"Gaming Culture" is toxic - Gamers AREN'T Good

JEFFREY GRUBB

GamesBeat.com reporter
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
786
Gamergate was a clusterfuck but it was pretty well documented that at least a portion of the shitty harassing, death threats, etc bascially all the bad shit attributed to GG was people trolling who didnt give a shit either way.

Not only that but gaming has become one of the most popular forms of pop culture today. Who is considered a "gamer" and thus responsible for fixing this issue? My contribution to the gaming sphere is relegated to this board basically and thats it. Is it my responsibility to go out and.....do what exactly? Shame sexists and racists on the internet? Shout into the void of twitter only providing what most of these trolls and douches are looking for: an offended audience?
You don't have to do anything. Just don't dismiss fair criticisms.

"It was pretty well documented that at least a portion of the shitty harassing, death threats, etc bascially all the bad shit attributed to GG was people trolling who didnt give a shit either way."

OK... so, what? We should just forget about it? You're free to do that, but I'm not gonna blame anyone who wants to investigate why gaming was such a potent breeding ground for that kind of reactionary behavior.
 

Calibro

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,686
Belarus
This is whataboutism in the vein of "not all men." Gaming is clearly a subculture, it would be bizarre to claim otherwise. And it's wack to try to shut down criticism of a culture by pointing to the existence of broader sources of shitty behavior.
It's human nature, that's all. And we're all human, so this problem is everyone's problem, not just a problem of some subcultures.
 

Alexandros

Member
Oct 26, 2017
11,553
Problems cannot be actively fixed without first acknowledging a problem exists. Disease cannot be cured without first identifying the underlying cause. To believe otherwise is to live in a state of denial and a passive form of consent for the evil that people commit under the cover of willful ignorance.
I agree but I believe that the focus on gaming is not helping anyone identify the correct underlying cause. All the issues being discussed regarding toxicity in gaming do not originate from gaming or gamer culture. They are deeply rooted issues with society and self respect, gaming is merely another outlet just like social media bullying and harassment or sports violence and other similar phenomena.
 

Deleted member 1258

User Requested Account Closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
2,914
To me I think its like saying "there is something toxic with Muslim culture" because Islamic Terrorism exists. That statement is damaging and false, and it is perfectly right to outright say 'Not All Muslims' in that context.
This is nowhere close to being equivalent to criticizing gaming culture. Gaming isn't a thousand year old religion that has shaped societies and built traditions. It's a hobby people often take way too damn seriously at times.
 

Professor Beef

Official ResetEra™ Chao Puncher
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,855
The Digital World
You don’t believe there is a stonger undercurrent of super toxic persecution complex in hardcore gamers? Have you ever read the Internet my good sir?

Gamers feel they need to justify and defend their prefered medium, and become wrapped up in a trying to defend sexist ad campaigns because people are attacking them- I mean their past time.

jesus christ i just vomited all over my screen
 

sensui-tomo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,871
I don't view it that way. It is more a way of saying one bad apple doesn't spoil the whole bunch. It is a valid viewpoint and it doesn't ignore the fact that there is a problem.
Problem is that it isn't a few bad apples , like a field of trees just producing these bad apples with few good ones (same analogy applies to cops in the USA )
 

Calibro

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,686
Belarus
As a gaming enthusiast board we are obviously more invested in gaming as a community and as such we obviously have more of a focus on that than all of humanity. Saying "oh it's just a problem with people in general" is just one more contributor to accepting the BS that occurs within gaming spaces (which just contributes to making humanity worse). It's basically establishing a self-fulfilling prophecy when people espouse trivialities like "it's a problem everywhere". That sort of rhetoric needs to be expunged.
Why though? What I'm saying is you have to deal with this everywhere, in every aspect of your life, not just gaming.
 

Tiber

Member
Nov 1, 2017
1,114
The human race as a whole cant be defined as either good or bad.

Why the hell would the small % of that species who talk about videos games on twitter all fall under one category?
 

