• We are delighted to introduce GiftBot 2.0, the next generation of our popular gifting feature. To celebrate, we'll be giving away some incredible prizes over the coming weeks in one big Giveaway Extravaganza!

Game of Thrones - Off Season No Book Discussion|OT|IncestERA

Status
Not open for further replies.

ComputerBlue

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,498





Please do not discuss any books or leaks in this thread.

NOTE: The reason there is no book discussion allowed in this thread is that many viewers of the show plan to read the books at some point, some are currently in the process of doing so and do not wish to have any major differences spoiled. Please respect that. Any major leak discussion is also not allowed, small leaks such as set pictures or character sightings are fine as long as they're tagged, linked and not embedded, but any story or script leaks are absolutely prohibited. Speculation and theories are welcomed and encouraged.

BOOK THREAD: A song of ice and fire |OT| The never ending Autumn



 
Last edited:

CountAntonius

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,069
The final season wouldn't have been the same without the constant time travel whining and fan fiction comparisons. Glad to be here.
 

Heshinsi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,949
So what's the under/over for Hodor coming back a zombie? My guess is that he's the one to finally kill Bran.

"This is what you get for having me wipe your ass all those years, you ungrateful little shit," he wanted to say but could only grunt out, "HOOOODDDOOOOORRR!!"
 

Einchy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
26,123
So what's the under/over for Hodor coming back a zombie? My guess is that he's the one to finally kill Bran.

"This is what you get for having me wipe your ass all those years, you ungrateful little shit," he wanted to say but could only grunt out, "HOOOODDDOOOOORRR!!"
He's 100% a Wight now but I don't think we see him again.
 
OP
OP
ComputerBlue

ComputerBlue

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,498
nicely done on the title
Nameless gets the credit for that!

So are we going to do the two thread thing again?
There are people who want to read the books still and don't want the changes spoiled. I asked before creating the thread and everyone agreed that it would be best for now.

I personally have no issues with book talk as long as it's mild, slight differences like Varys having hair vs. Being bald.

But when it's something like character deaths, then I don't think that should be in here because some of the differences are pretty significant.
 

Nameless

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,118

bye

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
3,670
Phoenix, AZ
Does the "book spoiler" thread not exist yet? Do we even need two threads still when there are no spoilers left?
 

Quinton

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
7,589
The Research Triangle
Slowly rewatching the series at a pace of around 2-3 episodes a week since one of my roommates has never seen it. She's familiar with several of the major milestone moments but lacks any context as to how they happen. We're up to 2x05.

The first couple of episodes in S2 don't really do it for me quite as much as most episodes do. (For context, this and Star Trek DS9 are my two favorite shows, and there are fewer than 4 episodes of Thrones I'd rate as low as a 6, so I mean. I still like even these eps OK.)

It's going to be interesting to try to finally lock down a seasonal ranking for myself once I'm through. The big struggles will be 2 and 5 (which are my least favorite seasons overall but I've had a tough time deciding on an order) and 7 (which, being new, I'm still not committed with just yet). Tentatively, I'm thinking 4 > 6 > 1 = 3 > 2 = 5. 7 will probably pop into the middle somewhere. I'll find out within the next few months. Maybe.
 
OP
OP
ComputerBlue

ComputerBlue

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,498
Does the "book spoiler" thread not exist yet? Do we even need two threads still when there are no spoilers left?
No it doesn't exist yet, I updated the OP with why there shouldn't be any book talk in this thread. Essentially, some people plan to read the books and don't want any differences spoiled.
 

louisacommie

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,073
New Jersey
Should there just be a book thread, or a book thread with no show talk and a separate 3rd thread for show and book talk like at the old place?
 

Einchy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
26,123
For me it has been.

6 > 4 > Last few episodes of season 5 > 3 > 2 > 1 > first episodes of season 5.

Season 5 is a lot better on re-watch, though. It's a slower burn that's helped when you don't have to wait each week, also, Dorne has barely any scenes in it and the only bad parts are a sum total of 2, which are still bad, but 2 scenes in a ten episode season isn't too bad. Still not sure where I'd put season 7, even though I ended up seeing it 3 times over whole it aired since I watched it with 2 people at 2 different times, and once by myself. I think because season 7 was supposed to just be ten episodes originally and no season 8, I think they couldn't really end season 7 with a ton of events, like in season 6, and also because a lot of the characters were together, you couldn't have an ending for Sansa and Arya, since their endings belong to both characters, same with Dany and Jon. Thought it wasn't my favorite and I was disappointed with a few things, I still thought it was a pretty damn great season and I'd put it maybe somewhere around 4-ish.
 

