• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Caleb187

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
165
Colorado
I preordered.

The onboard assistant and soli have me interested enough to do so, but certainly some of the choices this year have me eyeing other phone brands.

That's bad news coming from someone that's been pure Google for years.
 

Haint

Banned
Oct 14, 2018
1,361
Serious question, are these low volume products that only sell in the 10's or perhaps low 100's of thousands of units? I'm puzzled as to why anyone would buy these things at these prices as I can't imagine they're selling to anyone but a very small niche of Android/Google diehards.
 

BoboBrazil

Attempted to circumvent a ban with an alt
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
18,765
This is like a 2017 phone in 2019 except for the newer processor. Every other spec is 2017. Noone gives a crap about air gestures
 

Dinjooh

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
2,826
Who cares about the pixel 4, it's all about the a budget line.

Now, what we really need to discuss is how adorable the Pixel Buds are. Orange or White, what should we get?
 
OP
OP
signal

signal

Member
Oct 28, 2017
40,171
Who cares about the pixel 4, it's all about the a budget line.

Now, what we really need to discuss is how adorable the Pixel Buds are. Orange or White, what should we get?
It's not like the 3a was that great of a phone either. People are saying you can do better for less money with that 4 and that's just as true with the 3a.
 

Dinjooh

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
2,826
It's not like the 3a was that great of a phone either. People are saying you can do better for less money with that 4 and that's just as true with the 3a.

I'm really fucking happy with my 3a though, and impressed most of my colleagues as well. We're currently at 4 guys here with them.

Some of my main requirements for a phone is size, camera, os and price. The 3a fits neatly there.
 
Oct 25, 2017
1,881
I preordered.

The onboard assistant and soli have me interested enough to do so, but certainly some of the choices this year have me eyeing other phone brands.

That's bad news coming from someone that's been pure Google for years.

Got to admit with several months to go until I can change my current contract (2XL) I'm also going to shop around and really keep my options open (including....iOS). Given the price point I'm just not that impressed outside of the improvements to the camera software and on board assistant chip.

Hopefully like with my current handset by the time I go for another contract it's on deep discounts, as that's going to be needed to push me over the line.
 

Hoo-doo

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
4,292
The Netherlands
After watching the MKBHD impressions video, this thing just seems like a dud. What a wasted opportunity to just put in a telephoto lens instead of the ultrawide. Ultrawide has ten times more practical, everyday applications over a measly 2x zoom.

Also, I still don't understand the that huge chin and forehead. It's not 2016 anymore.
 

Kaguya

Member
Jun 19, 2018
6,404
My Pixel 2 phone is still working perfectly, so I'm probably not upgrading this year, but whenever I would, I can't see my self upgrading to anything other than a Pixel phone.
 

Snarfington

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
2,927
I'm not gonna lie, all the ultrawide spam from the iPhone 11 series recently has really put me off those shots. Just so many people using it in ways that look tacky as hell. But I'd still like it to have been here just to have the option. Unfortunately I'm a Pixel bitch so they know I'll keep on eating it up, but this is the first year the iPhone has looked seriously interesting to me, which is terrible news for Google. If Apple can get USB-C and fix their shitty notification system I might be on board for the 12.
 

mAcOdIn

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,978
The Android landscape is really driving me nuts right now.

My U11 just got Pie, which was awesome except that it somehow broke NFC payments and Lord knows if HTC will ever update that phone again, so that's annoying. I really want a headphone jack again as I have not enjoyed not having one and have been eyeing the LG V50 but it's remained locked behind Verizon and Sprint's networks since its' launch. Sony's dropped it from their line-up. The Pixel doesn't have a headphone jack but at least unlike LG, Sony or HTC I'd get timely updates but the phone is ugly as sin. Huawei's a huge question mark.

Guess I need to see if I can squeeze some more life out of this U11.
 

Breqesk

Member
Oct 28, 2017
5,229
I'm not gonna lie, all the ultrawide spam from the iPhone 11 series recently has really put me off those shots. Just so many people using it in ways that look tacky as hell. But I'd still like it to have been here just to have the option. Unfortunately I'm a Pixel bitch so they know I'll keep on eating it up, but this is the first year the iPhone has looked seriously interesting to me, which is terrible news for Google. If Apple can get USB-C and fix their shitty notification system I might be on board for the 12.
Their notification system has gotten much better lately fwiw. I used to absolutely hate the way my iPad handled notifications, to the point they were basically unusable for me, but once they added grouping and somewhat more granular settings, things improved dramatically.