JEFFREY GRUBB

GamesBeat.com reporter
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
786
Why though? What I'm saying is you have to deal with this everywhere, in every aspect of your life, not just gaming.
This is so strange! People are dealing with it in gaming, and you are saying "no -- don't deal with it in gaming, deal with it everywhere." But gaming is part of everywhere. Dealing with it everywhere would inherently mean addressing it within gaming.
 

CloseTalker

Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,557
I love video games and forums like this with all my heart, but gaming easily has one of the most volatile fandoms out there.
 

maximumzero

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,183
New Orleans, LA
Do you play games on a dedicated platform? Do you play more types of games than the yearly Madden or COD?

Yes?

Congrats, you are a gamer. It's nothing to be ashamed about. It's bad if you feel shameful for being who you are.
I consume as many videogames as I do movies, tv shows, music, books, and other forms of media. There's no reason I should identify myself as someone that enjoys one more than the other.
 

Jersey_Tom

Member
Dec 2, 2017
3,977
I think the bigger point here is that gamers are so coddled and they choose the media personalities that are least likely to criticize them.

The most popular people on YouTube for example all echo this same basic mentality:
  • Everything wrong with the gaming industry? Only the greedy publishers are guilty.
  • Never will we hear a word of even slight criticism of the gamer -- they are all perfect, blessed little angels.
  • Please, allow me to spin reality to justify your asinine outrage so you can continue your righteous gamer crusade in the comment section and in a game developer's twitter mentions.
Gamers overall aren't that bad, but there is plenty about the people who identify as "gamers" that is worth criticizing. But the issue is that those people seek out an echo chamber that will freak out if you suggest even a whiff of criticism.
Eh I don’t know.

I can’t speak to “every popular You Tuber” but from my vantage point I’ve seen plenty of criticism over individuals who’ve been toxic examples of the community. There was a fair bit of backlash, not just from this board mind you, over the xQc controversy from the Overwatch League over his homophobic comments and general as I’ll call it douchebaggery. PewDiPie is another one for his tastelessness was heavily criticized not only for the damage he was doing to himself but for all of You Tube’s personalities and gamers alike. Cheaters and other poor examples of friendly competition in the community are often called out.

I don’t think any rational personality on You Tube takes the stance that gamers are perfect little angels. Hell, even as irrational as Sterling can be, he spent two-three minutes on a disclaimer telling people not to go after Extra Credits as he was making a “kinda-sorta” response video to one they made and ultimately I believe said that he doesn’t trust people not to bug out and fill up their page with hate because of how rabid some gamers can be. Though in fairness that could be as much the fault of the personalities as it is their fans, I give you that and is part of Twitch’s new community guidelines for a reason. But as far as it being totally widespread the notion that gamers are all angels? I just haven’t had that experience.
 

More_Badass

Member
Oct 25, 2017
20,917
If I disagree with your usage of the word "huge" there, I will get banned and labeled as a racist, transphobe, and sexist. We not only can't disagree with that statement, we can't even disagree on the degree to which it is true.

And after I get banned for suggesting that "huge" might be an overstatement, how exactly do you think my opinions will then be affected? Which people will I then turn to have discussions? Who's opinions will I then cheer in public? Who's words will seem more reasonable? Who's company will I then keep? You want to know where the toxicity comes from in the gaming community? Look around you. You guys are just complaining that people don't actually go away when you ostracize them. What the fuck is wrong with them!? You already banned them! Why didn't they go crawl in a hole and die?
If getting banned from a forum is so scarring that it makes change your opinions in such a drastic way, just maybe the problem isn’t with the community you got banned from
 

julian

Member
Oct 27, 2017
11,218
The only thing GamerGate taught me was that gamers are truly self loathing. Even when, as you point out, it is shown that GamerGate was pushed and manipulated by the far right to sow divisiveness, you still buy into the narrative that there is something inherently worse about gaming culture than the culture at large. You are perfectly showing why gamers were such an easy target. It’s not because we actually are misogynist racist assholes, it’s because we are self loathing dorks who think so little of ourselves that even when it is shown how we were manipulated, we continue to think the worst of ourselves.

