• The GiftBot 2.0 Launch Giveaway Extravaganza has come to a close with an astounding 8073 games given away to the community by 696 members, a huge success thanks to you! The gifting now continues with more official prizes in the new Gaming Giveaways |OT|. Leftover Steam codes are also being given away to the PC Gaming Era community.

Halo tv show is now in production

DemonCarnotaur

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,646
So, episode 1 of the Mandalorian is out, and the lead character never once is without a helmet -- I feel like this is a good proof of concept for MC in this series.

Stinkles - any chance reactions to that character could help sell MC mostly wearing his armor/helmet.
 

Tawpgun

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,859
I am extremely weirded out by the reactions of this thread that a human raised by the covenant is in some way breaking established lore.

two very important things.

1. In the books Jackals have traded with human insurrectionist outposts. This was not approved by the actual covenant. But it does set a bit of a precedent.

2. As people have pointed out, only humans can interact with some key forerunner tech. The covenant needed to use both Miranda and Johnson to activate certain forerunner things. Wouldn't it make a LOT of sense to basically raise a human to act as your forerunner key instead of relying on reluctant prisoners?

Also can someone please point to me where it was said this was going to be non-canon? Nothing I've seen so far indicate that its going to be non-cannon. This takes place before Halo CE/Reach is all I can surmise just from the characters alone.
 

Kalentan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,531
I am extremely weirded out by the reactions of this thread that a human raised by the covenant is in some way breaking established lore.

two very important things.

1. In the books Jackals have traded with human insurrectionist outposts. This was not approved by the actual covenant. But it does set a bit of a precedent.

2. As people have pointed out, only humans can interact with some key forerunner tech. The covenant needed to use both Miranda and Johnson to activate certain forerunner things. Wouldn't it make a LOT of sense to basically raise a human to act as your forerunner key instead of relying on reluctant prisoners?
--
1. Jackals always played fast and loose and not all Jackals were in the covenant, many were pirates before and after the Covenant brought them on board.

2. But you don't see the problem with that? The Prophets wanted to wipe out humanity to prevent the Covenant from realizing that Humans were declared as the Reclaimers. By choosing to raise a human they're acknowledging their own bullshit in front of everyone.
 

Einchy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
27,420
I was starting to feel like this was never gonna happen. Again.

For a second there I was bummed that this show isn't considered canon but then I thought, "what even is the Halo canon?".
 

Tawpgun

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,859
2. But you don't see the problem with that? The Prophets wanted to wipe out humanity to prevent the Covenant from realizing that Humans were declared as the Reclaimers. By choosing to raise a human they're acknowledging their own bullshit in front of everyone.
Ok but where does it say that the rest of the covenant know about her?

What is also so weird about them keeping one for themselves for some other reason. There are a multitude of possible explanations the covenant can give to justify it and its still a super weird thing to get hung up on before we know the details.

If she is going to covenant school and having playdates with the other covenant kids or something like that than yeah I might see an issue too.
 

Prinz Eugn

Member
Oct 25, 2017
768
1. Jackals always played fast and loose and not all Jackals were in the covenant, many were pirates before and after the Covenant brought them on board.

2. But you don't see the problem with that? The Prophets wanted to wipe out humanity to prevent the Covenant from realizing that Humans were declared as the Reclaimers. By choosing to raise a human they're acknowledging their own bullshit in front of everyone.
Yeah, considering we've seen big internal divisions and lots of political infighting within the Covenant in the canon, it's definitely not hard to imagine some it's some prophet's secret project to raise some human kid to push magic space buttons.
 

Samurai G0SU

Member
Nov 2, 2017
3,576
Denver, CO
1. Jackals always played fast and loose and not all Jackals were in the covenant, many were pirates before and after the Covenant brought them on board.

2. But you don't see the problem with that? The Prophets wanted to wipe out humanity to prevent the Covenant from realizing that Humans were declared as the Reclaimers. By choosing to raise a human they're acknowledging their own bullshit in front of everyone.
your relationship to halo is pure negative. lol holy crap. why even bother fueling that fire still?

yikes
 

Kalentan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,531
your relationship to halo is pure negative. lol holy crap. why even bother fueling that fire still?

yikes
...What the hell are you talking about? I love Halo, I buy every book, nearly every game, and I made the lore OT both here and on the old forum. I have been wanting to play Halo Infinite every day since they announced it. I've been critical of 343i but generally have loved many of the things they have done in the universe.
 

Samurai G0SU

Member
Nov 2, 2017
3,576
Denver, CO
...What the hell are you talking about? I love Halo, I buy every book, nearly every game, and I made the lore OT both here and on the old forum. I have been wanting to play Halo Infinite every day since they announced it. I've been critical of 343i but generally have loved many of the things they have done in the universe.
well from that comment it appeared that you really hated halo and needed to express that vent.
 

Kalentan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,531
i didnt know you were looking forward to for years. lol i dont even know your post history except what i see in this converation and thread - more specifically what i quoted lol. but okay LOL the anger rises again!
...Then don't assume. You made a huge judgement based on one discussion and then got defensive when I told you it wasn't true.
 

Samurai G0SU

Member
Nov 2, 2017
3,576
Denver, CO
...Then don't assume. You made a huge judgement based on one discussion and then got defensive when I told you it wasn't true.
This convo is about the show. You have expressed your anger toward it. I replied and then you tried to justify it by calling it “criticism” because you bought x, y, z ... and that your opinion of being angry is more right than others ?? because of your personal investment in halo??

I guess I’m defensive? Idk ? about what? Being off base? Idk what that really even means in this conversation but I really don’t care. I just wanted to highlight your anger you have over a show that isn’t even out yet. Lol
 

Kalentan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,531
This convo is about the show. You have expressed your anger toward it. I replied and then you tried to justify it by calling it “criticism” because you bought x, y, z ... and that your opinion of being angry is more right than others ?? because of your personal investment in halo??

I guess I’m defensive? Idk ? about what? Being off base? Idk what that really even means in this conversation but I really don’t care. I just wanted to highlight your anger you have over a show that isn’t even out yet. Lol
When did I say that my opinion was more right than others? If you can quote me somewhere of me saying that, then please do as I literally never said once that was the case.

The only reason why I brought up my investment in the series is because you described my relationship to Halo as being "pure negative" because I happened to criticize this one thing.

Also should there simply no criticism? Should a product need to be out before one can say anything bad about it?
 

Gundam

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,601
I dunno, maybe wait to see the particular implementation to get angry about it? We have super vague plot details and casting. Basically, nothing.

I was starting to feel like this was never gonna happen. Again.

For a second there I was bummed that this show isn't considered canon but then I thought, "what even is the Halo canon?".
“not as deep as some people would have you think”