I’m so sick of Dogs getting Killed in Movies

SOLDIER

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 26, 2017
7,589
Are you watching a horror movie right now?

Is there a dog in it?

Congratulations! That dog is going to get horribly murdered!

You can apply this to thrillers too. Heck, not even R-rated movies. A PG-13 thriller by M Knight or Spielberg? They totally have no problems brutalizing Man’s Best Friend to a crowd of moviegoers.

It used to be a joke that the minority character is the one who gets axed. Scream 2 opened up with characters literally commenting about this. But now dogs have taken over the cliche victim role with astonishing certainty. It would be easier to list the movies where this doesn’t happen, and I don’t think I could come up with more than two.

It’s bad enough to see this keep happening as an avid dog lover, but it’s especially repulsive when they use this excuse to show an incredibly gruesome death because, like, it’s an animal so it’s okay, right? The dog’s death in V/H/S 2, for example, left me visibly upset for almost a day and a half because of how gratuitous it was, the camera zooming in on the poor creature as it cried out during its final agonizing moments.

And I recently experienced this again with The Wailing, a Korean horror movie on Netflix that was recommended by this very board. The movie is totally fine except for the part where

a flock of birds start eating away at a dying dog’s flesh. As in, it’s still alive and crying while the crows peck away at it

I’m seriously tired of it. It’s such an eye-rolling cliche at this point, it’s probably the most cliched trope in the history of cinema even. When are filmmakers going to ease up? It’s pretty much 1000% guaranteed that fido is going to have a rough time.
 

Lost

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,108
Everyone loves dogs.

It’s an easy way to get the audience emotionally invested.
 

Platy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
21,900
Brazil
There is a site where you can just look for specific things that triggers your anxiety and the site STARTED because of this

https://doesthedogdie.com

These days you can search for most phobias, more than one animal dying, lgbt people dying, harassment and even if anyone tells that santa is not real


edit: beaten because of a lonmg description =P
 

Violence Jack

Member
Oct 25, 2017
20,813
Friday the 13th Part 2
The Lost Boys
Gremlins
Silence of the Lambs

Those are the only horror films I can recall from the top of my head where the dog doesn’t die. But most of the dog deaths are offscreen that I know of.
 

MigrantOwl

Self-Requested Ban
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
231
Violence against any animal is really the only way I'm guaranteed to cry watching a movie. I think Hollywood knows this and they are plotting against me.
 

Plum

Member
May 31, 2018
12,859
This trope ruined "The Lobster" for me, that and another scene where someone falls from a window (if you've seen the movie you know the one). It turned what should have been a mildly amusing surrealist comedy into something just thoroughly... unpleasant. Like, what the fuck does showing that achieve other than to make people feel bad?
 

SatoAilDarko

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,416
I've never been shaken by an animal dying in films but I do not like innocent people getting killed but it's just part of the film's story and shows a deadly force.
 

Volimar

volunteer forum janitor
Member
Oct 25, 2017
21,863
This trope ruined "The Lobster" for me, that and another scene where someone falls from a window (if you've seen the movie you know the one). It turned what should have been a mildly amusing surrealist comedy into something just thoroughly... unpleasant. Like, what the fuck does showing that achieve other than to make people feel bad?

The Lobster is just a bizarre film all around. It's like a comedy that doesn't want you to laugh.
 
Oct 25, 2017
3,784
Yeah, this bothers me. Innocent people dying in movies makes me laugh, but can't deal with that shit when it's a dog.
 

Praxis

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,913
UK
When I was a kid I watched Turner and Hooch with my family. I started crying at the end and pretended to fall off the sofa and make out that was the reason I was crying, my mum wasn't having any of it though and just called me an asshole and laughed.
 

Plum

Member
May 31, 2018
12,859
The Lobster is just a bizarre film all around. It's like a comedy that doesn't want you to laugh.
If it had gone for the same kind of tone as "Under the Skin" (which itself had one of the most disturbing sequences I've ever seen in a film) scenes like the ones I described it would have worked, but as it is right now it's like this weird mish-mash that wants to make you laugh but wants you to feel genuinely uncomfortable at the same time. I can see how it might work for some people but it really did not work for me. I've yet to see the director's newer film (Killing of a Sacred Deer IIRC) but, knowing it's similar to The Lobster, I'm really not sure whether I want to.

You're not sick of humans dying though? Are you a psycho OP? :P
I know this is tongue-in-cheek but there is a genuine difference there, especially when it comes to people who own dogs themselves. When you're watching a film like 2012 you can see literally thousands of people dying horribly on-screen yet it's meant to still be a fun action (meant, not is, because that film's crap) movie, whereas a film would never, ever aim to make an action scene out of a dog (or kid)'s death. Maybe that's because we're all horrible people but I think it's just that (most) people are simply more inherently empathetic to those we know are both 100% innocent and, I think more importantly, naive to why they're in the situation they're in or even what the situation is in the first place, and Hollywood uses that phenomena (for lack of a better term) to their advantage.
 

TheGummyBear

Member
Jan 6, 2018
2,219
United Kingdom
Killing dogs in movies triggers my anxiety. I can't handle it. Whenever it happens I eject the disc, or end the stream.

But I can understand why movie makers do it. Psychologically, people empathise with dogs, often on a deeper level than with humans. Some psychologists believe that their proportionately large eyes trigger humans to treat dogs like babies, which is why dogs pull "puppy eyes" to try and get their own way. We are wired to love them, so killing them is bound to shock and/or horrify us.

So I can't really tell anyone to stop doing it either. It's a simple psychological technique to get beneath our skin and get the reaction that they want.
 
Oct 26, 2017
12,072
Now I want someone to do a flip the script john wick.

Bark Wag

A story of a doggie whos owner is killed in a home invasion, and the robbers took the one toy to remember his human by.

This doggie goes for vengeance.

*howling intensifies*
 
OP
OP
SOLDIER

SOLDIER

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 26, 2017
7,589
Killing dogs in movies triggers my anxiety. I can't handle it. Whenever it happens I eject the disc, or end the stream.

But I can understand why movie makers do it. Psychologically, people empathise with dogs, often on a deeper level than with humans. Some psychologists believe that their proportionately large eyes trigger humans to treat dogs like babies, which is why dogs pull "puppy eyes" to try and get their own way. We are wired to love them, so killing them is bound to shock and/or horrify us.

So I can't really tell anyone to stop doing it either. It's a simple psychological technique to get beneath our skin and get the reaction that they want.
Which is why I would respect it a whole lot more if filmmakers worked to make their cardboard cutout humans more sympathetic instead.

Great recent example: Hereditary.

even though that one also had a doggie death
 

Jessie

Member
Oct 27, 2017
9,913
American Horror Story plays with this trope in season 1.
The dog is the only one who survives.

Then they play it straight with the guinea pig in season 7.
 

Feral

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,006
Your Mom
I don't think I ever had much of a reaction to watching an animal die on the screem
This trope ruined "The Lobster" for me, that and another scene where someone falls from a window (if you've seen the movie you know the one). It turned what should have been a mildly amusing surrealist comedy into something just thoroughly... unpleasant. Like, what the fuck does showing that achieve other than to make people feel bad?
the second half of the movie ruins The Lobster
 

BocoDragon

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
5,207
Isn't it actually that lots of creatures and humans die in every movie, and dogs are usually miraculously spared? I think you've found a bunch of exceptions to an old Hollywood rule that the dog usually survives.