• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Is Hidetaka Miyazaki the Best Game Creator of All Time?

  • Yes

    Votes: 547 18.3%
  • No, Shigeru Miyamoto is

    Votes: 1,641 54.9%
  • No, Hideo Kojima is

    Votes: 175 5.9%
  • No, John Carmack is

    Votes: 23 0.8%
  • No, Sid Meier is

    Votes: 27 0.9%
  • No, Shinji Mikami is

    Votes: 30 1.0%
  • No, Someone Not On This List is

    Votes: 544 18.2%

  • Total voters
    2,987
  • Poll closed .
Sep 21, 2019
2,594
I am in awe of Hidetaka Miyazaki. He had already cemented himself as one of gaming's greats before the release of Elden Ring.

His resume is staggering, and his work has evolved tremendously over time. Demon's Souls was iconic and sent ripples through the gaming industry. Dark Souls remains one of my top 5 favorite games, further refining Demon's Souls' mechanics and honing it into a diamond.

Bloodborne mixed things up with an incredible setting and combat that rewarded and encouraged aggression. No shields. A blunderbuss. Pure genius.

Dark Souls III was a further refinement to the Souls combat.

Sekiro changed things completely and gave the gaming community the best sword combat ever seen in a game. Absolutely genius.

And now Elden Ring. Elden Ring. What an achievement. It is a game that could only have been made with all the previous games listed above serving as templates for its sheer splendor.

But, like with every new game, Miyazaki and company have further bumped their game by creating one of, if not the best, open worlds ever created in a game.

What's even more remarkable...the turnaround time from the studio. I don't know how they do it. It blows my mind (insert joke about poor performance here).

In all seriousness, I think Miyazaki is the best game creator of all time. Elden Ring has sealed the deal for me. He has eclipsed the other greats in the industry on the sheer impact of his work and how he has evolved his vision over time and graced us with several of the best games ever created.

I'm curious. What are your thoughts and why?


Edit: I'm not saying Miyazaki is the most influential game creator. I understand that influences in any artform are built upon ideas and people and techniques that came before. I'm talking about the best games, most consistent in quality, etc. I understand how important Super Mario Bros, Legend of Zelda, etc are and played them often as a kid. Mario 64 is my favorite Miyamoto-directed game.

And I am aware that games are built by teams and not people.

But directors and their visions are what lead a project, so that's why I'm putting Miyazaki and not From, Miyamoto instead of Nintendo, etc.

Not trying to flame anything. For me, personally, I think Miyazaki is the best. And I love the discussion about legacy, variety, etc. It's interesting.
 
Last edited:

Arkanim94

Member
Oct 27, 2017
14,110
nah, I don't think there is one person that I would consider on top of everyone else.
 

Possum Armada

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,630
Greenville, SC
I know the Elden Ring hyperbole machine is in full force at the moment but this seems like a bit of a stretch. I think he makes good games, but they are all way too similar in my opinion to call him the best game creator of all time.
 

lucablight

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,551
He is most certainly a genius when it comes to creating games. Hasn't made anything less than amazing post Demons souls. He deserves to be talked about as one of the all time greats.
 

Goron3

Alt account
Banned
Nov 24, 2020
613
I've been thinking about this a lot recently and I'm inclined to agree.

The direction he went with Sekiro especially before bringing it back to a game like ER is pretty mind-blowing.
 

GhostTrick

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,304
Hard to say. The combat still is an issue and some basic 3D gameplay elements thar From Soft has to assimilate (like basic camera control or physics/hitbox)
 

Kain

Unshakable Resolve - One Winged Slayer
The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
7,598
I didn't like a single game he made not even one bit.
 

Biestmann

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,412
Maybe with all of these different genres, there shouldn't be just one best creator, but a good bunch we celebrate all the same?
 

Geobros

Member
Dec 31, 2018
670
Oh man....he is good but for few gamers. Miyamoto is the best of all time and he will be in the top for many many years.
 

Couleurs

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,350
Denver, CO
He's great at making one type of game repeatedly, but I would put Shigeru Miyamoto at the top due to the variety of his games and his longevity.
 
Last edited:

Shadoken

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,206
He hasn't shown the variety in genres like Yu Suzuki , Shinji Mikami , Miyamoto ...etc
But he's definitely up there , and probably one of the most influential devs in the Modern era.

Yu Suzuki is so underrated on here. Dude legit pioneered so many genres and 3D gaming itself.
Hang On
Space Harrier
Outrun
Virtua Racing
Virtua Fighter
Shennmue
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
redflamingolingo
Sep 21, 2019
2,594
I've been thinking about this a lot recently and I'm inclined to agree.

The direction he went with Sekiro especially before bringing it back to a game like ER is pretty mind-blowing.

This in particular is really striking to me. To be able to so purely conceive two games so close to each other yet so different and knock them both out of the park back to back...just no words.
 

Gavalanche

Prophet of Regret
Member
Oct 21, 2021
17,408
He is an incredible genius, but I don't think there is one person I would give the vote to. if they were making a mount rushmore of game directors he would be on the short list to get on there for sure, but I don't know... there are some really really talented individuals who changed gaming, especially in the earlier years.
 

Nazgûl

Banned
Dec 16, 2019
3,082
Maybe he is the best in the genre of which his games are.

