My brother hasn't spoken to myself, or my parents in 18 months (long story)

Nocchi

Member
Oct 30, 2017
364
This is a long story, because it basically involves my whole life, so I apologize if it’s hard to understand all the facts. I realize this is a rather personal story to disclose on here, but I just want to get some outside perspective on the situation. We as a family have a very bias perspective of it all, so I feel sometimes getting an outside view would be helpful. Up front, I do not claim to be entirely innocent in this, because maybe my behavior instigated certain responses, but I also feel that my brother has also acted unfairly as well towards myself, but especially towards our mother. To protect his privacy, I’m going to use a fake name, and refer to my brother as Bruce. I feel lost on how to help not just myself, but my mother who seems to suffer the most from this situation that has been going on since July of 2016. It was at this time that there was an argument that occurred at a family gathering that led to this situation where my entire my parents, myself, and eventually my 2 other brothers no longer have any contact with Bruce and his household.


I think to help understand the situation, a little perspective and insight about me would be useful. I’m 34 years old, not exactly a smart of successful individual. I’m the youngest of 4, and so always felt like the target of teasing. Bruce was like a typical older brother, where I looked up to him, and kinda followed him like a puppy when we were kids. Even when we were adults, I looked to him for advice and support. I thought that’s what big brothers do for little brothers. He wasn’t a great big brother sometimes though, and in retrospect, I found he had a bit of a controlling complex. He loved to buy things like video games, never play them himself, and only buy them because he knew I wanted to play them. This way, he would have control over when I could play said video games. We did spend a bit of time in later years though playing stuff on Xbox live together. I still remember fondly both of us sleeping over night at a Best Buy to get the Xbox 360 at launch. I spent a better part of my life working at dead end up jobs, and not getting very far. I’m socially awkward, history of depression and emotional instability. Never made enough money where I felt comfortable moving out of my parent’s house, and in the past few years, my parents have encouraged me to pursue my dreams to finish school, and live overseas. They’re fully supportive of me doing that, and have said they were fine with me living with them as long as I finished school. I’ve made good on this, and am so close to graduating. I mention this, because this seems to be one of the major gripes that Bruce has had with me. He would always encourage me to move out, and get anything that had 4 walls and a roof, even though I never really had a good means to support myself. Bruce wasn’t exactly instantly successful either, it wasn’t until he met his now wife that he tried to get a better paying job, and then moved out, which wasn’t until he was around 27 years old himself. Now they own their own home, and have 2 kids (also fake names), Linus and Sally who I loved very much. I’m Linus’s godfather, but because of the current situation, I haven’t seen or spoken to either one of them either. This really crushes our parents, because they love those kids a lot too.


I’m going to skip a head now to near the incident that occurred; otherwise this will go on forever. In 2016, I was in the middle of still working on some of my own mental issues. I was going to therapy, I was feeling suicidal, but I was trying to improve. However, I was also feeling more alone then ever from lack of support. I didn’t ask much of Bruce at this time, I realize that he had a life and family of his own, but I simply wanted to be able to spend time with them sometimes. Just prior to the argument, I was feeling hurt by Bruce, because he was ignoring me, and denying me simple things. Every time he took Linus to go see a movie, I would ask if I could come along, even if it was a kid’s movie, I told him I’d love to go. He denied me this, and would just put up weird barriers. Prior to the family argument, I was upset with Bruce because I felt neglected, but I was also not trying to start anything, I was simply trying to avoid him. Shortly before the argument occurred, John Carpenter had come to our city to perform his music (yes, the film director, John Carpenter). Bruce knew from since we were kids, that I loved John Carpenter films. He knew that The Thing is one of my favorites of all time, so when I saw on facebook that Bruce had gotten tickets for this live performance by him, I was a little annoyed he didn’t even bother to tell me that he was coming to town. My mother thought it was kinda rude of him not to say anything either and she ended up buying me tickets for the show. On the day of the performance, I felt neglected again, because instead of asking me if I wanted to car pool together, or get drinks before the show, he went to go get drinks without me, and I ended up just going there by myself. I felt hurt by this, maybe I could have handled the situation differently, but I thought we were family, and he could at least be decent to me. At this point, I was just mad at him, and didn’t want to talk to him.


Things were kinda weird at Bruce’s home at this point in time also. Bruce’s wife had been calling my mother for a couple weeks crying, and thinking that Bruce was cheating on her with someone from his work. She threatened to leave Bruce, and was telling this to me and my mother for several weeks before the family gathering, which also made the day kinda uneasy beyond just my problems with Bruce. A little history about Bruce’s wife, but my parents always thought they were close with her, and that she was a decent person. The fact that she didn’t stand up for me, or my parents, even though they stood behind her a lot in the past had played a part in this I think.


On the day that the family argument occurred, it was at Bruce’s home. He was having a cook out for the family, and I was actually not planning on going. I ended up going to this gathering because on this day, my parent’s car had gotten a flat tire. My dad is disabled, and my mother couldn’t handle getting a new tire on her own, so I had to put on the spare tire, and drive with them to get the tire replaced before they went to Bruce’s home for the get together. I was forced to go along, even though I was fuming at the idea of seeing Bruce from the John Carpenter situation. At first, I went inside, and hung around, but I was…quiet. I was trying to think of ways not to make a scene, but because of my emotional tendency, I was just upset. I was desperate to just not argue, and I thought back to what my therapist told me. She said, if you feel a certain way, just try to avoid things that make you feel upset. I ended up going back out to the car, and planned to sit there and wait for my parents. My attempt to avoid making a scene, made a scene in itself.


