neither of these sides deserve platforms
 
OP
OP
IrishNinja

IrishNinja

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
9,837
Vice City
paper-boi-atlanta.jpg


this thread is 100% not about nonsense horseshoe theory or false equivalences - the alt-left is likewise not a thing

antifa isn't a group like the alt-right; historically they're a response to popular fascist movements that dies down when the former does
 
OP
OP
IrishNinja

IrishNinja

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
9,837
Vice City
I will rephrase this bud, the regressive left, and if I am not allowed to discuss this in this thread then I apologize, I just personally think we shouldn't focus on one side, but all of them.

this thread is clearly about the dangers of fascism & the alt-right. you're free to define other groups as you please, but yeah, appreciate it if you'd do so in another thread
 

Deleted member 30544

User Requested Account Closure
Banned
Nov 3, 2017
5,215
https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/03/why-the-alt-left-is-a-problem/amp

The Antifa must be stopped as well, they cause destruction and violence, but we should take care of the alt-right first though, mostly because one of them actually murdered someone.

No i mean...

The alt-right is fighting because they want to exterminate/control minorities, because they think they are superior because of their skin color.

According to you, what is the reason behind the fighting of the so call alt-left?
 
Feb 18, 2018
421
No i mean...

The alt-right is fighting because they want to exterminate/control minorities, because they think they are superior because of their skin color.

According to you, what is the reason behind the fighting of the so call alt-left?

They mean well and I do agree with many of their views but their methods are horrible

Not to mention I see a little bit of them on twitter wanting to silence regular republicans and I see them support Marxism , I can't support that.
 

corasaur

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,988
The central thesis of this thread is pretty much that bigotry should not be treated as a valid opinion within society, and that letting people participate in democracy who wish to end democracy is suicidal.

trying to equate the intentions or relatively-tiny amount of power antifa has in the world with the success and dangers of resurgent right-wing extremism is some bullshit. the notion that any kind of equivalence can be drawn there is vapid propaganda to convince moderates that it's not worth having opinions and to help alt-right efforts to normalize themselves.
 

legacyzero

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
4,252
Who would you even place in an "alt left?" Communist / Socialist? I keep hearing dumbfuck right wingers yelling "BUT THE ALT-LEFT?!" yet nobody can tell me who is part of it.
 

Laevateinn

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,137
Chicago
The only fuckers the "altleft" focus their hate is at fascist monsters who are a waste of oxygen. Won't someone think of the windows. Jesus Christ. Get out with this bullshit.