• We are delighted to introduce GiftBot 2.0, the next generation of our popular gifting feature. To celebrate, we'll be giving away some incredible prizes over the coming weeks in one big Giveaway Extravaganza!

K-Pop ERA | OT | Into the New World

Red Velvet 2019 rankings
OP
OP
llehuty

llehuty

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,060
The Red Velvet rankings are here



44 votes and uncountable number of edits later, here they are the points distribution:

283
193
181
103
76

And, this time, for the first time, you can also get the ranking reveal in video form, thanks to juicyb


Wendy with 76 points

Started as 4th, but she quicly started plummeting in the rankings, with 20 out of 44 votes for last place.

Yeri with 103 points


Maknae dodged the last place. Controversial figure for her addition to the group + her carefree attitude costed her 16 votes for last place.

Now the real battle begins here. The top 3.



Who will take the crown?

Joy with 181 points


Her charms land her comfortably in the 3rd place, where 17 of you placed her. She managed to close the gap to the 2nd spot, but enough to overtake her



Seulrene at the top. But which one of them is Kpop-ERA's favorite member?

It's Seulgi!






Taking the lead early on, and increasing the gap consistently, she ended up, not only getting not only 19 #1 votes, but not a single vote in last place.

And 2nd it is, Irene with 193 points



Despite the big amount of votes in the 1st position (9) and only getting one vote as the worst member, she lands in #2 due to the amazing results of Seulgi.

But that's not all, for the first time we also have the title track rankings!

First let's tackle the all the songs that got less than 100 points

14th.- Be Natural - 6 points
13th.- Power Up - 10 points
12th.- Zimzalabim - 19 points
11th.- RBB - 20 points
10th.- Happiness - 30 points
9th.- One of these nights - 31 points
8th.- Rookie - 39 points
7th.- Ice Cream Cake - 61 points
6th.- Automatic - 91 points

Which leaves us with our top 5:

Dumb Dumb, Russian Roulette, Red Flavor, Pekk-a-boo and Bad Boy

5th is 2017's Peek-a-boo with 124 points



2015's Dumb Dumb, with 126 points



And our number one is....


Bad Boy, with 171 points.



Got points from 28 voters, 11 of those in first place

Both 2nd and 3rd tracks were tied at 159, but a tiebraker that favours the track that got most #1 votes put's in 2nd place

Red Flavor



With Russian Roulette completing the podium in 3rd place



Congrats to Bad Boy for taking the crown

Thanks to everyone that participated and juicyb for making the video, and look forward to the upcoming ranking

 

greenbird

Member
Oct 25, 2017
849
Member rankings are perfect, song rankings are damn near perfect. Era came through. Thanks for the work llehuty & juicyb.
 

Bonefish

Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,072
Wendy last and behind Yeri. Disgusting lol. She hard carries the group vocal wise.
 
Last edited:

Delphine

Stat Sua Cuique Dies
Moderator
Mar 30, 2018
1,272
France
Peek-a-boo not getting that first place and just placing fifth, my fave has been done dirty. Bad Boy being second on my list, I ain't too mad about it taking the crown though. Seulgi is of course the queen, as she deserves. Thanks to llehuty & juicyb for this, much appreciated!
 

SilentMike03

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,599
Peek-a-Boo only placing 5th is a disgrace to this community. Shut the thread down, we've hit rock bottom.

[edit]: LOONA is next? Shit, guess I've got like 30 songs to listen to now and a billion members to familiarize myself with.
 
OP
OP
llehuty

llehuty

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,060
Peek-a-Boo only placing 5th is a disgrace to this community. Shut the thread down, we've hit rock bottom.

[edit]: LOONA is next? Shit, guess I've got like 30 songs to listen to now and a billion members to familiarize myself with.
Loona's won't have song ranking.