Einchy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
26,123
Should there just be a book thread, or a book thread with no show talk and a separate 3rd thread for show and book talk like at the old place?
I'd think it would be best to have a general thread for book readers, like how /r/asoif does it, so they can compare and contrast the show with the book, also, that way we're not split between 3 threads.
 
OP
OP
ComputerBlue

ComputerBlue

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,498
For me it has been.

6 > 4 > Last few episodes of season 5 > 3 > 2 > 1 > first episodes of season 5.

Season 5 is a lot better on re-watch, though. It's a slower burn that's helped when you don't have to wait each week, also, Dorne has barely any scenes in it and the only bad parts are a sum total of 2, which are still bad, but 2 scenes in a ten episode season isn't too bad. Still not sure where I'd put season 7, even though I ended up seeing it 3 times over whole it aired since I watched it with 2 people at 2 different times, and once by myself. I think because season 7 was supposed to just be ten episodes originally and no season 8, I think they couldn't really end season 7 with a ton of events, like in season 6, and also because a lot of the characters were together, you couldn't have an ending for Sansa and Arya, since their endings belong to both characters, same with Dany and Jon. Thought it wasn't my favorite and I was disappointed with a few things, I still thought it was a pretty damn great season and I'd put it maybe somewhere around 4-ish.
This might be the first time I've seen someone rate the first season as their worst.

You're right about S5 being better on re-watch. I like it more and more each time I watch it, something I noticed with my most recent viewing though is how dark and depressing it is. Yeah, the show has been like that since the start, but S5 is really just depressing for nearly every character. Arya probably the least but even hers ends poorly.
 

RustyNails

Member
Oct 26, 2017
9,197
Season 7 is an absolute blast. But I have t rate 6 a little higher because of 7's pacing issues. BoB and Hardhome are still to beat.
 

Heshinsi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,949
Since us book readers are known for being salty, I've been thinking about this one:

a song of ice and fire | OT | the night is dark and full of bitterness
This actually describes my book reader buddy to a T. Season 5 broke him, and whenever people ask me why I won't read the books, I just point to him and go, "yeah, I don't want any of that negativity in my life."
 

yunbuns

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
1,090
Utlimecia's Castle
This actually describes my book reader buddy to a T. Season 5 broke him, and whenever people ask me why I won't read the books, I just point to him and go, "yeah, I don't want any of that negativity in my life."
Most of the GoT YT channels I watched were book readers so I do think their criticisms rubbed on my before I even decided to read the first book. I feel that it's easier to just accept that the show is it's own thing and watch it for the spectacle (even if some things still bother me),
 

impact

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
5,380
Tampa
Season 7 is an absolute blast. But I have t rate 6 a little higher because of 7's pacing issues. BoB and Hardhome are still to beat.
Hardhome was 5, and the only thing saving that season from being a total disaster.

I say 6>7 even from a pure entertainment standpoint. Tower of Joy, Bran visions/not being a robot, BotB and the finale. 7 was just like... "hey member dragons" and a bunch of reunions. One win the show will always have is Beric though, who just makes every scene he's in amazing.
 

Hydrus

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,754

I'm in. Let's make magic happen! I'm just gonna jump right into it:



Day 60 without GoT:


Day 61 without GoT:


Nice work with the OP Vala... I mean ComputerBlue.

 
Last edited:

Hydrus

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,754
Yea!! I'm so happy to see everyone back in one spot!

Gonna be a hell of a wait. I'm not sure I will survive.
It will be tough. I will do my best to keep discussions going. Also you can always rewatch the series like I'm doing. One episode per week. I'm following the reddit schedule. It's making the wait MUCH easier. Now then:

Day 62 without GoT:
Brand new Special message from the Mother of Dragons herself !
https://twitter.com/SusanCalman/status/924165852487876609

Gonna miss Emilia Clarke as Daenerys :( Also this confirms she's gonna use a wig this season and not go with her natural hair, like some speculated when she dyed it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.