Let's get real: Jewish holidays suck

KimiNewt

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,533


So I was talking to a friend of mine yesterday and we were on the topic of Christmas and he was like "But you get presents for eight days or something!". Now, since that is a bold-faced lie made by Americans trying to equate Hannukah to Christmas as to not feel like they've got the short end of the stick. For the most part from what I've seen, on Hannukah kids just get Hannukah money a single time (and only kids).

So let's break it down and see what we have. Note that my experiences may differ since I live in Israel and so pretty much everyone celebrates it here (and public transport is shut down on most holidays).

Rosh Hashana - New years. Family dinners for two days. The special dish - an apple with some honey. Whoopie-fucking-doo, why not just get a plum and a packet of sugar while you're at it. At least there's a couple of days off, but it brings about the inexorable onslaught of family dinners. One star.​
Yom Kippur - This one widely differs according to your own tradition. Either you go to the synagogue and fast (boring and uncomfortable), just fast (just uncomfortable), or stay at home and play board games. If you're in Israel you can enjoy the fact that there are no cars and go jogging/cycling down the highway (and there's no television if you're into that), which admittedly is pretty awesome. However in recent years with the advent of various electric bikes, this too has become dangerous so this is somewhat nullified. Three stars for that one time I cycled to the beach and it was empty and so it was pretty nice.​
Sukkot - Another week-long holiday! Only if you're not a kid you only get two days off. This time it's family dinners in a sukkah! Which is basically a tent. I hope you like bugs in your soup and occasionally leaking water everywhere. Special dish - your ultra-religious uncle inspecting your sukkah and telling you it's not up to his standards and he can't eat there. One star.​
Hannukah - Ah! The festival of lights! Get ready to awkwardly sing dumb songs with your coworkers and eat inferior donuts. I don't need a fire-hazard in my house, I've got electric lights. It's eight days but you get none off unless you're a child, which means you're gonna see many of them at work. One star.​
Tu Bishvat - Even kids don't get a day off and all you get is you get is dried fruit. Like Halloween if every house gave only raisins. One star.​
Purim - Now we're getting somewhere! Three days of people wearing costumes and giving eachother candy (including adults). Sounds like an amazing version of Halloween, and it would be except that there are no days off for adults. Also, because it's three days long (and the previous day it's celebrated in schools) people can't be arsed to wear a costume for that long and so there's never a critical mass of people in costumes. Four stars for candy, folks in skimpy outfits and short-lived cultural references costumes. Best time of the year in the army. Also I fucking love Hamantash. If it were concentrated in one day (that we had off) it'd be five stars.​
Passover - We're back to family dinners! Another week of holiday with just two days off (and two family dinners). This time there's no leavened bread anywhere which means food is garbage everywhere unless you're in Tel-Aviv-- but it's definitely garbage at your family dinner in which kids sing loudly and the reading of the Hagada never ends. Prepare for a lot of stomach-ache from Matza. One star.​
Lag Ba'Omer - You light a bonfire and there's only time off for kids because the state has gotten sick of everyone skipping it. Do adults even celebrate this? I don't know. Four star as a child, one star as an adult.​
Shavu'ut - One day off, you always kinda forget about this holiday. It features eating a lot of dairy products and cakes and shit. I have no idea what vegans do during this time. Family dinner with no meat, hope you're not lactose intolerant. Two stars for cheesecake.​
Tu Be'Av - You're not getting two Valentine's, fuck off. One star for consumerism.​

I'm sure other religions / cultures have shitty holidays too. But I've always heard good things about Jewish holidays so it's good to put this out there.
Also, if you're thinking "at least you get a lot of time off as a kid"-- this comes at the expense of no winter vacation and a short summer vacation.
 

signal

Member
Oct 28, 2017
27,982
I'm sure at least a couple of those have good food. Maybe your family just doesn't love you OP. Enjoy your single raisin!
 

RiOrius

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,211
That's a lot of holidays. Christians really only celebrate, what, Christmas and Easter? I guess St. Patrick's, Halloween and Valentine's are technically religious in origin, but in practice not really. And as far as time off goes, just Christmas: Easter is always on a Sunday, and the others aren't work holidays.

Part of the problem might be that you're comparing religious holidays to secular ones. Thanksgiving and the 4th of July in America can be fun, but I'm guessing Israel isn't too big on nationally recognized secular holidays?
 