It's still nowhere near as versatile as Android's system, of course, but I think I could live with it now.

Honestly I think the two things I wish they'd fix on iOS the most at this point are the forced default apps, and the way applications pretty much always use in-app browsers instead of taking you straight to Safari. In-app browsers that, unlike the in-app browsers on Android, don't remember that you've signed in to any sites, or accepted any cookie requests, etc etc. It's a constant frustration.

This is actually still a pretty major improvement from where iOS was a couple of years ago, though. I think I could genuinely live with an iPhone at this point. I'd actually be kinda tempted to try one out if they weren't still so expensive, even at the low end.

The Android landscape is really driving me nuts right now.

My U11 just got Pie, which was awesome except that it somehow broke NFC payments and Lord knows if HTC will ever update that phone again, so that's annoying. I really want a headphone jack again as I have not enjoyed not having one and have been eyeing the LG V50 but it's remained locked behind Verizon and Sprint's networks since its' launch. Sony's dropped it from their line-up. The Pixel doesn't have a headphone jack but at least unlike LG, Sony or HTC I'd get timely updates but the phone is ugly as sin. Huawei's a huge question mark.

Guess I need to see if I can squeeze some more life out of this U11.
How about a Xiaomi? They actually have a pretty great track record for updates - even if their specific version of Android has some kinda irritating quirks - and they still make premium phones with headphone jacks. The Mi 9T Pro/Redmi K20 Pro, for instance.


(I particularly like the red version. Oh, and don't worry about the front camera issues discussed in the linked video: MKBHD's unit was defective, and every other review I've seen has produced far, far better results. Though, of course, the fact that one of the review units was defective could raise concerns over quality control.)
 
Last edited:

Snarfington

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
2,927
Their notification system has gotten much better lately fwiw. I used to absolutely hate the way my iPad handled notifications, to the point they were basically unusable for me, but once they added grouping and somewhat more granular settings, things improved dramatically.

It's still nowhere near as versatile as Android's system, of course, but I think I could live with it now.

Honestly I think the two things I wish they'd fix on iOS the most at this point are the forced default apps, and the way applications pretty much always use in-app browsers instead of taking you straight to Safari. In-app browsers that, unlike the in-app browsers on Android, don't remember that you've signed in to any sites, or accepted any cookie requests, etc etc. It's a constant frustration.

This is actually still a pretty major improvement from where iOS was a couple of years ago, though. I think I could genuinely live with an iPhone at this point.

It's definitely getting there for power users and it's getting there fast. Default apps are my other issue, if they roll that out as well they'll be on the verge of absolutely vacuuming up Android power users. It's something to watch in the market over the next couple of years as I can see the dynamic changing pretty fast.
I use an iPad at the moment for casual browsing and notifs are just annoying enough on there that it has dissuaded me from switching until they change it. Just too many instances of having to do that two-touch action over and over to dismiss multiple notifications from the same app.
 

Hoo-doo

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
4,292
The Netherlands
I'm not gonna lie, all the ultrawide spam from the iPhone 11 series recently has really put me off those shots. Just so many people using it in ways that look tacky as hell. But I'd still like it to have been here just to have the option. Unfortunately I'm a Pixel bitch so they know I'll keep on eating it up, but this is the first year the iPhone has looked seriously interesting to me, which is terrible news for Google. If Apple can get USB-C and fix their shitty notification system I might be on board for the 12.

Ofcourse you'll see an uptick in ultrawide photography seeing as the biggest and most popular phone brand now has it on all it's flagship phones. It's also a super versatile lens for group photography and conveying s sense of scale.

If anything, ultrawide is now rapidly becoming a standard requirement for high end phones. Which makes it utterly baffling why Google's new flagship doesn't have one.

Guaranteed that the Pixel 5 will have the ultrawide.
 

mAcOdIn

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,978
How about a Xiaomi? They actually have a pretty great track record for updates - even if their specific version of Android has some kinda irritating quirks - and they still make premium phones with headphone jacks. The Mi 9T Pro/Redmi K20 Pro, for instance.


