• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

jbug617

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,928
Haven't posted in a while.

Days 313 (Raw)
Looks like Tsukamoto finally scored a goal. The translations are over 100 chapters behind right now.


 

RuffMadman

The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
2,259
USA
One Piece 957
The lore in One Piece just keeps getting juicier. Wano Arc is definitely living up to all the hype.
 
Last edited:

Thores

Member
Oct 25, 2017
502
It's not out on any official simulpublish sites, or even on Japanese shelves right now. The chapter that's "out" currently is a leak that won't actually be available anywhere legal until this Sunday. The red text clearly states to put leaks in a spoiler tag and mark it.

Ruff's post was a lot less vague before he edited it, and I read it figuring that he was talking about last week's chapter. I didn't realize that next week's had already leaked.
 

B-Dubs

That's some catch, that catch-22
On Break
Oct 25, 2017
32,776
It's not out on any official simulpublish sites, or even on Japanese shelves right now. The chapter that's "out" currently is a leak that won't actually be available anywhere legal until this Sunday. The red text clearly states to put leaks in a spoiler tag and mark it.

Ruff's post was a lot less vague before he edited it, and I read it figuring that he was talking about last week's chapter. I didn't realize that next week's had already leaked.
As soon as it's available in English anywhere it's fine.
 

Lexxism

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,806
Toronto
One Piece 957

I really want a prequel about Garp. Goddamn boss. To think 3 of the 4 yonko were part of Rox pirates. Man, the info dump was just amazing.
 

Moara

▲ Legend ▲
Member
Oct 25, 2017
23,871
It always seemed hypocritical that discussion of chapters that were clearly pirated were always allowed tbh
 

BassForever

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
29,940
CT
Then what constitutes a leak?

Also, does that mean that this thread is exempt from ResetEra's policy on piracy?

Don't ask don't tell seems to be the policy, even if it requires admin and mods to look the other way on rampant piracy. The sad fact is that outside of the dozen or so series that officially get simulpublished there are 100's that are only licensed for volume sales or are never licensed. You almost have to look the other way to even read a lot of series.

Of course 90% of the manga this site reads are things that are available legally, and for most of them free, same day as Japan on Viz, Manga Plus, and Crunchyroll.
 

A.J.

Member
Oct 25, 2017
19,409
It's going to be a problem as long as Japanese publishers believe physical sales are worth the risk of their chapters being uploaded early. You can't expect big fans to sit out from their favorite series being basically fully translated for free several days earlier than official release.

Granted the best policy would be to spoiler anything that has an official release until the official release comes out.
 
Last edited:

Kreed

The Negro Historian
Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,110
It always seemed hypocritical that discussion of chapters that were clearly pirated were always allowed tbh

It's no different than the rules against sharing video game scans while allowing for discussion of the material in the scans. Discussing the scans shouldn't be an issue as long as the manga communities aren't promoting the translations/sharing unofficial sources.

Granted the best policy would be to spoiler anything that has an official release until the official release comes out.

This was brought up on the previous forum and the reason against it was always because you'd have nothing but lines and lines of spoiler tags on every page since the majority of the discussions are around unofficial translations. The name of the series and the chapter number has been the rule because of this.
 

Thuddert

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,298
Netherlands
It's going to be a problem as long as Japanese publishers believe physical sales are worth the risk of their chapters being uploaded early. You can't expect big fans to sit out from their favorite series being basically fully translated for free several days earlier than official release.

Granted the best policy would be to spoiler anything that has an official release until the official release comes out.

But they publish it digitally and simultaneously in English. While still rushed the official translation is also much better in general if we're talking about One Piece.
 

BassForever

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
29,940
CT
It's no different than the rules against sharing video game scans while allowing for discussion of the material in the scans. Discussing the scans shouldn't be an issue as long as the manga communities aren't promoting the translations/sharing unofficial sources.

The difference is that famitsu and other gaming magazines are just advertising.