GayAnimeDad

Member
Feb 13, 2018
3,326
Japan
Christian holidays: Jesus is great! Life is great! Everything’s great! Let’s have a feast’

Jewish holidays: Your ancestors felt like shit so now you’re gonna feel like shit too
 

Rory

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,385
That the days are not off is more of a political problem than religious so nothing to complain about.

If you ask me all that sounds pretty cool. Christian holidays are not better tbh.

Christmas dinner? Majority here serve sausage and potatoe salad. Boring. Presents? Usually stop being awesome post certain age as well cuz you could have gotten something yourself that you actually like.

Eastern? Looking for easter eggs in snow is not fun.

Feast day of Saint Nicholas? Oh well ifypu know who put stuff in your shoes & its nit special anymore its boring.
 

Ramathevoice

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,966
Paris, France
Christian holidays: Jesus is great! Life is great! Everything’s great! Let’s have a feast’

Jewish holidays: Your ancestors felt like shit so now you’re gonna feel like shit too
Also: they tried to kill us. We won. Let's eat.

I agree with you though OP, most Jewish holidays are boring. I mean I remember Succot and Purim being fun when I was a kid, but I haven't celebrated them in two decades. Passover I attend out of obligation, Yom Kippur I skip, Hanukkah is usually one night.

Meh.
 
Last edited:
Oct 25, 2017
2,529
In my drinking days, I'd never turn down an invite to a Purim party. Shit was almost always a blast.
 
Last edited:

Messofanego

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,728
UK
Look at this dude complaining while we muslims just get at most a couple days off during Eid (which is pretty amazing) and the rest is religious ceremonies. You got so much that you're taking for granted!
 

dude

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,905
Tel Aviv
Inferior donuts? Have you not tried Sphinj??
But yeah, most of our holidays suck - but I think most holidays in general suck. Halloween is the only one that seems kinda cool.
 
Oct 27, 2017
5,618
Spain
Look at this dude complaining while we muslims just get at most a couple days off during Eid (which is pretty amazing) and the rest is religious ceremonies. You got so much that you're taking for granted!
This. This dude is complaining about what mostly amounts to a bunch of feasts. The most uncomfortable part about that is bigoted relatives if that bothers you, and that's it. Like, seriously.
 

Ary F.

Member
Oct 30, 2017
736
They only suck if you're Ashkenazi. There I said it. That's my Sfardi hot take, sorry if its too spicy for you.
 

ishan

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
2,192
op.... your post needed a tldr.. thats way too much to read thru :) EDIT: im assuming its good so hopefully no offense.
 

BobLoblaw

This Guy Helps
Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,065
Truly enlightening. I had no concept of what Jewish holidays were actually like even though I have some in my family tree. We need more threads about other religious holidays!
 

nded

Member
Nov 14, 2017
7,302
The only good Christian holiday is Christmas and that's only because we gave up on observing it properly in favor of buying and exchanging stuff and elaborate Coca-Cola ads.
 

Ary F.

Member
Oct 30, 2017
736
Mizrahi/Sfaradi here and while the food is better, the holidays still suck pretty much. Mimouna is dope tho.
Lol, Mimouna is the only day we're allowed to have ZERO self control. And c'mon, Passover and Hannukah have waaaaaaay better food which make holidays something to look forward to, heading to the Synagouge is the only part that sucks for me because I live on the other side of the city. Maybe the holidays are fun for me because I dont have to deal with obnoxious relatives. Purim would be GOAT if we had the day off. I think we all agree Yom Kippur is awful.
 

kittoo

Banned
Apr 20, 2018
164
Nobody celebrates frstivals like us Hindus. On Diwali we celebrate for 3 (or 5) days and fireworks galore! Actually it starts 20 days before on Dussehra where wrle burn a giant ass effigy and then... firecrackers!
On Holi we throw colors and water at each other.
On Janmashtami we hang pots very high and then people climb on a human pyramid.
On Rakhi every sister gets gifts!
And them sweets on every single of these. Damn!

Although i must agree, Christmas sounds pretty awesome too.
By the reading of OP the Jewish holidays do sound boring. But be thankful OP that you guys got lucked out in the looks department. When i was in Israel there were 10s everywhere! Your average is our 10. Be thankful!
 

