People need a reason to come here.I think it's pretty clear the site stopped growing after it was created. It had like 44k a couple months after it was made over 2 years ago, and now it's at almost 49k?
The issue is that more people are leaving or getting banned then coming in.
GAF has a lot of insiders and some amazing GIF artists who had a lot of hilarious reactions (most were dumb and a lot of were unfair but we didn't care if it was funny).
Insiders have seemingly all gone to twitter and we don't have anything like those crazy GIFs because announcements are way more controlled now and twitter seems to be the place to get breaking news.
That said there are still a lot of cool people who post here and I can't think of a better place to discuss games on the internet.