Manga are stories that people are invested in. People who actually support the official release basically have to avoid threads discussing them 3-4 days a week because the people who pirate don't care and hide behind the "lol there is an English translation out". It becomes worse when jerks wander outside of this manga thread or the specific manga ot thread and post spoilers in non manga threads and go "lol there is an English translation" which even if I didn't care about piracy is still a jerk move.
 
Oct 25, 2017
8,874
One Piece 957

giphy.gif


That's helluva of lore right there.

Let me get this straight: Xebec's son is a Blackbeard? And how did the big 3 were recruited by Rocks from the beginning? And perhaps Wano is somehow related to that "incident"?

So much shits I'm having, but damn.
 

Lotus

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
105,923
One Piece 957

giphy.gif


That's helluva of lore right there.

Let me get this straight: Xebec's son is a Blackbeard? And how did the big 3 were recruited by Rocks from the beginning? And perhaps Wano is somehow related to that "incident"?

So much shits I'm having, but damn.

Blackbeard might be his son, it's not impossible, but not confirmed yet.

Rocks recruited them all at Beehive Island I guess, we'll eventually see a proper flashback for all that I imagine one day.

Wano has nothing to do with God Valley I'm pretty sure, but there's definitely a big reason as to why Oden/Wano keeps getting all this love
 

A.J.

Member
Oct 25, 2017
19,409
The difference is that famitsu and other gaming magazines are just advertising.

Manga are stories that people are invested in. People who actually support the official release basically have to avoid threads discussing them 3-4 days a week because the people who pirate don't care and hide behind the "lol there is an English translation out". It becomes worse when jerks wander outside of this manga thread or the specific manga ot thread and post spoilers in non manga threads and go "lol there is an English translation" which even if I didn't care about piracy is still a jerk move.
You can still support the official release even if you read the fan translations. Especially since official channels seem to make their money off backlogs and actual volumes now instead of immediately released chapters.
 

BassForever

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
29,940
CT
You can still support the official release even if you read the fan translations. Especially since official channels seem to make their money off backlogs and actual volumes now instead of immediately released chapters.

The issue is that fan translated chapters are still piracy, and the fact these chapters are free now makes it especially egregious how rampant it is and how much this site and others look the other way. Like it's one thing if the option is fan translated chapter or bust since the series hasn't been licensed for western distribution. It's another issue entirely when things like One Piece and My Hero Academia which have official, free, same day translations are available and spoilers run rampant through this site because a pirated copy is online for people to read.
 

Kreed

The Negro Historian
Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,110
The difference is that famitsu and other gaming magazines are just advertising.

Manga are stories that people are invested in. People who actually support the official release basically have to avoid threads discussing them 3-4 days a week because the people who pirate don't care and hide behind the "lol there is an English translation out". It becomes worse when jerks wander outside of this manga thread or the specific manga ot thread and post spoilers in non manga threads and go "lol there is an English translation" which even if I didn't care about piracy is still a jerk move.

As A.J. said people in the manga communities do support the official releases/have subscriptions to the official services while also reading spoilers/scanlations/etc... the same way people who go to see Marvel movies read spoilers and leaked scripts online. Regardless this specific manga community from the previous forum to our current forum for over a decade has discussed multiple mangas and series using the chapter and title system, many of which didn't/still don't have official releases in English. There are other threads that are dedicated to specific manga like One Piece and My Hero Academia with different rules in place for spoilers/etc... Maybe there should be additional threads for the official releases similar to how movie/TV show threads have regular and spoiler threads?

No disagreements from me on the "jerks" that post spoilers outside their specific manga threads/make OTs specifically about spoilers.
 

Lexxism

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,806
Toronto
Haikyuu!!! 367

Goddamn. My heart stopped when I read the chapter title. They were so close. I really thought they will win and face Fukurodani at least. Such a shame.
 

Xita

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
9,185
Land of the Lustrous Vol. 9

Every volume lately feels like a rollercoaster of reveals. Pad's fixed, the Lunarians can fix the ground up gems, Gem Civil War holy moly

Also I thought we were gonna go a whole volume without seeing Phos get wrecked but then that last chapter happened. Holy shit Cairngorm chill

My one nitpick with the manga is that I don't think action scenes are quite the strong suit here, for example the action was really hard to follow in Chapter 70. Man I really hope the anime get's a second season someday.
 

citrusred

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,964
I don't even have words to describe how I feel about the later volumes of Land of the Lustrous. Almost every chapter gives me extremely complex emotions.
 