FreeMufasa

Member
Oct 31, 2017
1,234
When I was kid I ain’t gonna lie, seeing man get presents for Christmas had me vex. But then eid rolls around (twice) and you eid feast, get eid money and a day off school. Bless
 

Deleted member 5549

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,198
That's a lot of holidays. Christians really only celebrate, what, Christmas and Easter? I guess St. Patrick's, Halloween and Valentine's are technically religious in origin, but in practice not really. And as far as time off goes, just Christmas: Easter is always on a Sunday, and the others aren't work holidays.
there's quite a few christian holidays, which (as far as I know) aren't special, but some regions treat them as holidays. other than the ones everybody knows (christmas, easter) there's epiphany (or 3 king's day), whitsun, assumption of Mary and I don't know if people celebrate it here anymore, but when I was a kid Walpurgis night was a thing. it's like Halloween but no candy and you make lanterns out of wild cabbage instead of pumpkin. also, during easter friday you're not allowed to eat meat, because it represents jesus' flesh? something like that, never paid attention anyway.
 

SilentRob

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,619
That's a lot of holidays. Christians really only celebrate, what, Christmas and Easter? I guess St. Patrick's, Halloween and Valentine's are technically religious in origin, but in practice not really. And as far as time off goes, just Christmas: Easter is always on a Sunday, and the others aren't work holidays.

Part of the problem might be that you're comparing religious holidays to secular ones. Thanksgiving and the 4th of July in America can be fun, but I'm guessing Israel isn't too big on nationally recognized secular holidays?
Epiphany
Ash Wednesday
Palm Sunday
Holy Thursday
Good Friday
Easter
Ascension of Christ
Pentecost
Corpus Christi
Assumption of Mary
All Hallows
All Soul's Day
Christmas

These are all of the German catholic vacation days, specifically in Bavaria. A few more than Christmas and Easter^^ Obviously only quite devout Catholics celebrate most of these except of Christmas and Easter, but it's a vacation day so eh, who cares.
 

sirap

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,501
South East Asia
When I was kid I ain’t gonna lie, seeing man get presents for Christmas had me vex. But then eid rolls around (twice) and you eid feast, get eid money and a day off school. Bless
Same, I was mad jealous seeing all the kids get presents. Now that I'm older I really appreciate the celebrations we have. Breaking fast with your family/neighbours, the open houses and all that amazing food.

Eid money ain't bad either. I must have visited hundreds of houses for my GBA fund lol.
 

Galkinator

Chicken Chaser
Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,979
Agreed. I pretty much go to these just for the food.

Passover is the worst holiday on planet earth. Food is atrocious, and going through the Seder is ridiculous. Good thing I come from a family of half assinh judaism because I wouldn't be able to go through a full thorough one.
 

Ary F.

Member
Oct 30, 2017
736
I mean, Opus Dei are not exactly mainstream Catholics. They are close to really pious Jews in a weird way. Also, thy flesh must be mortified.
I was only mortified at how boring the parties were lol. They were mostly curious that there was a Jewish person in the room. They had alot of questions to ask and the were respectful in the way they approached me and asked. No ignorant comments or offensive questions (i.e. Is this conspiracy theory about jews true?) were dropped at all in comparison to mainstream Catholics.
 

nel e nel

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,290
That's a lot of holidays. Christians really only celebrate, what, Christmas and Easter? I guess St. Patrick's, Halloween and Valentine's are technically religious in origin, but in practice not really. And as far as time off goes, just Christmas: Easter is always on a Sunday, and the others aren't work holidays.

Part of the problem might be that you're comparing religious holidays to secular ones. Thanksgiving and the 4th of July in America can be fun, but I'm guessing Israel isn't too big on nationally recognized secular holidays?
Lent
Palm Sunday
Ash Wednesday
 

The Watcher

Member
Oct 29, 2017
1,104
That's not too bad OP. I'm still trying to wrap my mind around Kwanzaa. I mean, it's gift giving for a week, but each day has a specific meaning and the gifts have to correlate and a whole mess of other rules. It's complicated compared to Christmas.
 

THE GUY

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,223
Look at this dude complaining while we muslims just get at most a couple days off during Eid (which is pretty amazing) and the rest is religious ceremonies. You got so much that you're taking for granted!
You niggas got Ramadan though. I've always thought that was cool as hell. A month of fasting where you spend every night doing a similar thing with your family which ends in a big celebration like Eid at the end of it.

I think the key to holidays is rarity. If you've got like a dozen celebrations in a year, it's meaningless. You need like a maximum of 3 or something.