I am not clear on all the details that happened inside the house while I sat in the car, I was out there for maybe 20 minutes. Apparently Bruce’s wife had said something mean about me, which made my mother upset though. She had come back to the car, and told me she understood how I felt, and convinced me to come back inside though. I did so, with the intent that I would try to just get along, and be nice. We were sitting around in circle, just chit chatting like family’s do. It was my parents though, that had to bring up the conversation on why Bruce was ignoring me as much as he was. It wasn’t just the situation at the John Carpenter show that they were referring to. Little things, like one day when I was killing 3 hours, and Bruce was nearby, I asked him if I could stop by his home. He told me he wasn’t doing anything, but said he did have to go to the grocery store. I asked if I could come along because I had nothing better to do, but he wouldn’t let me come along. My dad questioned him about things like that. Bruce’s reply was “who would want to go to the grocery store! I don’t even want to go there!” and my dad replied “well he did(pointing to me), because he just wanted to spend time with you”. At some point, I just yelled at him, because he didn’t seem to get that, he was my brother, and I thought we loved and cared about each other. His ignoring me hurt me, I told him how it hurt me that he never encouraged me, or supported me when I needed it when we were kids. He retorted by saying “it wasn’t my job! It was our parent’s job to raise you, not mine!” and I remember yelling back at him saying “you were my older brother, I looked up to you, you dumb fuck”. He said something like “how dare you yell at me in my house.” I specifically remember my brother referring to me as a 30 year old child, and that all my problems just amounted to me needing to grow up.


This was basically the start of the argument, just seemed to be a bunch of resentment coming to the forefront all at once. I was already done with him, and wanted to leave, but my parents kept the arguing going. Things might be out of order, because this is all such a blur to me, but my brother seemed to start showing his resentment not towards me, but towards my parents as well. My mother questioned him why he never calls her on the phone, and he yelled “what would I talk to you about, how I can’t pay my mortgage, how my back hurts, you don’t want to hear that!” and my mother said something like “of course I do, I’m your mother”. I wasn’t present for much else that happened, because I was walking to the car at this point. I know he was criticizing my parents for being bad with money, and how dare they not be able to afford taking him to Disney world when he was a kid. He is such a materialistic asshole, he complained so much anytime he needed to borrow my mom money for food. Both my parents expressed how upset they were with Bruce, and his wife. His wife wasn’t exactly as vocal as Bruce was, but she was backing him, even though only days prior, she was crying about how she was going to leave him for maybe cheating on her.


I’m going to cut that portion of the story off there, because that’s the gist of what happened that day. We had left the house, shortly after speaking around the cars. My 2 other brothers were also present when all this happened, but they largely stayed out of it. However, they ultimately agreed that Bruce was being a jerk also. Even they don’t speak to Bruce anymore, and that’s because Bruce cut them off after bad mouthing them for no real reason. This argument occurred in July 2016, and I still haven’t seen or spoken to Bruce since. I can maybe live with this, but more and more, my mother gets upset at the situation. Even though this situation started partly because of me, it isn’t really about me at this point. As far as Bruce and I are concerned, I felt like things finally came out in the open. He didn’t like me, and that’s all there is to it. Maybe I was a bad brother, but I’m not a drug user, I’m not in jail all the time, I’m not a murdered, I didn’t realize just being a “child” could be such a damnable offense. I could probably live if I never see him again, but it kills me that my mother has to be treated like this. I love my mother, but I won’t say I have perfect parents. My dad did plenty I’m upset about, and my mom maybe could have done better at things too…but ya know what, she loved us all, and that’s something some kids don’t grow up with. Bruce was spoiled rotten, and this is how she’s repaid. She hasn’t seen her son, or grandchildren in all that time either. She has made efforts to apologize for her outbursts, by sending Bruce birthday cards, and trying to reach out on facebook. This past Christmas, she tried to deliver some presents for the grandkids, but Bruce returned them. He sent a fb message telling my parents he has no intention of accepting her friend request, and that he was returning the gift because it would “confuse” his kids. I don’t know what kind of crap he is telling the kids, but my parents love the hell out of those kids.


That’s kinda the story…This is probably the longest thread in the world, and if you don’t want to read it, that’s fine. For those that do though, I wouldn’t mind hearing some advice or insight.
 

Bruceleeroy

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
5,381
Orange County
This could have all been avoided if you hadn't invited Shonuff to the party. Now you have to be airing our personal family squabbles in public. Its not my fault if the glow found me and not you and mom. If you guys have such a hard time sleeping at night then get some blackout shades or something.
 

jb1234

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,872
I don't think there's a great deal you can do here except hope that in the future, your brother realizes that he's been a gigantic douche and apologizes.
 

Br3wnor

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
4,356
Damn that’s long.

Just to clarify something, did Bruce lend your parents money? You said something like “he needed to borrow mom money for food” as in he was giving her money to buy food?

It seems like pretty typical family dysfunction. Bruce sees himself as someone who pulled him self up by his boot straps and made a life for himself, got married, bought a house, had kids, while you stayed living at home and not doing enough with your life (in his eyes) and he probably thinks he’s better than you. He thinks your parents enable you by letting you live at home (I’m assuming for free) while he’s dealing with real life money and family stresses. That leads to him resenting both you and your parents.

If he also let your parents borrow money than that heaps even more into the flames because he’s thinking why am I financially supporting my parents and my adult brother. You’re brothers being a prick but you also didn’t handle this well and your parents shouldn’t have let this blow up at a family get together. 18 months is a long time but if he doesn’t want to interact with you guys then that’s his decision, you can’t force him to. All you can hope for is that he’ll want to reconcile at some point, a lot of families do. My father in law didn’t talk to his brother for 5 years before finally squashing the beef when their mother died.
 

Piecake

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,005
Your Brother sounds like an selfish asshole who doesn't care about other people.

The only explanation that I can come up with that he might be doing this is if he thinks your family is toxic and just needs to avoid them all and that you hanging out with him and his kids is just enabling and extending your 'childish' behavior.

Based on what you wrote, I don't think that is true though. He just seems like a total dick who doesn't like you or the rest of your family.
 

Zippedpinhead

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,494
Sometimes it’s good to just collect your thoughts, explain what or how you did something and why you perceived it that way.

I guess you have to ask yourself if you want to have Bruce back in your life. 18 months is a long time. If you do want him in your life then you have to make an effort to say your sorry. Even if you are right, the relationship won’t repair because your brother thinks he is right too.

