Exactly to what extent and detail were these fans expecting with a reborn Jedi Order under Luke Skywalker? I'm genuinely interested in what they were expecting.
My personal head canon was for Luke to be along the lines of a jesuit priest like Oscar Romero and would abandon the more rigid edicts of the jedi order such as midichlorians, self imposed celibacy, and that jedi could never have attachments period. In essence, he would have been similar to Qui Gon Jinn, whom the films never really elaborate on, other than that he's supposed to be a "maverick" jedi master. If the writers decided to make the argument that he was a radical, it would have been interesting to see Jinn as flatly rejecting celibacy, much like progressive minded catholics do in real life. I just don't think that makes for a functionally healthy state of mind, and it would have been really effective if George Lucas made a case for that in the prequels.
Among writers, including George Lucas, what is the general consensus as it relates to jedi consummating relationships? Is it commonly accepted as expected practice or have they had characters openly question and unapologetically defy it as a matter of self preservation and dignity?