(I particularly like the red version. Oh, and don't worry about the front camera issues discussed in the linked video: MKBHD's unit was defective, and every other review I've seen has produced far, far better results. Though, of course, the fact that one of the review units was defective could raise concerns over quality control.)
They have a different issue that I've been fumbling about with, they don't support all the bands I'd like for T-Mobile, well, neither does Huawei for that matter but the recent trade kerfuffle already kinda turned me off from them. The Korean LG V50 also doesn't support all the bands I'd like that the US one does which was something I was initially looking at as well as it's cheaper than the US version and unlocked already. They are nice phones though, great value as are Oneplus.

The bands aren't exactly important today but I like to keep a phone for three years or more and to be honest this low band support is a bigger deal to me than 5G as having a plain old good 4G data connection indoors or in some of my weird areas is way more important to me than having an insanely fast 5G connection in random spots. Since my city's finally started getting the 700mhz rolled out and 600mhz is becoming common in the rural areas between my city and where my family lives it's something I've really been paying attention to.
 

Shadowrun

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,747
Not sure what to make of all the negativity in here. The phone seems great outside the battery and price, and based on the rough start to sales (initial shipment is still not sold out), I'm guessing the latter will be less of an issue come Black Friday.
 

Andi

Member
Oct 29, 2017
1,316
My Pixel 2 phone is still working perfectly, so I'm probably not upgrading this year, but whenever I would, I can't see my self upgrading to anything other than a Pixel phone.

Same for me but not a pixel like this.
I want my 3 cam setup, a fingerprint reader and if we have bezels they should be symmetrical.
 

Futureman

Member
Oct 26, 2017
9,397
Not sure what to make of all the negativity in here. The phone seems great outside the battery and price, and based on the rough start to sales (initial shipment is still not sold out), I'm guessing the latter will be less of an issue come Black Friday.

Agreed. I love my XL 2 and this is that but way better.

If my budget was around $800 I don't know what else I'd even look at besides Pixel 4, S10 and iPhone 11. That OnePlus phone everyone brings up in here is WAY too big (almost 7" screen... what?).

Smallish battery complaint is valid but let's see what the reviews say. I still see people complain about battery life all the time while I'm typically putting my phone on the charger at night with 30% battery. And this is on a 1.5 year old phone.

I really like the 4 design plus the camera system and 90hz display. Once this drops $200 or so which will probably not take long, it's an amazing value IMO.
 

lt519

Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,063
6P has a notorious battery drain issue, I would hop off that train to even something cheaper but stable. I'm surprised to see this phone still being used.

Never had a work phone before, but i imagine you are not concerned about having traces of your personal photos on a company device?

Nope not concerned about the photos. Already replaced my battery twice, it's super easy and cheap enough. Also replaced my USB-C connector. It's reputation for batteries is true but replacing them for $20 every two years is not a big cost. My bigger concern is it is definitely slowing down and not as responsive as I'd like it to be.
 

Fliesen

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,251
Ofcourse you'll see an uptick in ultrawide photography seeing as the biggest and most popular phone brand now has it on all it's flagship phones. It's also a super versatile lens for group photography and conveying s sense of scale.

If anything, ultrawide is now rapidly becoming a standard requirement for high end phones. Which makes it utterly baffling why Google's new flagship doesn't have one.

Guaranteed that the Pixel 5 will have the ultrawide.

Yup, 'SmartHDR' and computational photography in general can improve zoom quality with one lens like crazy - but no amount of computation can make the camera actually capture a wider field of view.

Which is why i was so happy that Apple included the Ultrawide in the 11 and not the telephoto, while withholding the ultrawide for the Pro.
(It's still likely i'm gonna go for the Pro next year, because i do also love the telephoto lens on my XS)
 

whatsinaname

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,047


Ouch. The poor outdoor brightness doesn't sound good either.

My dad's Pixel XL is showing its age, I think a 3a or a 1+ 7 might be a better replacement.
 
Oct 26, 2017
4,153
California
Pixel 3 series works fine with 4gb ram.
I had the 3XL. It literally did not work fine with 4GB. Apps closed in the background all the time.
If I could take a photo of myself holding my s9+ (I guess I could use the bathroom mirror at work) I would. The headphone jack is the other good thing about it I forgot to mention. But when I think about the phone the word that comes to mind is compromise.

A lot of people will gloss over the shitty parts of using a samsung (unresponsive, buggy unreliable software) because the specs look so good on paper. The experience of using the phone is not what it should be for the cost and on paper specifications.
Note 10+ user here, and thus is literally the smoothest, most powerful, no-compromise phone I've ever handled.
 