You can’t pick your family, but you can pick your friends. And not everyone in your family needs to be a friend. Even if you don’t want him in your life I recommend two things.

1) Send your brother, and his kids birthday cards every year. The thought really does matter in the end, and this is an inexpensive and thoughtful way to let him know they are on your mind.

2). If he ever contacts you, take the call. Even if you are still mad at him, especially if you know you are right, take the call. Every contact will be important
 

BossAttack

Member
Oct 27, 2017
28,906
You're bro sounds like a selfish asshole, as for his wife, of course she's going to back him. What did you expect her to do, turn on him? It's on him to repair his relationship with his family, but it sounds like he has a bunch of issues of his own that he's not really dealing with and are eating away at him.
 
OP
OP
Nocchi

Nocchi

Member
Oct 30, 2017
364
Damn that’s long.

Just to clarify something, did Bruce lend your parents money? You said something like “he needed to borrow mom money for food” as in he was giving her money to buy food?

It seems like pretty typical family dysfunction. Bruce sees himself as someone who pulled him self up by his boot straps and made a life for himself, got married, bought a house, had kids, while you stayed living at home and not doing enough with your life (in his eyes) and he probably thinks he’s better than you. He thinks your parents enable you by letting you live at home (I’m assuming for free) while he’s dealing with real life money and family stresses. That leads to him resenting both you and your parents.

If he also let your parents borrow money than that heaps even more into the flames because he’s thinking why am I financially supporting my parents and my adult brother. You’re brothers being a prick but you also didn’t handle this well and your parents shouldn’t have let this blow up at a family get together. 18 months is a long time but if he doesn’t want to interact with you guys then that’s his decision, you can’t force him to. All you can hope for is that he’ll want to reconcile at some point, a lot of families do. My father in law didn’t talk to his brother for 5 years before finally squashing the beef when their mother died.
There was a period where my mother was on unemployment, because she got laid off. My dad can't work anymore because of his disability, but even when they got steady income, they like to indulge. They're not perfect when it comes to money, but it's not like they spend it willy nilly. I think they just don't spend it smartly. He's got a lot of nerve being upset at the fact that he had to help a few times with a trip to the grocery store, yet when when my mom came into a casino jackpot, and bought Bruce and his wife a new couch, and king size bed, he was more then willing to accept.

I've had my fair share of times of having to help pay them for things that didn't involve me. You could say that while I live with them for "free", I've also helped out a lot around the house where it's hardly free tho. I'm not mean and resentful about it like he is though.
 

NHarmonic.

The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
8,620
Your brother sure lacks empathy, tbh. What an awful situation.

Tbh, i'm pretty sure he'll go back and apologize to your parents. There's gonna be a day, sooner or later, that he's going to need them.
 
OP
OP
Nocchi

Nocchi

Member
Oct 30, 2017
364
Damn that’s long.

Just to clarify something, did Bruce lend your parents money? You said something like “he needed to borrow mom money for food” as in he was giving her money to buy food?

It seems like pretty typical family dysfunction. Bruce sees himself as someone who pulled him self up by his boot straps and made a life for himself, got married, bought a house, had kids, while you stayed living at home and not doing enough with your life (in his eyes) and he probably thinks he’s better than you. He thinks your parents enable you by letting you live at home (I’m assuming for free) while he’s dealing with real life money and family stresses. That leads to him resenting both you and your parents.

If he also let your parents borrow money than that heaps even more into the flames because he’s thinking why am I financially supporting my parents and my adult brother. You’re brothers being a prick but you also didn’t handle this well and your parents shouldn’t have let this blow up at a family get together. 18 months is a long time but if he doesn’t want to interact with you guys then that’s his decision, you can’t force him to. All you can hope for is that he’ll want to reconcile at some point, a lot of families do. My father in law didn’t talk to his brother for 5 years before finally squashing the beef when their mother died.
I don't like to think about it, but my dad's health isn't perfect. He's had 2 heart attacks, and still refuses to quit smoking. Just hope the day doesn't come where something happens to him, and this is still going on.
 

JB1981

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
13,691
Tough to give you any advice without hearing your brothers side but it does sound like you have a dependency issue and maybe this came more fully to his awareness once he moved out. He probably thinks your parents are enabling your dependent behavior as well.
 
OP
OP
Nocchi

Nocchi

Member
Oct 30, 2017
364
Tough to give you any advice without hearing your brothers side but it does sound like you have a dependency issue and maybe this came more fully to his awareness once he moved out. He probably thinks your parents are enabling your dependent behavior as well.
At this point, I don't care if he talks to me, it's kinda more about wishing he would be a decent human being to our mother.

For the sake of just talking about it though, I'm not going to argue with you. I think you might be right, I'm hopeful it's something I can work out, but it might be true. However, even if it is true...does that make me such a horrible person? When it comes to family, if you had someone in your family like me, would that make me so unbearable? Especially if this is a person you would laugh together with, make jokes with, see movies with, etc...Is that so horrible to want nothing to do with them if you're supposed to care about them? I just don't get it.
 

Xiaomi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,987
They're not perfect when it comes to money, but it's not like they spend it willy nilly. I think they just don't spend it smartly. He's got a lot of nerve being upset at the fact that he had to help a few times with a trip to the grocery store, yet when when my mom came into a casino jackpot, and bought Bruce and his wife a new couch, and king size bed, he was more then willing to accept.
Not gonna lie, I'd be a little pissed if someone who I was supporting because they're on unemployment tended to spend their time at a casino of all places. That is spending money willy-nilly. Wouldn't have taken the gifts, though.

Helping out around the house every now and then is still pretty much living somewhere for free, by the way. It's nothing compared to paying the bills and saving for the future. I think you need to get out of there and start making the best decisions for your future now. Job-wise, financially, all of it. You can still help out your family, but the whole thing seems pretty crippling for you if you stay in that house. Your brother will come around if he wants to, but you need to find happiness and independence for yourself in the meantime.
 