But my opinion is worth shit cause I only know 2 names of that list. So I don't know
 
Last edited:

Artdayne

Banned
Nov 7, 2017
5,015
Nah, it's EA Tiburon, just look at how many incredibly good Madden games they've made over the years.
 

astro

Member
Oct 25, 2017
56,887
Elden Ring is my current favourite game. I have no idea how that will pan out over time, but as it's the first Souls I've ever been able to get into it will likely hold a speical place amongst them if I do go back and try the others.

It will likely make it into my top 10, too soon to tell.

There is no "greatest developer;", though all the ones you listed are great.
 

Griffith

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
5,585
Miyazaki's legacy is built upon the foundation of many other talented creators that came before him. Just as he benefits from the efforts of previous creators so too do new creators benefit from the unique things he added to his games.

I don't think there is such a thing as "the best game creator of all time", but I do think Miyazaki is one of the most influential contemporary creators.
 

Deleted member 68874

Account closed at user request
Banned
May 10, 2020
10,441
bdd.jpg
 

Pand

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
553
I think variety in gameplay ideas is an important factor in something like this, and Miyazaki hasn't really shown that as of yet. What he makes is brilliant, but he's a bit a of a one-trick pony.
 
Apr 3, 2020
2,638
The best game creator of all time? I don't believe such a title exists imo.

But one of the best game creator of all time?

Neither what I think, or anyone option means jackshit, his legacy speaks itself.
 

Shadoken

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,206
Miyazaki's legacy is built upon the foundation of many other talented creators that came before him. Just as he benefits from the efforts of previous creators so too do new creators benefit from the unique things he added to his games.

I don't think there is such a thing as "the best game creator of all time", but I do think Miyazaki is one of the most influential contemporary creators.

This.

Gaming isn't just 10 years old. It has a pretty long history that the term "All Time" is almost meaningless in most contexts.
 

NoobSauceG7

Member
Feb 7, 2022
1,518
He absolutely is since his games just don't miss. They are truly in a league of their own. Miyamoto and Kojima are up there for me too, but they both have had misses and frankly, Miyazaki's games I think are just better.
 

LabRat

Member
Mar 16, 2018
4,229
he's definitely up there with miyamoto, the housers, kojima, mikami etc as one of the greats
 

Hyun Sai

Member
Oct 27, 2017
14,562
He is the best at making me nauseous that's for sure. One day I'll be able to play Bloodborne.
 

POOPLE

Member
Aug 5, 2021
511
The Republic of Gamers
I still remember when Miyazaki pooped out Bloodborne fully formed all by himself i thought to myself, "wow this may be the greatest game creator of all time!" up there with Created and Directed by Hideo Kojima Surely!
 
Oct 26, 2017
7,294
Elden Ring and Dark Souls are probably in my top 10 games ever, but... no. It seems pretty obvious that Miyamoto is, and then there's a wide range of excellent craftsmen below him. Kojima and Mikami are more similar to Miyazaki, being excellent at a specific type of games. Carmack is more of a tech wizard who makes games almost incidentally. Sid Meier is probably one of the greats, but also hasn't really been creative in ages. Then there's people like Ueda and Fares who make stunningly emotional games that break new ground in terms of gameplay, but they haven't made enough games to really be that legendary yet.

I think it's very hard to catch up to Miyamoto because he was active in the most successful company at a time when you could push out several games a year and innovate all the time. When games take five years to make, even a genius don't have that many classics in them in the span of a career.
 

cowbanana

Member
Feb 2, 2018
13,663
a Socialist Utopia
Yes, probably.

At least I enjoy his team's games more than those of any other creator on that list.

Kojima is probably second for me. He's just so... extra.

Miyamoto is overrated in my opinion, his games never really did much for me.
 

big_z

Member
Nov 2, 2017
7,794
No. He found a formula that was fresh and interesting at the right time and has been mixing and matching the ingredients of that formula like a Taco Bell special since.
 

Stowaway Silfer

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 27, 2017
32,819
Hard to put someone over Miyamoto but Miyazaki is very impressive for how consistently and frequently he has directed some of the best video games of all time, this late into the industry's life where standards are so high. I don't know about all time, I think maybe there is a conversation, but he is pretty easily the best game director of the last 15 years.
 

8bit

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,390
Thes best game creator of all time should have a varied portfolio of differing genres, so, no.
 

Kida

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,899
Miyamoto is by far. Followed by another multi-genre visionary, Yu Suzuki.

Carmack, Kojima, Sakaguchi and Miyazaki would follow them.
 

Gavalanche

Prophet of Regret
Member
Oct 21, 2021
17,408
Yes, probably.

At least I enjoy his team's games more than those of any other creator on that list.

Kojima is probably second for me. He's just so... extra.

Miyamoto is overrated in my opinion, his games never really did much for me.

His games don't do much for me either, but come on, one can still recognise his influence while not enjoying his work. The man who created mario, Zelda, Donkey Kong etc etc can not be considered overrated.
 

alexdotgames

Member
Dec 5, 2021
979
Shout out to what an absolute juggernaut the Japanese gamedev industry is.

Anyway, cool it on your FROM hype. Also lmao at Carmack being on this list.