Looked back on Include just now, and her play never really seemed very scummy to me, she just uses a very particular style of play.
She was ready to play on D4 but didn't vote because she felt she was lacking a lot of info. On the other hand, Gorlak came in later than her and was happy to drop a vote and we know he flipped town, same goes for Kawl on D6. I wouldn't say this is necessarily a scum tell, just something worth mentioning about her entrance to the thread. She had some interactions with Monkey which were interesting because scumMonkey was asking Include if she was scum and Include told her she wasn't. Then scumMonkey meta-read that as meaning Include was actually scum, which Include responds to by joking about tunneling Monkey. Probably just fun jokes, but besides some questions towards the players in the thunderdome, she didn't do much else on D4, so those two things stick out.
She focused in on GP for most of D5, almost convinced that he was scum and lying about his role claim, but then she seemed less sure when Nin voted GP as well without really adding much, she called it a "throwaway vote" from him. She dropped GP after D5 from what I saw so it's not like she was still going on about him long after his claim, she just continued to apply some pressure on him when almost no one else was, and when someone she thought was kind of scummy started agreeing with her, she backed off.
She made good points against Blarg on D6, though I think we all did at some point. Other than that she started to feel more suspicious of Nin on D6 from what I can tell, which led to her D7.
D7 she was looking at Nin hard, even made a mention of the #MonkeyWasBussingNin theory, so it's not like I was ever all alone in thinking that. Ultimately she seemed frustrated that things took a turn towards Dr. Monkey instead. However, I think it was legit town frustration, Nin was looking like a good target on D7 and Include made some good points against him, then we decided to throw one of the more town-read people at the time up on the block instead alongside ET for pretty weak reasons in comparison to the many reasons to side-eye Nin's play.
So, in other words, I feel good about Include, who Sweet Nicole has now taken over for, and who, along with Zookfoodle, are all technically the same person as far as this game is concerned. Therefore, I feel like I can say that my town read on Nicole is not just coming from her posts yesterday, but from the play of her predecessors as well.
As for the others I want to look back on still:
Kopite has made a lot more posts, so that's going to take some time. I'll also want to review both Kits and ET again, I had been glancing back at some D2 and D3 stuff lately and Kits was looking kind of towny at times there. I don't know though, she was and still is a hard read for me. ET has a lot less posts so that shouldn't take as long.
She was ready to play on D4 but didn't vote because she felt she was lacking a lot of info. On the other hand, Gorlak came in later than her and was happy to drop a vote and we know he flipped town, same goes for Kawl on D6. I wouldn't say this is necessarily a scum tell, just something worth mentioning about her entrance to the thread. She had some interactions with Monkey which were interesting because scumMonkey was asking Include if she was scum and Include told her she wasn't. Then scumMonkey meta-read that as meaning Include was actually scum, which Include responds to by joking about tunneling Monkey. Probably just fun jokes, but besides some questions towards the players in the thunderdome, she didn't do much else on D4, so those two things stick out.
She focused in on GP for most of D5, almost convinced that he was scum and lying about his role claim, but then she seemed less sure when Nin voted GP as well without really adding much, she called it a "throwaway vote" from him. She dropped GP after D5 from what I saw so it's not like she was still going on about him long after his claim, she just continued to apply some pressure on him when almost no one else was, and when someone she thought was kind of scummy started agreeing with her, she backed off.
She made good points against Blarg on D6, though I think we all did at some point. Other than that she started to feel more suspicious of Nin on D6 from what I can tell, which led to her D7.
D7 she was looking at Nin hard, even made a mention of the #MonkeyWasBussingNin theory, so it's not like I was ever all alone in thinking that. Ultimately she seemed frustrated that things took a turn towards Dr. Monkey instead. However, I think it was legit town frustration, Nin was looking like a good target on D7 and Include made some good points against him, then we decided to throw one of the more town-read people at the time up on the block instead alongside ET for pretty weak reasons in comparison to the many reasons to side-eye Nin's play.
So, in other words, I feel good about Include, who Sweet Nicole has now taken over for, and who, along with Zookfoodle, are all technically the same person as far as this game is concerned. Therefore, I feel like I can say that my town read on Nicole is not just coming from her posts yesterday, but from the play of her predecessors as well.
As for the others I want to look back on still:
Kopite has made a lot more posts, so that's going to take some time. I'll also want to review both Kits and ET again, I had been glancing back at some D2 and D3 stuff lately and Kits was looking kind of towny at times there. I don't know though, she was and still is a hard read for me. ET has a lot less posts so that shouldn't take as long.