Oct 25, 2017
4,964
One Piece 957

So Bounties are just power levels now. Alright.

Theres never been a bounty hunter that could claim someone like Arlong, but its worth posting bounties on people worth like 150x that?
 
Oct 25, 2017
6,379
Of course 90% of the manga this site reads are things that are available legally, and for most of them free, same day as Japan on Viz, Manga Plus, and Crunchyroll.

I have a lot of opinions on piracy I'm sure you and I would disagree on, but if there's one thing I am with you on, it's this. I feel like the lax rules of the manga thread made a lot more sense when there was a lot more activity with reactions to weirder/older/nicher/newer series that hadn't picked up an official translation yet whether it be because they were too niche or there just didn't seem to be any interest in it in the west. Since the move, the thread has kinda just become the shonen power hour which is fine but I do miss the times I'd discover weird shit cause of this thread.

Side note; I recently went to a big chain bookstore and I think its nuts how many different manga they have started carrying. Especially those trashy isekai porn series I'd consider too trashy to sell.
 

Aaronrules380

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
22,473
One Piece 957

So Bounties are just power levels now. Alright.

Theres never been a bounty hunter that could claim someone like Arlong, but its worth posting bounties on people worth like 150x that?
I mean I imagine bounty hunters who could claim Arlong did exist, they just operated in the grandline since if you can catch pirates of that level there's a shitload more money to be made in the grand line than any of the blues
 
Oct 25, 2017
6,379
Seven Deadly Sins Yeah sure this chapter is cool but who gives a fuck we're getting Escanor's Sin chapter finally!

I mean I imagine bounty hunters who could claim Arlong did exist, they just operated in the grandline since if you can catch pirates of that level there's a shitload more money to be made in the grand line than any of the blues

Are there even bounty hunters really? I know Zoro's two friends waaaay back were, but outside of them I can't think of any?
 

Aaronrules380

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
22,473
Seven Deadly Sins Yeah sure this chapter is cool but who gives a fuck we're getting Escanor's Sin chapter finally!



Are there even bounty hunters really? I know Zoro's two friends waaaay back were, but outside of them I can't think of any?
Aside from the mentioned examples, we saw the strawhats being attacked by bounty hunters in Saobondy pre timeskip
 
Oct 25, 2017
4,964
There was Abdullah and Jeet in the Dressrosa arena.

But aside from Daz Bones or Zoro (who have higher allegiences) there's really no one worth a shit unless Mihawk was one.

Im just unsure of what the Bounties do if its impossible to claim them except give a power level
 

A.J.

Member
Oct 25, 2017
19,409
Considering Croc was behind Baroque Works, the Shichibukai were behind most of the bounty hunting we saw. So I guess it is kind of funny for a bounty hunting meeting to be held with the marines after dispanding the Shichibukai
 
Apr 11, 2018
2,437
Sweden
While One Piece is my favourite manga of all time, and this chapter was amazing I just have to say...

WHAT THE FUCK HOW AMAZING CAN HAIKYUU BE? I need to talk to SOMEONE about Haikyuu, holy fucking shit
 
Oct 26, 2017
1,235
Same here... Its like the Thanos snap, half of the cast is just done... I dread the next chapter where we'll surely get some reactions etc.

Amazing chapter but just as you said, broke my heart

Kept muttering "nonononononononono fucking nooooooooooooooooooooooooo"

So close, I wanted my Bokuto versus Hinata match in the finals

Guess get ready for new 1st year recruits and rematch galore
 

Chase

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,141
To Your Eternity 112
This arc is finally coming together (I write for the 2nd or 3rd time this arc).

Joking aside last couple of chapters have been great. Didn't think things would go in this direction and changes how I view Bon. Wonder where it goes after this development though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.