OP
OP
Nocchi

Nocchi

Member
Oct 30, 2017
364
Not gonna lie, I'd be a little pissed if someone who I was supporting because they're on unemployment tended to spend their time at a casino of all places. That is spending money willy-nilly. Wouldn't have taken the gifts, though.

Helping out around the house every now and then is still pretty much living somewhere for free, by the way. It's nothing compared to paying the bills and saving for the future. I think you need to get out of there and start making the best decisions for your future now. Job-wise, financially, all of it. You can still help out your family, but the whole thing seems pretty crippling for you if you stay in that house. Your brother will come around if he wants to, but you need to find happiness and independence for yourself in the meantime.
That wasn't at the same time, the jackpot at the casino was before she had unemployment.
 

Deleted member 19218

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,323
Tough to give you any advice without hearing your brothers side but it does sound like you have a dependency issue and maybe this came more fully to his awareness once he moved out. He probably thinks your parents are enabling your dependent behavior as well.
I was thinking the same. He probably just felt claustrophobic and annoyed and needs to get away, I can understand that however he refuses to pass on presents from his mother to his children. That's cold. I mean, just completely cutting off contact in the way he did? That's super extreme even if his younger brother (The OP) genuinely was clingy.

This could have all been avoided if you hadn't invited Shonuff to the party. Now you have to be airing our personal family squabbles in public. Its not my fault if the glow found me and not you and mom. If you guys have such a hard time sleeping at night then get some blackout shades or something.
Hey man, are you the poster that created the greatest OT of all time?
 

FeliciaFelix

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,778
He retorted by saying “it wasn’t my job! It was our parent’s job to raise you, not mine!” and I remember yelling back at him saying “you were my older brother, I looked up to you, you dumb fuck”
Maybe he's been resentful for a long time and thinks he was doing your parent's work for them? You and your parents sound merry-go-lucky, but that may be perceived as irresponsible. Maybe he had too much responsibility on his shoulders that should have been your parents?

What's your other 2 brothers take on this? Did you tell your therapist?

And yes, family is supposed to love one another, but sometimes they just don't. Reality is there are thousands of fucked up families out there, so family is no guarantee of love, sad to say.
 

Xiaomi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,987
That wasn't at the same time, the jackpot at the casino was before she had unemployment.
Sorry, I got confused by the timeline. Still, there's a pattern of harmful decisions being made by your folks that doesn't sound like a healthy environment for you to remain in. I also feel like you're focusing a lot of energy on resenting your brother but neglecting your own pursuit of happiness here. He sounds like a cold guy, sure, but that's not in your control at all. What is (partially) in your control is looking for a better environment and starting to succeed on your own and be happier.
 

Tapeworm

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
898
Bruce sounds like a grown adult with a wife and kids that are his main priority. And that seems to bother you and your mom. After 30 years of life, it probably bothers him that at some level he still has to play “big” brother to you. And it probably bothers him that your mom agrees. And it doesn’t help that he apparently has his own issues such as not behind able to pay the mortgage that puts a roof over his families head, or medical issues such as a bad back.

So now he has to take care of himself, his wife and kids, and now at his own home he is getting shit for making those things his priority.

Also, do you feel on some level he doesn’t like that his kids’ uncle has mental issues that has included thoughts of suicide? Maybe that is why he doesn’t always want you going to the movies with him and his child? Also, sometimes a father just might want to bond with their child?

The most selfish thing I can think of is not mentioning the John Carpenter thing.

I sort of feel for Bruce.

edit: actually I don’t like that he keeps the grandkids from grandparents.
 

papermoon

The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
1,858
Your brother is having trouble paying his mortgage. There's marital strife. He has two children whom he may adore but who rely on him for everything. You look up to your brother. You love him. And he loves you too, I bet, even if he's angry right now. But it sounds like he's got plenty burdens and troubles that demand a lot of energy and inner resources.

To you, it may seem such a small thing you're asking of him: his time and company. But he may just not have it to give right now. He's stretched thin. And you have to respect that. The way you describe the situation of him "depriving" you is concerning. We're not entitled to our siblings' time. And if they can't give it to us, as hurtful as it is, we have to accept it and respect their boundaries. For instance, maybe your brother doesn't have that much time to spend with his children. Maybe going to the movies with them is an activity where he wants to devote all his attention on them. I hope you can empathize with his position.

It's wonderful that your parents are so supportive of you. But if they continue to take sides in disagreements between their adult sons, then it's going to keep breeding chaos and unnecessary hurt feelings. They should stop that. OP, do you expect your parents to stand up for you against your brother? Would you be hurt if they didn't defend you? If you're sending subtle signals or setting expectations that they defend you against your bro, I urge you to stop. It's not good, and not fair to them and not fair to you and your bro. You're strong enough to negotiate your own disagreements.

You mentioned your sister-in-law not standing up for you and your parents was an issue. I get that they've been supportive of her in the past. But your sister-in-law did the right thing supporting her husband. That's her most important relationship: the one she has with her spouse, and it would be so damaging to their household if she decided to take your side. If you have similar expectations of your parents as you do of your sister-in-law, I encourage you to take another look at those expectations and maybe revise them.

Congratulations on nearly getting your degree. I hope you make that adventure abroad happen. It sounds like probably hurt feelings were festering for a long while on various sides, and they exploded. You can't control your brother. But maybe spending some time examining the dynamic that led to this problem will give you insights into how you can make some small changes in your life/perspective that will catalyse healing and reconciliation.
 

TheLetdown

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,538
Bruce sounds like a grown adult with a wife and kids that are his main priority. And that seems to bother you and your mom. After 30 years of life, it probably bothers him that at some level he still has to play “big” brother to you. And it probably bothers him that your mom agrees. And it doesn’t help that he apparently has his own issues such as not behind able to pay the mortgage that puts a roof over his families head, or medical issues such as a bad back.

So now he has to take care of himself, his wife and kids, and now at his own home he is getting shit for making those things his priority.

Also, do you feel on some level he doesn’t like that his kids’ uncle has mental issues that has included thoughts of suicide? Maybe that is why he doesn’t always want you going to the movies with him and his child? Also, sometimes a father just might want to bond with their child?