That doesn’t mean there aren’t serious issues within gaming, or that we shouldn’t be bettering ourselves, but the disparity between gaming and culture at large is blown completely out of proportion.
 

Deleted member 9971

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
9,743
While gaming is big to me i agree the toxic part of the community is just truly one of the worst, i try to avoid that plague at all costs.

Some of the twitter communities and reddit subs and more are just the worst. And then theres 4chan and way more too.

Lbgtq and more "minority" (i hate this word tbh) people get ridiculed, women get talked about as if they are objects and more dehumanising things.

Then theres huge racism and ridiculing of mental issues generalizing terms as autistic and callin people such terms . Flaming, trolling. Attacking devs for not getting what they want or callin in swat teams on streamers and more crazy things.

Yeah.... That's why i try my best to stay away from that part.

I am sure i missed lots of things still.
Can't people just not ya know.... Be nice? And respect others.
 

-PXG-

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
6,186
NJ


Still applicable today. But I'd change it a bit:

Fan driven hobby + tools that enable instant global communication + anonymity = X probability of someone being an asshole
 

Doof

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,434
Kentucky
While gaming is big to me i agree the toxic part of the community is just truly one of the worst, i try to avoid that plague at all costs.

Some of the twitter communities and reddit subs and more are just the worst. And then theres 4chan and way more too.

Lbgtq and more "minority" (i hate this word tbh) people get ridiculed, women get talked about as if they are objects and more dehumanising things.

Then theres huge racism and ridiculing of mental issues generalizing terms as autistic and callin people such terms . Flaming, trolling. Attacking devs for not getting what they want or callin in swat teams on streamers and more crazy things.

Yeah.... That's why i try my best to stay away from that part.

I am sure i missed lots of things still.
Like, I'm sure that I only feel this way because I'm on the spectrum, but the autism shit pisses me off something fierce. It's really not funny, and I see otherwise progressive people use terms like "sperg" and "tism", and it's really disappointing.
 

Professor Beef

Official ResetEra™ Chao Puncher
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,855
The Digital World
Do you play games on a dedicated platform? Do you play more types of games than the yearly Madden or COD?

Yes?

Congrats, you are a gamer. It's nothing to be ashamed about. It's bad if you feel shameful for being who you are.
if someone called me a gamer to my face, i'd probably slap their shit

i'm just a guy that likes video games, end of story
 

saenima

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
11,944
THAT'S NOT THE POINT. STOP TRYING TO MAKE IT THE POINT.
But that is THEIR point. It's their way of shifting the conversation from topics they can't openly defend to some other disingenuous bullshit. And repeat until conversation becomes impossible.

To the point of thread, 'gamer culture' is garbage.
 
Oct 25, 2017
17,537

Nah, Gamers can be trash who don't give an active shit about the people who make the games and the conditions they work in.

The #gamersaregood shit is just minimizing shitty behavior is the gaming fandom.
 

Deleted member 419

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,009
We are not all good, and it's about time we as a collective acknowledge that fact. Only then can we begin to actually look for solutions for the hate that is afflicting us.
We should already be looking for solutions. It's pointless to wait until the "collective" acknowledges there's a problem. That will never happen and if everyone involved just spends their time blowing hot air at each other trying to argue the point, there will never be progress because we've predicated actually doing anything on some vague expectation that at some point we'll reach a consensus first.

I don't mean to single you out OP but this is a problem with a lot of activism nowadays and with social media activism in general. A lot of talking and not a lot of doing. There need to be high-profile campaigns requesting Sony and Microsoft more strictly regulate and punish offensive behavior in online interactions. That is a more substantive step towards progress. Arguing with idiots on Twitter accomplishes nothing.
 