Dec 12, 2017
4,652
Their notification system has gotten much better lately fwiw. I used to absolutely hate the way my iPad handled notifications, to the point they were basically unusable for me, but once they added grouping and somewhat more granular settings, things improved dramatically.

It's still nowhere near as versatile as Android's system, of course, but I think I could live with it now.

Honestly I think the two things I wish they'd fix on iOS the most at this point are the forced default apps, and the way applications pretty much always use in-app browsers instead of taking you straight to Safari. In-app browsers that, unlike the in-app browsers on Android, don't remember that you've signed in to any sites, or accepted any cookie requests, etc etc. It's a constant frustration.

This is actually still a pretty major improvement from where iOS was a couple of years ago, though. I think I could genuinely live with an iPhone at this point. I'd actually be kinda tempted to try one out if they weren't still so expensive, even at the low end.


How about a Xiaomi? They actually have a pretty great track record for updates - even if their specific version of Android has some kinda irritating quirks - and they still make premium phones with headphone jacks. The Mi 9T Pro/Redmi K20 Pro, for instance.


(I particularly like the red version. Oh, and don't worry about the front camera issues discussed in the linked video: MKBHD's unit was defective, and every other review I've seen has produced far, far better results. Though, of course, the fact that one of the review units was defective could raise concerns over quality control.)
The inability to select your default apps is the only reason that I still have an Android. I have no hope in RCS.
 

The Albatross

Member
Oct 25, 2017
38,946
Not sure what to make of all the negativity in here. The phone seems great outside the battery and price, and based on the rough start to sales (initial shipment is still not sold out), I'm guessing the latter will be less of an issue come Black Friday.

It's the same as every Pixel announcement.

A flood of posts asking how anybody could ever buy a Pixel phone when the HONOR XIMI P169a is half the price and has 42GB of ram and you can submerge the phone in hot lava! And then like 2 months later everybody forgets about the HONOR XIMU PL12 while the Pixel line up goes on to quietly be among the best phones of the year, year after year, every year.

My Pixel XL and Pixel 3 have basically been perfect phones, and I'll probably upgrade to next year's Pixel phone or if they do a mid-cycle low-priced one maybe.

The inability to select your default apps is the only reason that I still have an Android. I have no hope in RCS.

Man RCS is awesome when it's there. My sister and I are like unicorns because we both have Pixel phones on Google Fi so we both have RCS messaging with one another, and it's such a joy. And then 98% of the other people in my contacts list its back to whatever prison we've been living in for a decade. I don't have any hope for it to take off either. There's too many companies with competing interests actively working against a new protocol for it to ever take off, and Google's attention span is probably not long enough to out-last them all.
 
Oct 25, 2017
3,789
Tech press remains trash. What the hell is with these "hands on" of the pixel buds which are literally non working plastic shells? "I put them in my ear and they feel okay, this is looking to be nice product releasing in 2020." If Google can't be bothered to show something then don't write an article about nothing. It's an insult to the readers, doubly so if they have to sit through a video to learn there's nothing to learn, just repost the spec sheet and move on.
 

meow

The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
1,094
NYC
I have a Pixel 2 that still works fine so will probably upgrade when Google gives $250 off or something. I got my Pixel 2 in early 2018 for around $500 and my mom/sister each got the Pixel 3 when they had that "buy 2 get $800 in credit" promo. At those price points, I don't see any reason to switch.
 

toythatkills

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,805
London, UK
Tech press remains trash. What the hell is with these "hands on" of the pixel buds which are literally non working plastic shells? "I put them in my ear and they feel okay, this is looking to be nice product releasing in 2020." If Google can't be bothered to show something then don't write an article about nothing. It's an insult to the readers, doubly so if they have to sit through a video to learn there's nothing to learn, just repost the spec sheet and move on.

Yeah, that video posted here of some guy talking for two minutes about how great they are, just parroting the talking points from the presentation (they cost this, they release at this time, they last for x hours) then at the end just casually drops "by the way these ones don't work."

Thanks.

Not sure what to make of all the negativity in here. The phone seems great outside the battery and price, and based on the rough start to sales (initial shipment is still not sold out), I'm guessing the latter will be less of an issue come Black Friday.