The most selfish thing I can think of is not mentioning the John Carpenter thing.

I sort of feel for Bruce.
Unless I’m misunderstanding, the John Carpenter thing would’ve been around the time Bruce’s wife was talking about leaving him.

If that’s the case, it’s pretty understandable that Bruce wasn’t necessarily thinking about OP liking The Thing when they were kids.
 

Figgles

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
2,568
You’re not a horrible person, but you need to give the guy his space. Can you really be upset with him not wanting to share his time alone with his son with you? This sounds like it’s been building for a long time. You live at home with your parents?
 

papermoon

The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
1,858
At this point, I don't care if he talks to me, it's kinda more about wishing he would be a decent human being to our mother.

For the sake of just talking about it though, I'm not going to argue with you. I think you might be right, I'm hopeful it's something I can work out, but it might be true. However, even if it is true...does that make me such a horrible person? When it comes to family, if you had someone in your family like me, would that make me so unbearable? Especially if this is a person you would laugh together with, make jokes with, see movies with, etc...Is that so horrible to want nothing to do with them if you're supposed to care about them? I just don't get it.
You're not a horrible person. You're not unbearable. You made an interesting thread, and you share intimate details about yourself. That automatically makes you fascinating.

Of course, you're gonna care deeply about your mother's hurt feelings. I bet the best thing you can do to help them reconcile is to stay out of their conflict. This is for them (your mom and bro) to solve. Not you. And telling you to stay out of it isn't because you're horrible. It's because whenever a third person gets involved in a disagreement primarily between two people, things get messy and confusing. Give them the space to work this out in their own way.
 

ZOONAMI

Member
Oct 27, 2017
19,151
I’m gonna probably have a different opinion than most but inviting yourself to things constantly is annoying and sitting in a car for no real reason is creating a scene and is extremely childish behavior. Calling your brother a dumb fuck also isn’t a good move over him essentially having his own life. I have a brother and a sister who live in the same city and yeah, we hang out occasionally but we certainly don’t invite ourselves to whatever someone’s up to.

Your brother is being a giant dick for cutting off all contact like that, especially with your parents, but some people it takes a long time for people to get over things. I have a close friend from HS who was pissed I invited his ex to my wedding and created a scene at my wedding (and he knew she would be there and I talked to him about it beforehand) and then didn’t talk to me over 3 years, and he was the one who was being a fucking dick. Sometimes people are irrational assholes about this kind of stuff and it can sometimes take a long time for things to be chill again. My guess is your brother will get over himself eventually and I wouldn’t really spend too much time worrying about it.
 

Cantaim

Member
Oct 25, 2017
19,579
Assuming Direct Cringe
Family situation sounds tense and complicated. I would try my best to stay out of your mom and brothers spat though. It sucks that he won't let her talk to him or her grandkids but it is your older brothers choice to make.
 

corasaur

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,861
It sounds like the amount of personal space he needs to cope with personal stresses is pretty big, and that he felt like the boundaries he needed were obvious enough that he had no clue how to enforce them constructively, so he just got hurt and withdrew more. Then the frustration blew up.

Cutting off family is rarely easy even in the worst, most justified estrangement cases. If he felt this was necessary, he's been feeling hurt or disrespected in some way for a while.

The carpenter concert was a dick move though.

And he is a jerk if he's cheating, but of course his wife picked him over the in-laws.


edit: actually I don’t like that he keeps the grandkids from grandparents.
If Bruce feels enough pain from interacting with his parents that he's had to limit contact, why would he expose his children to it in his place? And when it comes to other parenting decisions, people who feel threatened by boundaries in general are gonna disrespect childcare related boundaries too
 

xvr

Member
Oct 27, 2017
103
OP as several others have outlined you don't seem to be correctly looking at your brother's situation. He's a grown adult who can barely pay his mortgage, possibly in marital strife, with 2 kids to support. His brother's welfare, and feelings are very low priority on his list.
This is probably emphasised by the point that said brother is (probably in his eyes) living easy with his parents who he has had to bail out before.
Combination of the two would make it so that he may not have time, or make the time to see you. A good example of this is;
Prior to the family argument, I was upset with Bruce because I felt neglected, but I was also not trying to start anything, I was simply trying to avoid him. Shortly before the argument occurred, John Carpenter had come to our city to perform his music (yes, the film director, John Carpenter). Bruce knew from since we were kids, that I loved John Carpenter films. He knew that The Thing is one of my favorites of all time, so when I saw on facebook that Bruce had gotten tickets for this live performance by him, I was a little annoyed he didn’t even bother to tell me that he was coming to town. My mother thought it was kinda rude of him not to say anything either and she ended up buying me tickets for the show. On the day of the performance, I felt neglected again, because instead of asking me if I wanted to car pool together, or get drinks before the show, he went to go get drinks without me, and I ended up just going there by myself. I felt hurt by this, maybe I could have handled the situation differently, but I thought we were family, and he could at least be decent to me. At this point, I was just mad at him, and didn’t want to talk to him.
1. Why should your brother remember you love John Carpenter? I don't remember those sorts of things about my siblings

2. Why is it up to your brother to organise drinks before or carpooling? Why didn't you do it?

3. The only way he was maybe not decent to you was by telling you he would be in the city.

You're reaction to this whole episode, at least to me, does appear childish. It's all why HE doesn't do the things FOR ME, and you getting upset over it.
As you said, you do have mental health issues, so it could definitely be the influence of those on you that made you think this way, however it's important that you realise this.

On the argument though, he does come across badly. His wife acted fine, but you shouldn't have locked yourself in your car. That in and of itself is very childish.
 

Juturna

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,142
You both pretty much come off as children in different ways. Going to sit in the car at a family gathering? In what world isn't that going to invite questions and instigate things? Not trying to dogpile, but take some cues from your other brothers and grow up and be independent a bit.
 