Song ranking was only introduced becuase ranking only 5 members is very straightforward.
 

halvvapoori

Member
Oct 25, 2017
302
Amsterdam
Going by the song rankings... y’all have taste damn

Loona rankings will be hard to do. After kcon I started liking them all so much more, I don’t want to rank one above the other 😨
Will be interesting to see how it will differ from the previous one tho
 

alpha

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,171
Seulgi being number one shouldn't be a shock IMO. Bear = best. Wendy got done dirty though being last.

Also 100% agree with Bad Boy being best RV song.
 

No No Eul

Member
Oct 26, 2017
260
I voted for Seulgi at #1 but I honestly thought Irene would win hands down. Happy to be proven wrong. Nice to see a little appreciation for Yeri too.

Thank you llehuty and juicyb for your hard work.
 

questionmark

Member
Oct 25, 2017
201
The Red Velvet rankings are here



44 votes and uncountable number of edits later, here they are the points distribution:

283
193
181
103
76

And, this time, for the first time, you can also get the ranking reveal in video form, thanks to juicyb


Wendy with 76 points

Started as 4th, but she quicly started plummeting in the rankings, with 20 out of 44 votes for last place.

Yeri with 103 points


Maknae dodged the last place. Controversial figure for her addition to the group + her carefree attitude costed her 16 votes for last place.

Now the real battle begins here. The top 3.



Who will take the crown?

Joy with 181 points


Her charms land her comfortably in the 3rd place, where 17 of you placed her. She managed to close the gap to the 2nd spot, but enough to overtake her



Seulrene at the top. But which one of them is Kpop-ERA's favorite member?

It's Seulgi!






Taking the lead early on, and increasing the gap consistently, she ended up, not only getting not only 19 #1 votes, but not a single vote in last place.

And 2nd it is, Irene with 193 points



Despite the big amount of votes in the 1st position (9) and only getting one vote as the worst member, she lands in #2 due to the amazing results of Seulgi.

But that's not all, for the first time we also have the title track rankings!

First let's tackle the all the songs that got less than 100 points

14th.- Be Natural - 6 points
13th.- Power Up - 10 points
12th.- Zimzalabim - 19 points
11th.- RBB - 20 points
10th.- Happiness - 30 points
9th.- One of these nights - 31 points
8th.- Rookie - 39 points
7th.- Ice Cream Cake - 61 points
6th.- Automatic - 91 points

Which leaves us with our top 5:

Dumb Dumb, Russian Roulette, Red Flavor, Pekk-a-boo and Bad Boy

5th is 2017's Peek-a-boo with 124 points



2015's Dumb Dumb, with 126 points



And our number one is....


Bad Boy, with 171 points.



Got points from 28 voters, 11 of those in first place

Both 2nd and 3rd tracks were tied at 159, but a tiebraker that favours the track that got most #1 votes put's in 2nd place

Red Flavor



With Russian Roulette completing the podium in 3rd place



Congrats to Bad Boy for taking the crown

Thanks to everyone that participated and juicyb for making the video, and look forward to the upcoming ranking
Thanks for your hard work. The video is a great addition.

Top 3 members was exactly as I expected. While Irene is my favorite, I gotta give credit to Seulgi. When you factor in her talents as a dancer and vocalist, her charisma on stage, her visuals and personality, objectively speaking I think she's one of the greatest kpop idols of all time. If only she could wink, one might argue she is perfect. Well deserved win. Irene will have to settle for 2nd place, and all those wons from her CFs.

I fucking knew Bad Boy would win. By far their most popular song in the West. Not surprised by the rest of the top 5 songs either, or that Automatic was the biggest challenger. A little surprised RR managed to tie RF, but while RR is a great song, thankfully the superior song triumphed. Can you reveal how many #1s they got each?

I was pretty disappointed that b-sides were not included in the ranking. Body Talk was fucking robbed. I decided to rank every single song they have released.