Htown

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,144
Literally every fandom is terrible.
yes but gaming fandom is especially terrible, and this is shit we need to deal with

going "yeah but there are bad people everywhere" is useless and overlooks the unique problems in gaming culture

just think about all the shit that is just expected and treated as background noise in the gaming community

look at voice chat for example. like, you just EXPECT that if people are talking in an online game, you're gonna hear some vile shit a good percentage of the time, and everybody's just like "yeah that's just the way it is, just mute or only play with people you know in real life"

what? why is that acceptable? that's not even the way people in most fandoms or subcultures talk to each other, let alone society at large
 

Gentlemen

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,820


Still applicable today. But I'd change it a bit:

Fan driven hobby + tools that enable instant global communication + anonymity = X probability of someone being an asshole
No, this 'theory' was proven inaccurate by the very people who wrote and drew the comic. There is no 'Normal Person' in this equation, it's just an asshole with an audience. Look at Facebook or Twitter for example, loads of awful, awful people empowered by a big following, using their real names and faces and everything, spending their professional lives making other people (typically minority members in orbit of 'their' territorial claims on gamer culture) as miserable as possible.

And the reason to discuss this as a problem within the gaming community as opposed to "It's just human nature" is because it makes it easier to tackle. Gaming communities are generally private spaces, controlled by relatively small numbers of people in a position of authority to change the culture or begin excluding the worst elements of it. Abstracting the discussion to "it's like this everywhere" reads like it shrugs off all responsibility for a change to a better tomorrow.
 

sensui-tomo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,871
I want to be able to use chat/voice on console games again without worrying i'll hear people spout racism or other shit. Gaming culture doesnt allow people this luxury and with some people in this thread, never want to talk about it means it never will happen.
 

Deleted member 4044

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,121
Great thread as well as initial points in the OP. It's been pretty clear since the Mass Effect 3 ending debacle that gaming culture has serious issues. Since then, it's like the culture/community has been looking for the next big opportunity for outrage - XBox One initial reveal, SimCity, Witcher 3 downgrade, loot boxes, and so on. All of these events deserved criticism, but there is a difference between criticism and outright hostility. Gaming culture veers too closely to hostility too often on these.
 

4859

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,817
In the weak and the wounded
You don't have to do anything. Just don't dismiss fair criticisms.

"It was pretty well documented that at least a portion of the shitty harassing, death threats, etc bascially all the bad shit attributed to GG was people trolling who didnt give a shit either way."

OK... so, what? We should just forget about it? You're free to do that, but I'm not gonna blame anyone who wants to investigate why gaming was such a potent breeding ground for that kind of reactionary behavior.
Really? because you REAAAAAAALLY didn't want to talk about the corporate culture that cultivates that shit the other day.
 

Squidi

Banned
Oct 29, 2017
120
Member banned (permanently): Admitting to be a member of a hate group and openly advocating for it. Persistent downplaying of racism, sexism, homophobia etc.
You might be a little too hung up with the idea that disagreeing will get you banned.
I already have been. Twice. Once, I was banned for "sexism argumentation" for quoting Amy Henning and saying that my experience in the game industry suggested that the game industry is not as sexist as is being reported, and once for racism for saying that someone had the legal right to use the "n-word".

And if you don't believe me:

I am a member of GamerGate. I am willing to have a discussion about GamerGate, the gaming community, game journalism, white supremacy, harassment, or anything else. I feel like GamerGate has been incorrectly maligned and is the victim of a smear campaign by the very group of journalists it was originally created as a response to. There are a lot of misconceptions that I feel like I could clear up in a discussion. I will respectfully listen and respond, though I will not always agree or see eye to eye on particular subjects. And where we agree, it's possible that I may disagree on the extent to which we agree. But I will guarantee a civil discussion, at least on my end, in which no rules will be broken and all participants are treated with dignity and respect.
 

sibarraz

One Winged Slayer
Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
14,172
I feel like gaming culture is toxic for something that goes beyond your political beliefs. Even here, where we clearly are leftist from the most part, still show toxic tendencies while discussing games, or anything in general.