Chris McQueen

Self-requested ban
The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
5,378
London
Bruce sounds like a grown adult with a wife and kids that are his main priority. And that seems to bother you and your mom. After 30 years of life, it probably bothers him that at some level he still has to play “big” brother to you. And it probably bothers him that your mom agrees. And it doesn’t help that he apparently has his own issues such as not behind able to pay the mortgage that puts a roof over his families head, or medical issues such as a bad back.

So now he has to take care of himself, his wife and kids, and now at his own home he is getting shit for making those things his priority.

Also, do you feel on some level he doesn’t like that his kids’ uncle has mental issues that has included thoughts of suicide? Maybe that is why he doesn’t always want you going to the movies with him and his child? Also, sometimes a father just might want to bond with their child?

The most selfish thing I can think of is not mentioning the John Carpenter thing.

I sort of feel for Bruce.

edit: actually I don’t like that he keeps the grandkids from grandparents.
I have to agree with you on this. It sounds as though Bruce has more than enough on his plate already.
 
Oct 26, 2017
6,623
Appalachia
I bailed my step brother out of jail on a Grand Theft charge. He hops trains now. Has never reached out to the family outside of asking for whatever he can't obtain himself for about 8 years. His dad and my mom did everything they could to get him on a decent life trajectory while most of his childhood was destroyed by custody battles, and all he sees in that is them being assholes because they wouldn't let him do whatever he wanted like his grandparents did (yeah, my step dad's parents tried to get custody of their son's child).

I'ma get that $100 back one of these days.
 
Last edited:

Sho_Nuff82

Member
Nov 14, 2017
11,758
I think you’re going to have to accept that once hanging out with someone is an obligation rather than “fun”, most people will resent doing it. Your brother may not hate you, but he may see hanging out with his grown sibling (who complains whenever he’s left behind) as an obligation. Especially if his parents guilt trip him for it.

Most 30+ adults with spouses and kids see their siblings and parents a handful of times a year if they don’t live close by. Most wives aren’t going to turn every spat their husband has with his parents into an intervention to air all of her grievances. Your brother focusing on making his new family functional before inviting more drama is totally normal. Him calling you a ‘child’ is reflecting that; he expects you to have friends and a life of your own so you don’t need him for hanging out.

I don’t know what advice your therapy has provided, and I won’t pretend to be a mental health professional. I think it’s admirable that you’re finishing school and that you’re planning on traveling. But you can’t live your life being so obsessed with being a favorite in your small family circle. You’re going to have to find your own job, make your own way, plan your own vacations, make your own friends, find your own housing, and find your own idea of a happy life wherever you end up. And as much as you love your parents and siblings, they will not be there to console you every step of the way, not with a 7+ hour time difference.

Your brother may eventually soften his stance and apologize for his unkind words. Aside from offering your own apology for your part in the spat, there’s nothing else you can do but wait. Attacking him with your parents for his “transgressions” will only drive him further away.
 

Rory

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,379
What’s about his wife? Are they still together? If you ask me your scenario pretty much sounds like he cheated on her. As you said, weeks prior she didnt have another topic than his disapearing acts (about which you guys complain too). He claims that certain activities must be done all alone (gorcery shopping). Even as the biggest introvert that I am I understand that someone who has 3 hours to kill might want to hangout at my place. Also you noted that his wife and him joined forces pretty quickly. Most likely the wife doesnt want to believe her partner cheated on her and a common enemy is a good way to get distracted. Another reason why your brother might have been so mad is that he didnt want his wife to think twice about his latest disappearing acts. Eventually the whole thing will come up again.

I think that the wife is the easier person to talk to. You dont need to convince your brother, she must allow you to be part of the children’s life again and that will be way easier because you dont have so much of a history together. Honestly, it is ridiculous that your brother tries to keep you outbof the children’s lifes. As a child who had to undergo something similar in their childhood I can tell you it just makes the child suffer.

As soon as this has been settled things will come naturally.
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 14459

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,874
Your brother doesn't hate you, but his main allegiance is with his own family, ie his wife and kids. It is clear he holds resentment to your parents for having to take on responsibility he felt a kid should not have. He may be right. We don't know. But it is probably triggering him that your parents say to him as an adult that he should foster you and cater to your needs. He doesn't really have that obligation and if he should prioritize something it is probably trying to mend his marriage which doesn't seem to be on a great foot to begin with.

It might help if you zero the expectations towards your brother in what you think he owes you or what exactly his role as a brother to you entails. You could instead ask him what kind of relationship he'd like to have with you. And don't go to your parents when you feel he doesn't hold up whatever deal you work out as the standard of relationship. The problem for him is probably more your parents, but since you live with them it might be a hard equation to solve.

It strikes me a bit unfair that you are really stressing family ties and obligations, while at the same time criticizing your brother's wife for taking a stand for her husband (cheating or not) - when growing up would you have expected your mother to side with her brother in-law instead of her own family?
 
Last edited:
Oct 27, 2017
4,433
Uhh if my bro tried to guilt trip me for not taking him shopping or to the movies with my kids I'd stop talking to him too.

Get some friends or embrace being an introvert and do shit by yourself. Youre both grown. He doesnt need to remember which directors you like.

Like, YOU could have found out about the event first and asked him...But getting pissy that he didn't ask you? Nah.
 

Sho_Nuff82

Member
Nov 14, 2017
11,758
What’s about his wife? Are they still together? If you ask me your scenario pretty much sounds like he cheated on her. As you said, weeks prior she didnt have another topic than his disapearing acts (about which you guys complain too). He claims that certain activities must be done all alone (gorcery shopping). Even as the biggest introvert that I am I understand that someone who has 3 hours to kill might want to hangout at my place.

Also you noted that his wife and him joined forces pretty quickly. Most likely the wife doesnt want to believe her partner cheated on her and a common enemy is a good way to get distracted.

Another reason why your brother might have been so mad is that he didnt want his wife to think twice about his latest disappearing acts. Eventually the whole thing will come up again.

I think that the wife is the easier person to talk to. You dont need to convince your brother, she must allow you to be part of the children’s life again and that will be way easier because you dont have so much of a history together. Honestly, it is ridiculous that your brother tries to keep you outbof the children’s lifes. As a child who had to undergo something similar in their childhood I can tell you it just makes the child suffer.