  1. Body Talk
  2. Red Flavor
  3. Cool World
  4. You Better Know
  5. Ice Cream Cake
  6. Sunny Side Up!
  7. Kingdom Come
  8. Bad Boy
  9. Peek-A-Boo
  10. Happiness
  11. Some Love
  12. Butterflies
  13. Look
  14. Stupid Cupid
  15. Russian Roulette
  16. Automatic
  17. Huff N Puff
  18. Oh Boy
  19. Little Little
  20. Close To Me (featured)
RV has one of the greatest discographies of any group ever. Personally, almost all of these 20 songs would make my top 5-10 lists for most groups out there. I genuinely believe Body Talk is one of the greatest kpop songs of all time. In recent years, Oh My Girls Closer might be the only other song in contention. I've been listening to Body Talk a lot when making this list, and it still gives me chills like it did the first time. I've said it before, but it's a fucking tragedy that we'll never get a live performance. This is the closest we ever got. The rest of the top 4 are all close behind. Red Flavor reigns supreme as their best title track. Ice Cream Cake rounds up the top 5. I loved Happiness and Be Natural, but Ice Cream Cake was the song that solidified my love for RV, though I actually liked Stupid Cupid more back when the mini first came out. Sunny Side Up is the only late addition to my top 20, but what a great addition it is. Saved that album.

  1. Body Talk
  2. Red Flavor
  3. Cool World
  4. You Better Know
  5. Ice Cream Cake
  6. Sunny Side Up!
  7. Kingdom Come
  8. Bad Boy
  9. Peek-A-Boo
  10. Happiness
  11. Some Love
  12. Butterflies
  13. Look
  14. Stupid Cupid
  15. Russian Roulette
  16. Automatic
  17. Huff N Puff
  18. Oh Boy
  19. Little Little
  20. Close To Me (collab with Ellie Goulding)
  21. Mr. E
  22. Swimming Pool
  23. Carpool
  24. Power Up
  25. Candy
  26. Cause It's You
  27. I Just
  28. Cool Hot Sweet Love
  29. Wish Tree
  30. Red Dress
  31. Rebirth
  32. I'm Leaving (a cover from their appearance on Sugar Man)
  33. Umpah Umpah
  34. Time Slip
  35. Zoo
  36. Dumb Dumb
  37. Hit That Drum
  38. Sappy
  39. Be Natural
  40. Happily Ever After
  41. RBB
  42. Talk To Me
  43. Would U
  44. Aitai-tai
  45. Blue Lemonade
  46. #Cookie Jar
  47. Mojito
  48. Mosquito
  49. Parade
  50. Lucky Girl
  51. Zimzalabim
  52. Something Kinda Crazy
  53. Milkshake
  54. Love is the Way
  55. Take it Slow
  56. Lady's Room
  57. Attaboy
  58. About Love
  59. Taste
  60. My Second Date
  61. Sassy Me
  62. Perfect 10
  63. All Right
  64. One of These Days
  65. Jumpin'
  66. Campfire
  67. Fool
  68. Eyes Locked, Hands Locked
  69. Yossism (from some cartoon OST)
  70. Hear the Sea
  71. LP
  72. Bing Bing
  73. Last Love
  74. With You
  75. Bad Dracula
  76. Day 1
  77. Don't U Wait No More
  78. First Time
  79. Ladies Night
  80. Sunny Afternoon
  81. Moonlight Melody
  82. Time To Love
  83. My Dear
  84. So Good
  85. Light Me Up
  86. Sayonara
  87. Rose Scent Breeze
 

Neol

Member
Oct 25, 2017
392
Nicely done Era ;D

Thanks to llehuty and juicyb for there great work!

LOONA poll should be interesting. I actually do expect some of the rankings have changed since the last time.
 

Woozies

Member
Nov 1, 2017
13,588
So some Queendom stuff was revealed yesterday.

10 weeks of filming(so probably 10 episodes)
4 major performances (including the comeback)
Winner is determined by votes for every major stage as well as Chart position for the comeback song.
Winner is getting a dedicated show entirely to them.

And based on the spoilers i can feel the mess already.
 

DJChuy

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
1,318
Song is decent. Might change my mind after repeats, but I do love the last section.

MV is what you'd expect from Sunmi which to me is always great.