Late to the party, but I will say that I VIVIDLY remember my first experience with Silent Hill.
My local game rental store had a copy of Silent Hill 1. I had already beasted games like Resident Evil 1 and 3, Parasite Eve, Dino Crisis, and Clock Tower. I thought I "knew" survival horror games at this point, so I was eager to try a new one.
The very first second was promising.
The opening FMV grabbed me instantly. Akira Yamaoka's music is permanently lodged in my brain. The tone is set, and apart from being impressed by the FMV quality, the game's atmosphere is keenly unlike any survival horror game I've played thus far.
Then the game begins proper. Harry wakes up, surrounded by fog. Now, I had grown to detest fog as a graphical limitation in games like Turok and Nightmare Creatures, so I immediately felt this was just a limitation of the PS1.
But I soon started getting that claustrophobic feeling as my surroundings were obscured and I realized much of the fog was used intentionally. At any rate, I move forward and see Cheryl and begin to give chase. At this point, I fully believed most of the game was going to take place in the streets, in the gray fog. I start forward down the alleyway, past the fence with the "beware of dog" sign. "Great," I say, "zombie dogs, like Resident Evil. How original."
And then...
Geez. Okay, nothing has attacked me, and that dog is clearly not coming back. Some shocking gore and violence at the start, nothing out of the ordinary. I continue...
A siren blares in the distance. The gray fog fades, shrouding the alley in a thick, permeating darkness barely illuminated by Harry's road flare. I creep forward...
Things seem "off". The noises are unsettling. I hear clanging and pounding metal. The siren still blaring, the music starting to grow in intensity...
Soon, I start coming across bodies, drenched in blood, rusty metal fencing and grates, demonic howls filling the air. I'm still chasing after my little girl, but the whole world seems to be shifting out of reality into a horrific nightmare. I move down the maze-like passageway, which defies logic and sense, until...
Flayed bodies skewered with razor wire, maggots crawling across the floor, rain pouring down from a blackened sky over red metal and dripping meat... and then they come for me.
Dozens of them, slashing madly at me. I'm defenseless, no weapon or gun to fend them off. I panic and run, retracing my steps to the exit only to discover the way back is now blocked. "There has to be another way out!" I tell myself, frantically heading back down the alley as the malformed creatures lunge at me. There isn't. I'm soon overwhelmed, trapped in a corner, as they wash over me and kill me. "Well THAT was a quick game over..." I say to myself.
And then Harry wakes up.
I'm in a diner. Things seem normal-ish. The town is still empty, but Officer Cybil introduces herself and says she's stranded here too and that something strange is going on. I'm still trying to figure out if it was ALL a dream or what as she departs, handing me a gun that makes me feel empowered (for a brief moment). She takes her leave to help me locate my daughter. I take a breath. Okay, the game is going to obviously have more monsters, but I have a gun now, and for the moment I'm safe in this foggy version of the town, INDOORS, where it's safe and sound and...
Huh? Radio. What's going on with that radio? I'd better just...
... And at that moment, I became a Silent Hill fan for life.