As soon as this has been settled things will come naturally.
Whatever you do, do not listen to this poster and contact your brother’s wife behind his back. He’ll never forgive you if you harm his marriage.
 

Rory

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,379
Whatever you do, do not listen to this poster and contact your brother’s wife behind his back. He’ll never forgive you if you harm his marriage.
This is not about harming a marriage, if the brother doesnt want to talk it is his right, but that doesnt mean he can decide so for his kids nor his wife. If they decided together it is another thing, but she’d tell you so.

If anything it actually seems like the brother keeps the family in isolation... why? Does the brother truly believe in the family being that harmful? Just because of a very over-caring mom? The daughter in law was described as very close first who’d even talk about her husband cheating on her with her in laws, and all of a sudden she doesnt care anymore? One of the warning signs of an abusive relationship is that your partner keeps you from seeing your family... the brother was also described as avery controlling person, so... with the little information we have here my first step would be to reach out to the wife.

The question is what your goal is:to see your niece/nephew again or to talk to your brother. Yes, if something has happened this could burn the bridges for good, but at least you would gave helped your niece/nephew/their mom. Who knows if any of them even know that you guys contacted them.
 
Last edited:

Sho_Nuff82

Member
Nov 14, 2017
11,758
This is not about harming a marriage, if the brother doesnt want to talk it is his right, but that doesnt mean he can decide so for his kids nor his wife. If they decided together it is another thing, but she’d tell you so.

If anything it actually seems like the brother keeps the family in isolation... why?
They’re his kids. If he wanted to send them to boarding school in Detroit or move with them to the south coast of China, he doesn’t need his family’s permission.

The OP was barely good friends with his brother before the split, I doubt opening lines of communication with a woman he barely knows will be much easier. Put yourself in her shoes; do really think she’ll choose her in-laws over her husband and father of her kids if he says his family is toxic? If he was keeping her from her family (or she was keeping him from his) you might have a legitimate gripe.
 

Rory

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,379
They’re his kids. If he wanted to send them to boarding school in Detroit or move with them to the south coast of China, he doesn’t need his family’s permission.
The brother needed his wifes permission, and that’s the point. If she decided the kids should see the grandparents and uncles again he cant deny that.

The OP was barely good friends with his brother before the split, I doubt opening lines of communication with a woman he barely knows will be much easier. Put yourself in her shoes; do really think she’ll choose her in-laws over her husband and father of her kids if he says his family is toxic? If he was keeping her from her family (or she was keeping him from his) you might have a legitimate gripe.
She talked to her in laws about breaking up, so yes, i think she would because she badically already did. She didnt need to talk to them about this.

Her husbands opinion is not neccessarily hers, and that’s something to talk to her about. Maybe op shouldnt do that but grandparents, as they had the better bond to her.
 

Deleted member 14459

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,874
This is not about harming a marriage, if the brother doesnt want to talk it is his right, but that doesnt mean he can decide so for his kids nor his wife. If they decided together it is another thing, but she’d tell you so.

If anything it actually seems like the brother keeps the family in isolation... why? Does the brother truly believe in the family being that harmful? Just because of a very over-caring mom? The daughter in law was described as very close first who’d even talk about her husband cheating on her with her in laws, and all of a sudden she doesnt care anymore? One of the warning signs of an abusive relationship is that your partner keeps you from seeing your family... the brother was also described as avery controlling person, so... with the little information we have here my first step would be to reach out to the wife.

The question is what your goal is:to see your niece/nephew again or to talk to your brother. Yes, if something has happened this could burn the bridges for good, but at least you would gave helped your niece/nephew/their mom. Who knows if any of them even know that you guys contacted them.
Talk about flipping the story into a narrative that fits. Now it's a story not about OP but saving an abused spouse and children. The way to handle these two different scenarios is vastly different and if you read this situation wrong (odds are very high) the outcome can damage the relationship beyond repair.
 

Sho_Nuff82

Member
Nov 14, 2017
11,758
The brother needed his wifes permission, and that’s the point. If she decided the kids should see the grandparents and uncles again he cant deny that.


She talked to her in laws about breaking up, so yes, i think she would because she badically already did. She didnt need to talk to them about this.

Her husbands opinion is not neccessarily hers, and that’s something to talk to her about. Maybe op shouldnt do that but grandparents, as they had the better bond to her.
If they were friends with her like that they would have already done so in the past two years. I’m guessing she told them to kick rocks. If she confronts her husband on behalf of the parents and he finds out, you’re potentially fucking up their marriage. Parents don’t do that to children they profess to love, just to get access to kids they barely know.
 
Oct 27, 2017
8,318
Bandung Indonesia
You're being selfish, OP, to demand his time and attention and then proceeds to call him a dick when he failed to give you that. His bad back, his mortgage situation, etc, plus with parents and his brother guilt-tripping him, of course he's going to be upset about it.

Your brother is having trouble paying his mortgage. There's marital strife. He has two children whom he may adore but who rely on him for everything. You look up to your brother. You love him. And he loves you too, I bet, even if he's angry right now. But it sounds like he's got plenty burdens and troubles that demand a lot of energy and inner resources.

To you, it may seem such a small thing you're asking of him: his time and company. But he may just not have it to give right now. He's stretched thin. And you have to respect that. The way you describe the situation of him "depriving" you is concerning. We're not entitled to our siblings' time. And if they can't give it to us, as hurtful as it is, we have to accept it and respect their boundaries. For instance, maybe your brother doesn't have that much time to spend with his children. Maybe going to the movies with them is an activity where he wants to devote all his attention on them. I hope you can empathize with his position.
This is basically where I am at.

However to completely cutting off contact with parents like that and to disallow his children to contact their grandparents, man that's cold. I understand why he does it, I just don't appreciate that kind of thing.
 