I don't care about the price, but if I'm buying a new phone I want to be confident that the battery's gonna last me a day. That's really all I ask, priority number one. My S9 has a bigger battery than this and is regularly around 20% when I get home from work in an evening, so surely a phone with a smaller battery will die constantly, especially with that screen? I'll wait for hands-on impressions to be sure because hey, maybe Google did magic, but it seems doubtful.
 

Fliesen

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,251
A flood of posts asking how anybody could ever buy a Pixel phone when the HONOR XIMI P169a is half the price and has 42GB of ram and you can submerge the phone in hot lava! And then like 2 months later everybody forgets about the HONOR XIMU PL12 while the Pixel line up goes on to quietly be among the best phones of the year, year after year, every year.
But that's not the main narrative here, is it? It's more that the Pixel 4 is a downgrade to the Pixel 3 in some respects (battery size, fingerprint reader, headphone jack), while the upgrades range from neat (90Hz display) to gimmicky (Soli) to simply missed potential (Telephoto instead of Wide Angle or 3 cameras altogether).
I don't think this is simply "people always hate on the most recently announced Pixel" (which they do, to a degree, you're not wrong) - but this doesn't seem like a good Pixel year, like for example last year was (Call Screening, Night Sight, Google Camera)
 

Shadowrun

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,747
I don't care about the price, but if I'm buying a new phone I want to be confident that the battery's gonna last me a day. That's really all I ask, priority number one. My S9 has a bigger battery than this and is regularly around 20% when I get home from work in an evening, so surely a phone with a smaller battery will die constantly, especially with that screen? I'll wait for hands-on impressions to be sure because hey, maybe Google did magic, but it seems doubtful.

Oh, I agree. The batteries are too small on both models, and no amount of software optimization will ever, ever be enough to overcome the physics of battery drain.
 

GMT Master

Member
Oct 3, 2019
668
I pre-ordered, buy mainly because I'm in that stupid place where I will upgrade every year regardless of how mediocre the upgrade seems to be.

Most excited about the 90hz screen.

Hopefully the image quality is better, but the Pixel 3 camera is still incredible so I'm not worried.
 

The Albatross

Member
Oct 25, 2017
38,946
But that's not the main narrative here, is it? It's more that the Pixel 4 is a downgrade to the Pixel 3 in some respects (battery size, fingerprint reader, headphone jack), while the upgrades range from neat (90Hz display) to gimmicky (Soli) to simply missed potential (Telephoto instead of Wide Angle or 3 cameras altogether).
I don't think this is simply "people always hate on the most recently announced Pixel" (which they do, to a degree, you're not wrong) - but this doesn't seem like a good Pixel year, like for example last year was (Call Screening, Night Sight, Google Camera)

Yeah I think you're right, I really haven't followed the Pixel 4 this year because I'm very happy with the Pixel 3. But, I remember the Pixel 3 threads which were an identically negative reaction ... "omg the chin!" "no headphones!" "still just 4GB of ram?!" "my Pixel XL phone already has night sight!" etc. I've gotten used to every Pixel thread being overwhelmingly negative, and then the phones end up being great phones that are top contenders for the best phones released that year.

This year, it may be true, the Pixel 4 might be a step back from the 3, but that's been the narrative in threads like these for ~4 years...
 

DavidDesu

Banned
Oct 29, 2017
5,718
Glasgow, Scotland
The battery is the most depressing news. Unless there is some sort of magic going on.
Yeah I really like what I'm seeing with this phone, except the battery. I'd never get the XL, I want a smaller phone than the 4 quite frankly but I can manage it, but that battery life... My Pixel 2 was fantastic when I got it, got a few months left of my two year contract and it's shit now. This new phone should have have at least something like 3300mah battery. Just.. put a bigger battery in, make it a millimetre or two thicker if you have to, and give everyone trustworthy battery life for their device!
 

reKon

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,696
One Plus needs to go all in on camera tech. That's their missing piece.

Apple is going to slaughter everything next year with the redesign if they actually decide to go all in with the high refesh screen + USB C. That would be a wrap and only Samsung would be the only capable one to match if they substantially improve camera and battery.

Apple has figured out the camera and battery - two things that have been lacking compared to the competition. If they start allowing shit like pre approved default apps on that software, I see the beginning of the end (assuming they add USB C).

Pixel 4 is still a good phone, but it's lacking in too many ways to command that price. Photo quality is still top tier, but no competing wide angle and non 4K 60 FPS video is laughable. Pixel 4A might be the better buy.
 
Last edited: