1. SArcher

    SArcher
    Member

    Reading this whole mess and then thinking about the title of the movie

    Oh that's why they call it that (Peter Griffin voice)
     
  2. Boogs31

    Boogs31
    Banned Member

    Do you not understand why he didn't inform people? Because if he did, his friend would have been prevented from being in the film. You know, like exactly what transpired when people found out.

    It was 8 years ago and he already admitted his crime and was punished for it. I don't understand everyone's reaction here.
     
  3. Kin5290

    Kin5290
    Member

    Why is this a problem? Nobody is legally obligated to know that a coworker is a sexual offender.
     
  4. KarmaCow

    KarmaCow
    Member

    This is absurd because he's not owed a place in a movie as part of his rehabilitation nor is anyone else obligated to help him out. If Black wants to help out a friend, that's on him and him alone.
     
  5. TheEnd

    TheEnd
    Member

    It's called human decency.
     
  6. Falconbox

    Falconbox
    Member

    Yeah if you've got a sketchy past, as cliche as it sounds, honesty is the best policy.

    COVER YOUR ASS.

    Sure, you can skirt by and get a job or something without telling someone. But if/when it comes to light, more often than not you'll be let go.
     
  7. Vyer

    Vyer
    Member

    So Black is saying he was 'uninformed' about exactly what his friend did? Yeah....


    In any case, even if you want to discard the morality of it or the debate on forgiveness, trying to sneak your child sex offender friend on screen in a scene with a female co star in your big budget franchise IP movie worth millions to a big studio is pretty damn stupid.

    oh, and your movie is called The Predator.

    Just colossally dumb.
     
  8. Boogs31

    Boogs31
    Banned Member

    Do you understand how punishment should work as a principle? You do something wrong, you get caught, you admit your guilt, you serve time, you prove on the outside you're a changed person. He presumably did all of those things, for EIGHT YEARS! That should be the end of the punishment. Unfortunately most feel they should be punished forever. Oh, you want to do something, well, were you previously a sex offender? Okay well you can't.

    Ex cons shouldn't be prohibited from having opportunities, but in our society they're blacklisted from life.

    I agree with your point that no one is owed a place in a movie. That's not what this was. It was a friend trying to help out a friend, a friend who likely hasn't been given any help from society in general in a long time. Giving him a small bit in a dumb movie is a nice gesture.

    If you're not okay with this guy working a glorified extra role in a movie, you need to ask yourself, what is this human being worth enough to do?
     
  9. CastorKrieg

    CastorKrieg
    Member



    This mostly depends on the crime. There is a reason the worst people in prison will assault and give hell to child molesters and pedophiles. You are equating all the crimes as long as the sentence has been served all is fine. I disagree - pedophiles, child abusers, wife-beaters, rapists should be blacklisted for life.
     
  10. Boogs31

    Boogs31
    Banned Member

    I agree some crimes are worse than others. But do you believe some pedophiles, wife beaters, rapists, child abusers, murderers are worse than others as well? Is what Kevin Stacey did the same amount of evil in your mind as what Louis C.K. did? Or say a person that murdered 1 person versus a serial killer?

    Based on the OP this guy "attempted to lure a 14-year-old female into a sexual relationship via the internet." The word attempted to me would indicate nothing physical actually happened. I'm not disputing that's awful, but is it really something he should never be able to come back from? Is what he did on par with the worst forms of pedophilia?

    I'm honestly having a hard time myself with these sorts of questions. I just don't want to immediately throw a human aside like trash especially when they've been rightfully punished for their actions and may be a better person today.
     
  11. hodayathink

    hodayathink
    Member

    Except that according to the court documents, something did physically happen. They apparently didn't go far enough for it to be labeled a more serious offense, but they did interact physically.
     
  12. R1CHO

    R1CHO
    Member

    I just don't get it, why do we have to care so much about shit like this.

    Is this guy banned from life or something? You would like him to work as a cashier but not as an actor?

    Reading some comments seems like the director is using Nazi gold to produce the film or something.

    I don't hate on Munn, ok, she wasn't comfortable and she told the producers, I don't even hate on Fox, it's their fucking movie, they can do whatever they want, but why should we hate Black or his friend?

    What would you guys do with this dude? Grab a gun and shoot him it's the only real answer I can imagine reading some comments.
     
  13. Lukemia SL

    Lukemia SL
    Member

    Man those words, fits so well lol

    Anywho I agree with Olivia Munn where she said that the choice was made for her and she didn’t get a say in the matter in regards to the scene.
    Shane Black just sucks. This is not the friend you help out. Especially in a movie called The Predator, good lord.
     
  14. He tried to lure a 14 year old for sex. Society would be better without his type.
     
  15. WrenchNinja

    WrenchNinja
    Member

    Cause Black was hiding the fact that his friend, who he cast as a harasser with scenes with someone who has been been sexually harassed, was a pedophile, in a movie that also features an 11 year old.

    Why should we hate the pedophile? Well gee I wonder.

    You do realise there are other jobs out there. He's not entitled to this one.
     
  16. RedMercury

    RedMercury
    Member

    Why do we have to care about a child molester? Okay.
     
  17. Khanimus

    Khanimus
    Member

    Why are we concerned about a child predator? This is your argument?
     
  18. Khanimus

    Khanimus
    Member

    double post
     
  19. Carth

    Carth
    Member

    If we're going to blacklist from society it would be more humane to just make the punishment death.

    It is better than forcing people to commit suicide or starve.
     
  20. Lukemia SL

    Lukemia SL
    Member

    Been catching up on the thread, yup everything including pedos has a defence force. Smh
     
  21. It's not so much that pedos have a defense force as examining society's view on crime and punishment. I just had this conversation with a buddy the other day, and I have a four year old daughter. People need to be honest about law and criminals and how we treat them and whether or not we want incarceration to be punitive or rehabilitative. Everything and everyone these days seems to operate in absolutes, and it's frustrating. Is there nuance to the severity of how predators should be classified and punished? Should we stop fucking around with the illusion of civility and law and just say, "Yeah, you commit this crime and get this brand - there is no difference. there is no sentence other than life sentencing. They should be killed. Period."

    Because at the end of day, that's what people are really saying. They need to live only under overpasses. Fuck off on jobs. Down the line, they deserve death no matter if they were in jail for 10 days or 10 years.

    Do I want a pedo near my child? Absolutely not. That's why you remove their ability to ever be around children. But at one point are we sending them to jail only to come out and be in jail for life, or just changing it all to reflect how most people really feel: kill them.
     
  22. KarmaCow

    KarmaCow
    Member

    Two things:

    This isn't someone getting tossed in prison for holding a bag of weed or pissing in a public park while drunk, the guy deliberately groomed and sexually assaulted a 14 year old.
    He also isn't applying for a job to reintegrated back into society, he's getting a (small) role in a movie, something that most people will never have the opportunity to do.

    Personally I don't think child molesters should get that opportunity or be in the entertainment industry at all. There are plenty of other jobs that aren't considered prizes for the average person. It's a black mark on his person but so is mentally and emotionally scarring a child.

    And that's not even getting into the problem of trying to hide this from everyone else, especially Olivia Munn.
     
  23. SinkFla

    SinkFla
    Member

    Doesn't sound like the guy is too preoccupied with suicide (given his reaction and demeanor to his crimes), nor is in a place where he doesn't have friends who help him out and thus not starving.

    You seem oddly more concerned with him than someone who will potentially have to live with the trauma and abuse inflicted on their adolescent self.
     
  24. Sandstar

    Sandstar
    Member

    When did it become okay to defend pedophiles?
     
  25. SinkFla

    SinkFla
    Member

    (Tips fedora) Well actually, the correct terminology would be ep- (gets stomped in a prison shower).

    I have no idea but it's weird.
     
  26. frankenstrat

    frankenstrat
    Member

    Black not telling anyone is mad fucked up. That’s about the first thing I feel like anyone in their right mind would do.
     
  27. Lukemia SL

    Lukemia SL
    Member

    No I wouldn’t want them killed. I’d rather them live with their guilt and be shunned. I don’t care if they serves some sentence and came out, the fact they did this in the first place is enough to make me feel they deserve no second chance and the fact they hid this from the cast is messed up.
    Fox made the right choice I wouldn’t want to be in the same building as a pedo let alone act in a scene with sexual connotations.
     
  28. nel e nel

    nel e nel
    Member

    It’s part of the “Ban the Box” laws that many states have adopted. It’s to prevent hiring discrimination based on past convictions. California adopted their fair chance law this year.
     
  29. Sweeney Swift

    Sweeney Swift
    Member

    When did it become not ban-worthy
     
  30. Scuffed

    Scuffed
    Member

    One of the worst aspect of this is how Black and the rest of the cast have seemingly left Munn out in the cold. Black in particular seems to be actually angry at her. I don't know about recent activity but I watched an interview with her where she said that he hasn't even spoken to her since this all went down and just made the Twitter apology.
     
  31. nel e nel

    nel e nel
    Member

    Pissing in public can get you on the registered sex offender list in many places. And do you have any links showing that he actually assaulted the 14 year old? I’ve only found stuff talking about attempts to lure them into a relationship, not actually following through with it.
     
  32. Jam

    Jam
    Member

    I mean... Whether you actually have sexual relations with a child, or you merely intended to and groomed them online - you're still a paedophile. One act is worse than the other and would be punisher further, but even luring children online is worthy of the register.
     
  33. HammerFace

    HammerFace
    Member

    Pretty sure it literally says he molested her in the OP. If not I’m pretty sure it’s on the first page somewhere.
     
  34. nel e nel

    nel e nel
    Member

    I’m well aware that it’s enough to get you on the list, that’s not what I was asking.
     
  35. Tence

    Tence
    Member

    From earlier in the thread

     
  36. nel e nel

    nel e nel
    Member

    Ever mind found it.
     
  37. HammerFace

    HammerFace
    Member

    It’s in the article posted in the op
     
  38. nel e nel

    nel e nel
    Member

    Yeah, I found it. Thanks.
     
  39. LukeOP

    LukeOP
    Member

    • User Banned (1 Week): Conspiracy theories and inflammatory generalisations.
    I’m going to go out on a limb here and say that Black is a pedophile to.

    You just don’t stay friends with someone knowing they want to have sex with children.
     
  40. Lukemia SL

    Lukemia SL
    Member

    The dude that always has a kid in his movies in a central role around festive times be a paedophile? Nooo wayyy
     
  41. Part of me wants to sympathize with Black because it’s admirable to want to help a friend who has paid with ‘time served’ for doing something deplorable when the world has passed judgment.

    On the other hand, as LukeOP reasoned: why is he even still friends with this dude? This wasn’t some 18 year old with a 16 year old, or a botched “To catch a predator”. This guy actually fondled and kissed all over a kid on some R. Kelly/Polanski level deplorable behavior.

    So yeah..he did his time, and I hope that he gets some kind of work and becomes a contributing member of society again. However in the real world with man-code full on, we just can’t be buddies anymore. I’m not going to stick my neck out for you to find you work....

    Which goes back to my original point: is ANY AMOUNT of jail time enough to satisfy the public? Is allowing them freedom after penance just a cruel extended sentence when no one will hire them anyway? What’s the solution and how do you determine the severity of the crime and the punishment? These people are sick and were likely molested too. Should that be factored in? Does the legal repercussion to the crime need to change?

    These are tough questions and deserve a lot more than our knee jerk revulsion to crimes against children.
     
  42. Sweeney Swift

    Sweeney Swift
    Member

    And it wasn't just once, for the record. Black successfully gave him roles in Iron Man 3 and The Nice Guys before this, and attempted to produce another, sweeping it under the rug each time like nobody else deserved to know they were working alongside a convicted pedophile
     
  43. OrdinaryPrime

    OrdinaryPrime
    Member

    This person didn't piss in public. Man can we not create hypotheticals that don't exist in this case?
     
  44. Scuffed

    Scuffed
    Member

    I'm really hard line when it comes to pedos. I don't really care about their well being at all tbh. I'm sorry if past experiences made them pedos it means nothing to me. Abusing a child ruins multiple lives forever it's despicable beyond anything else. There is a reason even in prison pedos are beyond the pale. I'm not sure how one is to be handled legally(I am very harsh in this regard) but at the very least I want to be told when they are near me and I sure as hell want to be told if they are working with me.

    Revulsion at a pedo is not a kneejerk reaction because no amount of context can ever explain it away or soften it's impact.
     
  45. I mean, I get it. In a town without ethics (because Hollywood IS a cesspool), having a code and sticking by someone is an act of Herculean fortitde. That said, one has to question such devotion to this particular trial.

    Hiding parts of your past seems like a necessity in the current climate, but why THIS hill to die on? Why THIS fight to pick? Strange choice opens up questions that I’m sure he’d rather not answer...

    By knee jerk reaction, I mean it very literally. We’re biologically wired to protect children at all costs. Even criminals have this hard wiring, which is why they react (in their way) to people that hurt children. It’s quite literally an involuntary reaction. I’m definitely not trying to minimize its importance. Im just saying that as a society, we need to figure out how to really deal with this sickness if the current system isn’t working for most people.

    I’m a very peaceful man, but my wife and I say all the time that should anything happen to my kid, I’m fully prepared to go to prison to pay for my inevitable retribution spree. My wrath would be BIBLICAL.

    That’s how hard-wired most people are.
     
  46. Lukemia SL

    Lukemia SL
    Member

    Right on.
     
  47. Blunt

    Blunt
    Member

    Holy shit at that reach. Is Chris Columbus a pedophile too then ? For fuck's sake.
     
  48. nel e nel

    nel e nel
    Member

    Man, can we please read the thread before responding so you can see that I found what I was asking for?
     
  49. Lukemia SL

    Lukemia SL
    Member

    Is he?

    I love how upset you got at a joke.
     
  50. Blunt

    Blunt
    Member

    He wrote/directed three movies set at Christmas with a kid as a central figure, you tell me.