I'd also like to know this when you get a chance melonrabbit.
This is also a good point. If we're going to believe everything Melon has to say right now, then we should find out if she can kill again in the next night and if so, who it should be if we're going to vote on *Splinter.
nah, Mafia would never fake Red-check. 1-1 trade-off is a no-no, Melon's got to be the real deal or else a Neutral with ulteriors
That vote was to win the religion hint apparently, it could have been on anyone I think. What she won for that was the ability to check whether someone was town or not, and she used it on *Splinter.
I did think he was town, because of his early interaction with Zeke regarding recruiting. If I was scum I wouldn't make one of my first posts be defending a partner.
I messed up with my exo vote. Trying not to make that mistake again.
The point is it's such a value tradeoff if we lynch Splinter and if he's town we move to lynch Melon.
Are you saying Fantomas and B-Dubs are scum? I'm gonna need you to walk me through that one.
Alright, lets say Splinter comes in and says he's a vanilla town and Melon must be scum. What would you do?
I think he means they were pressuring Splinter, so less likely to be scum.
I think he's saying the opposite, though I don't understand what he means by "busing", might be a term I'm not familiar with.
I was actively arguing for people to jump to him when he pulled out in front. If we're both scum why the heck would I do that?
Like I said, if that was me I wouldn't have been arguing that we should lynch him and we'd learn more on day 1 by doing so over blarg.
Oh, well in that case then, I explained my vote on *Splinter already and I stood by the vote until Friday when we were getting towards the end. It seemed like the conversation was moving elsewhere after a while and the case against Kitsune was adding up in my mind over time, so that's why I made the switch off of him. I don't know if that's indicative of "bussing" but that's what went down.
I do wanna see what story he's got, because I could use the laugh.
Thing is, before the whole Blarg thing yesterday, Splinter was on his way to a Day 1 lynch. Besides, if this all turns out to be bullshit and he's town we'll lynch Melon in retaliation. Either way we lynch a scum in the next two days.
Sorry for the slow response. DCPat would flip at day end if he targeted scum.
Blarg should have never stopped that if there was ever any conviction toward the lynch
If melon is lying, that's 2 days where scum can basically hide in the shadows. Sure, they'd be down a member, but they would also have 2 nights to do what they wanted, whittling us down further. And this is especially worth noting because three people died on night one, already bringing player numbers down lower than they normally are at this point in time. It could be all that Scum needs to start a murder snowball of death. But it might not. A large part of whether I actually end up voting melon will come after we hear what splinter has to say in response. If he comes off as flaky, I might relucantly bite the bullet and help get splinter lynched. If he comes off as more sincere, I might start pushing into melon a bit.
There are 4 votes on splinter right now, which i consider to be significant because of how early it is in the day. Considering the bar to surpass first in votes was actually 4 votes for a significant period of time, I want to call attention to it
This is how it went on day 1 though. 4-ish votes came out for Splinter, then people came out defending him then people started getting on the blarg train.
Not comparable situations. D1 was general suspicion, which shifts naturally throughout the day. This is a red check.
Fuckin tell em!
Remember that time spider did it as town and basically singlehandedly won the game?
How on earth does melons opinion of her cop check target influence the outcome? A red check is a red check.