Feral

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,006
Your Mom
okay, I got through the OP

it sounds like you're a bit clingy for your age, and I think that you may want to stop to get your parents involved every time there is an argument. By sitting it out in your car, you did actually cause a scene, even if you didn't mean to, this comes across as classic passive aggressive behavior and makes things just weird
your brother is acting like a hurt overgrown child over a stupid fight that happened more than a year ago, with similar passive aggressive actions, i.e. ignoring your whole family completely and returning the gifts

it seems like your brother is dealing with his own set of issues - finances, health and marriage. On top of that, he and his wife don't really respect you. That doesn't necessarily mean that he doesn't like you, he may very well care about you, but he clearly doesn't see you eye to eye

the best you can do is to try and reach out periodically, call him if you have his or the wife's number. If you get him on the line, try to mend your relationship. That argument really doesn't sound that bad - the Disney World line, come on. You all should get over it already. As long as he still refuses to speak with you and your family, there isn''t really anything you can do about it. In the meantime, focus on your education
 
OP
OP
Nocchi

Nocchi

Member
Oct 30, 2017
364
I wish some of you would stop judging me as being clingy. You're reading all the events in one big thread, and so it all sounds like it's coming close together, but some of these sequences may have happened months, if not years apart in some cases. I feel my desire to want to spend time with a brother who I grew up thinking was my closest friend, to start being treated like I didn't exist was pretty shitty.

Also, some people pointed out how obscure him knowing that I loved John Carpenter films don't know the relationship we had. We were the types of brothers who grew up as movie fanatics. We saw action movies like crazy in theaters growing up, and we still watched them into adulthood together. Our father had bought a 35mm projector, and we had a private movie theater in our basement, so watching movies was like our thing. He knew I loved JC's The Thing, because we owned it on 35mm film, technocolor print, so the color didn't fade. That's the kind of history Carpenter had for us. We went to movie conventions just to seek out movie posters to buy together. I know I'm kinda going on about this, but imagine having that kind of relationship with someone, and sure...he's married, but does that mean you forget about your family and close friends completely?

He made me his son's godfather, I was his best man at his wedding, it wasn't like we didn't have a close relationship at one time, and it wasn't like he didn't trust me with his kids.

As far as my parents go again, he's got some nerve treating them this way, because his wife's parents have done far worse. Bruce was in an accident, and had pain in his neck and shoulders alot, and was taking pain medication. His wife's mother at one point, stole some of his medication and replaced it with something else, putting his life in danger. Her parents are still welcome at his home, yet he won't talk to his own mother.

Edit: One of the reasons I made this thread today, is my mom talks to me because we're pretty close, and she was crying a lot today because she found this. Something that he gave her, only about a year before the incident. Does what it say mean nothing?

 
Last edited:

Vagabundo

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
2,311
Bruce sounds like an ass hole to be honest. I can't see a reconciliation without him coming to that realisation. Mabye years etc.

However do grandparents have visitation rights in your country? I might be worth investigating that legally. They do in mine. At least your parents could see their grandkids. That's the toughest part of that story. And the major reason why Bruce - and his wife - are major league assholes.
 

Feral

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,006
Your Mom
I wish some of you would stop judging me as being clingy. You're reading all the events in one big thread, and so it all sounds like it's coming close together, but some of these sequences may have happened months, if not years apart in some cases. I feel my desire to want to spend time with a brother who I grew up thinking was my closest friend, to start being treated like I didn't exist was pretty shitty.
the thing is, I don't really know you. I'm just going by what you said in the OP, and that's the impression some of us got. If any of it applies, it helps to be self-reflective of your own actions and allow some criticism. If it's completely off the mark, I want to apologize. Like I said, I (we) know practically nothing about you
 
OP
OP
Nocchi

Nocchi

Member
Oct 30, 2017
364
the thing is, I don't really know you. I'm just going with what you said in the OP, and that's the impression some of us got. If any of it applies, it helps to be self-reflective of your own actions and allow some criticism. If it's completely off the mark, I want to apologize. Like I said, I (we) know practically nothing about you
I understand, and I'm not trying to attack you or anyone who says that directly. I'm just trying to defend myself a little, and wanted to clarify some things.
 

Wishbone Ash

One Winged Slayer
The Fallen
Oct 29, 2017
1,359
Michigan
I hope you guys can resolve your issues. I won't pretend to be a therapist and evaluate the content of the OP, but there's very little there that seems worthy of causing such a rift between family members.

My brother was always nice towards me, but had a bad temper and was verbally abusive towards my parents to an explosive level at times. It lead to him going in and out of being in contact with our family for months on end, missing holidays and birthdays (and any phone calls I can remember turned awful for little reason). Even though I got along with him fine, I felt like he was too abrasive and mean to my parents and made that clear to him.

Anyway, he ended up killing himself, and all of that seemed so trivial in retrospect. I guess I'm trying to tell you to make peace/work your shit out with him, because it all sounds really petty and silly.
 

Deleted member 14459

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,874
I wish some of you would stop judging me as being clingy. You're reading all the events in one big thread, and so it all sounds like it's coming close together, but some of these sequences may have happened months, if not years apart in some cases. I feel my desire to want to spend time with a brother who I grew up thinking was my closest friend, to start being treated like I didn't exist was pretty shitty.
But are you asking us to judge your brother based on one big thread? You also wrote that you get the feeling your brother tried to control you when you were children with these same things that you cling to as your most revered memories that you'd like somehow to replicate etc. If you reach out to your brother, do it for yourself not your mother, ask what kind of relationship he'd like to have with his youngest brother and try to respect that instead of putting expectations and pressure on him, his life sounds pretty shitty...
 

noctix

Member
Oct 27, 2017
427
I read all of it. It feels to me ur brother is going through alot. He is having financial difficulties and difficulties at home. May be he is resenting you because he i dunno may be he wants you to pick up some of the load. From ur post i feel u need him ur family around u. Take care of u. But u need to realise may be he is getting upset because he really needs u to grow up/mature up and help him take care of things instead of him having to raise u as well.

I am speaking from personal experience where my brother hates me because he expected alot more from me and i never realised until it was too late.