He's a fantastic Doctor. As for his seasons, I think 8, his debut one, is on the lower end of new Who but I thought 9 and 10 were pretty good stuff. The only series I properly put on a pedestal is 5 though, I feel like the rest of them all have similar ups and downs, RTD or Moffat.Was the Capaldi stuff any good? I stopped watching during the second Matt Smith season I think and saw that pretty much everything is on Prime
(You say you stopped watching with Matt Smith though, and he's probably my favourite Doctor. So I dunno how much our tastes align.)