I don't know if this is related with videogames per se, nerd culture in general, or our own issues leading us to get obsessive with a hobby
 
Nov 22, 2017
338
Some of those gamers like football too and maybe the same movies as everyone.
It's not just specific to "gamers", it's people.
Being "anonymous" on the internet just allows them to express those things and not only at their local pub but all over the world so now we get the impression that their are more of those assholes...
It was always here..
 

Deleted member 12186

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,467
The anonymity definitely has people act out of the ordinary and push their luck with people online and vent. If I have numerous bad experiences with whomever, people usually try dismissing it like it does not happen. The R6 community in general(not saying 100% obviously) can be pretty toxic and the discrimination and harassment which can lead to team killing is pretty common and expected. I know I'll have people come in and tell me the people are so helpful and so on, but those people are far and few comparative to the others. For myself, I try to counter that in the game and I usually am met with surprise that someone could say or behave the way I do(especially considering my experience). I tend to pair up with friends too so the occasional random that is apart of the team ends up getting whatever they need(patience, fun, guidance, etc).

That's the only way to do anything about these type of things. Set an example.

Unfortunately for me, I have had bad experiences with Destiny 2. I don't have people I know on there anymore so I had to find random people for raids(the prestige one in particular). The amount of elitism and looking after your own arbitrary shit(like their completions their stats and overall looking superior to others) is baffling. People are rarely patient and expect perfection. On numerous occasions I had to defend people because others wanted them to figure things out when funnily enough that said person didn't know either and others on the team were patient with them. We had a guy be all humble because he didn't know what to do, but when he eventually beat it with other people and he came back this dude was yelling at everyone.

My experiences on PS4 itself is weird too, I feel like I get an abnormal amount of hate mail. When I tried doing youtube....considering I get like 0-4 viewers(hehe), I still somehow got people telling me to kill myself and all sorts of other nonsense. None of that stuff helps a guy like me with a pretty unsatisfactory life, so in the case of R6, I just play when my friends are on now.

Sorry, I needed to vent all that...
 

Nairume

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,479


Still applicable today. But I'd change it a bit:

Fan driven hobby + tools that enable instant global communication + anonymity = X probability of someone being an asshole
Is it really applicable? The past several years has made it perfectly clearly that people are more than happy being fuckwads without anonymity hiding them.

Even the guy who drew this has no issues occasionally being a fuckwad despite being a public figure.
 

CaptNink

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,061
B.C, Canada
It's basically Twitter, which is a playground for utter wallies.

We've created a mode of communication that strips all the joy, nuance, laughter, kindness, honesty, profundity and dignity out of human communication and replaced it with revolting, shrieking pettiness, cruelty, malice and spite. It's awful.
Very well put! Agree 100%
 

spman2099

Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,069
So, most game forums that aren't heavily moderated, degrade into something awful and ugly very quickly. I have other hobbies and nothing else is comparable. There is a problem that is more apparent in gaming than in most other hobbies.
 

Deleted member 135

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
11,682
I consume as many videogames as I do movies, tv shows, music, books, and other forms of media. There's no reason I should identify myself as someone that enjoys one more than the other.
There is a much higher barrier of entry for dedicated gaming than music, movies, and books. If you are playing on a Switch that's $300 minimum plus the price of each game which is an average of $60.
 

okayfrog

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,968
If I disagree with your usage of the word "huge" there, I will get banned and labeled as a racist, transphobe, and sexist. We not only can't disagree with that statement, we can't even disagree on the degree to which it is true.

And after I get banned for suggesting that "huge" might be an overstatement, how exactly do you think my opinions will then be affected? Which people will I then turn to have discussions? Who's opinions will I then cheer in public? Who's words will seem more reasonable? Who's company will I then keep? You want to know where the toxicity comes from in the gaming community? Look around you. You guys are just complaining that people don't actually go away when you ostracize them. What the fuck is wrong with them!? You already banned them! Why didn't they go crawl in a hole and die?
This is all very true.

People want to talk with others on the internet. If they get banned from one place for their opinions, they'll hop somewhere where their opinions are accepted, which can then lead to them developing even more toxic opinions.

It's a tricky situation.